This is not to say that Musk would definitely do such a thing. However, the employee(s) who talked to the WSJ are risking personal legal liability for talking to a journalist.
Any journalist worth their salt is going to allow sources to go on “deep background” when appropriate.
I write all this as a soon to be Tesla customer. Yes, asking for manufacturer rebates is not completely unheard of, but it’s also the case that this very rarely happens.
If you’re thinking there’s a conspiracy, keep in mind the WSJ’s auto reviewer just published an overwhelmingly positive review of the Model 3 this week, which Musk retweeted.
US libel and defamation law puts newspapers in legal jeopardy if they intentionally publish false information (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/New_York_Times_Co._v._Sullivan). News Corp has a couple billion reasons to let the WSJ’s newsroom do a thorough and honest job.
Do you really need someone to explain to you why this is a silly idea?
"Tesla declined to comment on the specific memo. But it confirmed it is seeking price reductions from suppliers for projects, some of which date back to 2016, and some of which haven’t been completed."
The second source the WSJ found was Tesla itself. Uninformed assertion does not make for a proper, useful Hacker News comment.
They literally said that they WERE seeking price reductions for past contracts.
Is this really the hill to die on? A story that was confirmed by the direct source that this was regarding.
This is a bullshit appeal to authority.
Let's be very clear about the process:
* The WSJ reports the claims of anonymous sources. It bases entire reports off these claims and makes no effort to provide verifiable evidence of what it is reporting.
* When called on the sordid affair the WSJ and its defenders insist the paper is a serious journalist effort.
This happens over and over at major American newspapers to the extreme detriment of the American people. And yet, here we are again in 2018.
Here's an idea: instead of appealing to authority why not provide evidence? Why not make the sources go on record? Or provide verifiable evidence of the source's anonymous claims? Isn't this what journalism actually is?