News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Hackers Breached Virginia Bank Twice in Eight Months, Sto... by darkstar999 on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @10:39AM (#17601408)
I'm on the bank's side of the lawsuit based on what I read in this article. They were covered under "computer and electronic crime" insurance. If the hacks don't fall under that coverage, what would?
Re:Hackers Breached Virginia Bank Twice in Eight Months, Sto... by bdhess on Wednesday July 25, 2018 @12:21AM (#17606889)
If the attackers had gotten the money out via wire transfers, then that would presumably be covered.

The attackers likely avoided that route because it would be easy to trace.

That’s likely the same reason that the insurance policy has special treatment for debit card/ATM incidents, because those sorts of transactions are more difficult to trace and therefore have a higher risk classification.

Re:Hackers Breached Virginia Bank Twice in Eight Months, Sto... by swarnie_ on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @10:48AM (#17601504)
I've seen similar insurance claims invalidated because the company couldn't prove then had taken reasonable steps to prevent an attack.

The fact there were two similar incidents 8 months apart tells me there was a fundamental security issue which wasn't addressed correctly.

Re:Hackers Breached Virginia Bank Twice in Eight Months, Sto... by mattnewton on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @11:03AM (#17601645)
That seems a bit like a catch 22 to me - if you get hacked enough, it must be your fault, so no payout.
Re:Hackers Breached Virginia Bank Twice in Eight Months, Sto... by jrhurst on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @11:44AM (#17602058)
Wait. How is this a catch 22? There is no. "In order to do Y you must first do X. But in order to do X you must first do Y"
Re:Hackers Breached Virginia Bank Twice in Eight Months, Sto... by shawabawa3 on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @11:53AM (#17602174)
In order to get paid you must be hacked, in order to be hacked it must be your fault, if it's your fault you can't be paid
Re:Hackers Breached Virginia Bank Twice in Eight Months, Sto... by fundingshovel on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @10:18PM (#17606468)
That's not what this is staying at all though. It's saying "In order to get paid you must show you took reasonable precautions not get hacked AND get hacked." It's pretty hard to argue ignoring a known issue for 9 months is taking reasonable precaution. I don't see how that's any different then not paying when someone falls on because of broken steps you knew about and didn't fix, which would be pretty common.
Re:Hackers Breached Virginia Bank Twice in Eight Months, Sto... by pjc50 on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @11:16AM (#17601756)
For years people were arguing that the "free market" way to get companies to actually care about IT security was to do it through their insurance premiums: companies with poor practice should be charged more. It sounds like that's come to pass now.
Re:Hackers Breached Virginia Bank Twice in Eight Months, Sto... by ergothus on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @12:11PM (#17602371)
Does this show it's come to pass at all?

It's possible, but the only evidence we have is that insurance companies want to avoid the payout, not that poor practices impacted premiums at all. Given what I've seen from security audits of the past, particularly when influenced by non-security professionals (such as the accountants in this scenario, both the insurers and the insured), I have little faith that if insurance companies dictate the practices that we'll get actual useful security increases, but plenty of extra bureaucratic hoops that will result in the same "productivity vs security _risk_" dilemma we have now, except the CBA changes to "is the hit to our productivity worth this hoop compared to the cost our lawyers would involve to prove this hoop was unnecessary or unrelated times the likelihood that it comes up"

Re:Hackers Breached Virginia Bank Twice in Eight Months, Sto... by slededit on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @12:38PM (#17602669)
An unpaid claim is only slightly worse than higher premium. Bank management wants to sleep soundly on that pile of money they're holding.
Re:Hackers Breached Virginia Bank Twice in Eight Months, Sto... by 0xfeba on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @12:34PM (#17602620)
From one example? Hardly.

What about Equifax?

Re:Hackers Breached Virginia Bank Twice in Eight Months, Sto... by jessaustin on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @10:54AM (#17601550)
I'd like to see some big payouts on that, just to get those silly riders off every blessed insurance estimate I ever receive. "It's a vacant building with no internal walls or floor! It's not going to get hacked!" I don't understand why these riders are all on basic real estate insurance, rather than specifically on e.g. business liability or whatever.
Re:Hackers Breached Virginia Bank Twice in Eight Months, Sto... by zokier on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @07:16PM (#17605695)
> If the hacks don't fall under that coverage, what would?

The things actually specified in the contract, taking account the exclusions?

Re:Hackers Breached Virginia Bank Twice in Eight Months, Sto... by raesene9 on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @11:56AM (#17602204)
The insurance company has a pretty strong financial incentive to try and minimize their loss here, so I'm not surprised they're trying.

That said if too many "hacking insurance" policies fail to pay out, business are going to be less keen to use them.

Re:Hackers Breached Virginia Bank Twice in Eight Months, Sto... by runciblespoon on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @11:12AM (#17601715)
> I'm on the bank's side of the lawsuit based on what I read in this article

Did you read this bit:

‘The second exclusion in the C&E rider negates coverage for “loss involving automated mechanical devices which, on behalf of the Insured, disburse Money, accept deposits, cash checks, drafts or similar Written instruments or make credit card loans . . ..”‘’

And never lose the opportunity to blame 'Russian' hackers.

“Foregenix .. determined the hacking tools and activity appeared to come from Russian-based Internet addresses .. according to the bank Verizon’s forensics experts concluded that the tools and servers used by the hackers were of Russian origin”

They're clever enough to hack a bank but not clever enough to disguise their IP address.

Re:Hackers Breached Virginia Bank Twice in Eight Months, Sto... by bdavisx on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @12:34PM (#17602630)
Why would the Russian's care if their address was known? They aren't going to be extradited or punished by the Russian government, they may be funded by the government or people very well connected to the government. Not to make it political, but they hacked many of our election systems and didn't even get punished for that.
Re:Hackers Breached Virginia Bank Twice in Eight Months, Sto... by acct1771 on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @12:55PM (#17602831)
I love the casual potential blaming of Russian state actors for corporate cyber attacks, but complete disbelief when NSA is accused/implicated in the exact same...
Re:Hackers Breached Virginia Bank Twice in Eight Months, Sto... by bvc35 on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @01:23PM (#17603129)
Complete disbelief? I thought it was common knowledge that the NSA spies on everyone and has spies working or intercepting shipments from most of the major tech manufacturers in the world.
Re:Hackers Breached Virginia Bank Twice in Eight Months, Sto... by Kalium on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @02:16PM (#17603625)
The NSA's typical practices aren't generally thought to include encouraging domestic criminal groups to steal sizable quantities of money from foreign banks. Or sitting idly by as it happens on a regular basis.

We expect the NSA to be compromising foreign systems. We don't expect them to be doing this with them.

Re:Hackers Breached Virginia Bank Twice in Eight Months, Sto... by bdavisx on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @01:38PM (#17603281)
I'm pretty sure the NSA isn't hacking banks to steal a few million dollars, considering their budget.
Re:Hackers Breached Virginia Bank Twice in Eight Months, Sto... by darkstar999 on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @11:20AM (#17601798)
That rider sounds to me like the ATM itself has to be compromised. It wasn't. The hack was upstream and the ATM was just doing what the network rules told it to.
Re:Hackers Breached Virginia Bank Twice in Eight Months, Sto... by zokier on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @02:25PM (#17603711)
No, it just says that the ATM must be involved in the loss, they need to be the cause or the source of the loss. And I think it is pretty well arguable that ATMs were involved in this case, even if in relatively minor role.
Re:Hackers Breached Virginia Bank Twice in Eight Months, Sto... by rdiddly on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @03:41PM (#17604263)
Yeah it makes it seem a bit implausible or at least should be cause for just a teeny weeny second of consideration. If I were hacking into a bank I'd consider myself pretty smart if I thought to pin it on the most boringly believable (by most Americans, stewed as they are in a soup of anti-Russia talk) hacking culprit.
Re:Hackers Breached Virginia Bank Twice in Eight Months, Sto... by dyarosla on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @11:17AM (#17601773)
Or they disguised the IP addresses to look like Russian IPs? Although I'm no hacker- anyone know hard that would be to do?
Re:Hackers Breached Virginia Bank Twice in Eight Months, Sto... by monocasa on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @12:07PM (#17602320)
If you're going to build a botnet, it'll probably mainly be a bunch of Russian and Chinese machines. They've got the most WinXP instances still running without hardly any updates.
Re:Hackers Breached Virginia Bank Twice in Eight Months, Sto... by darkstar999 on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @11:19AM (#17601784)
Easy enough by using a VPN and/or compromised Russian machines.