News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:MacBook Pro with i9 chip is throttled due to thermal issu... by slantyyz on Tuesday July 17, 2018 @10:01PM (#17555072)
In fairness, Lee criticized the Dell XPS 15's thermals in a video a couple of days ago. Of course, he also posted a video last week about how he was starting to hate Apple products.

If you watch a lot of his videos, you'll notice that he almost always talks about thermals, so it's not surprising to see him focus on that aspect of the MBP.

Re:MacBook Pro with i9 chip is throttled due to thermal issu... by wukerplank on Wednesday July 18, 2018 @12:04AM (#17555506)
In all fairness: If you sell a >3000€ laptop, people should expect to get the full value out of it. Maybe it's hard to cool CPUs in thin laptops. But then don't let people pay for expensive upgrades that have no performance benefit.
Re:MacBook Pro with i9 chip is throttled due to thermal issu... by whywhywhywhy on Wednesday July 18, 2018 @06:13AM (#17556896)
Seems like it's hard to cool GPUs in desktops too if you're Apple

>their maximum FP32 compute performance is 11 TFLOPS (which points to around 1340 MHz clock-rate for the Vega 64) and their peak memory bandwidth is 400 GB/s (indicating about 1600 MT/s memory speed), which is slower when compared to the Radeon RX Vega cards for desktops. The main reasons why Apple downlocks its GPUs are of course power consumption and heat dissipation https://www.anandtech.com/show/12152/apple-starts-imac-pro-s...

Sad to see that this is becoming a recurring theme from Apple's pro line.

Re:MacBook Pro with i9 chip is throttled due to thermal issu... by rbanffy on Wednesday July 18, 2018 @07:19AM (#17557264)
Downclocking, by itself, tends to increase component lifetime. It makes sense for a professional machine that's not supposed to break after a couple years.

Of course, if the component still overheats, that completely beats the purpose of the downclocking.

Re:MacBook Pro with i9 chip is throttled due to thermal issu... by 52-6F-62 on Wednesday July 18, 2018 @09:41AM (#17558259)
Exactly. In other tech this is called headroom.

It’s just a pragmatic approach to a physical limitation. The right choice given the clientele— debatable. But just the same it’s not unique to computer manufacturers.

Re:MacBook Pro with i9 chip is throttled due to thermal issu... by alluro2 on Saturday July 21, 2018 @08:10PM (#17584560)
Or, they've gotten a really good deal on binned chips.
Re:MacBook Pro with i9 chip is throttled due to thermal issu... by vbezhenar on Wednesday July 18, 2018 @12:22AM (#17555563)
It depends on workload. If I'm typing code for a minute and then spending few seconds compiling and launching it, it won't trigger throttling, but reducing each compilation from 3 seconds to 2 seconds is certainly a benefit.
Re:MacBook Pro with i9 chip is throttled due to thermal issu... by improbable22 on Wednesday July 18, 2018 @06:37AM (#17557029)
Exactly. It seems that fast chips in slim laptops are like fast chips in phones. They may be worth having for performance on 2-second tasks, and might keep up with a desktop there.

If what you care about is performance on 2-hour tasks, there's just no chance, that's a completely different thing.

Re:MacBook Pro with i9 chip is throttled due to thermal issu... by gaius on Wednesday July 18, 2018 @01:50AM (#17555806)
“Creative” workloads require sustained CPU tho’ and that’s who Apple claims this is for
Re:MacBook Pro with i9 chip is throttled due to thermal issu... by imtringued on Wednesday July 18, 2018 @07:03AM (#17557175)
Or people whose projects require several minutes of compilation rather than just 2 seconds...
Re:MacBook Pro with i9 chip is throttled due to thermal issu... by coldtea on Wednesday July 18, 2018 @04:19AM (#17556328)
Which "creative" workloads? Video, 3D, and photography mostly require sustained GPU.

For audio, it's more the CPU.

Re:MacBook Pro with i9 chip is throttled due to thermal issu... by raverbashing on Wednesday July 18, 2018 @05:18AM (#17556577)
It's both, it's actually hard to have a very high GPU load and a low CPU load (unless you're doing crypto mining, I guess)

For typical loads, both will be at a high level of usage

Re:MacBook Pro with i9 chip is throttled due to thermal issu... by gaius on Wednesday July 18, 2018 @04:44AM (#17556406)
I expect the GPU generates heat as well. Which is why all the interest in external enclosures.

This entire thread is baffling to me. Everyone rushing to justify buying a new high performance laptop which they don’t mind throttling because they never needed the performance in the first place??

Re:MacBook Pro with i9 chip is throttled due to thermal issu... by wtallis on Wednesday July 18, 2018 @07:13AM (#17557238)
> Everyone rushing to justify buying a new high performance laptop which they don’t mind throttling because they never needed the performance in the first place??

Time scale is relevant. I want interactive tasks to be faster. I won't notice a 5% improvement in a job that takes long enough for a coffee break, but I will appreciate if more short tasks can cross the threshold of being indistinguishable from instantaneous.

Re:MacBook Pro with i9 chip is throttled due to thermal issu... by AstralStorm on Wednesday July 18, 2018 @12:54PM (#17560018)
We're talking 100% improvement here. This could be reducing a render from an hour to 20 minutes, a qualitative difference.
Re:MacBook Pro with i9 chip is throttled due to thermal issu... by andromeduck on Wednesday July 18, 2018 @05:07AM (#17556527)
Does the internal GPU generate enough heat to throttle under typical conditions? Having the option for external GPUs is a completely different story.
Re:MacBook Pro with i9 chip is throttled due to thermal issu... by imtringued on Wednesday July 18, 2018 @07:07AM (#17557199)
If it's the 13 inch model with an iGPU only then yes. The CPU and GPU will share their total TDP.
Re:MacBook Pro with i9 chip is throttled due to thermal issu... by xyzzyz on Wednesday July 18, 2018 @07:02PM (#17562737)
Video encoding and photography processing mostly use CPU.
Re:MacBook Pro with i9 chip is throttled due to thermal issu... by zamalek on Wednesday July 18, 2018 @12:50AM (#17555645)
> But then don't let people pay for expensive upgrades that have no performance benefit.

The number of people who want performance stats, or at least think they need, far outnumber the amount of people who need performance. It makes absolute sense to sell these lemons, even though it is unethical.

Re:MacBook Pro with i9 chip is throttled due to thermal issu... by geezerjay on Wednesday July 18, 2018 @03:23AM (#17556114)
> or at least think they need,

Irrelevant. If you pay premium for performance expecting to get the level of performance you've paid for then you better get what you've paid for.

Otherwise we're dealing with something very similar to consumer fraud covered with a thin paternalist veil of "corporation knows best".

Re:MacBook Pro with i9 chip is throttled due to thermal issu... by zamalek on Wednesday July 18, 2018 @02:35PM (#17560940)
> pay premium [...] get what you've paid for

That makes no sense. "Premium" strictly means "at a higher cost." You can't possibly get what you have paid for with premium products, because some of your money has been spent purchasing the premium.

Regardless of sour reviews such as this one, most people will continue to buy Apple products because Apple sales have managed to transcend the quality of their products. Apple will continue to push the boundaries of what is acceptable and people will continue to buy their products, defend them and praise them - no different from the past decade.

The fault lies squarely with consumers. Apple is just doing what they are being asked to do: flatter things, bigger numbers, higher prices.

Re:MacBook Pro with i9 chip is throttled due to thermal issu... by wukerplank on Wednesday July 18, 2018 @02:11AM (#17555868)
> it is unethical

The only part that matters. Maybe it's even illegal.

Re:MacBook Pro with i9 chip is throttled due to thermal issu... by noir_lord on Wednesday July 18, 2018 @06:55AM (#17557149)
My ThinkPad T470P can run at 100% on a hot day, the CPU gets hot but it doesn't throttle down.

Stockfish (chess engine) will batter a CPU like that.

Re:MacBook Pro with i9 chip is throttled due to thermal issu... by glogla on Wednesday July 18, 2018 @07:16AM (#17557252)
Actually, it throttles as well, see notebookcheck review:

https://www.notebookcheck.net/Lenovo-ThinkPad-T470p-Core-i7-...

Re:MacBook Pro with i9 chip is throttled due to thermal issu... by coldtea on Wednesday July 18, 2018 @04:18AM (#17556319)
>In all fairness: If you sell a >3000€ laptop, people should expect to get the full value out of it.

The full value out of it includes:

1) It not being short-lived by rampant overheating (even if it's within cpu tolerances) 2) It being quiet as you expect a MBP to be

It's not supposed to render 6K 3D all day at full speed in the tropics...

Re:MacBook Pro with i9 chip is throttled due to thermal issu... by zaarn on Wednesday July 18, 2018 @04:48AM (#17556433)
I think it's supposed to render for a few dozen minutes fairly fast though and it fails at that. And I don't think it was 6K 3D footage either, considering the render time it was probably closer to 1080p60.

"You're using it wrong" (ie, "it's not supposed for" with different wording) has been a long time excuse for many Apple failures at this point and I'm tired of it.

Re:MacBook Pro with i9 chip is throttled due to thermal issu... by kalleboo on Wednesday July 18, 2018 @05:21AM (#17556592)
> It's not supposed to render 6K 3D all day at full speed in the tropics

Hyperbole aside, their advertising shows it hooked up to a 5K external display running the Unity debugger. So it should at least be able to render 5K 3D for a typical work day.

Re:MacBook Pro with i9 chip is throttled due to thermal issu... by coldtea on Wednesday July 18, 2018 @06:39AM (#17557044)
And it doesn't? Before that was not part of the test in TFA -- which was quite simplistic.
Re:MacBook Pro with i9 chip is throttled due to thermal issu... by djsumdog on Wednesday July 18, 2018 @01:06AM (#17555679)
I have a Dell XPS 15 (2017) and the thermals are really bad. I saw constant throttling in my kernel logs and the laptop sometimes slowed to a crawl when compiling, running a ton of docker containers, using Light Table or even just having a ton of browser tabs open.

I finally ditched it a few weeks ago, finally replacing it with a Ryzen 7 desktop.

I'll admit my XPS 15 was a factory refurbished model, so maybe I just got a lemon. It got so hot the battery is now swelling and it popped out the trackpad (I think there might be a recall; or if not take it in since that's gotta be under warranty).

My current laptop is a HP Spectre. It's thicker than the XPS, but I think it's got a much better cooling solution and preforms better. I don't think I'd recommend a Dell XPS again.

Re:MacBook Pro with i9 chip is throttled due to thermal issu... by nickjj on Wednesday July 18, 2018 @06:53AM (#17557134)
I don't know if this is sad or funny but my $350 Chromebook[1] that I modified to run Linux happily runs large Docker based Rails apps and has overall been a great development laptop for the last 2+ years. It has a 1080p IPS panel, a keyboard that I like more than my workstation, a real SSD and it weighs under 3 pounds.

[1]: https://nickjanetakis.com/blog/transform-a-toshiba-chromeboo...

Re:MacBook Pro with i9 chip is throttled due to thermal issu... by eropple on Wednesday July 18, 2018 @01:25AM (#17555746)
YMMV, but in addition to a dodgy (manufacturer defect) and oddly designed (strangely shaped modifier keys) keyboard, my HP Spectre got really hot under comparatively minor load.
Re:MacBook Pro with i9 chip is throttled due to thermal issu... by anothergoogler on Wednesday July 18, 2018 @01:12AM (#17555696)
The higher end Latitudes seem like a better comparison to the MBP, I'd be interested to know how they stack up (thermal and otherwise).
Re:MacBook Pro with i9 chip is throttled due to thermal issu... by crispinb on Wednesday July 18, 2018 @05:58AM (#17556797)
I have the new 2018 9570 with an i9, and throttling is very modest. My workloads tend to be bursty rather than sustained, so I probably wouldn't notice in normal use anyway. But running the Intel XTU stress test, I only get very short periods of throttling.

Perhaps the 9570 is improved, or as many suggest Dells QC is poor and I got lucky.

Re:MacBook Pro with i9 chip is throttled due to thermal issu... by alluro2 on Saturday July 21, 2018 @08:18PM (#17584590)
Oh man, it's not a lemon...My experience, with a pricy 7700HQ, 4K touch, is exactly the same. First a faulty SSD which first replacement of SSD and motherboard didn't solve (second repl. of drive did), then throttling, and then the swollen battery pushing out the touchpad - I even also got a Ryzen desktop instead (1700x)!
Re:MacBook Pro with i9 chip is throttled due to thermal issu... by _Codemonkeyism on Wednesday July 18, 2018 @03:03AM (#17556038)
Thermal on my i7 xps13 is abysmal. Never again.
Re:MacBook Pro with i9 chip is throttled due to thermal issu... by prolikewh0a on Thursday July 19, 2018 @10:48AM (#17566781)
Thermals on my early 2018 9370 i7 are perfect and I haven't really seen any throttling even doing video rendering unless I'm sitting in my apartment while its 85F+ (Seattle still doesn't know what AC is) and it's on my lap.

The fans do spin up and they're audible, but not louder than my Thinkpad or any of the Macbook Pro's we have at work. It is dead silent unless I'm actually doing intensive work.

It seems people have a lot of issues with older models though, so YMMV.

Re:MacBook Pro with i9 chip is throttled due to thermal issu... by m_fayer on Wednesday July 18, 2018 @03:13AM (#17556074)
Same. It's hot, loud, and still never feels as fast as it should.
Re:MacBook Pro with i9 chip is throttled due to thermal issu... by kowdermeister on Wednesday July 18, 2018 @05:57AM (#17556783)
Loud? it's the quietest machine I ever had. No problems so far (9370 model)
Re:MacBook Pro with i9 chip is throttled due to thermal issu... by m_fayer on Wednesday July 18, 2018 @09:09AM (#17558013)
Mine is the 9360 with the i7-8550U. In high performance mode, it's a hair drier. In balanced, the fan is a constant annoying whine if I have, for example, Webpack in watch mode, or am typing code quickly and keeping the IDE's language service active, or if any browser tab has any active JS at all. Basically if the CPU is at a reasonable speed and at 20% load, constant fan noise.

It's quiet if I have it in "silent" mode, but then I might as well be using a 350$ machine, as far as performance is concerned.

Maybe you have a slower CPU, or they fixed the thermals in your model?

Re:MacBook Pro with i9 chip is throttled due to thermal issu... by kowdermeister on Wednesday July 18, 2018 @11:35AM (#17559334)
Then I'm glad I have the '18 model, despite the USB-C tyranny. I don't know if they fixed stuff, but it's a pleasant experience so far. CPU is i5-8250I with Windows 10 if feels snappy.

https://imgur.com/a/afvqtbQ

The fan is running at around 10%, barely noticeable.

Re:MacBook Pro with i9 chip is throttled due to thermal issu... by spatular on Wednesday July 18, 2018 @11:09AM (#17559115)
I have 9360 with i5-7200U. I've just checked, fan kicks in after 90 seconds of sha1sum /dev/zero and stays always on lowest RPMs. 25C ambient. With 50% core load at 3.1GHz it stays silent most of the time...
Re:MacBook Pro with i9 chip is throttled due to thermal issu... by m_fayer on Wednesday July 18, 2018 @12:57PM (#17560051)
50% at 3.1GHZ would make for one noisy experience here. Either mine's a lemon, or, more likely, there's no way to get a CPU like the i7-8550U into such a small case without causing thermal issues.
Re:MacBook Pro with i9 chip is throttled due to thermal issu... by _Codemonkeyism on Wednesday July 18, 2018 @09:29AM (#17558178)
Same here.
Re:MacBook Pro with i9 chip is throttled due to thermal issu... by kart23 on Wednesday July 18, 2018 @02:18AM (#17555886)
My old xps 13 with the i5 had great thermals on the other hand, but was still snappy enough for almost everything I threw at it. Didn't like it b/c the screen was just a tad too small for me and I had some problems getting good audio on the machine. Also, coil whine. It was awful.
Re:MacBook Pro with i9 chip is throttled due to thermal issu... by gambiting on Wednesday July 18, 2018 @03:14AM (#17556080)
Same here. 13 inch XPS, coil whine is insane. Had the motherboard replaced 3 times, no improvement. It was a replacement for my ageing Air 13", and I honestly wish I didn't swap. At first glance it's just as nice, the build quality and form factor are identical - and then you start using it, and see that Dell charges just as much if not more than Apple, but quality of several different elements is ages behind apple.
Re:MacBook Pro with i9 chip is throttled due to thermal issu... by saas_co_de on Wednesday July 18, 2018 @03:47AM (#17556188)
I was thinking about getting an XPS 15 soon so this gives me pause.

> Dell charges just as much if not more than Apple

Not even close. XPS 15 with 6 core, 16GB RAM, 256GB SSD is $1500. MBP is $2400 for the same specs.

What I really like on the XPS 15 is the 97 WHR battery. I haven't seen any other notebook with this capacity.

Re:MacBook Pro with i9 chip is throttled due to thermal issu... by clappski on Wednesday July 18, 2018 @04:47AM (#17556426)
I bought a Nvidia/i7 XPS 15 in March and have never understood the coil whine complaints, yeah there is some but nothing too bad (comparable to my 2012 MacBook Air). Alternately everyone else has super hearing or I’m deaf, YMMV.
Re:MacBook Pro with i9 chip is throttled due to thermal issu... by gambiting on Wednesday July 18, 2018 @03:57AM (#17556220)
Yes, I mean obviously right now the brand new MBP is absurdly expensive. But when I got the XPS 13 it was actually more expensive than an equivalent MacBook Air(with the caveat that the XPS had a higher resolution screen).
Re:MacBook Pro with i9 chip is throttled due to thermal issu... by garmaine on Wednesday July 18, 2018 @06:12AM (#17556891)
MacBook Air is not comparable to an XPS...
Re:MacBook Pro with i9 chip is throttled due to thermal issu... by gambiting on Wednesday July 18, 2018 @06:30AM (#17556990)
The one I have(9333) is literally identical in form factor and inside construction to the Air - if you open the bottom cover, the layout of everything is exactly the same, it's as if Dell copied the whole design as-is. Nowadays the XPS 13 has exceeded everything the Air can offer, but just couple years ago that was not the case.
Re:MacBook Pro with i9 chip is throttled due to thermal issu... by TomMarius on Wednesday July 18, 2018 @06:28AM (#17556981)
You can buy older (but unused) Macbook Pro with these specs (except it's 4 core instead of 6) for $1000 and it has way more battery life, nicer screen and better touchpad.
Re:MacBook Pro with i9 chip is throttled due to thermal issu... by ben-schaaf on Wednesday July 18, 2018 @07:02AM (#17557174)
The Aero 15 has a 94WHr and a better gpu
Re:MacBook Pro with i9 chip is throttled due to thermal issu... by prolikewh0a on Thursday July 19, 2018 @10:53AM (#17566831)
What model XPS 13? My 2018 9370 has no coil whine even when I hold the keyboard to my head.

I think it's a fixed issue, but only in 2018 models, so YMMV.

Re:MacBook Pro with i9 chip is throttled due to thermal issu... by gnufied on Tuesday July 17, 2018 @10:22PM (#17555155)
And thermals is real issue with race to making thinnest laptops possible. My Thinkpad T450s throttles just running Chrome and bunch of tabs. I don't see how a competitor having thermal problems exonerates Apple from having similar problems.
Re:MacBook Pro with i9 chip is throttled due to thermal issu... by eropple on Tuesday July 17, 2018 @10:56PM (#17555279)
A big part of why I got the T480 instead of the T480s was to avoid the thermals issue. Seems okay so far, but who knows how long (I've only had it a couple days) that'll go.
Re:MacBook Pro with i9 chip is throttled due to thermal issu... by rz2k on Wednesday July 18, 2018 @12:05AM (#17555512)
In biology thin would imply a high surface area to volume ratio, and great performance if you're trying to get rid of internally generated heat. Here, I guess we're talking about room for cooling systems so as to avoid blistering users' skin or charring their pants?
Re:MacBook Pro with i9 chip is throttled due to thermal issu... by lebrad on Wednesday July 18, 2018 @12:19AM (#17555553)
We were able to shave 1mm off of the skin by removing the sweat glands. When you start to feel hot just stop what you're doing.
Re:MacBook Pro with i9 chip is throttled due to thermal issu... by locusm on Wednesday July 18, 2018 @01:55AM (#17555818)
A CPU in a laptop destined for any target market that doesn't even hold base clock speeds should not have made it out of the QA dept.
Re:MacBook Pro with i9 chip is throttled due to thermal issu... by pixelcloud on Tuesday July 17, 2018 @10:39PM (#17555215)
But does the i9 version have performance issues (i.e. it under performs compared to the i7)? The XPS 15 with the i9 configuration comes with 32GB ram and it much cheaper than an equivalent macbook pro. I can deal with it getting hot!
Re:MacBook Pro with i9 chip is throttled due to thermal issu... by lhl on Tuesday July 17, 2018 @10:50PM (#17555260)
The XPS 15 i9 does do a bit of throttling, but off the boost clock (it manages to mostly stick to 4GHz in the stress test that Lee shows) while the MBP i9 apparently can't even maintain the 2.9GHz base clock.

That, along with performance that's below the previous-gen i7 but charging $300 more is the real kicker - honestly, I'm not sure how anyone at Apple would be able to justify that as not just bilking their customers out of money.

It seems like these days, the mantra is "buyer beware" if you're looking to buy a Mac.

Re:MacBook Pro with i9 chip is throttled due to thermal issu... by shub on Tuesday July 17, 2018 @11:26PM (#17555389)
IMO the last good laptops Apple made were the pre-Touch Bar Retina MBPs. I've used three different ones, two for work and one that I purchased myself, and they were all solid performers with excellent screens, excellent keyboards, excellent performance, adequate ports, and adequate portability. The new MacBook, with its terrible everything-aside-from-thickness-and-weight, showed that Apple has lost interest in making a usable laptop in favor of any kind of differentiation they can get. Even if it's pointless or apparently even worse than nothing.
Re:MacBook Pro with i9 chip is throttled due to thermal issu... by wlll on Tuesday July 17, 2018 @10:55PM (#17555274)
In the video he shows the i9 rendering slower than the i7. When he runs the render on the i9 in a freezer then it runs faster.
Re:MacBook Pro with i9 chip is throttled due to thermal issu... by crispinb on Wednesday July 18, 2018 @06:04AM (#17556831)
A couple of weeks into f/t use, mine (XPS 15" 9570, i9, 32GB RAM) doesn't get hot at all (fairly typical dev stuff - Docker, VMs, browsers, IntelliJ). It throttles intermittently, for short periods (perhaps 5% of the time) under a stress test.
Re:MacBook Pro with i9 chip is throttled due to thermal issu... by Kurtz79 on Wednesday July 18, 2018 @05:51AM (#17556750)
I have had thermal issues both in my old Lenovo T61P and a more recent Macbook Pro 15, both with dedicated graphic cards.

No replacing of soldering paste on my part was ever able to improve the situation, with the result of having powerful machines only on paper, that were brought to their knees even by light workloads.

My Mac becomes impossibly hot and slows down playing games like Hearthstone and Civ5, FFS.

I have long decided that my next laptop (regardless of the brand) will have integrated graphics and a medium TDP CPU, and I will just limit heavy workloads and gaming to my desktop.

Re:MacBook Pro with i9 chip is throttled due to thermal issu... by skgoa on Wednesday July 18, 2018 @06:08AM (#17556865)
> I have long decided that my next laptop (regardless of the brand) will have integrated graphics and a medium TDP CPU, and I will just limit heavy workloads and gaming to my desktop.

You get more bang for your bucks this way, too. Desktop hardware costs a fraction of a comparable laptop.

Re:MacBook Pro with i9 chip is throttled due to thermal issu... by Kurtz79 on Wednesday July 18, 2018 @06:40AM (#17557053)
Of course. A laptop, no matter how powerful and well designed, is always going to be a compromise compared to a desktop, in terms of raw power and relative cost.

The tradeoff is convenience, where you would have single machine that is able to fill all your needs (power and mobility), instead of two.

But, for me at least, in the end it's not worth it. Also, cloud and sync services made working in parallel on multiple machines almost painless.