I suspect Netflix's DRM is purely about pacifying video industry executives, and that it makes approximately no difference to the bottom line of anybody except the people hyping their proprietary DRM solutions.
DRM appears to be useless because you are incorrectly assuming DRM's purpose is to stop or reduce piracy. DRM is and always has been about controlling the playback platform.
Media companies like DRM so the can force anyone making a player to not implement features they don't like. Their ability to control how media is used was severely limited when the Betamax case[1] (1984) established that using a home video tape recorder to time shift was is fair use. Unable to legally control how media is used, media companies hade regularly attempted to establish and require a DRM scheme they could use to technologically control use.
The proper response is to tell the media companies their right to control a copyright protected work ends at the first sale[2].
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sony_Corp._of_America_v._Unive....
I'm no fan of DRM or the idiots in Hollywood but isn't "controlling the playback" a means to control piracy? Why must they be mutually exclusive?
>"Media companies like DRM so the can force anyone making a player to not implement features they don't like."
I'm curious is there any evidence of this? How would the Hollywood studios even be aware of all of the new hardware devices?
No, it's about controlling the channels of publication so they can maintain their position as a gatekeeper.
> I'm curious is there any evidence of this?
See the SCOTUS case at my previous [1]. Universal Studios sued Sony over their new "Betamax" video tape recorders, arguing they were liable under the Lanham Act because their device could record video, which could be copyright infringement.
For more recent examples, see the requirements in DVD/BD licensing that force playback of ads and allow disks to disable various features (like fast-forward or track-skip during an ad).
What industry are you referring to here - the tech sector, the entertainment industry? This is rather vague. Also which tax are you referring to? Who are the "incumbents"?
To me, it is rather the other way round: As Netflix offers no DRM-free version, I will never subscribe. So in other words: by insisting on DRM, the movie industry openly states that they don't want any money from people who don't want DRM.
But if you "reverse" this sentence "in a hacker way", this means that they are not losing any money, if DRM-haters pirate (because they just stated that they don't want the DRM-haters' money).
Thus, in my opinion is quite a pro-pirating slogan coming from the mouth of Hollywood.
I do not get your point. Perhaps I misunderstand it, because English is not my mother tongue.
I do not see a problem. First: If I really download a lot, I will soon get out of disk space (even if I own a NAS). Second: Netflix adds new movies/series all the time to its library. So there is an incentive to stay a subscriber.
I'd pay for one month of Netflix every two years instead of monthly, without question.
The primary benefit of DRM free netflix is to watch higher resolution videos on any browser that isn't Edge. [1]
I can imagine that in this case Netflix would just have to change the price model somewhat: Make the first month much more expensive than the following ones to give a disincentive for canceling the subscription. At least this pricing model is applied by many software companies who love to sell subscriptions for their software.
Sure they could have used a different business model, but had they, we wouldn't be talking about Netflix.
I can already torrent anything I want. But I don't because it's easier for me just to pay.
How so? Can you not find Netflix shows on piracy sites?
If you mean "Netflix has been successful in getting people to pirate less" that has nothing to do with the DRM, but with the fact that Netflix is a cheap and convenient enough service to stop many people from wanting to watch pirated content.