News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Sci-Hub Proves That Piracy Can Be Dangerously Useful by TACIXAT on Saturday August 04, 2018 @07:01PM (#17688843)
I know this is a controversial view, but how much progress has been lost to intellectual property in general? I do not think the temporary monopoly on an idea incentives innovation. If it does, it encourages the people who I don't want to be innovating in the first place. If someone sees that as attractive they will probably take other anti-competitive steps once in a position of power.

If people were free to copy ideas and products, we would make an extraordinary amount of progress in a very short time.

Re:Sci-Hub Proves That Piracy Can Be Dangerously Useful by projektir on Saturday August 04, 2018 @07:10PM (#17688880)
I would say the motivation is important. We do not live in a society where one can simply do a lot of work and see nothing for it without consequence. The problem is not originally with intellectual property, the problem is that every person has to justify their right to exist, and they do that through acquiring money by some means, which means a big chunk of what they're doing has to be concerned with acquiring money. Things like research and innovation take a lot of time.

We already have somewhat of this situation in reality. Many people involved in research a very poorly paid. Is it really resulting in better/faster research, or just people moving from academia to industry, and a lot of benefits pocketed by side actors?

> If it does, it encourages the people who I don't want to be innovating in the first place.

I.e., people who do not have lots of resources and need to figure out how to survive? You only want to see innovation from rich people with nice safety nets?

Re:Sci-Hub Proves That Piracy Can Be Dangerously Useful by komali2 on Saturday August 04, 2018 @08:11PM (#17689027)
In my mind, it boils down to an extremely simple question - if money didn't exist, and you didn't have to work to stay alive, would people do job x or job y?

The answer for many jobs is yes. We know this because volunteers exist, personal projects exist, people help each other fix their roofs and cars and fridges, etc.

In a society like this, things might move a little more slowly (probably we wouldn't have the airline or public Transit systems we have now), but things would absolutely still get done.

Re:Sci-Hub Proves That Piracy Can Be Dangerously Useful by projektir on Saturday August 04, 2018 @09:44PM (#17689262)
> The answer for many jobs is yes. We know this because volunteers exist, personal projects exist, people help each other fix their roofs and cars and fridges, etc.

Volunteers and especially personal projects really strike me as activities one undertakes when they have secondary means of survival and/or safety nets. The latter is commonly mentioned as problematic in terms of requiring GitHubs from job applicants.

The existence of these people is not sufficient, we also have to prove that these people are not distributed in some highly biased way, which I suspect, they are. There could be a lot of consequence to such biases. For instance, software developers creating software that blind people can't use.

Re:Sci-Hub Proves That Piracy Can Be Dangerously Useful by peterburkimsher on Saturday August 04, 2018 @11:46PM (#17689558)
I've done personal projects precisely because I don't have another safety net.

Posting my projects here on Hacker News gets attention, which might possibly lead to a job offer. (In practice this doesn't work all the time, but it's been more successful in the past than trying to cold-email HR departments). I think personal projects show my interests and skills better than interviews.

On that note, I am looking for work, and I'll do your (2 month) project for free just to get a reference letter. The 2 month limit is because I'll be out of cash by then.

Re:Sci-Hub Proves That Piracy Can Be Dangerously Useful by TeMPOraL on Sunday August 05, 2018 @10:19AM (#17691424)
> For instance, software developers creating software that blind people can't use.

I think you'll have much better luck with such things with the hobby group. Commercial software is done by focusing on tasks that make money. Blind people are unlikely to make you money, unless you fall under regulations that will fine you for not catering for this group. Hobby software is focused on making the actual artifact, the program, better. Getting it accessible to blind users is clearly making it better.

Re:Sci-Hub Proves That Piracy Can Be Dangerously Useful by nine_k on Sunday August 05, 2018 @10:38AM (#17691530)
There are places where money doesn't exist, and you don't have to work to stay alive. There are still tribes in Amazon area in Brazil who live by hunting and gathering.

I'm not sure if you find their social, cultural, and material progress sufficient for your taste.

Re:Sci-Hub Proves That Piracy Can Be Dangerously Useful by vor0nwe on Sunday August 05, 2018 @12:43PM (#17692126)
How is hunting and gathering not working?
Re:Sci-Hub Proves That Piracy Can Be Dangerously Useful by chongli on Sunday August 05, 2018 @04:00PM (#17693196)
No one is paying them to do it. That's the difference. Our society has drawn a line in the sand: if you're not getting paid for it, it's not work.

This is why people completely discount volunteering, childcare, elder care, community associations, and more when they talk about the economy. If it's not earning a profit for somebody, it's not considered work.

Re:Sci-Hub Proves That Piracy Can Be Dangerously Useful by nine_k on Sunday August 05, 2018 @07:45PM (#17694200)
It's not "work" in the sense that you're not hired and told what to do. You fend for yourself, this way or another, fishing today, picking fruit tomorrow, etc.

But it of course is not living without any labor at all, Eden-style.

Re:Sci-Hub Proves That Piracy Can Be Dangerously Useful by edanm on Saturday August 04, 2018 @09:49PM (#17689277)
I mean, you're kind of framing it as a yes or no situation. It's more a question of degree.

And you could theoretically look at history before the modern concept of capitalism to see what gets done and what doesn't. I'd argue that saying we didn't have airplanes is underselling it by quite a bit - we went through how many centuries in which things barely progressed? And I'm talking things like "kids not doing quite as much".

Re:Sci-Hub Proves That Piracy Can Be Dangerously Useful by FranzFerdiNaN on Sunday August 05, 2018 @01:22PM (#17692339)
Things progressed and changed every single century. Just not like some it happens in a tech tree in a computer game. Unfortunately history gets taught as something that is teleological, with things only having value if they bring them closer to what we consider important. So people look at multiple centuries of scholastic thought and proclaim ''well, that was a waste of time!" because it wasnt the scientific method.
Re:Sci-Hub Proves That Piracy Can Be Dangerously Useful by Jagat on Sunday August 05, 2018 @12:22AM (#17689646)
I find it hard to believe that people would just band together and volunteer to build things without a monetary (or an equivalent) incentive.

Say, we're at the beginning of the neolithic age, and our village has just discovered agriculture, and the magic of iron ploughs. We already have food supply enough for 6 months.

There's just one small farm left, someone needs to go mine for iron ores, and someone needs to plough the fields, someone needs to sow the seeds.

One person 'volunteers' to do all three tasks because they couldn't agree on who'll do the mining.

The village decides to feed this guy while he does all these things, because he can't hunt while he's working. The 'volunteer' realizes that he could share part of his food with someone else in exchange for some help with iron ore mining and plough-building.

Ok we're now back to the monetary system.

Re:Sci-Hub Proves That Piracy Can Be Dangerously Useful by nine_k on Sunday August 05, 2018 @10:44AM (#17691565)
People absolutely band together and volunteer to build things without a financial or other material incentive. They do it for fun, from open-source projects to festivals like Burning Man.

The catch is, of course, that they do so after having secured the material means for that. You don't go play music just for fun is you're starving. But when you reliably are not starving, you can find resources for having fun.

maslow-pyramid.png should be attached here.

Re:Sci-Hub Proves That Piracy Can Be Dangerously Useful by Jagat on Sunday August 05, 2018 @12:16PM (#17691999)
Completely agree. I was responding to OPs assertion that even that is not necessary.
Re:Sci-Hub Proves That Piracy Can Be Dangerously Useful by ratacat on Sunday August 05, 2018 @03:43AM (#17690223)
You're coming at it with a framework of thinking that has already been immersed in present ideas about money. Check out, Debt: the first five thousand years. We tend to under estimate how differently people of different time periods and cultures think.
Re:Sci-Hub Proves That Piracy Can Be Dangerously Useful by akqu on Saturday August 04, 2018 @07:54PM (#17688986)
The problem with intellectual property is that it favors the sum, rather than the rate, of innovation. Companies have a natural incentive not to innovate. Since you make profit by not spending the revenue of your previous innovation on new innovation. If you want to have continuous innovation the profit should instead be based on your rate of innovation. Meaning that you don't get a monopoly on past achievements. That is how you don't have to wait decades for new cars or rockets while people with spreadsheets calculate their most opportune moment to start innovating again.
Re:Sci-Hub Proves That Piracy Can Be Dangerously Useful by brownbat on Sunday August 05, 2018 @04:25AM (#17690334)
It's weird how different graphics cards are from pharmaceuticals. Both have big startup and research costs, but GPUs are basically obsolete in a couple years, they run the supply out and constantly plan to move to the next model. Pharma you can do that, or build a portfolio and collect rents for a while.

It's weird that patent durations are one sized fits all, even though how long you can capture value is completely dependent on the industry.

Re:Sci-Hub Proves That Piracy Can Be Dangerously Useful by TACIXAT on Saturday August 04, 2018 @10:10PM (#17689334)
Where did you get that I want to only see innovation from rich people? I explain in the next sentence the type of people who I do not want in positions of power, those who take anti-competitive steps. I do not think that is at all synonymous with people who have no resources. You put those people in power and they fuck their workers.

Anyway, even with temporary monopolies, the legal system is stacked in the favor of those with money, so I don't really see how that helps people with no resources.

Re:Sci-Hub Proves That Piracy Can Be Dangerously Useful by incompatible on Saturday August 04, 2018 @11:56PM (#17689587)
There's nothing wrong with people getting paid for doing good work, and nothing wrong with that work being widely available, for free, to everybody who can use it. The problem is fixation on an economic system that simply doesn't work in every situation. Information shouldn't be packaged and artificially rationed just so that it can be crammed into a market model.
Re:Sci-Hub Proves That Piracy Can Be Dangerously Useful by intended on Sunday August 05, 2018 @01:07AM (#17689797)
The thing is it’s not just people.

Corporations are shifting copyright law to their favor.

And as institutions they can do things that individuals can’t. Like aggregate content and become forces of nature in their own right.

Re:Sci-Hub Proves That Piracy Can Be Dangerously Useful by dredmorbius on Saturday August 04, 2018 @10:10PM (#17689333)
Property is theft.

Property rights are predicated on exclusion. This is especially true of intellectual property.

Todays patent wars (yes, I'm aware the present article addresses copyright) feel new, but in fact are merely echoes of earlier abuses -- Watt's stem engine patents and extension (1770s), Westinghous, Edison and lightbulbs, or Norbert Wiener's lifelong excoriation of AT&T, refeereenced in this brief video clip:

https://youtube.com/watch?v=ys4XEtVcTFI

Copyright carries absolutely massive deadweight losses.

Re:Sci-Hub Proves That Piracy Can Be Dangerously Useful by anticensor on Sunday August 05, 2018 @04:12AM (#17690302)
If you abolish all property rights, all social trust would eradicate. I also think intellectual property is nonsense, but you cannot easily extend that notion into all kinds of property.
Re:Sci-Hub Proves That Piracy Can Be Dangerously Useful by dredmorbius on Sunday August 05, 2018 @04:54AM (#17690411)
We can debate what property rights we do or don't care to maintain, or how to offset their harms -- taxes on wealth, IP renewals, and the like, would likely help, for example.

The principle of private land ownership, as distinguished from either common holdings or a tenancy granted by (usually) royal charter, is fairly novel. And the distortionary consequences of rents amongst the oldest and most pernicious problems in economics.

http://www.henrygeorge.org/pchp29.htm

But it is not possible to argue against property's very mechanism. It is a grant of right of exclusion under legal sanction.

Proudhon's original words on this are well worth reading, if an unpopular opinion these days.

[dead]
Re:Sci-Hub Proves That Piracy Can Be Dangerously Useful by dang on Saturday August 04, 2018 @09:05PM (#17689173)
Please keep nationalistic flamewar off HN.
Re:Sci-Hub Proves That Piracy Can Be Dangerously Useful by edanm on Saturday August 04, 2018 @09:53PM (#17689282)
> I know this is a controversial view, but how much progress has been lost to intellectual property in general? I do not think the temporary monopoly on an idea incentives innovation.

Why not? You're saying things that seem to fly in the face of what almost any economist thinks, that fly in the face of common sense, and that fly in the face of actually asking people why they do what they do.

So why do you think what you're saying is true?

Re:Sci-Hub Proves That Piracy Can Be Dangerously Useful by TACIXAT on Saturday August 04, 2018 @10:07PM (#17689324)
From personal experience, which I know is not a great indicator, but if it holds true then it would be the society I want to live in (which biases me to the idea).

I like to build, a lot. I'm obsessive about it. I would like to build something useful, have it picked up freely, then move on to the next thing that I think would make a difference. I think a lot of innovators are like this. People like money, of course, but I think the builders would still build with no competitive protections.

Re:Sci-Hub Proves That Piracy Can Be Dangerously Useful by edanm on Sunday August 05, 2018 @12:36AM (#17689687)
Well, I'd love to live in that society too, but like you say, that's not really indicative. And remember, the question isn't just whether builders like you will build cool things. It's whether builders that build boring but marginally useful products will build them. Lots of people will still build games, but how many will still build web applications for helping perform tax audits for lawyers? Sure biologists would still do interesting work, but how many of them will personally put up the millions of dollars in funding necessary to create drugs that sightly improve some patient outcomes?

I'm not saying patents are implemented perfectly right now, or that there aren't better possible alternatives (and I think at least one of my examples is a case where things usually aren't protected by patents). But I think it's wrong to assume that innovation will happen At the same rate if you remove most of the money in it.

(and again, just look at the history here - almost all innovation for hundreds of years came from the few really privileged few who could do innovation for fun, afaict)

Re:Sci-Hub Proves That Piracy Can Be Dangerously Useful by civilitty on Sunday August 05, 2018 @04:51AM (#17690400)
The same people who are investing in biotech now would be the ones investing in it then.

Inventors may do it for fun but capital needs to generate an ROI to justify its existence and in a growth obsessed global economy, scientific and technological progress leading to spending power increases is the only reliable growth mechanism. Massive underinvestmet in long term prospects and over reliance on government granted monopolies is a symptom of our IP system, not an argument for its existence.

Re:Sci-Hub Proves That Piracy Can Be Dangerously Useful by edanm on Sunday August 05, 2018 @05:06AM (#17690437)
I'm... not sure where we disagree? Except for your first and last sentences?

I mean, the whole point of granting a monopoly is to give incentives to investors to invest in biotech, so that they can reap the reward of it. You haven't explained why an investor will choose to invest in something at the same level, if they aren't able to get the same money back for it?

If a drug company didn't have a monopoly, the generics that drive down the price of the drug would be out the day after the drug, thus ruining most potential profits. Therefore, developing new drugs wouldn't be worth as much money, so less people will invest in it. You seem to completely agree with this point when you write: "Inventors may do it for fun but capital needs to generate an ROI to justify its existence and in a growth obsessed global economy, scientific and technological progress leading to spending power increases is the only reliable growth mechanism."

The whole (practical) idea of the capitalistic system in e.g. the US is to align private incentives with public incentives, so if someone develops a worthwhile drug (or e.g. writes a good book), they will be able to receive a reward for it. Just because scientific and tech progress is the only growth mechanism, doesn't give any one specific investor the incentive to invest in it (I forget the technical term for it, it's a kind of commons problem).

Again, I'm not sure I understand you, because you seem to be saying something similar, but coming to a completely different conclusion?

Re:Sci-Hub Proves That Piracy Can Be Dangerously Useful by TACIXAT on Sunday August 05, 2018 @09:20PM (#17694541)
Ok, I was writing a reply and I got to talking about how we do not have perfect markets, we do not have infinite suppliers that would drive the profit to zero. That actually got me asking an interesting question, do we have "infinite supply"? Do we have the means to produce medicine for everyone?

This might put a finger on a weird feeling I have about the economy right now. We have a trillion dollar company that is producing easily copied electronics (their operating system is harder to replicate), we have very drugs that can be easily ripped off into generics, we have media that commands hundred plus dollar a month subscriptions that can be readily shared online. I guess the feeling that I can finally put to words is that all of this stuff is horribly mispriced.

Would there be a single initial investment? No, probably not. There would still be profit opportunity though. Innovation would be spread between more parties. Rather than one company doing huge amounts of R&D it would be many individuals making incremental improvements, to address their own needs or to address profit opportunities. It is the same with software ideas, I could tell you my most brilliant idea (give up my monopoly) but the chances that you would go and implement it are low. Not everyone is going to be producing generics, not everyone can, not everyone wants to. The profit does not go to zero, hopefully it would just go to affordable.

Re:Sci-Hub Proves That Piracy Can Be Dangerously Useful by jasonkostempski on Sunday August 05, 2018 @07:53AM (#17690871)
"but how many will still build web applications for helping perform tax audits for lawyers?"

Maybe we're better off without that software. Or maybe its useful enough that a group of IRS agents and lawyers would still be willing to pay somebody to build it, even though they don't get new "IP" out of it.

Re:Sci-Hub Proves That Piracy Can Be Dangerously Useful by TeMPOraL on Sunday August 05, 2018 @10:22AM (#17691451)
I think it would be built. Were my SO a corporate lawyer, I'd sure as hell built her software to make her life easier. At scale, there's probably always someone on this planet with some basic programming skills that's a close friend or a partner to a person in any possible occupation.
Re:Sci-Hub Proves That Piracy Can Be Dangerously Useful by edanm on Sunday August 05, 2018 @08:12AM (#17690928)
But then we might be ruling out a whole host of products, because of the incentive problems. No one person has the incentive to fund the entire development of the software, since it's prohibitively expensive. But if offered at a much lower charge, they would use it.

I mean, would you fund the development of MacOS / Windows by yourself, just so you can use it? (Keep in mind that person #2 can then free-ride on your funding and buy it practically at cost, since why not?).

Or let's take the argument to books. I assume most people wouldn't fund someone's salary for a year to write a book. But I really enjoy the end result of the fact that someone can write a book, then spread their costs on thousands of people. (I'm not too worried about the JK Rowling's of the world, btw, I'm worried about a mid-level author, not someone who is rich in our world, someone who manages to make a decent living off of a back-catalogue of dozens of stories and books. They're the ones who are usually the most hurt). You can of course extend this argument to things that cost a lot more to produce - movies, music, etc. Many things we value would not have been produced, simply because of lack of incentives (or lack of time while these people do some other job to earn money).

You can certainly think of alternative methods of funding these things, but they have their own problem. E.g. something like Patreon, which in some ways is a homage to how things were funded before modern capitalism - a rich patron would fund specific artists to produce great works.

And that's great! I love Patreon, and support numerous very deserving creators on there. But this has problems too - for one, some things are too expensive to do this way (e.g. most movies). For another, patronage gives a huge preference to things people know will work (how many people will fund drug-research to the tune of billions, with a small chance of success?). And patronage gives a preference to things people knowingly prefer - and again, we miss out on the mid-level artists of today scraping by, who can't get a large enough following, but still get some fans (and who potentially turn out to later be considered geniuses).

I'm not saying IP is perfect, and I certainly don't agree with all the things done for it (like the numerous extensions to IP which might not make sense). And our current system has issues too! We "missed" artists like Van Gogh, after all. I'm just saying that taking an un-nuanced view at this and concluding "IP is terrible, let's just get rid of it" is, in my mind, incredibly wrongheaded, at least if you believe that it won't significantly change the amount of stuff produced for the worse. You might have reasons to prefer that anyway, I suppose, but let's first understand the actual effects of throwing out IP law.

Re:Sci-Hub Proves That Piracy Can Be Dangerously Useful by icebraining on Sunday August 05, 2018 @12:00PM (#17691933)
how many will still build web applications for helping perform tax audits for lawyers?

Enough. During my professional life, the software companies I worked for built business software like that, and we licensed it under A/LGPL. Much of it actually published online for everyone to use.

Instead of relying from rents based on IP, we simply got paid ahead of time to build new applications, or change existing ones. Lawyers would simply do the same if they need that software, either individually or as a group. Crowdfunding works too (even for B2B software!).

Re:Sci-Hub Proves That Piracy Can Be Dangerously Useful by Matticus_Rex on Saturday August 04, 2018 @11:48PM (#17689562)
I'd be more careful about asserting that about economists. Economists are much more likely than most people to be anti-IP, and IP abolitionism is a respectable opinion among mainstream economists (see Boldrin & Levine's Against Intellectual Monopoly for the most prominent example.

Now, "most economists" are not anti-IP, because most economists have never read a paper even touching on the economics of IP. And while the literature is pretty damning, it's not one of those integrated conclusions of the field that every economist gets taught in school, like the idiocy of rent control.

Re:Sci-Hub Proves That Piracy Can Be Dangerously Useful by edanm on Sunday August 05, 2018 @12:27AM (#17689658)
Interesting! How wonder how mainstream is ip abolitionism. I'm not an economist, but do read a lot of economics and haven't really run across this argument. It seems to make little sense to me, but I'd like to try and dig in to their data on this.
Re:Sci-Hub Proves That Piracy Can Be Dangerously Useful by benchaney on Saturday August 04, 2018 @10:28PM (#17689387)
Basic economic theory says that monopolies lead to less innovation and poor service, so I don’t see how you could honestly claim that avoiding creating monopolies “flies in the face of what almost and economist thinks”.
Re:Sci-Hub Proves That Piracy Can Be Dangerously Useful by Matticus_Rex on Saturday August 04, 2018 @11:49PM (#17689570)
Especially not if he'd looked at the economics literature on the question, which is at best tepid on the question of whether IP has a net positive effect, and at worst an outright rejection of its validity on historical, empirical, and theoretical grounds.
Re:Sci-Hub Proves That Piracy Can Be Dangerously Useful by edanm on Sunday August 05, 2018 @12:16AM (#17689630)
Basic economic theory also says that incentives matter. And that all things considered equal, if the value you can extract from a good goes down, so does the amount of that good provided. In this case, the good bring innovation.
Re:Sci-Hub Proves That Piracy Can Be Dangerously Useful by betterunix2 on Saturday August 04, 2018 @10:44PM (#17689418)
I can only speak for my own field, cryptography, where patents have slowed the deployment of new techniques and by extension reduced the insights and feedback we can gain from real-world users. Economists' models for human behavior and their understanding of incentives do sometimes fail.
Re:Sci-Hub Proves That Piracy Can Be Dangerously Useful by ratacat on Sunday August 05, 2018 @03:49AM (#17690239)
I think the more correct version is something like...

Economists models for human behavior do sometimes work.