News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Please stop asking me to use the app by ajross on Monday July 02, 2018 @10:10PM (#17446947)
At this point I'm genuinely wondering if they're about to Digg themselves into a amusingly-recursive grave. All it would take is one great, open forum site to absorb the refugees from a terrible management mistep, and they're toast. Just like Digg.
Re:Please stop asking me to use the app by slg on Monday July 02, 2018 @10:23PM (#17447007)
The funny thing is that Reddit completely inadvertently killed one of the possible heirs in Voat. That site had potential to steal the traditional Reddit audience due to Reddit's mismanagement. However Reddit's crackdown on hate on the site caused a big exodus of problem users to Voat. The end result is that Voat is now a vile alt-right wasteland that presents no threat of stealing Reddit's mainstream audience.
Re:Please stop asking me to use the app by supertrope on Monday July 02, 2018 @11:26PM (#17447258)
That's like how some online games don't entirely ban cheat users but only match them with other cheaters, giving them a taste of their own medicine. There's a tipping point in the evolution of communities. When there are too many acting in an anti-social manner such that fun or business is impaired, people quit. If not addressed the community permanently declines.

There's a term of art in philosophy called universalizability (Kant). Basically, what would happen if everyone followed a principle or strategy. Locke spoke of the social contract - civilization is not compatible with unlimited individual freedom.

Reddit already has an interesting user sorting and self-selection process: sub-reddits. People can more easily congregate around common interests. They don't even have to buy a domain, learn HTML, or pay hosting bills. Which would seem to reduce flame wars. But this can result in groupthink and safe spaces for extreme views.

Re:Please stop asking me to use the app by matthewwiese on Tuesday July 03, 2018 @01:39AM (#17447825)
> universalizability

Just for those interested in philosophy but lacking knowledge of the subject, this is technically correct but not the complete picture. The term "universalizability" is informal and not precise in describing Kant's morality; it falls under his categorical imperative.[0] I suggest the entire linked SEP article for a more thorough discussion of the topic.

[0]: https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/kant-moral/#CatHypImp

Re:Please stop asking me to use the app by swyx on Tuesday July 03, 2018 @05:14PM (#17453666)
> That's like how some online games don't entirely ban cheat users but only match them with other cheaters

this sounds interesting and im not sure its common knowledge. does anyone have a source?

Re:Please stop asking me to use the app by supertrope on Tuesday July 03, 2018 @06:27PM (#17454090)
Steam games using VAC do not fully ban cheaters. They can still play on non-VAC servers. Of course, those tend to be scarce because no one wants to uncheck that feature when creating a server.

Xbox Live: https://arstechnica.com/gaming/2013/07/microsoft-explains-xb... I've never owned an Xbox so I don't know how effective it was.

Re:Please stop asking me to use the app by toomanybeersies on Monday July 02, 2018 @11:35PM (#17447299)
Oh wow. Last time I looked at voat was when gamergate was in full swing and voat had just started up. Most of the content was fairly similar to reddit, maybe with a slight alt-right bent.

Looking at the front page now, it's just turned into 4chan.

Re:Please stop asking me to use the app by taneq on Monday July 02, 2018 @11:14PM (#17447203)
Agreed. When Reddit first started treating their mods with contempt, I swore off the place. I spent a fair while on Voat at that point and it was crude at times but there was still a lot of good content. I gave up on it after a while because toxic Reddit refugees turned it into such a cesspool.
Re:Please stop asking me to use the app by xtracto on Tuesday July 03, 2018 @03:27PM (#17452967)
There is actually another alternative which is quote good called https://tildes.net/

Right now it is very closely editorialized, but conversation level is at a good point.

Re:Please stop asking me to use the app by K2L8M11N2 on Saturday July 07, 2018 @12:09PM (#17479120)
How can one get an invite?
Re:Please stop asking me to use the app by fjsolwmv on Tuesday July 03, 2018 @01:30AM (#17447785)
Why can't another site pop up? There was one last year with a 4(?) letter name I forget (Lyme or something?) but it failed and shut down because it's impossible to pay the server bills with only nontoxic content, apparently.
Re:Please stop asking me to use the app by foobarchu on Tuesday July 03, 2018 @09:53AM (#17450168)
I think the core issue is that no site can just "fill the void" suddenly, or else it will immediately become a toxic cesspool as trolls take over immediately and scare off all potential users. These sites have to grow slowly and naturally, like Reddit did, or like Digg and Facebook did. The trickle of users needs to start slow and grow through slow word of mouth, not hype.

Reddit itself did grow massively with the Digg exodus, but that was after it had already grown into its own, it had a community behind it to begin with. There was no content void for trolls to fill up with crap. It only worked because Reddit had grown up naturally already.

If a site is hyped as "reddit competitor", it will fail, just like sites hyped as a "facebook competitor" or "twitter competitor". Hype is a horrible thing for any site that depends on user interaction and discussion.

Re:Please stop asking me to use the app by Tommah on Tuesday July 03, 2018 @02:01AM (#17447912)
You may be thinking of Imzy. IIRC, Imzy required you to sign in before you could see anything. That probably scared off a lot of potential users.
Re:Please stop asking me to use the app by poe876 on Monday July 02, 2018 @10:38PM (#17447057)
I like to think of Voat as 'redditified' 4chan.
Re:Please stop asking me to use the app by pdkl95 on Tuesday July 03, 2018 @12:04AM (#17447434)
> they're about to Digg themselves into a amusingly-recursive grave

"You'll get over it"

> All it would take is one great, open forum site to absorb the refugees from a terrible management mistep

This is fundamental risk to any business that depends on a social space. The best explanation of the mechanics that create this risk is Joe Peacock's talk[1] at NOTACON 8 about the time fark.com made the same mistake... and then poured gasoline on the fire with the infamous "You'll get over it" comment being the only publicly visible response by fark.com's management.

[1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YnVeysllPDI

Re:Please stop asking me to use the app by doubleunplussed on Tuesday July 03, 2018 @02:52AM (#17448084)
As I recall, people got over it.
Re:Please stop asking me to use the app by pdkl95 on Tuesday July 03, 2018 @09:17AM (#17449877)
Most people got over it, but it's hard to estimate if people actually "got over it". Looking at the behavior of the people using the site afterwords probably doesn't include[1] the people that left. In Q&A at the end of the talk they mention that the incident caused a significant drop in paid-account revenue[2]. They eventually recovered, but the exodus was real for a while.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Survivorship_bias

[2] They also mentioned that some of the loudest people that left came back later under a different username. That's the lesson the talk is trying to explain: most people probably do like (or will eventually like) the benefits of the "new and improved" version, so involve them in the process and respect that they might just need some time to adapt. Forcing people to adapt immediately only associates the new version with a strongly negative experience.

Re:Please stop asking me to use the app by go1dfish on Tuesday July 03, 2018 @12:56AM (#17447646)
> All it would take is one great, open forum site to absorb the refugees from a terrible management mistep

This is the goal of https://notabug.io it's a p2p fork of reddit based on GUNdb. Still very early; but my hope is that there will be enough interest in lifeboats that people will be interested in helping to construct one.

Re:Please stop asking me to use the app by vanderZwan on Wednesday July 04, 2018 @04:00AM (#17455869)

    notabug is a p2p link aggregator app that is:
    
        distributed: peers backup/serve content
        anonymous: but don't trust it to be
        immutable: edits are not supported
        votes are PoW *voting is CPU heavy*
Hmm, I don't think that's going to scale well
Re:Please stop asking me to use the app by go1dfish on Friday July 06, 2018 @04:18PM (#17474781)
Any specific reason?

In practice it will tend towards federation for calculation of sorts/searches I expect.

Re:Please stop asking me to use the app by scythe on Tuesday July 03, 2018 @12:01AM (#17447411)
I think the future of reddit, if it doesn't fix its UX problems, is not being usurped like Digg, but being chewed up by piranhas like Craigslist. There probably won't be a multidisciplinary full-on reddit "replacement", but a bunch of sites that manage to steal large fractions of the userbase. The "long tail" can't spin off a new site for every subreddit, but it can split into several smaller tails. StackExchange is the first and best example. Two categories that seem like they could be targeted by insurgents are games and localities. A lot of subreddits for certain cities and/or certain games are good, but it's an open secret that some games and/or places have absolutely terrible subreddits -- and reddit doesn't have much of a correction mechanism for that, save for the userbase getting fed up and establishing a new one (like when the creator of /r/marijuana started posting a bunch of racist drivel and everyone moved to /r/trees).

The big thing protecting reddit right now, IMO, is that /r/worldnews for all its faults is still a much less awful way to browse international news headlines than the vast majority of news sites. Sure, the headlines are editorialized and the comments are mostly trolls, but at least it won't crash your phone browser and it's not gonna interrupt your unhealthy obsession with foreign affairs to bring you someone else's unhealthy obsession with celebrity gossip. And for all the ads pimping the reddit app, just try to download a recipe from Cookstr or the Food Network or whatever and you'll soon be begging to see fake loading screens that ask you to download an iPhone app. (Serious Eats is good though.)

So it'll be a while.

Re:Please stop asking me to use the app by bobthepanda on Tuesday July 03, 2018 @01:38AM (#17447817)
Reddit is nice as a platform where lots of subforums exist. Going back to maintaining a bunch of logins in a bunch of forums, each with their own security setup, would be a hell of a headache for a lot of people.

The only other ubiquitous logins are Facebook and Google, and I trust neither of them to do Reddit's job better than Reddit does (which is, admittedly, not the highest bar.)

Re:Please stop asking me to use the app by baby on Tuesday July 03, 2018 @04:39AM (#17448482)
I was telling friends not so long ago that Reddit would NEVER redesign their webpage because of ehat happened to Digg. Then BOOM the redesign happened. Oh boy was I wrong.

HN did introduce a minifier [-] in the wrong side of the comments, but at least the rest is pretty much the same.

Re:Please stop asking me to use the app by gremlinsinc on Monday July 02, 2018 @10:18PM (#17446987)
Anyone know, who owns the content on reddit? Could the mod/admin of a sub, export all conversations to another framework, or a federated one? Assuming there was an easy way to do so.
Re:Please stop asking me to use the app by shakna on Monday July 02, 2018 @10:44PM (#17447073)
The poster.

> You retain the rights to your copyrighted content or information that you submit to reddit ("user content") except as described below.

> By submitting user content to reddit, you grant us a royalty-free, perpetual, irrevocable, non-exclusive, unrestricted, worldwide license to reproduce, prepare derivative works, distribute copies, perform, or publicly display your user content in any medium and for any purpose, including commercial purposes, and to authorize others to do so.

> You agree that you have the right to submit anything you post, and that your user content does not violate the copyright, trademark, trade secret or any other personal or proprietary right of any other party.

The individual users retain the rights to their comments and posts and so on, Reddit just gets permission to display them.

So, a mod would probably have to gain permission from every user before federating, legally speaking.

Re:Please stop asking me to use the app by gremlinsinc on Monday July 02, 2018 @11:44PM (#17447338)
Could build a system, that mirrors/pulls/aggregates all posts from reddit because anyone can pull those and use them via their api, and once a person 'connects' their account from reddit, it could import/transfer all comments over...for that one user... the key would be seemly duplicating all reddit, and moving their traffic to the federated version.

How does archive.org get away w/ archiving reddit pages and content?

You'd think their api would make it not possible to break the policy above, but you can grab comments/posts/etc json feeds without an api key, and agreeing to anything at all.

It says and 'to authorize others to do so too....' could that mean by 'others' anybody who accesses reddit endpoints via api? Or uses the .json feeds?

Re:Please stop asking me to use the app by fjsolwmv on Tuesday July 03, 2018 @01:32AM (#17447792)
Archive.org uses the "archival library" argument of fair use.
Re:Please stop asking me to use the app by pjc50 on Tuesday July 03, 2018 @04:54AM (#17448537)
The archival isn't the most interesting or useful part of it. It's the new posts.

For a while during the LJ/Dreamwidth transition there were people using apps to post on both, and Dreamwidth even let you follow arbitary RSS feeds so you could include reading public LJ through it. It still took a long time to transition most communities, until the Russian buyout and change of policies.

Re:Please stop asking me to use the app by dredmorbius on Tuesday July 03, 2018 @01:37AM (#17447814)
There are already multiple of these.

The most avid consumers of my own posts seem to bee reputation-farming robots at reddit clones, on Twitter, and the odd Wordpress blog.

Reddit publishes RSS feeds, and has a pretty robust API. The behaviour described is one consequence of these.

Re:Please stop asking me to use the app by dionidium on Monday July 02, 2018 @10:50PM (#17447102)
>All it would take is one great, open forum site to absorb the refugees from a terrible management mistep, and they're toast

I doubt it. Unlike Digg, Reddit has community lock-in. If your content is generic memes and videos and general-interest news articles, then you can switch without caring too much if everybody else follows right away.

But if you’re in a small city sub or the sub of some niche hobby or interest, then it matters a lot if everybody else agrees to move. You want to be where the other people are and it’s really hard to get an entire community to organize somewhere else. A site that can pull 20% of a small sub’s users isn’t 20% as good. It’s useless.

Re:Please stop asking me to use the app by fphhotchips on Tuesday July 03, 2018 @02:47AM (#17448069)
Lots of those subs are already migrating large chunks of community to Discord.
Re:Please stop asking me to use the app by greenleafjacob on Tuesday July 03, 2018 @04:51PM (#17453523)
Discord is also a money burning VC funded company...
Re:Please stop asking me to use the app by dionidium on Friday July 06, 2018 @01:02PM (#17473044)
This is probably specific to your interests. I'm not a gamer. I've never heard Discord even mentioned in any of the subs I frequent.
Re:Please stop asking me to use the app by throwaway77384 on Tuesday July 03, 2018 @03:41AM (#17448265)
www.tildes.net
Re:Please stop asking me to use the app by poe876 on Monday July 02, 2018 @10:21PM (#17447000)
I disagree. Reddit has done a good job of branching itself out across various diverse communities, and has been experimenting with geographical location based customization among other things which I feel should be enough of a buffer against going down Digg's path.