News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:States Can Require Internet Tax Collection, Supreme Court... by Animats on Thursday June 21, 2018 @02:20PM (#17367901)
See [1]. Sales tax as a service is available from seven different providers. Shopping cart integration is available. You pay one bill, they handle the rest.

[1] http://www.streamlinedsalestax.org/

Re:States Can Require Internet Tax Collection, Supreme Court... by lightbyte on Thursday June 21, 2018 @02:49PM (#17368156)
So this is another needless regulation that creates more useless rent-seekers?
Re:States Can Require Internet Tax Collection, Supreme Court... by mikeash on Thursday June 21, 2018 @06:00PM (#17369639)
Governments need to fund their operations, and allowing some businesses to dodge taxes because of arbitrary geographical differences is unfair and distorts markets.
Re:States Can Require Internet Tax Collection, Supreme Court... by shagie on Thursday June 21, 2018 @10:46PM (#17370906)
One should note that its not the businesses that are dodging taxes, but rather citizens of the state that are dodging taxes (and not reporting them). From The Tax You Probably Forgot To Report ( https://www.forbes.com/sites/ashleaebeling/2013/04/15/the-ta... )

> Think you got a great deal not paying sales tax on your online purchases last year? In most states, there’s a pesky tax called “use tax” that you are supposed to pay in lieu of sales tax if you buy stuff out of state or online--and bring it in state. Theoretically, you’re supposed to root through all your receipts and credit card statements, calculate what you owe and report it on your state income tax return.

Or http://www.pmbusinessadvisors.com/use-tax-reporting-requirem...

> Use tax is a tax imposed on the use of taxable items and services in a state when the sales tax has not been paid. For example, use tax would be due if taxable property is purchased from a seller located outside of New York, the property is used in New York, and sales tax was not paid on the purchase. With online platforms and sales being increasingly popular currently, this concept is significant. Remote retailers that make sales into a state but do not have any presence there (i.e. an office, store, storage, employees) may not be registered to collect sales tax in that state because of the lack of presence there. However, the use tax reporting requirement that has been recently implemented by a number of states requires remote retailers to notify their customers that they may owe use tax on their purchases.

Re:States Can Require Internet Tax Collection, Supreme Court... by mikeash on Thursday June 21, 2018 @11:00PM (#17370955)
Good point, technically the businesses haven't been doing anything wrong, it's really more of a loophole than a dodge.
Re:States Can Require Internet Tax Collection, Supreme Court... by Dylan16807 on Thursday June 21, 2018 @08:35PM (#17370344)
The problem is not the general idea of paying sales tax. It's the complication of having ten thousand different sales tax jurisdictions. Complying with the law should not be such a nightmare you need to hire a middleman.
Re:States Can Require Internet Tax Collection, Supreme Court... by gwright on Friday June 22, 2018 @12:15AM (#17371249)
It is way more complicated than just 10,000 jurisdictions:

    - mapping an address to one or more jurisdictions
    - digital deliveries might not have a shipping address
    - tax rates often depend on the type of product
    - product types have different definitions in different jurisdictions
    - some taxes are time dependent (back to school tax holidays)
    - some buyers are exempt in some jurisdictions for some products
Re:States Can Require Internet Tax Collection, Supreme Court... by azinman2 on Thursday June 21, 2018 @09:21PM (#17370555)
Why not? We pay for all kinds of professionals to help us navigate what’s required to run a business, pay taxes, and follow the law.
Re:States Can Require Internet Tax Collection, Supreme Court... by Dylan16807 on Thursday June 21, 2018 @10:41PM (#17370874)
"It's already complicated" is a very poor argument to justify increasing the complication a hundredfold.
Re:States Can Require Internet Tax Collection, Supreme Court... by pas on Friday June 22, 2018 @08:04AM (#17373296)
Yeah, and it makes a barrier to entry, so a lot of potential economic activity does not take place, or it takes place off the records, and generates no tax revenue.
Re:States Can Require Internet Tax Collection, Supreme Court... by azinman2 on Friday June 22, 2018 @01:33PM (#17375771)
If you don't start a business because of having to pay a SaaS provider to setup tax payment, then you weren't really serious at all. Note this is only required at over 100k in revenue...
Re:States Can Require Internet Tax Collection, Supreme Court... by mikeash on Thursday June 21, 2018 @10:12PM (#17370761)
I don't think the proper solution to that is to just declare that you don't have to pay taxes at all when you sell to someone far enough away. Simplify things if needed, but don't give a nonsensical advantage to certain businesses.
Re:States Can Require Internet Tax Collection, Supreme Court... by curun1r on Friday June 22, 2018 @12:23AM (#17371286)
The proper solution is to put the onus on the payment networks. They're large enough to build out support for this issue without it being overly burdensome. Internet retailers should only be required to report what customers bought and whether taxes were collected. Then payment networks can report to the states who can send taxpayers a report of the use taxes they owe.
Re:States Can Require Internet Tax Collection, Supreme Court... by shaftoe on Friday June 22, 2018 @07:45PM (#17378485)
How about putting the onus on the party that wants to collect money off transactions between other parties. If a government wants a cut, they can make it reasonably easy to comply or they can get ignored.
Re:States Can Require Internet Tax Collection, Supreme Court... by SubiculumCode on Thursday June 21, 2018 @09:53PM (#17370687)
How does one legally define where one buys a product? Shipping address? Home address? Point of sale?
Re:States Can Require Internet Tax Collection, Supreme Court... by mikeash on Thursday June 21, 2018 @10:11PM (#17370753)
Seems to be the shipping address.
Re:States Can Require Internet Tax Collection, Supreme Court... by davidgh on Friday June 22, 2018 @12:34AM (#17371338)
Some state sales tax rates are destination-based and others are origin-based. Since sales tax was not designed to consider the internet, things get complicated fast.
Re:States Can Require Internet Tax Collection, Supreme Court... by SubiculumCode on Friday June 22, 2018 @12:00AM (#17371173)
Then is shipping to an intermediary low-tax address (as a service) followed by a separate shipping event to your home an illegal circumvention?
Re:States Can Require Internet Tax Collection, Supreme Court... by snuxoll on Friday June 22, 2018 @12:20AM (#17371268)
Yes, you owe use tax to your home state on the difference in sales tax.
Re:States Can Require Internet Tax Collection, Supreme Court... by scarface74 on Thursday June 21, 2018 @04:13PM (#17368861)
So any service that makes it easier to do business is a “rent seeker”? Does that include Square? AWS? Every site that does e-commerce web hosting?
Re:States Can Require Internet Tax Collection, Supreme Court... by michaelmrose on Thursday June 21, 2018 @07:37PM (#17370098)
I think its a rent seeker when uncle sam either dictates you give them money or buries you in shit you have to pay acme shovel co to dig yourself out of.

I think its more tenable for governments to provide an optional sales tax as a service and remit the money to the states. One singular report to file one party to pay.

Re:States Can Require Internet Tax Collection, Supreme Court... by User23 on Thursday June 21, 2018 @07:35PM (#17370090)
If the service they're providing is only necessary because of artificial barriers, then basically yes. The banking cartel that controls the payment system is a huge fan of collecting economic rents, yes.
Re:States Can Require Internet Tax Collection, Supreme Court... by scarface74 on Thursday June 21, 2018 @08:37PM (#17370350)
So how do you purport to have a global electronic payment network?
Re:States Can Require Internet Tax Collection, Supreme Court... by Dylan16807 on Thursday June 21, 2018 @08:48PM (#17370396)
If the EU can manage instant bank transfers that cost less than a penny, the US can manage it too.
Re:States Can Require Internet Tax Collection, Supreme Court... by scarface74 on Thursday June 21, 2018 @09:26PM (#17370579)
Bank transfer fees have nothing to do with the fees charged when taking payments via credit cards.

While the average EU interchange fee for taking credit cards is cheaper than in the US, it’s not “less than a penny”

https://www.valuepenguin.com/interchange-fees-na-vs-eu

Re:States Can Require Internet Tax Collection, Supreme Court... by Dylan16807 on Thursday June 21, 2018 @10:39PM (#17370857)
Yeah, that's kind of the point. Credit cards are mostly supplied by a couple huge companies that aren't interested in improving their rates. It's very rent-seeking, even though there are very feasible alternatives that cost an order of magnitude or two less.
Re:States Can Require Internet Tax Collection, Supreme Court... by snuxoll on Friday June 22, 2018 @12:27AM (#17371298)
They aren't interested in improving their rates because providing a competitive credit card in the US isn't cheap. You've got cards that provide 2% flat cash back (Citi Double Cash, for example), or cards that provide even higher benefits on rotating or fixed categories. Interchange fees aren't going to drop unless American cardholders are okay with dropping these benefits, and seeing as merchants aren't likely to share the savings I don't see that happening.

The time to lower interchange fees was before reward programs became standard, interest is where card issuers make their money.

Re:States Can Require Internet Tax Collection, Supreme Court... by patates on Thursday June 21, 2018 @11:44PM (#17371125)
> Credit cards are mostly supplied by a couple huge companies that aren't interested in improving their rates.

This situation is called an oligopoly. I don't think it has something to do with government sanctioned rent seeking.

Re:States Can Require Internet Tax Collection, Supreme Court... by Dylan16807 on Friday June 22, 2018 @12:03AM (#17371191)
Government-sanctioned rent-seekers are not the only kind. The comment by User23 was about payment system rent-seekers in general, with no mention of the government.
Re:States Can Require Internet Tax Collection, Supreme Court... by scarface74 on Friday June 22, 2018 @08:51AM (#17373549)
The original comment I replied to was about a software as a service company that was a “rent seeker” because it helped businesses manage thier tax liability.

At one small company I worked for, we paid SAAS companies for:

- expense reporting and reimbursement (Concur)

- managing payroll

- Managing retirement benefits

- source control hosting (Github)

- Infrastructure (Microsoft Azure)

- Salesforce (I don’t know what they do)

- Training and Compliance

- Chat (Slack)

- Email, Office software (Microsoft Office 365)

- vending services

Etc.

How are these companies any different than the company that helps businesses manage tax collection? They all saw a business opportunity and my company was glad to pay them so it could focus on its niche.

Re:States Can Require Internet Tax Collection, Supreme Court... by patates on Friday June 22, 2018 @02:12AM (#17371783)
Yes but the mentioned problem comes from the companies forming an oligopoly.
Re:States Can Require Internet Tax Collection, Supreme Court... by seanp2k2 on Friday June 22, 2018 @02:30AM (#17371862)
VISA and MasterCard do pretty well from what I hear. PayPal too.
Re:States Can Require Internet Tax Collection, Supreme Court... by eli_gottlieb on Thursday June 21, 2018 @02:52PM (#17368185)
So the internet imposes a moral requirement for all states/provinces to have uniform sales taxes or value-added taxes?
Re:States Can Require Internet Tax Collection, Supreme Court... by michaelt on Thursday June 21, 2018 @03:21PM (#17368438)
Not moral, but some would say being a single country imposes a certain practical requirement that the taxes not be too complicated, if we agree commerce is a good thing and waste is a bad thing.
Re:States Can Require Internet Tax Collection, Supreme Court... by dsr_ on Thursday June 21, 2018 @03:33PM (#17368530)
The United States of America is, in the terms of other countries, 50 states that have given up certain powers and responsibilities to a federal government but retain their own powers, including the ability to set tax policy inside their own borders.

The Commerce Clause gives Congress the power: "To regulate Commerce with foreign Nations, and among the several States, and with the Indian Tribes." This has been widely construed as meaning that states cannot make taxes that affect other states' citizens unless they are doing business in that state.

The Supreme Court has just ruled that their earlier ruling (that Store A had to have some physical presence in State S in order for S to require A to charge sales tax) is wrong, and no such physical presence is required.

Re:States Can Require Internet Tax Collection, Supreme Court... by pseingatl on Thursday June 21, 2018 @10:12PM (#17370755)
More importantly, it is now clear that American States can tax non-residents, even FOREIGN non-residents who have no connection with the U.S. whatsoever. There will be collateral consequences to this decision. For example, why should I have to pay out-of-state university tuition if I became a state taxpayer due to the sales--and soon to come other--taxes? Drive a car into my state? You have to pay a roads tax. It will be interesting to see how far this goes. Long-arm jurisdiction will become more robust, at the least; another rationale for diversity jurisdiction is removed.
Re:States Can Require Internet Tax Collection, Supreme Court... by zrobotics on Thursday June 21, 2018 @11:19PM (#17371037)
>>For example, why should I have to pay out-of-state university tuition if I became a state taxpayer due to the sales--and soon to come other--taxes?

Did you pay income tax in the state, which will be what supports the university? Congrats, you get in-state tuition.

>>Drive a car into my state? You have to pay a roads tax.

Two points: 1) you are using the roads in the state, why can't you fund them? 2) that tax already exists, you pay it when you buy gas.

Re:States Can Require Internet Tax Collection, Supreme Court... by astura on Thursday June 21, 2018 @03:44PM (#17368629)
Congress has the ability to nationalize sales tax collection and remittance for online purchases. In fact, there have been bills introduced in the past that proposed to do just that.

We might actually see some movement in this direction now.

Re:States Can Require Internet Tax Collection, Supreme Court... by eli_gottlieb on Thursday June 21, 2018 @03:38PM (#17368578)
It looks like people are downvoting @dsr for, I dunno, being a pedant or something, but I think their point is important: Americans really do seem to value the extreme heterogeneity, and even outright waste, of having 50 different jurisdictions to do business in, rather than passing uniform laws at the federal level.
Re:States Can Require Internet Tax Collection, Supreme Court... by owenversteeg on Thursday June 21, 2018 @06:27PM (#17369784)
Although I do agree that in this case it's a bit of a disaster and going to be a huge pain, sometimes it is nice having 50 different jurisdictions.

Most things are pretty similar state-by-state, but it can be really nice being able to pick your laws if you have to. Maybe you love weed and you want to pick a state with legal weed. Or maybe you like drones and want to pick a state with fewer drone laws. So many things differ state-to-state, from REAL ID to trans rights to surveillance to taxes to guns to driving age to social aid to public transit. Gay marriage, slavery, and interracial marriage were all issues of the past but they were very important in their day too.

I do think it's an important part of what makes America America, and being able to "pick your laws" is an amazing freedom that most people don't have.

Now, the actual ability to move wherever you want can sometimes be limited. If you're in Vermont and you want New Hampshire laws, well, that's easy. (Differences: weed, guns, advertising, taxes, many more.) But if you're in Maine and you want Hawaii laws, a move like that probably isn't doable. Still, I think it's a valuable freedom.

Re:States Can Require Internet Tax Collection, Supreme Court... by padobson on Thursday June 21, 2018 @03:57PM (#17368728)
I spend $1000/yr in effort and fees on my federal income tax return. There's nothing especially practical about letting the feds take care of things.
Re:States Can Require Internet Tax Collection, Supreme Court... by sp332 on Thursday June 21, 2018 @02:40PM (#17368074)
Where do you get to see the list of providers?
Re:States Can Require Internet Tax Collection, Supreme Court... by Animats on Thursday June 21, 2018 @04:35PM (#17369066)
Re:States Can Require Internet Tax Collection, Supreme Court... by sp332 on Thursday June 21, 2018 @04:45PM (#17369141)
Thanks. I'd swear that button only gave me a menu when I clicked on it before.