News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:EPA is allowing asbestos back into manufacturing by hanniabu on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @11:07AM (#17707268)
Welcome to the US lobbying system, where science, ethics, and morals take a backseat to agendas of those with the deepest pockets.
Re:EPA is allowing asbestos back into manufacturing by bruinjoe on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @11:22AM (#17707411)
This is so true. We should just ban lobbying because it is only used by rich corporations and individuals.
Re:EPA is allowing asbestos back into manufacturing by ekianjo on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @11:28AM (#17707478)
Lobbying is just a legal form of corruption. Ban it, and it will still continue to exist underground anyway. What we need is to stop voting for idiot politicians.
Re:EPA is allowing asbestos back into manufacturing by autoexec on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @03:17PM (#17709678)
As long as good politicians feel they'll be disadvantaged if they aren't selling themselves like the idiot ones are the good ones will line up for the money.

Certainly it's better to outlaw it rather than to simply allow it to happen. You will never catch 100% of the people breaking the law, but you can create an environment of transparency and accountability to help and you can make it costly enough for those who are caught to make the next person reconsider risking it.

Re:EPA is allowing asbestos back into manufacturing by ekianjo on Wednesday August 08, 2018 @10:25AM (#17716213)
lobbying is illegal in many countries yet it does not make corruption dissappear, far from it. Its like the war on drugs: it makes cartels stronger, if anything.
Re:EPA is allowing asbestos back into manufacturing by staunch on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @01:25PM (#17708599)
What about creating a "Direct Democracy Lobbying Group" that lets citizens donate/vote online on issues and then (legally) bribes the appropriate people with total transparency?

The depressing thing about most bribery is how small the amounts of money are. Politicians take bribes in the form of campaign financing because they want to stay in power. It's easy for them to rationalize if they think they're serving the greater good, and many of them would probably prefer to take money from citizens instead.

It seems like one super rich person could fix every level of US politics by implementing a backdoor direct democracy and seeding it with matching donations. If crowdfunding has proven anything, it's that people have more than enough money to spend when they want something.

It's only now that everyone is on the internet that this idea is even possible, and no one has tried it yet.

Re:EPA is allowing asbestos back into manufacturing by cam_l on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @11:15PM (#17712958)
We have a group sort of like that in Australia, Getup (not bribing but lobbying). The current sitting party is trying to get it deemed as a political party as it consistently lobbies against government policy (policy which is consistently against the will and interests of the public).
Re:EPA is allowing asbestos back into manufacturing by michaelmrose on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @02:23PM (#17709159)
The rich people and companies have more money than we have all we could do is slightly raise the stakes and still lose.
Re:EPA is allowing asbestos back into manufacturing by trhway on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @12:56PM (#17708329)
For that you need to stop produce idiot voters.
Re:EPA is allowing asbestos back into manufacturing by hanniabu on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @02:59PM (#17709523)
Well to be fair, it's difficult to be an educated voter since the candidates are allowed to say whatever they want in the election period and aren't beholden to follow through with the terms they were elected for.
Re:EPA is allowing asbestos back into manufacturing by dwd on Wednesday August 08, 2018 @03:44AM (#17713936)
This...

Electioneering should be treated the same as advertising and have the same penalties for making false or misleading statements.

Re:EPA is allowing asbestos back into manufacturing by peterwwillis on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @01:16PM (#17708511)
Exactly. Garbage in, garbage out. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jpWrsEpWgrc
Re:EPA is allowing asbestos back into manufacturing by CyberDildonics on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @01:03PM (#17708378)
I guess we shouldn't have any laws at all then.
Re:EPA is allowing asbestos back into manufacturing by vkou on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @01:26PM (#17708613)
And while we're at it, let's build the new Soviet man. The USSR only tried doing that for what, sixty years?

Your politicians aren't idiots, they rationally respond to the incentives in the system. What's broken is the system.

Re:EPA is allowing asbestos back into manufacturing by menacingly on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @12:41PM (#17708212)
I've always looked at money's influence in politics as a sort of balanced system, like the house and senate. We need both equal access to politics and proportional access to politics based on resources. Otherwise, democracy devolves into two me's and a Jeff Bezos voting on who pays for my stuff.
Re:EPA is allowing asbestos back into manufacturing by forapurpose on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @05:57PM (#17711228)
> We need both equal access to politics and proportional access to politics based on resources. Otherwise, democracy devolves into two me's and a Jeff Bezos voting on who pays for my stuff.

I've actually considered that, because it's effectively the status quo, but then I conclude: Why should wealthy people have special proportional access? There are so many more groups who are so much more at risk: Small business? Orphans? Groups facing systemic discrimination (women, minorities, LGBTQ)? Homeless? Minority party members in solid red/blue districts? People with rare diseases? With unpopular political beliefs? OpenBSD users? Wealthy people already have so much power and so many advantages; they might be the absolute last group that needs special protection.

Re:EPA is allowing asbestos back into manufacturing by xg15 on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @04:56PM (#17710721)
But now you have one you and 10000 Jeff Bezos' voting on how much tax Amazon should pay. Doesn't seem much better.
Re:EPA is allowing asbestos back into manufacturing by genericid on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @07:38PM (#17711922)
> Otherwise, democracy devolves into two me's and a Jeff Bezos voting on who pays for my stuff.

Democracy does not "devolve" into that, that is what democracy is.

Re:EPA is allowing asbestos back into manufacturing by a3n on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @12:06PM (#17707854)
Any attempt to ban lobbying would be heavily lobbied against.
Re:EPA is allowing asbestos back into manufacturing by TimTheTinker on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @01:09PM (#17708446)
Haha, yes - but so true.

Lobbyism forms a power structure that effectively cuts off and circumvents the will of the people. So by definition, it's actually a form of tyranny.

Re:EPA is allowing asbestos back into manufacturing by a3n on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @09:31PM (#17712492)
Mike Mulvaney, former House Rep and Trump's destroyer of agencies, said out loud that when he was in Congress he said out loud that he wouldn't talk to anyone unless they made a donation to his campaign. He also said out loud that other members of Congress should do the same.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mick_Mulvaney#Pay-to-play

Re:EPA is allowing asbestos back into manufacturing by jpindar on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @12:10PM (#17707886)
Would you include the ACLU, EFF, etc. in your ban?
Re:EPA is allowing asbestos back into manufacturing by Arubis on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @01:04PM (#17708386)
Yes; if lobbying were truly reduced/eliminated across the board, at least they'd have an even playing field. Loopholes will inevitably be used by those with the most money and power.
Re:EPA is allowing asbestos back into manufacturing by ateesdalejr on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @12:00PM (#17707792)
Do many technology companies (Facebook, Google, etc.) not use lobbying to fight for tech interests?
Re:EPA is allowing asbestos back into manufacturing by smolder on Wednesday August 08, 2018 @06:56AM (#17714770)
So? And you think tech companies lobby for nobler reasons than others? Not the case.
Re:EPA is allowing asbestos back into manufacturing by ericb on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @11:40AM (#17707606)
edited: Lobbying should be considered treasonous.
Re:EPA is allowing asbestos back into manufacturing by dang on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @12:03PM (#17707825)
Please don't post unsubstantive comments.
Re:EPA is allowing asbestos back into manufacturing by ericb on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @12:41PM (#17708207)
Would "should be considered" be more appropriate wording and less hyperbolic? I'm being serious.

I think cash contributions for legislation fundamentally subvert our democracy, and my comment was intended to raise that point for discussion. I don't see discussion of the perversion of democracy as unsubstantive.

Re:EPA is allowing asbestos back into manufacturing by dang on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @02:58PM (#17709514)
A substantive comment is one that contains information that people can learn from. Your comment I replied to was just name-calling.
Re:EPA is allowing asbestos back into manufacturing by fossuser on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @01:03PM (#17708383)
Not really, no - you need to expand on the why in order to have some sort of substantive discussion (especially when using politically loaded language).

Lobbying in its positive form is about experts trying to explain things to representatives that don't understand the specifics of the field. When done right a representative should get perspective from different areas and be able to understand the issues/regulations that are being discussed from multiple parties that have their own different incentives.

Your comment that's it's 'treasonous' absent any discussion doesn't really offer any explanation of how congressional representatives are supposed to be informed about any subject they don't already know about.

People that do this work are going to be paid by the companies trying to explain things.

Political contributions to campaigns are a different issue and I think do pose a corrupting influence, this talk does a good job explaining the issue: https://www.ted.com/talks/lawrence_lessig_we_the_people_and_...

Re:EPA is allowing asbestos back into manufacturing by ericb on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @01:26PM (#17708610)
I would argue that the advent of PAC's and Citizens United has more or less obsoleted the positive case--which you're right, I don't object too. What I mean is, if I'm a politician and two lobbyist show up "explaining" if I listen to the one from a PAC with the briefcase full of campaign contributions, in the next election I'm more likely to stay a politician, so there's now a selective pressure toward corruption on politicians. The same goes for promises of lucrative jobs (Ajit Pai). So lobbying in some senses is collapsing toward the lowest common denominator because the "positive form" players have their cards trumped.
Re:EPA is allowing asbestos back into manufacturing by fossuser on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @02:18PM (#17709110)
Yeah I agree that that's a problem (you'd probably like the video I linked in my original comment and his book Republic Lost).

I heard an interview on the Stay Tuned podcast (Preet Bharara's podcast) where he interviewed one of the lawyers that argued the winning side of citizen's united. It was an interesting interview and an over simplified summary was that the influence of campaign contributions which come from concentrated groups is a serious problem that needs to be dealt with, but putting government restrictions on speech in order to do it sets a dangerous precedent (at what point are you rich enough where you're no longer allowed to participate in political speech?).

Anyway - thanks for clarifying.

Re:EPA is allowing asbestos back into manufacturing by clairity on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @03:11PM (#17709619)
> “...the influence of campaign contributions which come from concentrated groups is a serious problem that needs to be dealt with, but putting government restrictions on speech in order to do it sets a dangerous precedent”

that’s an interesting perspective on citizen’s united worth mulling over.

but while speech is free from governmental limits, it is not protected from the response of other citizens. it’s still problematic that political contributions can be hidden behind organizations to shield the wealthy from the consequences of their speech.

citizens—nay, people—are equal in the eyes of the constitution (as affirmed in the bill of rights), and moneyed citizens are not entitled to unequal, government-protected veils from such consequences.

this is part of the larger discussion around who gets a public (media) voice and in what proportion. it seems an argument can be made that constitutionally, that proportion should correlate to the population (one person, one vote; not one dollar, one vote). we can defer to representatives to voice our opinions for us, but they should do so with only the aggregate backing of the citizens standing behind them. (then you also have to deal with the tyranny of the majority issues arising therefrom).

Re:EPA is allowing asbestos back into manufacturing by fossuser on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @03:30PM (#17709791)
I agree that you shouldn't be able to obscure where the speech is coming from - some of the laws around television ads were supposed to help with this, but because of the organization thing you mention they're mostly of the form "paid for by people for a better tomorrow" or something else equally useless.

Ultimately I think that was what the decision was about - that there need to be better controls and fixes for how campaign finance currently works, but that the citizen's united solution (that lost) was not the safe way to do it.

Re:EPA is allowing asbestos back into manufacturing by a1369209993 on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @01:43PM (#17708769)
> you need to expand on the why

The US Constitution defines treason thus:

> Treason against the United States, shall consist [...] in adhering to their Enemies, giving them Aid and Comfort.

If you assume the US is a democracy[0], ie that its enemies are the enemies of its citizens, rather than its nobility^Wgovernment, then any politician who passes laws at the request of (or otherwise Aids and Comforts) eg Facebook, Dow Chemical, [insert human-rights-violating corporation here], is de facto guilty of treason.

You could certainly argue that treason means something other than what the constitution says it does, but taken at face value this is rather obvious.

0: If you don't, then that's a different discussion.

Re:EPA is allowing asbestos back into manufacturing by fossuser on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @02:24PM (#17709176)
This is a dramatic oversimplification and somewhat beside the point.

The US is a republic/representative democracy, but that aside working with organizations to pass laws isn't zero sum - laws can be good for organizations and the public. If Google is lobbying to prevent the government from passing key escrow laws that weaken encryption that's better for everyone.

These companies are also made up of citizens and a part of the society (not enemies of the government or the people) - working with experts in the field to try and understand things better isn't 'de facto treason'.

Re:EPA is allowing asbestos back into manufacturing by rayiner on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @01:29PM (#17708642)
The unhinged emotional reaction to asbestos in this thread is a good example of why lobbying is important. There is a cost-benefit analysis to be done for products containing asbestos, just like for any other product. Lobbyists present that analysis to the regulator. The alternative is regulation by knee jerk reaction, which undermines to point of regulatory agencies.
Re:EPA is allowing asbestos back into manufacturing by omegaworks on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @01:47PM (#17708810)
This would be fine if the dollar-cost value of usage of these toxic materials actually represented the health and wellbeing of a population. Putting a dollar value on health has never been a simple proposition.

In many of these cases, these costs are externalized; they are borne by (healthcare, communal, familial) systems outside the industry where the asbestos is used. Only where a link can be definitively traced back to the industry itself can these costs begin to be rectified.

That the EPA allows this represents a shift in our society, that the costs to life and wellbeing are to be borne by the individual worker exposed to the chemical and not the manufacturer of the chemical or the employer cutting costs by not using alternatives.

Re:EPA is allowing asbestos back into manufacturing by tortasaur on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @10:07PM (#17712660)
How is this a shift in our society? When in recent history has this not been the standard?
Re:EPA is allowing asbestos back into manufacturing by omegaworks on Wednesday August 08, 2018 @02:39PM (#17718284)
Strong unions in the post-war era kept it at bay, but those have been declining in power.

Cost externalization has always been there. It's inherent in capitalist systems, and it lurked silently under the covers of neoliberalism for the past several administrations.

The change is its shift from covert to overt under this administration. They've saturated our ability to cover scandal, so they're no longer maintaining the facade.

Re:EPA is allowing asbestos back into manufacturing by jdietrich on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @02:30PM (#17709237)
Every lobbyist is going to present an analysis that concludes "our client's product is the best thing since sliced bread". They commission dodgy research, they fudge figures, they gloss over unflattering facts and emphasise others, because that's their job.

Regulators in other developed nations have concluded that while asbestos may have some marginal advantages in certain use-cases, the externalities are immensely expensive. There are plenty of good, cheap, safe substitutes for asbestos.