News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What happens when a Pacific island upsets China by amaccuish on Sunday August 19, 2018 @03:21PM (#17795748)
> There is an ongoing discussion about China weaponizing tourism

And America tried the same tatic with Cuba and many other countries. It's an effective tatic. China isn't doing anything new that hasn't been done before.

Re:What happens when a Pacific island upsets China by sonnyblarney on Sunday August 19, 2018 @04:26PM (#17795998)
No.

A) Cuba w/Soviets pointed nuclear missiles at the US. Iran's government perpetually declares they want to destroy the US. that's a tad offside compared to 'listing Taiwan as a country'.

B) The US very very rarely controls where it's citizens can go.

The moral/relative arguments used by the pro/defend China camp are tiring.

Re:What happens when a Pacific island upsets China by Leary on Sunday August 19, 2018 @05:02PM (#17796159)
Why does the US still embargo Cuba when it's no longer a military threat? Do you think that Cubans in Florida play an outsized role in US politics?
Re:What happens when a Pacific island upsets China by sonnyblarney on Sunday August 19, 2018 @09:24PM (#17797170)
"Why does the US still embargo Cuba when it's no longer a military threat? Do you think that Cubans in Florida play an outsized role in US politics?"

That's complicated but the Cuban regime is still to this day fairly totalitarian and are openly hostile to the US, which is not some little diplomatic thing.

Re:What happens when a Pacific island upsets China by imbokodo on Sunday August 19, 2018 @05:07PM (#17796178)
Cuba pointed missiles at the US because the US was openly gearing up for one of its many invasions of Cuba, shortly after the failed Bay of Pigs invasion. The Soviets put nukes there because the US put nuclear missiles into Turkey.

The US government has declared they want to destroy the US. It has been the US interfering in Iran, not vice versa.

The US banned Nobel Prize winner Linus Pauling from leaving the US, only giving him one shortly before his second Nobel prize to avoid international embarrassment.

Playwright and former Marilyn Monroe husband Arthur Miller was denied a passport, blocking him from seeing the Crucible open in London.

Civil rights icon Paul Robeson was denied a passport, explicitly to deny him the opportunity to talk about the state of national oppression of those of African descent in the US.

Also NY Post reporter William Withy Jr., Corliss Lamont, Howard Fast, Rockwell Kent...

In more recent days one can not drive a car in the US without a license, travel a plane without one, take an Amtrak train without one or ride a Greyhound bus without one. The US absolutely exercises control over where its citizens can go, many of these restrictions are new.

Re:What happens when a Pacific island upsets China by paulie_a on Sunday August 19, 2018 @05:44PM (#17796344)
You don't need a license to travel Amtrak. In many cases you don't even need a ticket when boarding the train. I routinely buy mine after it has left the station.
Re:What happens when a Pacific island upsets China by imbokodo on Sunday August 19, 2018 @06:38PM (#17796570)
You might want to send a note to Amtrak's web site, as they say their policy is otherwise https://www.amtrak.com/passenger-identification
Re:What happens when a Pacific island upsets China by paulie_a on Sunday August 19, 2018 @08:31PM (#17797007)
Hell no, I love the low friction travel. But I haven't been asked for an ID on Amtrak since the mid 2000s when they still served booze on that line. On the line I use most frequently they never ask for an ID. And a ticket for tomorrow works for today. Almost nothing nothing in that faq is adhered to on my experience.
Re:What happens when a Pacific island upsets China by greedo on Sunday August 19, 2018 @06:11PM (#17796458)
I doubt there are many (if any) countries where a drivers license isn't required for operating a car.
Re:What happens when a Pacific island upsets China by bausshf on Monday August 20, 2018 @08:23AM (#17799333)
And usually the license is good, because it requires training and if you can't pass that then you probably shouldn't drive.
Re:What happens when a Pacific island upsets China by phkahler on Sunday August 19, 2018 @04:36PM (#17796039)
Have you noticed what's happening in the Puerto Rico? An actual US territory.
Re:What happens when a Pacific island upsets China by perl4ever on Sunday August 19, 2018 @03:51PM (#17795869)
It's reasonable to note that it's a much smaller offense in this case than with Cuba, regardless of what one may think of the merits. There's a difference between holding a grudge over acts like expropriation and revolution and trying to enforce correct speaking and writing by everyone. The latter seems hypersensitive and quixotic. It would be silly if the US cut off travel to Canada because they recognized the existence of the new government of Cuba.
Re:What happens when a Pacific island upsets China by amaccuish on Sunday August 19, 2018 @05:27PM (#17796276)
> It would be silly if the US cut off travel to Canada because they recognized the existence of the new government of Cuba.

The US is quite happy right now to punish countries trading with Iran.

Re:What happens when a Pacific island upsets China by Leary on Sunday August 19, 2018 @05:03PM (#17796164)
Do you think in the Civil War, the US would've cut off travel to the UK if the UK recognized the Confederate States of America?
Re:What happens when a Pacific island upsets China by perl4ever on Sunday August 19, 2018 @09:37PM (#17797223)
"In the Civil War" is one thing. 70 years later is another.

There's no way to tell what would have happened if a hypothetical rump CSA territory still existed circa 1934.

But we can look at Vietnam for comparison. The US normalized relations after 20 years, not >70.

Re:What happens when a Pacific island upsets China by Leary on Sunday August 19, 2018 @04:52PM (#17796118)
Why do we still have an embargo on Cuba?
Re:What happens when a Pacific island upsets China by antidesitter on Sunday August 19, 2018 @03:28PM (#17795782)
> And America tried the same tatic with Cuba and many other countries.

Do you have more information about this?

Re:What happens when a Pacific island upsets China by mcculley on Sunday August 19, 2018 @04:29PM (#17796010)
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_embargo_against_...

The embargo is still in effect. I recently took a cruise to Havana. I was annoyed at the frequent reminders to those of us passengers who are US citizens about our restrictions on engaging in unallowed economic activity. Passengers who were not citizens of the Land of the Free have no such restrictions.

Re:What happens when a Pacific island upsets China by altcognito on Sunday August 19, 2018 @03:41PM (#17795833)
The US claimed Cuba as a part of its territory?
Re:What happens when a Pacific island upsets China by nickserv on Sunday August 19, 2018 @03:52PM (#17795872)
Nobody is claiming Palau. The point is that China has effectively embargoed Palau, similar to the US embargo on Cuba following their revolution.
Re:What happens when a Pacific island upsets China by tomc1985 on Sunday August 19, 2018 @06:05PM (#17796423)
They have a limited agreement with the US. There's a video (I think it was on Vice) about how its a hot spot for Chinese tourists to pick up tech at US prices and gamble away from Chinese supervision.
Re:What happens when a Pacific island upsets China by sonnyblarney on Sunday August 19, 2018 @04:27PM (#17796001)
It's not remotely 'similar'.

One is from a minor diplomatic dispute.

The other arose from a nuclear standoff that was the closest we ever came to starting World War 3 and therefore the destruction of all human life as we know it.

Re:What happens when a Pacific island upsets China by erk__ on Sunday August 19, 2018 @04:37PM (#17796047)
Well they did lease the Guantánamo Bay, but the current goverment says that the lease is illegal.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Guant%C3%A1namo_Bay

Re:What happens when a Pacific island upsets China by knuththetruth on Sunday August 19, 2018 @04:03PM (#17795909)
More or less, actually:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spanish%E2%80%93American_War

EDIT: Sorry about...history, I guess?

Re:What happens when a Pacific island upsets China by gaoshan on Sunday August 19, 2018 @03:33PM (#17795805)
I remember this basic "argument" from my childhood. After getting caught doing something of dubious moral value a child would say "Well everyone else is doing it". You knew it was wrong but you did it anyway and justified it by pointing out that "everyone else" did it. One of these days I'd love to see a grown up country come along and just do the good thing. Probably never happen since people are the same everywhere and really only like to point out shortcomings when they aren't the beneficiary but it would be so nice to find that there actually is an adult somewhere in the room.
Re:What happens when a Pacific island upsets China by gerdesj on Sunday August 19, 2018 @04:27PM (#17796002)
One of these days I'd love to see a grown up country come along and just do the good thing.

I like your parent/child allusion and who wouldn't? However, there is no parent available that could cuff the miscreant and make it all good. Besides: what exactly is "the good thing"?

Re:What happens when a Pacific island upsets China by Waterluvian on Sunday August 19, 2018 @04:32PM (#17796023)
Traditionally that parent has been the US. And like many parents they subscribe whole heartedly to, "do as I say, not as I do."
Re:What happens when a Pacific island upsets China by gerdesj on Sunday August 19, 2018 @04:38PM (#17796058)
Traditionally that parent has been the US

Your tradition seems to only go back a few decades.

Re:What happens when a Pacific island upsets China by Waterluvian on Sunday August 19, 2018 @05:23PM (#17796255)
That's fair. Maybe like.. cold war onwards.
Re:What happens when a Pacific island upsets China by gerdesj on Sunday August 19, 2018 @06:11PM (#17796457)
I'm a Brit. In the past Britain might be said to have imposed itself a little bit across the planet. I'm not sure that the world is ready yet for either your or my country's style of nation scale parenthood.

That said: we can persuade around 2 billion people to watch a Californian princess become a Duchess and convince those watchers and the rest of the world that the opposite happened! The US and its mythology can be pretty persuasive but I defy you to beat that 8)

Re:What happens when a Pacific island upsets China by gerdesj on Sunday August 19, 2018 @07:11PM (#17796737)
... I was a bit unfair on assuming a few things. Meghan Markle became the Duchess of Sussex on marring Prince Harry. Strictly speaking she is not a Princess but I defy anyone to enforce that fact ...
Re:What happens when a Pacific island upsets China by Waterluvian on Monday August 20, 2018 @08:46AM (#17799445)
The Royal family is so cool. Its like a look through a time machine. These are real Queens and princes and dukes and lords. They don't exactly do what they used to back in the day, but the look at the ceremony and the "authenticity" is really neat.

I just wish the Queen of Canada visited more. She doesn't even live here.

Re:What happens when a Pacific island upsets China by gerdesj on Monday August 20, 2018 @07:41PM (#17805215)
The Queen of Canada absolutely does live there - Rideau Hall is her residence. I accept she spends rather more time here in the UK these days but she is >90 years old.

The Canadian, British, Australian, New Zealand, etc etc Monarchy is a bit of a funny old thing but I think that through the Commonwealth (QEII's personal project) and other initiatives it is very useful and a force for good. At the moment the Royal Family are very, very popular in the UK (it hasn't always been so). They seem to have managed to re-invent themselves rather cleverly over the last 20 years or so.

The recent Royal marriage was frankly breathtaking - Harry is prince no. 2 and Megan is a Yank and yet the firm turned this into a fairy tale. Harry is as near a war hero as can be allowed and Megan is a pretty lass and clearly very bright and talented - good initial ingredients. Throw in a bloody great castle and chapel, amazing weather and a few other things and you get a right old tear jerker of a wedding.

The Queen of Canada was in attendance.

I live in the south west of England in a county called Somerset. I'm roughly 130 miles away from Buck Pal. You are a few thousand miles away but we both have the same link to our Royals.

Re:What happens when a Pacific island upsets China by tomohawk on Sunday August 19, 2018 @04:05PM (#17795919)
Cuba's communist government nationalized property from people and corporations without any compensation.

It still illegally holds these properties today.

The communist Cuban government acceded to hosting Soviet nuclear missiles pointed at the US. This almost caused a nuclear war.

The US embargo was based on these and many other things.

It is hardly a comparable situation.

Re:What happens when a Pacific island upsets China by amaccuish on Sunday August 19, 2018 @05:31PM (#17796295)
> Cuba's communist government nationalized property from people and corporations without any compensation.

That's not anyone else's business. Countries should be free to a certain extent to act as they wish. It's not for America to decide what political system another country should have.

>The communist Cuban government acceded to hosting Soviet nuclear missiles...

I think you skipped a key part of history usually referred to as "Bay of Pigs Invasion"...

Re:What happens when a Pacific island upsets China by tomc1985 on Sunday August 19, 2018 @06:06PM (#17796434)
> That's not anyone else's business. Countries should be free to a certain extent to act as they wish. It's not for America to decide what political system another country should have.

Until you nationalize American-owned businesses, then yes it is.

Re:What happens when a Pacific island upsets China by Leary on Sunday August 19, 2018 @05:04PM (#17796168)
Do you think the damages that the US embargo have caused over the decades to the Cuban people is justified because of Cuba's communist policies?
Re:What happens when a Pacific island upsets China by tomohawk on Sunday August 19, 2018 @05:09PM (#17796188)
I don't know. Do you think the damages the communist government have caused over the decades to the Cuban people are justified?

The embargo didn't ultimately work, and neither did the government.

I was just responding to the idea that an island that is no threat whatsoever to China, and which has never had nuclear missiles pointed at China, and which has not ever nationalized property from citizens of China was somehow equivalent to the Cuba situation.

Re:What happens when a Pacific island upsets China by imbokodo on Sunday August 19, 2018 @05:45PM (#17796349)
The US invaded and seized Guantanamo Bay in 1898. What was the cause for that?

It's a standard American imperial idea. The US seizure and continual occupation of Guantanamo Bay is "legal". Cubans reclaiming what Americans stole in other parts of Cuba is "illegal".

It's quite a joke. The US invading and seizing sugar plantations from 1898 to 1959 is legal, the American thieves being driven out is "illegal" and "without any compensation".

This sort of imperial hubris is why Arabian patriots have been flying planes into the Pentagon.

Re:What happens when a Pacific island upsets China by dang on Sunday August 19, 2018 @08:03PM (#17796907)
You've been using HN primarily for ideological battle. It's normal to comment occasionally on a politicized topic, but using the site primarily for this is crossing the line that the guidelines draw: https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html. There are lots of reasons why we draw the line there, but what it boils down to is that we can't both have a site for intellectual curiosity—the mandate of this place—and also have ideological warfare. The one destroys the other, regardless of which ideology you favor. Flamewar comments like the one you just posted are an excellent illustration of this.

If you'd please review the site rules and use this place as intended from now on, we'd appreciate it.

Re:What happens when a Pacific island upsets China by mistermann on Sunday August 19, 2018 @05:20PM (#17796236)
> China isn't doing anything new that hasn't been done before.

If you drop sufficient detail from any comparison you can indeed come to such a conclusion, but it isn't an honest conclusion. In this case the detail that was dropped is the motive for engaging in the "same tactic", and in this case the motive is very different.

In my opinion, this style (discarding non-trivial details until two different scenarios can be declared ~identical) of reporting, in both formal mainstream print & media journalism as well as the more casual but still extremely influential late night talk shows, is what has caused such a large percentage of the public to hold opinions that do not line up very well with reality, and you can observe this in online discussions when people get very emotionally upset with those who disagree with them - they "know" something to be a fact, because they likely did in fact hear something very similar to what they believe reported in a serious news outlet. But if you ask them to provide any citations that include this extra detail (say, during a discussion over an instance of the story that does include the dropped details), unsurprisingly they are utterly incapable of finding any evidence. And rare is the case where the person in question be able to realize their mistake, and change their beliefs.

And if you fact check the media outlets on any of this, you'll almost always find that what they literally say is indeed factually true, it's just that they've dropped a whole bunch of context, resulting in their readers having a distorted understanding.