News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why Intel will never let owners control the ME by wpietri on Sunday July 22, 2018 @03:49PM (#17588562)
To me, Netflix is evidence that there's no point to DRM. I still can torrent any content I want, but I almost never do. But if it's on Netflix or anything else I subscribe to, I won't bother.

I suspect Netflix's DRM is purely about pacifying video industry executives, and that it makes approximately no difference to the bottom line of anybody except the people hyping their proprietary DRM solutions.

Re:Why Intel will never let owners control the ME by pdkl95 on Sunday July 22, 2018 @04:30PM (#17588771)
> there's no point to DRM. I still can torrent any content I want

DRM appears to be useless because you are incorrectly assuming DRM's purpose is to stop or reduce piracy. DRM is and always has been about controlling the playback platform.

Media companies like DRM so the can force anyone making a player to not implement features they don't like. Their ability to control how media is used was severely limited when the Betamax case[1] (1984) established that using a home video tape recorder to time shift was is fair use. Unable to legally control how media is used, media companies hade regularly attempted to establish and require a DRM scheme they could use to technologically control use.

The proper response is to tell the media companies their right to control a copyright protected work ends at the first sale[2].

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sony_Corp._of_America_v._Unive....

[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/First-sale_doctrine

Re:Why Intel will never let owners control the ME by bogomipz on Sunday July 22, 2018 @08:52PM (#17589738)
>"DRM appears to be useless because you are incorrectly assuming DRM's purpose is to stop or reduce piracy. DRM is and always has been about controlling the playback platform."

I'm no fan of DRM or the idiots in Hollywood but isn't "controlling the playback" a means to control piracy? Why must they be mutually exclusive?

>"Media companies like DRM so the can force anyone making a player to not implement features they don't like."

I'm curious is there any evidence of this? How would the Hollywood studios even be aware of all of the new hardware devices?

Re:Why Intel will never let owners control the ME by pdkl95 on Sunday July 22, 2018 @10:07PM (#17590068)
> isn't "controlling the playback" a means to control piracy?

No, it's about controlling the channels of publication so they can maintain their position as a gatekeeper.

> I'm curious is there any evidence of this?

See the SCOTUS case at my previous [1]. Universal Studios sued Sony over their new "Betamax" video tape recorders, arguing they were liable under the Lanham Act because their device could record video, which could be copyright infringement.

For more recent examples, see the requirements in DVD/BD licensing that force playback of ads and allow disks to disable various features (like fast-forward or track-skip during an ad).

Re:Why Intel will never let owners control the ME by wpietri on Monday July 23, 2018 @05:54AM (#17591644)
Sorry, but I'm not seeing the relevance of this to a streaming world. In what fashion do you believe they are controlling playback on Netflix, Amazon Prime, HBO, Starz, or any of the other streaming apps?
Re:Why Intel will never let owners control the ME by EvanAnderson on Sunday July 22, 2018 @09:51PM (#17589982)
Controlling playback allows the industry to insure that new works are industry-sanctioned and appropriately taxed by the incumbents. DRM allows the middle-men to continue being in the middle in the face of the democratization of production and distribution that technology has created.
Re:Why Intel will never let owners control the ME by bogomipz on Monday July 23, 2018 @10:40AM (#17593063)
>"Controlling playback allows the industry to insure that new works are industry-sanctioned and appropriately taxed by the incumbents"

What industry are you referring to here - the tech sector, the entertainment industry? This is rather vague. Also which tax are you referring to? Who are the "incumbents"?

Re:Why Intel will never let owners control the ME by wolfgke on Sunday July 22, 2018 @04:05PM (#17588653)
> To me, Netflix is evidence that there's no point to DRM. I still can torrent any content I want, but I almost never do.

To me, it is rather the other way round: As Netflix offers no DRM-free version, I will never subscribe. So in other words: by insisting on DRM, the movie industry openly states that they don't want any money from people who don't want DRM.

But if you "reverse" this sentence "in a hacker way", this means that they are not losing any money, if DRM-haters pirate (because they just stated that they don't want the DRM-haters' money).

Thus, in my opinion is quite a pro-pirating slogan coming from the mouth of Hollywood.

Re:Why Intel will never let owners control the ME by CJefferson on Sunday July 22, 2018 @04:11PM (#17588683)
I might just not have to imagination, but a DRM free Netflix wouldn't seem to work -- you pay a low monthly fee for temporary access to a huge library. What would you prefer?
Re:Why Intel will never let owners control the ME by wolfgke on Sunday July 22, 2018 @04:16PM (#17588701)
> I might just not have to imagination, but a DRM free Netflix wouldn't seem to work -- you pay a low monthly fee for temporary access to a huge library. What would you prefer?

I do not get your point. Perhaps I misunderstand it, because English is not my mother tongue.

I do not see a problem. First: If I really download a lot, I will soon get out of disk space (even if I own a NAS). Second: Netflix adds new movies/series all the time to its library. So there is an incentive to stay a subscriber.

Re:Why Intel will never let owners control the ME by joshuamorton on Sunday July 22, 2018 @04:38PM (#17588807)
Storage is cheap. You can store 500 hours of video in a TB. And four TB is less than one year of Netflix, but gives you enough storage to download enough video to last a few years.

I'd pay for one month of Netflix every two years instead of monthly, without question.

Re:Why Intel will never let owners control the ME by imtringued on Monday July 23, 2018 @04:13AM (#17591281)
At that point why even bother with netflix? Downloading the streams and watching them without a subscription is still copyright infringement. Illegal streaming sites have existed for decades already.

The primary benefit of DRM free netflix is to watch higher resolution videos on any browser that isn't Edge. [1]

[1] https://help.netflix.com/en/node/23742

Re:Why Intel will never let owners control the ME by wolfgke on Sunday July 22, 2018 @04:57PM (#17588890)
> I'd pay for one month of Netflix every two years instead of monthly, without question.

I can imagine that in this case Netflix would just have to change the price model somewhat: Make the first month much more expensive than the following ones to give a disincentive for canceling the subscription. At least this pricing model is applied by many software companies who love to sell subscriptions for their software.

Re:Why Intel will never let owners control the ME by CJefferson on Sunday July 22, 2018 @08:10PM (#17589602)
But, that would I imagine be terrible for Netflix -- their cheap monthly price encourages people to sign up on a whim. I suspect very few people would sign up if the first month had been much more expensive.
Re:Why Intel will never let owners control the ME by nybble41 on Monday July 23, 2018 @12:49PM (#17593949)
They could keep the cheap monthly price for first-time subscribers, and just make it so that if you cancel and want to sign back up later you're charged for all the months in between.
Re:Why Intel will never let owners control the ME by joshuamorton on Sunday July 22, 2018 @05:03PM (#17588915)
I'm sure Netflix would have seen explosive growth if it required 1 year, $100+ contracts, and that's assuming content producers would have been okay with it (they wouldn't have).

Sure they could have used a different business model, but had they, we wouldn't be talking about Netflix.

Re:Why Intel will never let owners control the ME by xfer on Sunday July 22, 2018 @10:43PM (#17590221)
The point is content maynot be worth watching, but you don't know unless you paid for it. You can make space by just keeping the content that are worth watching more than once, which in my experience is a very small fraction of the amount of movies produced.
Re:Why Intel will never let owners control the ME by wpietri on Monday July 23, 2018 @05:57AM (#17591651)
A DRM-free Netflix would work just fine. How much work am I going to go to just to cheat Netflix out of $8/month?

I can already torrent anything I want. But I don't because it's easier for me just to pay.

Re:Why Intel will never let owners control the ME by TomMarius on Sunday July 22, 2018 @03:52PM (#17588577)
Yes, I completely agree. I not only can torrent stuff, I can do it very comfortably as I used to do it a lot and have created a pipeline that will download it complete with subs in English and Czech, correctly name and categorize and make it available to my network so I can play it directly on my TV - all just by clicking on a magnet link. And yet since Netflix is available, I don't, Netflix is even more comfortable, and I want to support their original work.