News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tesla has asked some suppliers for cash back to help it b... by Puer on Sunday July 22, 2018 @09:57PM (#17590014)
"Tesla declined to comment on the specific memo. But it confirmed it is seeking price reductions from suppliers for projects, some of which date back to 2016, and some of which haven’t been completed."

The Wall Street Journal is one of the most reputable sources for business journalism. Claiming that they would publish this article without proper vetting is ridiculous and equating it to "fake news" is shameful.

Re:Tesla has asked some suppliers for cash back to help it b... by seldon999 on Sunday July 22, 2018 @10:05PM (#17590060)
A few months ago the WSJ reported that the aerospace supplier Woodward was in talks to be acquired by Boeing. [1]

After the market closed, Woodward came out and categorically denied the WSJ's report, saying that it was not in talks. Period.

Its not necessarily nefarious, but the WSJ does in fact publish stories that rely on questionable sources. It's absolutely not out of the question that that could have happened here as well.

Note that since [1] was published, Woodward has not been acquired by Boeing, and its stock took a dive after the WSJ's poorly sourced story caused the stock to shoot up ~10% when it published. A lot of people that bought it on the WSJ's bad report lost a lot of money.

1. https://www.wsj.com/articles/boeing-in-talks-to-buy-aerospac...

Re:Tesla has asked some suppliers for cash back to help it b... by Animats on Sunday July 22, 2018 @10:25PM (#17590140)
About half of all big deals that are announced in the press don't close. They collapse for lots of reasons.
Re:Tesla has asked some suppliers for cash back to help it b... by seldonnn on Sunday July 22, 2018 @10:29PM (#17590161)
This isn’t about a proposed deal not closing. This is about a proposed deal being reported as such, when in fact there had not ever been deal talks in the first place.
Re:Tesla has asked some suppliers for cash back to help it b... by Puer on Sunday July 22, 2018 @10:34PM (#17590188)
"Tesla declined to comment on the specific memo. But it confirmed it is seeking price reductions from suppliers for projects, some of which date back to 2016, and some of which haven’t been completed."

Also, if you're going to create throwaway accounts just to comment you might want to remember which one you're logged into.

Re:Tesla has asked some suppliers for cash back to help it b... by Gigablah on Sunday July 22, 2018 @10:27PM (#17590152)
Not sure what that has to do with this case. It wasn't announced, WSJ reported a rumor.
Re:Tesla has asked some suppliers for cash back to help it b... by Puer on Sunday July 22, 2018 @10:15PM (#17590100)
Just because the company denied the report it doesn't necessarily mean it wasn't true. Companies deny things all the time in accordance to whatever suits their current interests.

"Several hours after The Wall Street Journal reported on the talks, Woodward issued a news release saying that it “is not in discussions with Boeing over a possible acquisition of Woodward... After the statement, the people familiar with the matter said the companies remained in talks."

The Wall Street Journal has a long history of thorough research and well-respected publications. There's no doubt that the vetting process for industry sources is extensive. Remember when a right wing group tried to approach the Washington Post with a fake story and how quickly they were able to expose it? It's entirely possible for sources to give occasionally incorrect or unreliable information based on changing events, but the notion that the WSJ consistently relies on "questionable sources" is ignorant of how extensive the process is.

Just because it isn't transparent (which is precisely to protect the quality of their sources) it doesn't mean it isn't reliable.

Re:Tesla has asked some suppliers for cash back to help it b... by dnomad on Sunday July 22, 2018 @10:23PM (#17590131)
> The Wall Street Journal has a long history of thorough research and well-respected publications.

This is a bullshit appeal to authority.

Let's be very clear about the process:

* The WSJ reports the claims of anonymous sources. It bases entire reports off these claims and makes no effort to provide verifiable evidence of what it is reporting.

* When called on the sordid affair the WSJ and its defenders insist the paper is a serious journalist effort.

This happens over and over at major American newspapers to the extreme detriment of the American people. And yet, here we are again in 2018.

Here's an idea: instead of appealing to authority why not provide evidence? Why not make the sources go on record? Or provide verifiable evidence of the source's anonymous claims? Isn't this what journalism actually is?

Re:Tesla has asked some suppliers for cash back to help it b... by cepth on Monday July 23, 2018 @02:52AM (#17590977)
Keep in mind that John Carreyou’s sources for the Theranos articles faced actual 24/7 surveillance, and received legally threatening letters from one of the country’s top law firms (Boies Schiller).

This is not to say that Musk would definitely do such a thing. However, the employee(s) who talked to the WSJ are risking personal legal liability for talking to a journalist.

Any journalist worth their salt is going to allow sources to go on “deep background” when appropriate.

I write all this as a soon to be Tesla customer. Yes, asking for manufacturer rebates is not completely unheard of, but it’s also the case that this very rarely happens.

If you’re thinking there’s a conspiracy, keep in mind the WSJ’s auto reviewer just published an overwhelmingly positive review of the Model 3 this week, which Musk retweeted.

US libel and defamation law puts newspapers in legal jeopardy if they intentionally publish false information (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/New_York_Times_Co._v._Sullivan). News Corp has a couple billion reasons to let the WSJ’s newsroom do a thorough and honest job.

Re:Tesla has asked some suppliers for cash back to help it b... by neotek on Sunday July 22, 2018 @10:51PM (#17590252)
>Why not make the sources go on record?

Do you really need someone to explain to you why this is a silly idea?

Re:Tesla has asked some suppliers for cash back to help it b... by imh on Monday July 23, 2018 @12:40AM (#17590621)
[citation needed] is one of the best things that happened to wikipedia and it could stand to show up in more places. I'm amazed internet journalism doesn't use citations. It's not like there's a lack of space like print papers.
Re:Tesla has asked some suppliers for cash back to help it b... by pvg on Sunday July 22, 2018 @10:32PM (#17590179)
The sources are not anonymous to the WSJ. They're not publishing random uncorroborated things.
Re:Tesla has asked some suppliers for cash back to help it b... by StudentStuff on Sunday July 22, 2018 @10:51PM (#17590251)
The source may not be anonymous to the WSJ (we the readers have no insight as to whether or not the source was anonymous), but articles like this where WSJ was unable to find a second source shouldn't be published as journalism. Uncorroborated hearsay does not make for a proper, publishable news article.
Re:Tesla has asked some suppliers for cash back to help it b... by Puer on Sunday July 22, 2018 @11:04PM (#17590296)
It's disingenuous to associate yourself as a "reader" when you evidently didn't read the article carefully:

"Tesla declined to comment on the specific memo. But it confirmed it is seeking price reductions from suppliers for projects, some of which date back to 2016, and some of which haven’t been completed."

The second source the WSJ found was Tesla itself. Uninformed assertion does not make for a proper, useful Hacker News comment.

Re:Tesla has asked some suppliers for cash back to help it b... by pvg on Sunday July 22, 2018 @11:03PM (#17590295)
That's why they don't publish 'uncorroborated hearsay'. You are just calling it that. We the readers have a pretty decent idea what standards major newspapers adhere to. It's a minor exercise in reading to get familiar with them if you personally happen not to be.
Re:Tesla has asked some suppliers for cash back to help it b... by stale2002 on Monday July 23, 2018 @01:16AM (#17590729)
It's not uncorroborated. Tesla confirmed the main claim, which was that they were seeking price reductions for past contracts.
Re:Tesla has asked some suppliers for cash back to help it b... by tssva on Monday July 23, 2018 @07:13AM (#17591890)
Tesla confirmed something but from that statement it is impossible to determine they confirmed that they are looking cash back from past contracts. It can be read that Tesla confirmed they are looking for price reduction of current contracts some of which may have been established in 2016 but the terms of which have not completed. If suppliers have failed to fully deliver as required under the contracts such as meeting quality or timeline terms it would not be unusual for Tesla to go back to the suppliers to ask for a refund.
Re:Tesla has asked some suppliers for cash back to help it b... by empath75 on Sunday July 22, 2018 @11:49PM (#17590452)
I’ve worked at multiple companies that have been acquired. They’ll deny that talks are occurring up until the day the deal happens.
Re:Tesla has asked some suppliers for cash back to help it b... by stale2002 on Monday July 23, 2018 @01:13AM (#17590723)
But... Tesla confirmed the story.

They literally said that they WERE seeking price reductions for past contracts.

Is this really the hill to die on? A story that was confirmed by the direct source that this was regarding.

Re:Tesla has asked some suppliers for cash back to help it b... by eeeeeeeeeeeee on Monday July 23, 2018 @09:42AM (#17592648)
Maybe they were in talks and it fell apart? That happens a lot and the company doesn't always confirm it publicly. Nothing you have said is surprising at all.
Re:Tesla has asked some suppliers for cash back to help it b... by carlmr on Monday July 23, 2018 @03:39AM (#17591129)
Reputability should never be reason not to question something. There's a name for that and it's appeal to authority.

Is Reuters reputable enough to question the sensationalism in WSJ? http://blogs.reuters.com/felix-salmon/2010/02/26/the-sensati...: "In any case, it’s clear from the photograph and the two main stories on the WSJ’s front page that the paper is aggressively becoming both sensationalist and political. That might be a sensible move, from the point of view of selling copies, especially on the newsstand. But it will also inevitably serve to erode the trust that many people, on Wall Street especially, have in the reporting of the WSJ."

Re:Tesla has asked some suppliers for cash back to help it b... by Sangermaine on Monday July 23, 2018 @09:01AM (#17592414)
Reuters yes. An Op/Ed in Reuters, no. You have to know you’re being disingenuous here.
Re:Tesla has asked some suppliers for cash back to help it b... by anilshanbhag on Sunday July 22, 2018 @10:28PM (#17590157)
Wall Street Journal is reputable and I subscribe to it. It is probably the best one for US business news.

However it has a long history of publishing sensationalist articles especially about Tesla. I remember the articles about executives stepping away, NTSB probes, yellow lines, bankruptcy ... The recent article by Dan on how good Model 3 is is the only positive article I remember on WSJ about Tesla.

Re:Tesla has asked some suppliers for cash back to help it b... by praneshp on Sunday July 22, 2018 @10:29PM (#17590164)
> I remember the articles about executives stepping away, NTSB probes, yellow lines, bankruptcy ... The recent article by Dan on how good Model 3 is is the only positive article I remember on WSJ about Tesla

Do you remember any of them being factually incorrect?

Re:Tesla has asked some suppliers for cash back to help it b... by compcoffee on Sunday July 22, 2018 @11:55PM (#17590476)
So which of those stories weren't true?

You are implying bias, where I see a troubled company.

Can you name another instance where the WSJ wrote negatively about a company and it turned out to be false? As a subscriber, why the sudden skepticism?

Re:Tesla has asked some suppliers for cash back to help it b... by rory096 on Monday July 23, 2018 @12:55AM (#17590674)
Andy Pasztor published unfounded speculation that the highly classified Zuma mission was a SpaceX failure.[0] It certainly was not and is believed to be a Northrop Grumman failure.[1]

[0] https://www.wsj.com/articles/u-s-spy-satellite-believed-lost...

[1] https://www.wsj.com/articles/probes-point-to-northrop-grumma...

Re:Tesla has asked some suppliers for cash back to help it b... by perl4ever on Monday July 23, 2018 @01:34AM (#17590776)
There was a time when the WSJ wrote over and over articles with a negative slant about Apple, before Jobs came back. They would always describe them as "beleaguered" and similar terms. For some reason the "party line" changed, and it was quite striking to me. While it's undeniable that Apple was turned around, the sense of a manipulated narrative never left me. And while I don't trust Rupert Murdoch, this was before his involvement.
Re:Tesla has asked some suppliers for cash back to help it b... by jonknee on Monday July 23, 2018 @02:36AM (#17590930)
Apple was beleaguered before Steve came back. That's why he came back! They very nearly went out of business, you can't get much more beleaguered than that.
Re:Tesla has asked some suppliers for cash back to help it b... by perl4ever on Monday July 23, 2018 @12:33PM (#17593823)
Apple wasn't levered though. To this day, many people will tell you they were on the brink of bankruptcy. The "beleaguered" stuff was self-reinforcing judgement of their product line and its prospects.

It is possible to be extremely biased against an entity that has real issues, just like a paranoid can have real enemies.

Re:Tesla has asked some suppliers for cash back to help it b... by rwc on Monday July 23, 2018 @03:16PM (#17595114)
Yes, many people will tell you that, including Jobs:

https://thenextweb.com/apple/2010/06/02/steve-jobs-90-days/

Re:Tesla has asked some suppliers for cash back to help it b... by perl4ever on Wednesday July 25, 2018 @11:20PM (#17614842)
I'm coming from the perspective of having read Apple's annual SEC filings back in the day and noted what a huge amount of cash they had stockpiled even in their doldrums.

Apple would never have survived if they had not been run so conservatively, which speaks to the efforts of people other than Jobs and Gates.

At the end of 1997 their 10-K says they had around $1.4B dollars in cash, and around $900M in long term debt.

The 2000 10-K shows they had $4 billion in cash and short term investments compared to $300 million in long term debt.

Re:Tesla has asked some suppliers for cash back to help it b... by ryanhuff on Monday July 23, 2018 @12:23AM (#17590569)
You don't have to be factually incorrect to be biased in your writing.
Re:Tesla has asked some suppliers for cash back to help it b... by r00fus on Monday July 23, 2018 @04:12AM (#17591278)
WSJ is owned by Murdoch's NewsCorp. The new owners view WSJs reputation as an asset to be exploited as needed.
Re:Tesla has asked some suppliers for cash back to help it b... by paidleaf on Monday July 23, 2018 @10:51AM (#17593145)
> The Wall Street Journal is one of the most reputable sources for business journalism. Claiming that they would publish this article without proper vetting is ridiculous and equating it to "fake news" is shameful.

So WSJ is beyond reproach and criticism? WSJ has had problems in the past with their reporting. Nobody is beyond reproach, especially a company owned by rupert murdoch.

If you have an issue with the guy's comment, why not point that out instead of attacking him for being "shameful" for criticizing the wsj?

https://apnews.com/d71bf1b8c2304329866441ec4089760f

"It's Not Just The Editorial Page: Study Finds WSJ's Reporting On Climate Change Also Skewed"

https://www.mediamatters.org/blog/2015/08/11/its-not-just-th...

It's worrisome the social media campaign to quash criticism of the corporate media.

Re:Tesla has asked some suppliers for cash back to help it b... by Puer on Monday July 23, 2018 @11:09AM (#17593262)
Yes, the WSJ does make mistakes and, like all human creations, has some degree of underlying bias. However, it is generally a reliable and quality source of information.

The parent comment was edited so of course there's no way you could have known, but it had previously equated the WSJ to being no better than "fake news." I think a fair interpretation of "fake news" is inflammatory information that's intentionally misleading and has no ties to any sort of reality.

In this age of misinformation, I think it's important to support and recognize quality sources of information and education. Comparing the WSJ to a fake news publication is disrespectful and ignorant and I think it's worth calling out.

Re:Tesla has asked some suppliers for cash back to help it b... by paidleaf on Monday July 23, 2018 @11:32AM (#17593416)
> The parent comment was edited so of course there's no way you could have known, but it had previously equated the WSJ to being no better than "fake news."

I didn't realize he said WSJ is fake news. That is a bit hyperbolic but that's his opinion and he's certainly entitled to it.

> In this age of misinformation, I think it's important to support and recognize quality sources of information and education

In the age of misinformation, it is more critical that we hold a light to established news sources. Especially those that people blindly accept on faith.

> Comparing the WSJ to a fake news publication is disrespectful and ignorant and I think it's worth calling out.

So what if it was disrespectful? That's his opinion. Why attack him for it? Should he attack you for blindly accepting the WSJ?

WSJ is just a company. Why are you so offended? There's plenty the WSJ did for people to disrespect it. Obviously there's plenty they did for you to respect it. Whatever happened to respecting each other opinions?

You can disagree with him without calling him ignorant and attacking the guy.

[dead]
Re:Tesla has asked some suppliers for cash back to help it b... by sctb on Monday July 23, 2018 @09:17AM (#17592495)
If you keep trying to spark flamewars here we'll ban the account.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:Tesla has asked some suppliers for cash back to help it b... by dnomad on Monday July 23, 2018 @10:36AM (#17593047)
I don't see anything in those guidelines that I've violated. Is there any hope that you might be more specific?

All of my comments include supporting evidence whenever possible. They are not vague or dismissive. They are certainly not flamebait meant to spark flamewars.

Re:Tesla has asked some suppliers for cash back to help it b... by pvg on Monday July 23, 2018 @02:49PM (#17594880)
"bullshit appeal to authority" "sordid affair" "the extreme detriment of the American people" "It is fake news" "Iraqi war and the deaths of hundreds of thousands of innocent people" "Seriously, grow up." https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=29M_VElHoFI

This is all about some fairly basic reporting about a car manufacturer and its suppliers.

Re:Tesla has asked some suppliers for cash back to help it b... by luckydata on Thursday July 26, 2018 @01:05PM (#17618996)
They are doing it with everything lately though. I agree with the original post. It's classier, but completely aligned with MAGA. They put a nicer face on it which is scary. I prefer my Nazis to be recognizable for the monsters they really are.