News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:EPA is allowing asbestos back into manufacturing by rayiner on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @01:29PM (#17708642)
The unhinged emotional reaction to asbestos in this thread is a good example of why lobbying is important. There is a cost-benefit analysis to be done for products containing asbestos, just like for any other product. Lobbyists present that analysis to the regulator. The alternative is regulation by knee jerk reaction, which undermines to point of regulatory agencies.
Re:EPA is allowing asbestos back into manufacturing by omegaworks on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @01:47PM (#17708810)
This would be fine if the dollar-cost value of usage of these toxic materials actually represented the health and wellbeing of a population. Putting a dollar value on health has never been a simple proposition.

In many of these cases, these costs are externalized; they are borne by (healthcare, communal, familial) systems outside the industry where the asbestos is used. Only where a link can be definitively traced back to the industry itself can these costs begin to be rectified.

That the EPA allows this represents a shift in our society, that the costs to life and wellbeing are to be borne by the individual worker exposed to the chemical and not the manufacturer of the chemical or the employer cutting costs by not using alternatives.

Re:EPA is allowing asbestos back into manufacturing by tortasaur on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @10:07PM (#17712660)
How is this a shift in our society? When in recent history has this not been the standard?
Re:EPA is allowing asbestos back into manufacturing by omegaworks on Wednesday August 08, 2018 @02:39PM (#17718284)
Strong unions in the post-war era kept it at bay, but those have been declining in power.

Cost externalization has always been there. It's inherent in capitalist systems, and it lurked silently under the covers of neoliberalism for the past several administrations.

The change is its shift from covert to overt under this administration. They've saturated our ability to cover scandal, so they're no longer maintaining the facade.

Re:EPA is allowing asbestos back into manufacturing by jdietrich on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @02:30PM (#17709237)
Every lobbyist is going to present an analysis that concludes "our client's product is the best thing since sliced bread". They commission dodgy research, they fudge figures, they gloss over unflattering facts and emphasise others, because that's their job.

Regulators in other developed nations have concluded that while asbestos may have some marginal advantages in certain use-cases, the externalities are immensely expensive. There are plenty of good, cheap, safe substitutes for asbestos.