News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why Intel will never let owners control the ME by bumholio on Sunday July 22, 2018 @03:38PM (#17588489)
It's incredible how much effort and money has gone down this drain, chasing the fundamentally flawed idea of DRM. All to satisfy some inflated management egos and sell snake oil to the content industry - the enginners implementing these schemes must surely realize it's in vain, that the attack surface includes all devices in the world and all it takes is a single successful hack against a single device to decrypt the content after which it's game over.

And the consumer is paying for all of this security theater.

Re:Why Intel will never let owners control the ME by hlandau on Sunday July 22, 2018 @03:58PM (#17588610)
The really horrible truth is, DRM was probably never intended to prevent piracy. I used to think this - then you realise what DRM is actually intended to do. So long as we argue like this, we're not confronting the real motives.

There seem to be two arguments for DRM which could be considered logical from an executive's perspective (even if in my view unethical):

- Firstly, it delays the initial piracy of new releases. This is very variable and since new DRM systems aren't created as often as new films, this only seems to be successfully pulled off every now and then... but there have demonstrably been cases of it delaying piracy by a few weeks (hell, there's at least one video game which wasn't cracked for over a year). This probably feels valuable to executives who expect the bulk of returns on a film or video game to come immediately after release (especially if they have unrealistic expectations about correlations between piracy and lost sales).

- Secondly, and more significantly, it ensures that media companies can control how content is consumed, and control the devices available to consume content. If you want to make a Blu-ray player, you have to sign contracts, and those contracts can tell you what functionality to add and what not to add. "Unauthorized" players, circumvention technology will always exist for the fringes, but that's too minor to care about. What it does mean - in tandem with the anticircumvention technology ban legislation, 17 USC 1202 - is that you can't walk into a retail chain store and buy a Blu-ray player that'll happily make copies, or so on. Most likely this is what these companies really care about - ensuring they have a say on what Homer Simpson has to choose from in Best Buy.

To be clear, I unequivocally oppose DRM; but I suspect the above points are a closer approximation of the motives of the media industry in pushing it.

Re:Why Intel will never let owners control the ME by vesinisa on Sunday July 22, 2018 @05:39PM (#17589062)
Moreover, DRM enables content industry to control where content can be played, known as geoblocking. For example, I live in North Europe, and the titles that are available in 'official', DRM-controlled sources, such as Netflix, are noticeably different than in North America. Maybe Netflix only has distribution rights for some title in the US market, so when I try to look it up the search comes back empty.

What DRM allows Netflix is to still sell one and the same subscription globally. The content you can view is not tied to your account's registered post address or such, but which physical region of the Internet you are actually accessing the service from currently. When we were visiting the US, my spouse was able to play titles with her Netflix subscription that are not available at home, because she was connecting to the US DRM servers from the WiFi of our Airbnb in California.

For our flight home, she put her phone in flight mode and was able to watch cached titles during the flight. But as soon as she turned on her data in Europe, the titles magically disappeared in thin air, as the EU DRM server realized the geoblocking violation and revoked her license to those titles.

Re:Why Intel will never let owners control the ME by bubblethink on Sunday July 22, 2018 @06:37PM (#17589277)
Geoblocking is entirely different from DRM. The former is a simple transaction of "Show me your IP" -> "You can't have this". DRM is a far more complicated thing that needs cooperation from all levels of the stack to enable, "Your computer can see this, but you, the user, can't".
Re:Why Intel will never let owners control the ME by vesinisa on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @08:50AM (#17600509)
Yes, but combining DRM and geoblocking allows the content distributor to retroactively revoke access to content when you change the geoblocking region, such as traveling to another continent. Even content that you have downloaded to an offline cache can be rendered unavailable. From the distributor's point of view combining the two offers an enhanced form of geoblocking that transcends time.
Re:Why Intel will never let owners control the ME by seba_dos1 on Monday July 23, 2018 @05:57PM (#17596362)
Well, in some cases DRM allows you to geoblock stuff that couldn't be easily geoblocked otherwise.
Re:Why Intel will never let owners control the ME by Angostura on Sunday July 22, 2018 @04:12PM (#17588688)
Regardless of how effective DRM is, don't forget it was an absolute requirement that Apple had to agree to implement in order to get the iTunes Store open, that Netflix et al had to follow in order to get up and running with agreement from the studios.

DRM enabled a huge number of online businesses by providing content makers with the minimal assurances that they needed that those channels wouldn't be a simple, easy way for their content to be pirated.

Re:Why Intel will never let owners control the ME by bscphil on Sunday July 22, 2018 @07:16PM (#17589411)
The irony, of course, is that both of them (and Amazon as well) are simple, easy ways for content to be pirated. Pirates have broken the DRM of all three sufficiently that the original bitstream from each source can be muxed into a mkv and shared - it doesn't even need to be reencoded.
Re:Why Intel will never let owners control the ME by Qub3d on Monday July 23, 2018 @09:28AM (#17592553)
As Always, a Relevant XKCD about DHCP: https://xkcd.com/129/

(Free Culture, as Randall notes in the mouseover text, warned us about this over 10 years ago)

Re:Why Intel will never let owners control the ME by __sr__ on Sunday July 22, 2018 @07:06PM (#17589376)
No one ever accused the MBA toting managers of being tech savvy .. or smart, for that matter. /s

Sarcasm aside, in my experience, most managers do not understand technology even at a high level. Even the ones who come from a tech background often don’t bother to keep up. The typical mentality being, “I don’t know and I don’t want to know. Get someone from <insert tech department name here> to handle it.” When the <insert tech department name here> does come up with a solution, it is usually shot down if there is even the slightest hint of risk involved. And there usually is — any disruptive change — as all invocations tend to be — inherently carry a certain amount of risk. Even Steve Jobs was unable to convince the record labels to allow them to sell DRM free music via iTines until Apple had grown too big for them to go against — at least as far as music business was concerned.

Basically, the only things the so called managers are good at are passing around the blame and covering their asses. Way too many companies have been destroyed or are a shell of their former glory - having missed major opportunities because the management was not willing to deal with the risks associated with innovation — because they were content to milk their cash cow till it was dead — while laughing at deficiencies of the more innovative competitors’ version 1.0 products.

The real managers — the people who know what they are doing — go on to found successful tech companies.

Re:Why Intel will never let owners control the ME by forkerenok on Sunday July 22, 2018 @04:15PM (#17588699)
Inflated Management Egos -> IME

Was that intentional? :)

Re:Why Intel will never let owners control the ME by __sr__ on Sunday July 22, 2018 @07:14PM (#17589402)
Well spotted!
Re:Why Intel will never let owners control the ME by TaylorAlexander on Sunday July 22, 2018 @03:46PM (#17588541)
It seems as though it has been working for them though, no? Isn’t Netflix and its DRM evidence of that?
Re:Why Intel will never let owners control the ME by wpietri on Sunday July 22, 2018 @03:49PM (#17588562)
To me, Netflix is evidence that there's no point to DRM. I still can torrent any content I want, but I almost never do. But if it's on Netflix or anything else I subscribe to, I won't bother.

I suspect Netflix's DRM is purely about pacifying video industry executives, and that it makes approximately no difference to the bottom line of anybody except the people hyping their proprietary DRM solutions.

Re:Why Intel will never let owners control the ME by pdkl95 on Sunday July 22, 2018 @04:30PM (#17588771)
> there's no point to DRM. I still can torrent any content I want

DRM appears to be useless because you are incorrectly assuming DRM's purpose is to stop or reduce piracy. DRM is and always has been about controlling the playback platform.

Media companies like DRM so the can force anyone making a player to not implement features they don't like. Their ability to control how media is used was severely limited when the Betamax case[1] (1984) established that using a home video tape recorder to time shift was is fair use. Unable to legally control how media is used, media companies hade regularly attempted to establish and require a DRM scheme they could use to technologically control use.

The proper response is to tell the media companies their right to control a copyright protected work ends at the first sale[2].

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sony_Corp._of_America_v._Unive....

[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/First-sale_doctrine

Re:Why Intel will never let owners control the ME by bogomipz on Sunday July 22, 2018 @08:52PM (#17589738)
>"DRM appears to be useless because you are incorrectly assuming DRM's purpose is to stop or reduce piracy. DRM is and always has been about controlling the playback platform."

I'm no fan of DRM or the idiots in Hollywood but isn't "controlling the playback" a means to control piracy? Why must they be mutually exclusive?

>"Media companies like DRM so the can force anyone making a player to not implement features they don't like."

I'm curious is there any evidence of this? How would the Hollywood studios even be aware of all of the new hardware devices?

Re:Why Intel will never let owners control the ME by pdkl95 on Sunday July 22, 2018 @10:07PM (#17590068)
> isn't "controlling the playback" a means to control piracy?

No, it's about controlling the channels of publication so they can maintain their position as a gatekeeper.

> I'm curious is there any evidence of this?

See the SCOTUS case at my previous [1]. Universal Studios sued Sony over their new "Betamax" video tape recorders, arguing they were liable under the Lanham Act because their device could record video, which could be copyright infringement.

For more recent examples, see the requirements in DVD/BD licensing that force playback of ads and allow disks to disable various features (like fast-forward or track-skip during an ad).

Re:Why Intel will never let owners control the ME by wpietri on Monday July 23, 2018 @05:54AM (#17591644)
Sorry, but I'm not seeing the relevance of this to a streaming world. In what fashion do you believe they are controlling playback on Netflix, Amazon Prime, HBO, Starz, or any of the other streaming apps?
Re:Why Intel will never let owners control the ME by EvanAnderson on Sunday July 22, 2018 @09:51PM (#17589982)
Controlling playback allows the industry to insure that new works are industry-sanctioned and appropriately taxed by the incumbents. DRM allows the middle-men to continue being in the middle in the face of the democratization of production and distribution that technology has created.
Re:Why Intel will never let owners control the ME by bogomipz on Monday July 23, 2018 @10:40AM (#17593063)
>"Controlling playback allows the industry to insure that new works are industry-sanctioned and appropriately taxed by the incumbents"

What industry are you referring to here - the tech sector, the entertainment industry? This is rather vague. Also which tax are you referring to? Who are the "incumbents"?

Re:Why Intel will never let owners control the ME by wolfgke on Sunday July 22, 2018 @04:05PM (#17588653)
> To me, Netflix is evidence that there's no point to DRM. I still can torrent any content I want, but I almost never do.

To me, it is rather the other way round: As Netflix offers no DRM-free version, I will never subscribe. So in other words: by insisting on DRM, the movie industry openly states that they don't want any money from people who don't want DRM.

But if you "reverse" this sentence "in a hacker way", this means that they are not losing any money, if DRM-haters pirate (because they just stated that they don't want the DRM-haters' money).

Thus, in my opinion is quite a pro-pirating slogan coming from the mouth of Hollywood.

Re:Why Intel will never let owners control the ME by CJefferson on Sunday July 22, 2018 @04:11PM (#17588683)
I might just not have to imagination, but a DRM free Netflix wouldn't seem to work -- you pay a low monthly fee for temporary access to a huge library. What would you prefer?
Re:Why Intel will never let owners control the ME by wolfgke on Sunday July 22, 2018 @04:16PM (#17588701)
> I might just not have to imagination, but a DRM free Netflix wouldn't seem to work -- you pay a low monthly fee for temporary access to a huge library. What would you prefer?

I do not get your point. Perhaps I misunderstand it, because English is not my mother tongue.

I do not see a problem. First: If I really download a lot, I will soon get out of disk space (even if I own a NAS). Second: Netflix adds new movies/series all the time to its library. So there is an incentive to stay a subscriber.

Re:Why Intel will never let owners control the ME by joshuamorton on Sunday July 22, 2018 @04:38PM (#17588807)
Storage is cheap. You can store 500 hours of video in a TB. And four TB is less than one year of Netflix, but gives you enough storage to download enough video to last a few years.

I'd pay for one month of Netflix every two years instead of monthly, without question.

Re:Why Intel will never let owners control the ME by imtringued on Monday July 23, 2018 @04:13AM (#17591281)
At that point why even bother with netflix? Downloading the streams and watching them without a subscription is still copyright infringement. Illegal streaming sites have existed for decades already.

The primary benefit of DRM free netflix is to watch higher resolution videos on any browser that isn't Edge. [1]

[1] https://help.netflix.com/en/node/23742

Re:Why Intel will never let owners control the ME by wolfgke on Sunday July 22, 2018 @04:57PM (#17588890)
> I'd pay for one month of Netflix every two years instead of monthly, without question.

I can imagine that in this case Netflix would just have to change the price model somewhat: Make the first month much more expensive than the following ones to give a disincentive for canceling the subscription. At least this pricing model is applied by many software companies who love to sell subscriptions for their software.

Re:Why Intel will never let owners control the ME by CJefferson on Sunday July 22, 2018 @08:10PM (#17589602)
But, that would I imagine be terrible for Netflix -- their cheap monthly price encourages people to sign up on a whim. I suspect very few people would sign up if the first month had been much more expensive.
Re:Why Intel will never let owners control the ME by nybble41 on Monday July 23, 2018 @12:49PM (#17593949)
They could keep the cheap monthly price for first-time subscribers, and just make it so that if you cancel and want to sign back up later you're charged for all the months in between.
Re:Why Intel will never let owners control the ME by joshuamorton on Sunday July 22, 2018 @05:03PM (#17588915)
I'm sure Netflix would have seen explosive growth if it required 1 year, $100+ contracts, and that's assuming content producers would have been okay with it (they wouldn't have).

Sure they could have used a different business model, but had they, we wouldn't be talking about Netflix.

Re:Why Intel will never let owners control the ME by xfer on Sunday July 22, 2018 @10:43PM (#17590221)
The point is content maynot be worth watching, but you don't know unless you paid for it. You can make space by just keeping the content that are worth watching more than once, which in my experience is a very small fraction of the amount of movies produced.
Re:Why Intel will never let owners control the ME by wpietri on Monday July 23, 2018 @05:57AM (#17591651)
A DRM-free Netflix would work just fine. How much work am I going to go to just to cheat Netflix out of $8/month?

I can already torrent anything I want. But I don't because it's easier for me just to pay.

Re:Why Intel will never let owners control the ME by TomMarius on Sunday July 22, 2018 @03:52PM (#17588577)
Yes, I completely agree. I not only can torrent stuff, I can do it very comfortably as I used to do it a lot and have created a pipeline that will download it complete with subs in English and Czech, correctly name and categorize and make it available to my network so I can play it directly on my TV - all just by clicking on a magnet link. And yet since Netflix is available, I don't, Netflix is even more comfortable, and I want to support their original work.
Re:Why Intel will never let owners control the ME by mtgx on Sunday July 22, 2018 @04:00PM (#17588623)
> Isn’t Netflix and its DRM evidence of that?

How so? Can you not find Netflix shows on piracy sites?

If you mean "Netflix has been successful in getting people to pirate less" that has nothing to do with the DRM, but with the fact that Netflix is a cheap and convenient enough service to stop many people from wanting to watch pirated content.

Re:Why Intel will never let owners control the ME by ryanlol on Sunday July 22, 2018 @10:08PM (#17590078)
Netflix videos are pretty easy to decrypt, there are a bunch of public exploits you can use to dump videwine device keys.
Re:Why Intel will never let owners control the ME by benologist on Monday July 23, 2018 @12:20PM (#17593731)
It's also incredible how much effort and money has gone into producing and debating and selecting open source licenses that have just the right restrictions on how everyone else can use code. I think there are some parallels with that and DRM.
Re:Why Intel will never let owners control the ME by mistrial9 on Sunday July 22, 2018 @03:58PM (#17588613)
This is fine rhetoric, but you clearly have no idea the sales volumes and number of players involved in some markets. It is far more money than say, writing the ssh protocol handler or whatever you might think is cool. Sorry, it is that harsh.
Re:Why Intel will never let owners control the ME by bryanbuckley on Sunday July 22, 2018 @07:40PM (#17589494)
> the enginners implementing these schemes must surely realize it's in vain

I wonder, if it is so "in vain", why have so many folks been so spooked by it (e.g. Stallman, Doctorow)? Are they worried about the needless increased cost to consumers, or maybe they think it might actually work well enough? If you are really against DRM, I don't get how saying DRM "will never work" will help avoid it.

I worked at TI on OMAP MShield, TrustZone stuff (iirc we were the first (w/ Galaxy Nexus) to have good-enough DRM to be the first to have Netflix HD) and later at Trustonic which is the OS (and more) vendor of AMD PSP and many ARM-based devices.

Everyone* knew that some use-cases of DRM meant a single successful hack meant the content being leaked. It is mostly the low-level designers (CPU arch, physical die, OS/firmware etc) to be responsible for making it more difficult/expensive. Some use-cases will be necessarily be concerned with simpler attacks e.g. recording a few key pages of a secure/DRMed PDF with a hidden camera (and thus more complex protections like a Central Licensing, watermarking server becoming involved). There are some use-cases of DRM where leaks are not a big issue (e.g. a more dynamic content which involves occasionally communicating with peers/servers).

[*] This is probably not true. That basic case is easy enough to see, but I've personally seen other schemes where customers leave out key steps or end up trusting something that shouldn't be trusted.

@hlandau makes good points, I think.

I've always been on the fence regarding DRM. I think property rights seem like a decent idea so why not extend that to the digital realm? Do we not want digital scarce goods, collectibles? Is a technical enforcement of property rights superior to meat-space? I see many cool uses for DRM, trusted computing (and in the end I think it would transfer power from publishers, platforms, manufacturers to creators and owners). It's interesting (and makes sense) to see how blockchain people are generally in favor of trusted computing (though for many it seems to be too much of a "silver bullet"); iirc bitcoin wallets were some of our first customers after video DRM.

I've talked with many folks over the years (including EFF people) and I've still not gotten a sense of why the theory of DRM is bad (I would agree that most implementations have been horrible), other than it starting a snowball towards a cyberpunk dystopia future, maybe. I 100% agree that "you own the device, you should be able to control it". That means I support the right to tinker, am against DMCA, and think owners of devices should be able to run whatever software they prefer and be able to wipe, disable, replace whatever they want (e.g. root of trust). While I worked at Trustonic, I pestered the CEO many times (and rallied co-workers to do the same) to open source the OS. In the end there was (allegedly) not a good enough business reason to do so (and of course open source competitors began to pop up: trusty, tlk, OP-TEE, etc).

Re:Why Intel will never let owners control the ME by bubblethink on Sunday July 22, 2018 @07:58PM (#17589552)
>I think property rights seem like a decent idea so why not extend that to the digital realm? Do we not want digital scarce goods, collectibles?

What does digital scarcity even mean ? You are just transferring the scarcity from the origin, i.e., the creator's resources, to the final output, which is not scarce at all in reality. We have accepted a model where the cost of the investment is recuperated after the fact. Hence, we need the artificial scarcity once the output is produced. If you change it to a patron model where something is only produced if it is funded, you don't need to make it artificially scarce. That is not very profitable of course.

Re:Why Intel will never let owners control the ME by bryanbuckley on Sunday July 22, 2018 @08:22PM (#17589642)
> What does digital scarcity even mean ?

In a world of trusted computing, it might mean some amazing HD+++ digital image being one-of-a-kind (and having some attestation/proof of origin, authorship, etc), even if there are lower res/quality versions out there for cheaper/free. It also might mean other granularities to accessing the data like functional permissions (e.g. for this version of the encrypted, wrapped data, the computer is only allowed to apply function X (265a1b..), or function Y (f00fe7..) is blacklisted, or the computer is allowed to view once or infinitely, etc). That might sound like shit to many, but certainly not to all.

Re:Why Intel will never let owners control the ME by bubblethink on Sunday July 22, 2018 @09:06PM (#17589790)
That is still artificially scarce. It is not scarce in the sense a painting is scarce because the artist only made one. And even the artist cannot make an exact copy even if he/she wishes to. Anything digital is indistinguishable from its copies, at least as far as enjoying it is concerned. There may be some limited value of bragging rights in getting the first edition, or a signed edition, of something digital, which you can verify using elaborate signature schemes, but that's where the novelty ends.
Re:Why Intel will never let owners control the ME by bryanbuckley on Sunday July 22, 2018 @09:22PM (#17589862)
I guess it's just semantics then, tomato tomato. One could theoretically make a digital painting with a DRM-enabled stack and could be left with only one (more likely to see DRM-enabled stacks coming to video/picture cameras, though). It's up for debate whether meat-space scarcity is more ... "authentic"? (higher effort to duplicate?) thanks to physics than something digital (e.g. DRM systems that might be more easily broken).
Re:Why Intel will never let owners control the ME by benchaney on Monday July 23, 2018 @12:46AM (#17590643)
> Are they worried about the needless increased cost to consumers, or maybe they think it might actually work well enough?

Obviously the former. They are both focused on ethical issues related to computing, which DRM has many implications for despite it's complete inability to achieve its stated goals.

> If you are really against DRM, I don't get how saying DRM "will never work" will help avoid it.

The idea is that if the companies pushing DRM realize that they are spending a ton of money pushing something that is useless, they will stop. Personally I don't think this is a viable strategy simply because it requires a level of rational thought from large companies that they clearly are incapable of acting on.

Re:Why Intel will never let owners control the ME by mycall on Sunday July 22, 2018 @10:29PM (#17590167)
1. You agree with "you own the device, you should be able to control it"

2. You agree with "I think property rights seem like a decent idea so why not extend that to the digital realm"

thus, if you own the device and the physical property rights with it, and you want to extend the property rights into the digital realm, you should also own the software on the device. Isn't that the logical conclusion?

Re:Why Intel will never let owners control the ME by bryanbuckley on Sunday July 22, 2018 @11:11PM (#17590324)
Should I (or do I?) own the firmware, OS, applications, etc? Maybe, maybe not. Certainly if I own a device, I should have the capability to use the device to its fullest with my own owned software (i.e. no gimping of hardware/firmware allowed depending on what is booting) i.e. I do not really own my iPhone. The DRM/trusted computing ecosystem might then be (realistically) opt-out via taking an alternative fork (running alternative software) of the web/tree/chain of trust. There need not be only one DRM/trusted computing fork, all-or-nothing choice, though.
Re:Why Intel will never let owners control the ME by seba_dos1 on Monday July 23, 2018 @07:54PM (#17597013)
There are plenty of morally legitimate use cases for trustable computing, and not that much for trusted computing, aside of the fact that technology behind those two are often the same or similar. There's nothing wrong with Secure Boot in how it works, it just becomes bad when you keep the user from putting their key there.