Not only a good economy, but it still has industrial output. There are plenty of big German car companies. It's not just "services". Plenty of politicians want to "bring back those blue collar jobs"
Do they really, or is that a soundbite they can use to appeal to their demographic?
”We believe that working people should run both the economy and society democratically to meet human needs, not to make profits for a few. ”
Sounds pretty similar to the thinking behind the German setup.
These have poor reputations and are only getting worse.
The quality of Audi/VW and BMW are no longer the cutting edge. Their mechanical components are known to fail often and their beauty(the biggest feature) is on par with GM and Ford.
Every 15-20 years it seems like car companies get complacent and need to be affected by the market to 'wake up'.
German cars have always been about luxury and performance,not beauty (that would be the italians) and they are still top of the pile. The M3/M5 are the definitive sports sedans still, the S-Class is the definitive full-size luxury sedan, and Porsche is the go to brand for performance sports offerings (look at caranddriver's website, Porsche has 0 offerings with less than 4 stars).
New complicated features aren't as reliable as simpler old ways, but "breaking occasionally" and "expensive to maintain when old" aren't really turn-offs for the people who buy those cars, especially on short term leases with covered maintenance.
Having seen piles of headlines about stagnant wage growth in Germany, I had to look up some stats, and found these links:
https://tradingeconomics.com/united-states/wage-growth https://tradingeconomics.com/germany/wage-growth
Except for 2009/10 being particularly bad in the US, wage growth seems much stronger in the US.
And when I look at tech salaries in the EU, I'm not sure I want that. Or at least that attitude to compensation.
This the same everywhere outside the US though. Salaries are much lower as the skill ceiling tends to be much lower and there is more skilled labour available.
The US just has a huge amount of investment, a small skilled labour force and a more meritocratic outlook in general (bear in mind, even just 50 years ago, being a manager or not would depend on your family and school in the UK for example, and you wouldn't even eat with your subordinates).
I don't think worker representation would change much there, the Americans already have it so good.
But anyway, it makes arguments of "look how well Germany is doing" not very compelling to me.
I don't hate the idea of codetermination tbh, but I do have lots of questions about how it would work in practice.
At the very least you have to ask whether contractors get a vote, which gets you into a question if incentive and which workers are more or less aligned with a company.
1. US - $19.42T GDP (25% of world GDP) 2. China - $11.8T GDP 3. Japan - $4.84T GDP 4. Germany - $3.42T GDP 5. UK - $2.5T GDP 6. India - $2.45T GDP 7. France - $2.42T GDP 8. Brazil - $2.14T GDP 9. Italy - $1.81T GDP 10. Canada - $1.6T GDP
Personally, the one that shocked me is Italy, what with the all you see about the country's debt problems, but I hear a lot of that is due to corruption and tax evasion.
[1] https://www.investopedia.com/articles/investing/022415/world...
From your, presumably different view, what would you prescribe? Allow taking advantage of workers until those in power find enough wealth, and only then give workers a voice?
Somehow the work gets done!
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Working_time#Average_annual_...
This my experience from living 5 years in the former East and afterwards moving to the West (already 7 years).
I agree. We should aim for nothing less than paradigm shift.
There’s nothing here that Marx didn’t articulate ~150 yrs ago.
They get to use an artificially cheap currency (cheap for them) to drive the largest trade imbalances on earth. They're plundering the Eurozone and EU, just look at the trade surplus they have in their own economic region ($180b trade surplus just with the EU alone). Were they using their own currency, their exports would suffer immensely. How long can that destabilizing arrangement continue? Not much longer, judging by several of their fellow Eurozone nations.
Even with all of that, their median household net worth is still lower than the US.
Seriously, I don't understand, what does a cheap currency (what does that even mean) have to do with trade surplus?
The way international trade works in theory is like this: when a country is running a trade surplus, demand for its currency increases, so that other countries can buy its goods. That extra demand drives up the exchange rate, which makes its goods more expensive, which drives down exports, which brings the balance of payments (exports minus imports) back into equilibrium.
What happens in the EU is that, because you have a shared currency, this balancing mechanism breaks down, and so trade imbalances between countries can only be corrected via deliberate subsidies (exactly as happens between rich and poor regions inside the US, for instance).
But, more than any other EU member, Germany has blocked this kind of policy, choosing to interpret trade imbalances in moral rather than economic terms (southern countries are too lazy, laid back, inefficient, etc).
Are poor regions in the US effectively assisted by subsidies? I feel in the EU the main problem is lack of integration, for example if I design a product here in The Netherlands, it would be a lot cheaper to set up a factory in say Poland or Spain, but I'd be hesitant to do that because of cultural and language barriers. I suppose that's less of a problem in the US, though in the US distances are greater.
What I'm saying is that, once you remove currency mechanisms which automatically bring into equilibrium the balance of payments between EU member states, you can have permanent trade imbalances between countries. German exports remain artificially cheap within Europe because they are Euro-denominated. So Germany keeps racking up balance-of-trade surpluses, which then allow it to go into the southern countries and buy up real estate and major companies, so that they become the effective owners of the country. Obviously they have a vested interest in maintaining the current system.
> Are poor regions in the US effectively assisted by subsidies? I feel in the EU the main problem is lack of integration, for example if I design a product here in The Netherlands, it would be a lot cheaper to set up a factory in say Poland or Spain, but I'd be hesitant to do that because of cultural and language barriers. I suppose that's less of a problem in the US, though in the US distances are greater.
There are quite a lot of factories in southern Europe, because salaries are much lower, but that does not really help the southern countries much, as the profits flow back north into their parent companies' countries. Obviously over time, salaries in the south will also tend to rise, hence the enthusiasm of Germany for an open-borders policy which floods the entire European market with cheap immigrant labour, thus holding wage levels low.
This is a 100% match to the remarks made in the article.
[1]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Codetermination_in_Germany#Int...
US median household annual disposable PPP income is around $34,000.
German median household annual disposable PPP income is around $25,000.
Note PPP means adjusted for cost of living, so that is not hiding the difference.
There is likely some differences in household makeup, etc., but it seems unlikely that any demographic difference is going to make up for Germans having ~25% less disposable income.
So somehow the US system is generating significantly more disposable income for its people.
If the German government cuts funding for those two sectors, passes on the savings to people by reducing tax rates, and requires them to pay for those services out of pocket like the US, the disposable income may reach parity, but the people would probably be worse off in real terms.
Household disposable income is net including those social benefits, so the complaint is incorrect. Here's the definition used in these datasets:
They all have healthcare when they need it and have no health-related bankruptcies or anxiety over such. Having a part-time job isn’t crippling to their health and safety. Their transportation systems are cutting edge as well.
If you combine only the tangible cost benefits of healthcare and transportation availability, that should account for approximately the difference in disposable income.
These PPP income are pretty hard to compare. You have so much local variability within a country that you can only really compare the same kind of family situation in the same kind of city. You also need to compare against what you get from the system. For example, in the US, a part of your revenue is in your PPP if you are not ill, but if you get a cancer, you are good for a good stack of expenses depending on your health insurance, in the EU, the health insurance will cover all the costs. If you are in Denmark, you get access to free education (you even get paid to study), in Germany education is free.
As a French who has been working/living is several countries in the EU and have friends nearly all over the world, I can say, the real factor, if you are an engineer, is where you live, that is, the cost of housing. Because the salary as an engineer will be nearly the same in the country you live but the cost of living can vary a lot.
So basically Germans are equally productive, hour for hour, but have collectively chosen more free time over more purchasing power.
(Also that chart has 2016 data for the US and 2013 data for Germany, making the comparison somewhat awkward)
Then why are so many people complaining about the cost of living, housing, healthcare, education etc? Could someone remind us what is and what isn't included in "disposable"?
The US median cost of living is lower than in: Germany, France, UK, Australia, Sweden, Finland, Canada.
Healthcare is a very legitimate complaint. It's plainly outrageous. Even in the case where the bill is often mostly footed by an employer, that comes out of wages to one degree or another.
Housing is not a legitimate complaint (everyone doesn't live in NYC, LA, Seattle and SF). The median US costs on rent and housing are lower than any comparable disposable income nation, and you get far larger accomodations (space) in the US than the other nations.
Education is not a legitimate complaint. The US is overflowing with modestly priced, high quality in-state university choices, including quite affordable state schools. If you spend $160,000 on a shit paying degree from a tier two school for no good reason, that's on you. You don't get to bitch about doing something that dumb when you could have gotten the exact same degree for $40,000 and paid for half of it with a part-time job over four years.
$40,000 euros for a degree is still a ridiculous amount. It costs $11,000 to go to Oxford per year right now, and before the ridiculous fee increases it would be about $11,000 for a 4 year degree.
It's about $5,000 per year on average across the EU, with some countries offering free tuition. Because, hey, it turns out educating people ends up a net benefit to society!
Education benefits but degree mills whether Asia, America or Europe don't benefit much. And this is increasingly common.
I don't think this is accurate. Maybe it used to be, but not anymore. For example, Numbeo says:
> Rent in Germany is 30.85% lower than in United States (average data for all cities).
https://www.numbeo.com/cost-of-living/country_result.jsp?cou...
It would be better to find more official data, but I wasn't able to find anything for Germany.
> Education is not a legitimate complaint. The US is overflowing with modestly priced, high quality in-state university choices, including quite affordable state schools. If you spend $160,000 on a shit paying degree from a tier two school for no good reason, that's on you. You don't get to bitch about doing something that dumb when you could have gotten the exact same degree for $40,000 and paid for half of it with a part-time job over four years.
$40,000 for four years of education + living expenses? Do you think students are living out of garbage cans? $10,000/year will probably cover in-state tuition + books/fees/etc., sure, and what do you think is a reasonable cost for housing, food, transportation, etc. for a student?
Could you please refer me to a source for cost of living comparison? I am not disputing this assertion, I have just been unable to find a good source comparing cost of living between countries.
We in the US fund our defense and Germany's defense (and cover the rest of the free world too) and still end up with more post-tax income than Germany does. That's a massive productivity gap.
I agree that the USA has used its military to keep a kind of pax americana. But that is not the complete story. The super expensive wars on Afghanistan and Irak didn't had anything to do with "the free world" and a lot with oil.
BTW That may have changed nowadays, but it was a very good idea that Germany had a low military budged.
It's all about priorities.
What's the point of 'bothering' to keep a token airforce airworthy when your total military personnel is capped to far below a useful amount (350,000) for any reasonable attempt at defence, and for historical reasons you are incredibly adverse to using them overseas?
Is that like preemptive forward defense in other peoples countries?
That's a fantastic way to put it. If we aren't being productive to improve happiness (directly or indirectly), then why are we doing it?
My point is that a life of comfort is not the ideal to which we should aspire, and that humanity's accomplishments have not come from people who didn't want to bother exerting themselves.
As I've said previously, European social policy is basically rest-and-vest at civilization scale.
You are equating a life of comfort with happiness. A lot of people have a more nuanced ways of evaluating their lives, where they value facing challenging and meaningful problems while also seeking stability and comfort.
It's why we have better adjectives to describe a good life than "happiness", i.e "fulfillment".
> humanity's accomplishments have not come from people who didn't want to bother exerting themselves.
Many of humanity's greatest breakthroughs came from people who were specifically insulated from the uncertainties of daily survival. From aristocrats experimenting with physics, to lifetime tenured monks (and later academics) who were given the day to day security to pursue lines of thought that otherwise wouldn't be considered.
Despite the oft-repeated cliche, necessity is more often the enemy of invention. Necessity serves as a pruning mechanism to select the best hypothesis of the many that were created when resources were plentiful.
Some grand, hand wavy idea of great fulfilment somewhere down the line doesn't cut it, because you know what never built a great bridge, cured a disease, or discovered a new particle? Living with crushing debt, stagnant wages whilst working paycheck to paycheck.
Back in my day, every Philosophy 101 curriculum included John Stuart Mill, who had this to say.
"Human beings have faculties more elevated than the animal appetites, and when once made conscious of them, do not regard anything as happiness which does not include their gratification."
You're using a very narrow definition of happiness. A uselessly narrow definition IMO, and apparently for no reason but to spread bigotry. Most people wouldn't be happy knowing they hadn't achieved anything (see: Maslow's hierarchy of needs). Even the otherwise rather short-sighted "Objectivists" tacitly accept this view, with "enlightened self interest" being their phrase of choice to avoid acknowledging the origin of that thought.
Modern Germans do not lack in accomplishment. They just choose to balance goal-directed work with enjoyment of its fruits, instead of staying on the treadmill past the point of diminishing returns. Here in the US, there's a bit of a fetish about claiming to work super-long hours to satisfy a Calvinist "work is virtue" image, while actually goofing off for (at least) half of that whenever nobody's looking. That's really stupid. The European approach of actually enjoying that time with family and friends guilt-free seems smart, compared to spending it in the office neither being productive nor having fun.
Per capita it's equal to over 20% of the median full-time wage ($50k).
Also - this does not take into account additional costs such as healthcare that will pull down the US amount.
The statistic here tells us that the person right in the middle of the American income distribution makes more than the person in the middle of the German income distribution, even when disregarding the actual incomes at other points in that distribution.
But household income is very tricky to measure and for example its unclear if they include health expenditure in exactly the same way
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/World_Happiness_Report#2018_Wo...
Disposable income doesn't factor in the higher cost of healthcare (huge) or other "taxes" that aren't taken into account.
Purchasing power is a metric that needs to be adjusted by actual cost of living and quality of such living.
The only fair way to compare healthcare over time is if the exact same quality of care drops in price over time.
Germany is economically successful. But here is few things for you to know about it: 1. the industry taxed near to the limit. 2. Welfare is not cheap by any means. 3. Germany is an ageing country, and the amount of welfare payouts will go even further.
I not fan of idea that a company can be public, nor the form of relationships in between its owners and management that evolved in the USA: 1. I find the idea that a man owning a single share of the company can sue the management to death for doing virtually anything. 2. The subsequent dominance of extreme CYA attitudes that American managers are famous for. 3. The fact that company ownership became an extremely bureaucratised thing.
I'm a big believer that a business must have an owner. My own experience working in public companies: an omnipresent atmosphere of "ownerlessness" and people not minding "leaving things broken" for reasons that they are not paid to fix them. Without a clear "boss" around, work tend descend into being a Brownian motion. And all of that gets progressively worse closer to C-suite offices, if the company is of type that changed few generations of management.
Words of my father: "a collective ownership of business is like life in family where a woman has 10 husbands, all trying to make love to her at the same time."
Surely you are also a big believer that a country must have a king. If not, why not?
> Words of my father: "a collective ownership of business is like life in family where a woman has 10 husbands, all trying to make love to her at the same time."
Quotations aren't even arguments if they come from famous people.
>Surely you are also a big believer that a country must have a king. If not, why not?
No, I believe that monarchies are weak, and risky. There might be modern day monarchs doing best for their realms, but the chance that after 3-4-5 good successions will come a man "who wrecks it all" is just too high. This is what history has demonstrated.
In case of business, the risks are not human lives. In case of a failing business, an employee is free to vote with his feet at any moment, moreover if he is valuable specialist in a competitive market. In such circumstances, business owners are compelled to do well do deter desertions. This is in big contrast to command economies dominated by state businesses. Speaking about command economies, that not necessarily assumes communists countries - just how much of F500 a decade ago were de-facto state co's? GE - with net negative tax rate, GM - needs no explanations, defence companies - being de-facto one with their states in every country, agri businesses with roots in banana republics, dozens of megabanks kept alive by financial life support from taxpayers.
> In case of a failing business, an employee is free to vote with his feet at any moment, moreover if he is valuable specialist in a competitive market.
A non-democratic economy works for certain people under certain circumstances. That is simply not enough.
Equating democratic elections, the act of freely chosing how you run your society, to what amounts to fleeing a sinking ship is beyond ridiculous. So is calling the US a command economy.
That said even though democracy is quite an awful system, it's probably the least awful of the alternatives. We, the people, are very unlikely to meaningfully change anything in any given election - but that power is, at least technically, there. Whereas if you have an awful monarch/dictator/life serving republic/etc then your only option is a bit messier.
It sounds like we tried 100s of different things since we got rid of royality and after a lots experiments 'representative' democracy was proven best.
I think it's more the case of the new royality finding it quite comfortable and this is one of the standard FUD lines we get.
The rulers don't have to be particularily benevolent to promote the people's interests if their interests and the people's interests are the same.
If the manipulation is completely and totally successful, then shouldn't they be able to maintain a higher approval rating than just 15%?
The only reason people care about the president is because he maintains a high visibility throughout his term. Even then it's very superficial. I'd be extremely surprised if the average voter could list 5 actual effected policy decisions of Obama that they liked/disliked. Yet they will love or loath him in spite of the lack of that knowledge. The various videos demonstrating this effect are my favorite. Individuals will be surveyed on what they think of described "Obama" policies, which are actually Trump policies - or vice versa. Their view on the policy invariably has little to nothing to do with the actual policy, and everything to do with the name attached to it.
Presidency sees a lot of marketing from each side, so high approval ratings might be more difficult to maintain, but congress should be far less of a battleground.
If you’re correct, then theres no reason for them to have 15% approval except out of sheer laziness; just as no one questions them during the election process, no one should be questioning during the term too
It actually is a recurring problem with monarchies (and often that's how democratic republics get established); heredity is no guarantee of competency.
Not that I'm advocating we go back to that or anything.
> Only a democracy will promote the interests of everybody.
Doesn't the first statement contradict the second?
Want to explain to me how this is even a bad thing? It sounds like the Germans have solidarity for their fellow people/workers and realize everyone should be provided the basics for a peace of mind and overall better workers that can rest and enjoy life outside of work.
American capitalism doesn't have to happen everywhere. It's a system that provides for the few instead of the many, unlike Germany that provides for the many instead of the few
That's a silly argument. US citizens make more on average than German citizens. Both systems provide for the many (with the US arguably providing moreso for that middle of the curve).
The problem is the unfortunate people on the left side of the curve who get hit with medical bankruptcy, a loss of industry, etc. Those people get screwed in the US where there is a better safety net in Germany.
I believe Germany can do even better if they can find ways to reduce the ratio of people in workforce to welfare recipients. Don't forget, we talk about that in the context of EU. Germany is carrying half of EU on its shoulders.
>it sounds like the Germans have solidarity for their fellow people/workers and realize everyone should be provided the basics for a peace of mind
Doing just "basics for a peace of mind" is doable with not much less, but nevertheless less money. The few developer countries in Asia can show how to do that well. My main criticism is that Germany's welfare is more expensive that that of other countries because not only direct payouts are moderately high, but welfare paid infrastructure and services are taking quite a lot too: lifts for pedestrian overpasses in the middle of nowhere, free transit ticket for people with minimal and non-mobility hampering disabilities, access to free housing (depending on a state) for people with income that qualifies as high in countries just across the border... and on and on
Big issue with all extensive welfare systems in the West is that in them, needs of people in need are not being known by people who are entrusted with administering welfare to them. I can easily pull out many example of welfare states where people in need live miserably. When the welfare does not benefit to the person in need, what's use of it? In that case it just becomes wasted money.
With all my militant atheism, I can give high mark to welfare administrators in the gulf region. Zakat distribution by mosques is very straightforward, addressing needs of people in need in the most straightforward way.
>and overall better workers that can rest and enjoy life outside of work.
I believe a professionals can enjoy life even more if they simply get higher salaries. In that context, I believe that German labour councils serve a good role, making people understand that "they can't milk a dead cow."
It is very good when both sides can come to terms knowing how much money they can extract from the business before it kicks the bucket.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Codetermination_in_Germany
Worker representation at the board level is good for companies as well because it can encourage pay restraint when the company really can't afford a pay rise. A board of very rich people telling you the company can't afford a pay rise for you is very different from some of your fellow workers saying the company can't afford a pay rise.
The German law goes a lot further than this law does though since it applies to all companies with over 500 employees.
Considering Germany is an economic powerhouse this law probably isn't harming the economy.