The true 3 year old behavior on display here is the market behavior you're advocating: ignoring a potential long term problem in favor of a short term gain.
Environmental toxins are not something to be cavalier about. Once soil gets contaminated, it's damned hard and expensive to clean up. Land is one of the single most limited resources we have. We can ultimately live with out lithium ion batteries. We can change our behavior, use other electrical sources, or as the article argues for, find other sources of electrode material.
We cannot live with out clean soil in which to grow healthy food. Or on which to live.
It sounds romantic but is it really ? Even agricultural land is relatively cheap and there are more scarce resources that are needed for development.
Water and soil in particular are very important resources to protect, far beyond their price in economic terms. They are vital strategic assets because so much of our economy and ecology depend on them.
We see this with oil prices. The price across the demand/supply balance point is nothing like linear.
There are plenty of mechanism to stabilize the price, plenty of alternative ways to produce food as price increases just like with Oil
Lithium ion batteries are incredibly important if we want to make a fast transition to green energy. The environmental calculus is 100% in favor of finding a thorium disposal site and making rare earths / lithium cheaper now, rather than being picky about where minerals are mined and pumping way more CO2 into the air due to the delay
Localized thorium pollution is something that we can manage and deal with. Global warming, especially if it reaches a runaway tipping point, could displace a billion people, cause massive famines, and destroy tens of trillions of dollars of infrastructure and assets. Also consider that localized thorium pollution would probably be on-par with the pollution from washing coal, which is what would be replaced
Thought we reached that a long time ago, and yet things haven't really changed.
Also things have changed. Something like 10 of the hottest years on record have been within the last 15 years. Global warming is not simply a modeled prediction, it is very much measurable and ongoing
Is that based on straight up measurements, or based on measurements that were adjusted based on a realization that the measuring method was flawed to begin with? Aren't the adjustments based on a best guess by people that may have a bias?
And of course Toxic is not a problem because most of the metals a rare earth mine would deal with would be toxic.
You can actually find heavily concentrated earth in the US that would basically count as nuclear waste because nuclear policy is so insane.
Eh, you're technically correct in the sense that you can also make a bed out of asbestos and sleep on it and be fine, as long as it doesn't become airborne. Sure, you won't get thorium in your system as quickly but it's still a material that you probably don't want in your household or in the environment in general if you don't need it.
I do agree that in the general sense fears of radioactivity are exaggerated, and even then only selectively: those scanners we installed at all airports in the last decade will also cause more incidences of cancer, but you hardly ever hear anyone about that.
What should be feared more is the mining industry not giving a shit about human health, the environment or, for the lack of a better term, "the commons".
If the waste of the mining industry ends up in the groundwater we do have a big problem. And in practice this is not an "if", it's a "when", or even "how long will it take before they are found out this time and still get away with it".
Right; because compared to the radiation dose you get during the flight itself, it's nothing.
So not having a domestic rare earth industry because of thorium regulation is totally insane.
It's like lead in car batteries. Lead is incredibly toxic, but is mostly safe in that application, as there is a very tight chain of custody for batteries and good recycling programs.
You might look here [0]. A great quote about the radiation levels: "Searching for uranium is in some ways easier than for other mineral resources because the radiation signature of uranium's decay products allows deposits to be identified and mapped from the air."
Key phrase:
mapped from the air
That's a pretty high level.[0] http://www.world-nuclear.org/information-library/nuclear-fue...
the benefit is that you can directly tell that it's uranium due to it giving off specific wavelengths, vs with diamonds, you need significant interpretation of the data to look for not-diamonds and hope that there are diamonds there too
CA: San Bernardino, Shasta, Rancho Cucamonga and Near Primm (35.478098,-115.532034)
MT: Place called Rye Near Ravalli. Could not locate it manually, and the coordinates were listed incorrectly as 46.015278,-114.171389. Directions: "Turn east off of Highway 93 onto Tanner Ave. Follow it until it dead ends and turn right onto dirt road and follow it for approx 1/4 mile into mine site."
NV: Esmeralda, Churchill, Pershing (38.119167,-117.993611)
OR: Coos
UT: Salt Lake (itself?)
WA: Stevens, Grant
At the levels where it is recommended that you remediate your home, your likelihood of dying from lung cancer is equivalent to dying in a car accident. That's potentially 50 people a year when you look at a population of 200,000 people.
You need rare earth for batteries as well, also for many other things in the new electric transport infrastructure.
This is a pervasive and utterly false idea. There are no rare earth elements in li-ion batteries and never have been. It's a weird kind of free-association that people think so.
Also, nickel and cobalt mining are completely different from rare earth mining. The only rare earth element used in EVs in any significant amount is neodymium, about 1.6 kg in 200-300 horsepower PM motors. Induction motors, like those in the Model S and X, use none at all. Neodymium is entirely replaceable for EVs and has perhaps a 1% impact on range. If it becomes expensive it won't be used.
According to the USGS the US has enough mapped, recoverable neodymium for 1 billion EVs[1]. Australia already produces enough for over 10 million cars per year.
[1]: https://minerals.usgs.gov/minerals/pubs/commodity/rare_earth...
That would be like saying in 1800 that Britain will not use domestic coal because they want to save it.
It's not a limited resource problem but a profitability problem. Think the main article's point is that you probably want to research diversifying now before a resource squeeze forces you to catch-up.
The history of mining in the West can be pieced together from hundreds of different online sources. The BLM spins the story that all the old mines have all been worked out and that is why they were abandoned, which is believable, but certainly not the case, although some mines have been worked out.
http://www.miningartifacts.org/Mining-Photo-Index.html has a brief history of mining by state.
Executive Order 6102 made it illegal for a U.S. Citizens to hold or own more than $100 in gold; coins, bullion or otherwise. It allowed the Federal government to seize gold and required citizens to turn in all of their gold, at the face value of $20.67 per ounce, or face up to 10 years in Prison and or a $10,000 fine.
Later Executive order L-208 essentially banned all non-essential mining operations. Gold and Silver mines being paramount on that list. Later expensive bonds were required before a new mine could be cut, which limited new mining to well funded mining companies. All of these contributed to the end of most small scale mining.
Source: https://plus.google.com/+NationalbureauofminesOrg1/posts/fDh...
1971 475 closures
1972 725 "
1973 692 "
1974 455 "
1975 711 "
1976 1,406 "
1977 1,248 "
1978 2,750 "
1979 5,378 "
1980 4,232 "
1981 2,901 "
1982 3,681 "
1983 2,598 "
1984 2,990 "
1985 4,401 "
1986 2,539 "
1987 1,944 "
1988 2,007 "
1989 1,855 "
1990 1,805 "
1991 1,879 "
1992 1,705 "
1993 1,425 "
1994 1,329 "
1995 1,212 "
1996 1,116 "
1997 1,013 "
1998 994 "
1999 1,151 "
2000 1,041 "
2001 1,368 "
2002 1,521 "
2003 1,450 "
2004 1,266 "
2005 1,298 "
2006 1,431 "
2007 1,465 "
2008 1,564 "
2009 1,664 "
2010 1,669 "
2011 1,894 "
2012 2,371 "
2013 2,752 "
2014 3,636 "
2015 2,622 "
So overall, a fairly steady figure. I imagine they'd go at it until a mine was played out, at least in the economic/profitability sense.
Rare earth contained lots of Thorium and that has to be handled as nuclear waste and that means you have 1000s of tons of nuclear waste on your hands. This is of course completely idiotic because Thorium not really a big problem as it is not radioactive.
The few Rare Earth mines that do exist only extract the lower group so you can avoid the Thorium.
Because the US drives policy for the whole West, there is basically no Rare Earth mining in the West.
China on the other hand understands that the more expensive rare earths are outside of China the more likely people will manufacture in China.
While I am 100% with Simons (one of the best economists ever) the unlimited stupidly of government is stopping a real market solution.
There was quite a bit of effort to change this and it got traction in congress because many people are really concerned that all US military equipment depends on rare earths from China.
See:
- https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=O7QNZ56j-HM
- https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lxwF93wnRQo