Re:Sci-Hub Proves That Piracy Can Be Dangerously Useful
by anticensor on Sunday August 05, 2018 @04:12AM
(#17690302)
If you abolish all property rights, all social trust would eradicate. I also think intellectual property is nonsense, but you cannot easily extend that notion into all kinds of property.
Re:Sci-Hub Proves That Piracy Can Be Dangerously Useful
by dredmorbius on Sunday August 05, 2018 @04:54AM
(#17690411)
We can debate what property rights we do or don't care to maintain, or how to offset their harms -- taxes on wealth, IP renewals, and the like, would likely help, for example.
The principle of private land ownership, as distinguished from either common holdings or a tenancy granted by (usually) royal charter, is fairly novel. And the distortionary consequences of rents amongst the oldest and most pernicious problems in economics.
http://www.henrygeorge.org/pchp29.htm
But it is not possible to argue against property's very mechanism. It is a grant of right of exclusion under legal sanction.
Proudhon's original words on this are well worth reading, if an unpopular opinion these days.
Property rights are predicated on exclusion. This is especially true of intellectual property.
Todays patent wars (yes, I'm aware the present article addresses copyright) feel new, but in fact are merely echoes of earlier abuses -- Watt's stem engine patents and extension (1770s), Westinghous, Edison and lightbulbs, or Norbert Wiener's lifelong excoriation of AT&T, refeereenced in this brief video clip:
https://youtube.com/watch?v=ys4XEtVcTFI
Copyright carries absolutely massive deadweight losses.