Re:Designing Solo, a new U2F/FIDO2 Token
by pvg on Thursday August 23, 2018 @11:45PM
(#17832626)
Are there technical reasons that device (well, maybe not quite that blue-sky-ish, but the general idea) can't be your phone? You've already paid for it, people seem to think they're quite secure, etc. I don't get the whole desire to make hw tokens more computery so we can better use our computers while also already carrying another computer in our pockets.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Designing Solo, a new U2F/FIDO2 Token
by tptacek on Thursday August 23, 2018 @11:51PM
(#17832658)
This is a can of worms. Experts will tell you that iPhones are quite secure, and there is a lot of hardware security going into making them secure. It doesn't follow that any piece of hardware you build with L4 and a cheap ARM core will protect keys, such that losing sight of your token for a couple minutes won't mean you have to ditch the keys it stored.
Right, I mean a secure phone, so a recent iPhone with the enclave and the exurb and the whatnot. The U2F key I get - it's cheap, it's indestructible, I can buy a bunch and put them on my keychain and hide them under the couch and forget them in drawers filled with old SCSI terminators. But the phone already can do things like, say, authorize access to my google account by gmail app push notifications. Why not my ssh keys or all the other zany things people want to do with fancier USB tokens?
Krypton does this:
https://krypt.co https://krypt.co/developers
It acts as a U2F token, but can also hold a private key for SSH authentication and/or git commit signing. On iOS, it can use the secure enclave.
I think (I don't have the numbers and I might be wrong) that the price difference between a Yubico U2F key and the Yubico Y4 key that will also hold your SSH key is in large part down to the BOM cost of the NXP chip they're using as the on-board HSM.
You would then have to replace all the not-secure phones your users have, iOS market share is ~15%. It could work for company-internal things w/ work phones though. Phones generally get lost, broken and out of battery a lot though.
Why not just house the yubikey guts inside the phone enclosure then?
Re:Designing Solo, a new U2F/FIDO2 Token
by badrabbit on Friday August 24, 2018 @06:12PM
(#17838192)
Separation of duties. You want the hsm to be unchanged in many years with minimal maintainance. While your phone is already being used for too many things which means it will need an upgrade frequently and you will have a harder time securing it.
Think of the hsm as just another key on your keychain. It has no ui other than a button,does not need charging and will remain in your pocket until needed. You don't want someone grabbing it off your hand while texting or making a call,that would mean they can access all your accounts.