News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Remains of the murdered Romanovs 'authentic' by Melchizedek on Wednesday July 18, 2018 @06:06AM (#17556847)
Nicholas II, his German-born wife and their five children were shot by Bolsheviks as a consequence of the October Revolution

They were not "shot as a consequence of". They were deliberately murdered under direct orders from Lenin, Dzerzhinsky, et al.

They were all brought together in a room and were shot and stabbed in a process that took about 20 minutes. Their bodies were then desecrated and disposed of.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Execution_of_the_Romanov_famil...

Re:Remains of the murdered Romanovs 'authentic' by dang on Wednesday July 18, 2018 @07:38AM (#17557355)
All: please don't re-fight the Russian Revolution here. HN is a place for intellectual curiosity, not rageful reactivation.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:Remains of the murdered Romanovs 'authentic' by Gargoyle on Wednesday July 18, 2018 @10:31AM (#17558737)
I continue to be fascinated by the discussions you feel compelled to chime in on.
Re:Remains of the murdered Romanovs 'authentic' by Boulth on Wednesday July 18, 2018 @06:50AM (#17557112)
> They were deliberately murdered under direct orders from Lenin,

Unfortunately, according to the Wikipedia article you posted, it's not that easy to verify:

> The written record taking the chain of command and the ultimate responsibility for the fate of the Romanovs back to Lenin was, from the beginning, either never made or carefully concealed.

...

> However, as of 2011, there has been no conclusive evidence that either Lenin or Sverdlov gave the order.

Re:Remains of the murdered Romanovs 'authentic' by imbokodo on Wednesday July 18, 2018 @06:35AM (#17557015)
And Lenin's brother was murdered by the Tsar's father, and the Tsar murdered many other Russians of his own account.

Those Bolshevik soldiers sent the parasitical Romanovs to where they belonged - into the dustbin of history.

Re:Remains of the murdered Romanovs 'authentic' by Melchizedek on Wednesday July 18, 2018 @06:43AM (#17557059)
Lenin's brother was tried and executed after trying to assassinate the Tsar. Comparing that to butchering children in secret is pretty rich.
Re:Remains of the murdered Romanovs 'authentic' by YorkshireSeason on Wednesday July 18, 2018 @06:47AM (#17557097)
Those Bolshevik soldiers and their leaders the proceeded to make the situation a lot worse than Tsar, and exported their incompetency to many other countries, with the last major eruption of Bolshevik violence happening in the 1970s in Cambodian by the Khmer Rouge (the Khmer branch of the Bolshevik/Leninist party).

The world would probably have been a much better place without the Bolshevik, despite, and in full view of the many imperfections of the Tsarist rule.

Re:Remains of the murdered Romanovs 'authentic' by lostlogin on Wednesday July 18, 2018 @07:05AM (#17557192)
> Those Bolshevik soldiers and their leaders the proceeded to make the situation a lot worse than Tsar

Lenin was exported to Russia by Germany with the specific aim of causing a revolution. To mangle Churchill’s quote, Lenin was sent in as “plague bacillus”. Obviously he acted with a lot of local support, but German intervention wanted and helped fund the revolution to end the war on their Eastern Front.

In hindsight it wasn’t a very good strategy for Germany.

Re:Remains of the murdered Romanovs 'authentic' by pjc50 on Wednesday July 18, 2018 @07:34AM (#17557331)
Everyone remembers the October revolution, but few remember the November revolution: Germany collapsed from the Kiel mutiny onwards, and turned from a monarchy into a socialist anti-war state in 1918.

There was a lot of it about. Churchill sent tanks into Glasgow in 1919; during this period Ireland also fought for its independence (and subsequent civil war).

The old authoritarianism was doomed but it absolutely wasn't going to go without bloodshed. Some of it still lies latent to the present day like a dormant virus.

Re:Remains of the murdered Romanovs 'authentic' by YorkshireSeason on Wednesday July 18, 2018 @07:42AM (#17557388)
Everyone remembers the October revolution, but few remember the February Revolution [1], the first of two revolutions which took place in Russia in 1917. It was the February revolution that lead to the abdication of Czar Nicholas II. For various reasons no decisive new leadership emerged, until the Bolsheviks took over in October.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/February_Revolution

Re:Remains of the murdered Romanovs 'authentic' by YorkshireSeason on Wednesday July 18, 2018 @07:20AM (#17557271)

   wasn’t a very good strategy for Germany
In what sense?

It did end the war in the East, and delayed the war for dominance in the East (which was seen as inevitable -- as it by the US left today, pace the mainstream press' demonisation of the Trump/Putin connection) by two decades. Even today Germany is wealthier than Russia despite having no natural resources.

The biggest victims of the Bolsheviks were the Russian people (and inhabitants of neighbouring states).

[1] https://history.stackexchange.com/questions/14608/did-the-ge...

Re:Remains of the murdered Romanovs 'authentic' by cm2187 on Wednesday July 18, 2018 @11:53AM (#17559482)
But the rise of communism and resulting violence in Germany greatly contributed to the rise of the nazis in the 20s and 30s.

I think comparing Germany to Russia today is missing the point. Europe self-destroyed through two world wars during the XX century. At the end of the XIX and for about 300 years before it pretty much dominated the world. Now it is a club of mid-size countries that have lost most of their international influence and military might.

The rising demography of developing countries being probably the second biggest factor.

Re:Remains of the murdered Romanovs 'authentic' by amaccuish on Wednesday July 18, 2018 @06:49AM (#17557109)
Yes Russia was a extremely well developed nation with good education, healthcare etc until those pesky bolsheviks came along and ruined everything...
Re:Remains of the murdered Romanovs 'authentic' by YorkshireSeason on Wednesday July 18, 2018 @07:08AM (#17557211)
What kind of argument is this supposed to be?

Russia was at an average level of development in 1918. European parts of Russia (St Petersburg) where relatively modern, and while much of the rest of the country was rural and backwards

* there is no reason whatsoever to assume that it wouldn't have been developed with other forms of government in Russia, whether under a Tsar, or -- even better -- a modern western democracy.

* Bolsheviks retarded the development of Russia. All comparable western nations developed faster, practically all 'Soviet' technology was basically invented in the west. The Soviets had nothing to offer but violence.

For example (from [1]): "Russia's population growth rate from 1850 to 1910 was the fastest of all the major powers except for the United States."

Let me emphasise: I'm not saying that the Tsarist regime was particularly good, just a lot better than the Bolsheviks. If Russia had stayed Tsarist, or -- even better -- become a normal western democracy, it would have been much better than the Bolshevik rule.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_Russia_(1855%E2%80%...

Re:Remains of the murdered Romanovs 'authentic' by jkabrg on Wednesday July 18, 2018 @08:52AM (#17557887)
Which "comparable western nations" are you referring to?
Re:Remains of the murdered Romanovs 'authentic' by jahaja on Wednesday July 18, 2018 @08:28AM (#17557701)
> If Russia had stayed Tsarist, or -- even better -- become a normal western democracy, it would have been much better than the Bolshevik rule.

There's a lot of "if onlys" that could be said about the period between 1905 and Stalin's takeover. To stay Tsarist seems a peculiar focus.

Re:Remains of the murdered Romanovs 'authentic' by golergka on Wednesday July 18, 2018 @07:07AM (#17557202)
Yes, it actually was, in many different areas, one of the most developed countries in Europe in 1914.
Re:Remains of the murdered Romanovs 'authentic' by lostlogin on Wednesday July 18, 2018 @06:29AM (#17556982)
He was a terrible leader. Racist and horrifically anti Semitic, aggressive, incompetent as a military leader and in domestic policy. The number of deaths directly attributable to him is right up there with most the other Russian leaders. This doesn’t justify what happened to him, but certainly helps explain it.
Re:Remains of the murdered Romanovs 'authentic' by baybal2 on Wednesday July 18, 2018 @07:27AM (#17557305)
Are you referring to Lenin?
Re:Remains of the murdered Romanovs 'authentic' by lostlogin on Wednesday July 18, 2018 @04:25PM (#17561784)
Nicholas II, though I suspect you know that. Nicely done.

It seems to need stating each time, both the guys were terrible.

Re:Remains of the murdered Romanovs 'authentic' by tzahola on Wednesday July 18, 2018 @06:39AM (#17557041)
>Racist and horrifically anti Semitic

Just like basically everyone else at the time.

Re:Remains of the murdered Romanovs 'authentic' by lostlogin on Wednesday July 18, 2018 @06:50AM (#17557113)
To be clear, his anti-semitism extended to support of murderous pogroms. This wasn’t common elsewhere.
Re:Remains of the murdered Romanovs 'authentic' by lostlogin on Wednesday July 18, 2018 @02:16PM (#17560776)
The first and last are 100 years earlier and the second two relate to catholics.

I may be missing your point but you don’t give any context to those sources.

Re:Remains of the murdered Romanovs 'authentic' by tzahola on Wednesday July 18, 2018 @03:07PM (#17561214)
Yes, catholics. Why does it matter? Persecution is persecution, be it against jews, catholics, protestants, muslims, atheists, whatever.

Also, you’re saying “100 years earlier” as if that’s a long timespan in history. I know, the USA is not much older than that, but in Europe, 100 years is nothing.

And considering that ~40 years after the last Russian pogroms there was this thing called “the Holocaust”, I’m not really convinced that antisemitism was a thing of the past in Western Europe either.

Re:Remains of the murdered Romanovs 'authentic' by lostlogin on Thursday July 19, 2018 @04:05AM (#17564587)
You are right, it’s still there and does periodically make it into the news (eg the U.K. Labour Party is still struggling with anti-semitism this week). https://www.google.co.nz/amp/s/amp.theguardian.com/politics/...

The cited persecution of Catholics was and is still undoubtably, but it things happening around the turn of the 20th century in Britain really weren’t of the same nature as what was happening in Russia, not at all. British weren’t raping and killing Catholics in massive waves of concerted violence with state involvement and approval and that’s exactly what was happening in Russia around that time. 100 years is relatively short time but I definitely argue that a lot has changed and the level of violence is declining. Pinker has some good article on the subject of violence but which notably don’t say anything about violence toward small groups, though say a lot about the larger picture.

https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/steven-pinker-thi...

https://www.edge.org/3rd_culture/pinker07/pinker07_index.htm...

Re:Remains of the murdered Romanovs 'authentic' by littletimmy on Wednesday July 18, 2018 @07:08AM (#17557213)
Saying that the Tsar's death was because he was anti-semitic gives credibility to the notion that Bolshevism had a large Jewish influence. Is that what you're trying to say?
Re:Remains of the murdered Romanovs 'authentic' by JadeNB on Wednesday July 18, 2018 @07:29AM (#17557317)
> > Racist and horrifically anti Semitic

> Just like basically everyone else at the time.

Does this really matter? I mean, one probably should understand racism and anti-Semitism in the context of their times, but that doesn't excuse them; a racist and anti-Semite is a horrible leader even if surrounded by people with those same horrible qualities.

EDIT: Jeez, I hope the downvotes are because people find this off-topic or something, rather than because they disagree with the sentiment.

Re:Remains of the murdered Romanovs 'authentic' by tzahola on Wednesday July 18, 2018 @09:26AM (#17558162)
Let's say, that in a 100 years, we'll introduce the same fundamental rights to animals as we already have for humans. Killing animals and eating them would become a barbaric thing of the past.

Would you find it fair if people of the future spat on your grave, and refer to you with the utmost contempt, because you were a meat eater?

"He was a horrible, disgusting meat-eater! He deserved to die!"

Re:Remains of the murdered Romanovs 'authentic' by mcgarnagle on Wednesday July 18, 2018 @10:43AM (#17558850)
Yes, that would be the logical thing to find fair once you forgo your current ego. Disclosure, I eat meat, and if people should critique me in the future, so be it.

Half the people in this thread are ripping on Lenin because of the things he did, even though at the time they were mostly "lawful" since he wrote the law.

We absolutely should disgrace the horrible things people did in the past, so that to not do them over again.

Re:Remains of the murdered Romanovs 'authentic' by tzahola on Wednesday July 18, 2018 @10:56AM (#17558983)
"like many of his contemporaries, he held racist beliefs"

vs

"he was a disgusting racist antisemite! those bolsheviks sent him where he belongs! shooting and stabbing the whole family to death, hell yeah xDDDDD"

Re:Remains of the murdered Romanovs 'authentic' by JadeNB on Wednesday July 18, 2018 @11:37AM (#17559345)
> He was a horrible, disgusting meat-eater!

Possibly, if that's the consensus of current mores, but I didn't say that; I said that a racist and an anti-Semite is a horrible leader.

> He deserved to die!

No, I definitely didn't say that. In fact, lostlogin explicitly disclaimed this position (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17556982):

> This doesn’t justify what happened to him, but certainly helps explain it.

(emphasis mine). There are plenty of horrible people out there, but, most (and possibly all) of the time, wishing death on them is equally horrible.

Re:Remains of the murdered Romanovs 'authentic' by vixen99 on Wednesday July 18, 2018 @07:40AM (#17557377)
What is the point of anonymous opinion casters? They're anonymous, quote no sources and believe think their opinions are important enough to made public. Readers too can check out the last Tsar of Russia and come to their own private views.

If you don't like the estimate of 85 and 100 million people killed under communism (other Russian leaders) according to https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Number_of_deaths_in_the_Soviet... then please offer a counter offer more in line with your assertion. Whatever please stop offering off-the-cuff unsubstantiated views. They have zero value for others.

Re:Remains of the murdered Romanovs 'authentic' by lostlogin on Wednesday July 18, 2018 @02:05PM (#17560675)
To compare like with like, should the death toll due to communism be compared to that from the Romanov line, or to that from imperial systems of government? I’m not sure communism will compare too badly.

A good source is the Montefiore book on the Romanovs and is in my comments here. It’s worth reading.

https://www.nytimes.com/2016/05/22/books/review/the-romanovs...