News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Machine Fired Me by isostatic on Tuesday June 19, 2018 @07:43PM (#17351219)
Surely a 3 year contract means the company is in breach of it by not paying you?
Re:The Machine Fired Me by jacobsenscott on Tuesday June 19, 2018 @08:11PM (#17351361)
Sounds like he's contracting at a huge company. His contracting company isn't going to make waves over this. I would guess the contracting company is making $300+ an hour off this guy, paying him $50 an hour, and they have 200+ other contractors in the building.
Re:The Machine Fired Me by rectang on Tuesday June 19, 2018 @08:18PM (#17351391)
So, wage theft.

Now we're not just talking about a lost opportunity to reward a loyal worker. If you're right, somebody ought to be going to jail.

Re:The Machine Fired Me by fixermark on Wednesday June 20, 2018 @12:57AM (#17352680)
But nobody will. This is a common story in contractor arrangements---the big, unwritten benefit of the process is that all incentives are aligned to sweep small mistakes (1) under the rug. Contracting client doesn't want to jeopardize a good contract, contractee doesn't want to jeopardize their contract, and employee doesn't want to get fired and black-balled. Who cares if it's a little illegal? :(

(1) "Small" in relation to the whole contract deal; what's one employee's salary in a million-dollar agreement between two corporations?

Re:The Machine Fired Me by Spooky23 on Wednesday June 20, 2018 @02:16AM (#17352998)
Its not wage theft. Contractors aren’t humans, from a human resource pov.
Re:The Machine Fired Me by LarryL on Wednesday June 20, 2018 @08:33AM (#17354744)
> Contractors aren’t humans

Real story from one of the (big) french telecom companies I worked for, as a contractor (a few years ago)...

In that company, a regular employee was given a full desk, contractors were only given 2/3 of a desk (meaning 2 desks put side by side for 3 persons).

Also, contractors were NOT allowed to go to ANY conference. Even when it was about technical stuff that was directly for their project. We had to rely 100% on a transmission of information by our managers/team leads. This led to humorous results, to say the least. Things like: a BIG meeting with plenty of people and managers, who then decided a HUGE technical change on the network, without the ONLY expert because he happened to be a contractor. Once given the results of the meeting, the guy was in a "WTF?" shock. He told me that be immediately binned the request: it basically asked him to disable the authentication server! Not the best decision for a BIG ISP, LOL. Seriously, that's almost beyond belief. (But I have other incredible stories similar to this one).

As a contractor, I have really been mistreated A LOT. So much so that I've sworn never to do it again.

Re:The Machine Fired Me by baud147258 on Wednesday June 20, 2018 @10:16AM (#17355565)
I'm a contractor in France, the treatment depends on where one is working. Canal+ and PSA were bad, but the current situation is good, there's no difference between myself and the employees.
Re:The Machine Fired Me by isostatic on Wednesday June 20, 2018 @03:34PM (#17358913)
Sounds like departments were using contractors as full members of staff. Contractors should be brought in for a specific purpose, as a consultant to staff, as an extra pair of hands to follow the whims of staff.

If contractors are the only expert in a domain, there are big problems. Of course in corporations this is quite frequent - middle managers have yearly budgets for contractors, but aren't allowed to use that money to increase their headcount.

A company I work for decided to get a contractor in to run a £40m project. This makes sense for a management perspective, they get to blame the contractor (who's already left) if it fails, and they get to claim the glory if it works. It's terrible for a company though.

If I want 500 cables run in a data centre, or even 5 cables if it's a long way, I'll get a contractor in. Saves me a day by not having to do that work neatly and lets me do more important things (like ranting on HN). If I want someone to build me a fancy gui, I'll specify the frameworks, and let them mess around with the look and feel, but ultimately I own the output of the work, I need to be able to deal with it as if I wrote it myself.

Re:The Machine Fired Me by jacobsenscott on Thursday June 21, 2018 @05:29PM (#17369456)
I don't really know if there's wage theft going on. I suppose the client company got some free work out of him, but the company can argue he shouldn't have been in the building. His badge didn't work, etc. But maybe the will let him bill those hours retroactively.
Re:The Machine Fired Me by icebraining on Wednesday June 20, 2018 @05:22AM (#17353736)
If he's working for a contracting company, why would he lose wages? Wouldn't he still have a contract with that company? I work for a contracting company (in the EU), and if the client lets me go, I still get paid until a new project can be found.
Re:The Machine Fired Me by garmaine on Wednesday June 20, 2018 @06:40AM (#17354070)
That’s not how it works everywhere.
Re:The Machine Fired Me by astura on Tuesday June 19, 2018 @08:55PM (#17351538)
Their account got cancelled because the contract did not get renewed. Sounds like the company fulfilled the terms of the original contract, just (accidentally) didn't renew it. Many long term contracts require periodic renewals and/or options.

>Some of that work included renewing my contract in the new system... When my contract expired, the machine took over and fired me.

Re:The Machine Fired Me by Bartweiss on Wednesday June 20, 2018 @10:51AM (#17355915)
> in the new system... my contract expired

As I interpreted the piece, it was a three year contract which was stored in an old system, and not transferred when that system was replaced. So the firing was triggered by the system no longer seeing any valid contract.

If that's true, it would be breach of contract. But if it was a rolling contract expected to end after three years, then yes, it would be a weird situation but not a breach.

Re:The Machine Fired Me by davedx on Wednesday June 20, 2018 @01:59AM (#17352944)
That's weird though. Was it a three year contract or wasn't it?
Re:The Machine Fired Me by Bartweiss on Wednesday June 20, 2018 @10:49AM (#17355890)
As I read the piece, it was a three year contract which was included in the old HR system, but not ported to the new one. If that's true, it was certainly breach of contract - "we forgot to upload the paperwork" doesn't get you out of honoring it.
Re:The Machine Fired Me by astura on Thursday June 21, 2018 @04:54PM (#17369197)
If that was the case they would have not said "renew." "Renew" has special meaning in contracts.
Re:The Machine Fired Me by Spooky23 on Wednesday June 20, 2018 @02:19AM (#17353008)
With contract staff, the duration is usually a not to exceed. Also, it’s typically a contract to deliver a person with specific skill, not a specific person.

There are exceptions, but they are pretty rare in tech.

Re:The Machine Fired Me by astura on Thursday June 21, 2018 @04:51PM (#17369179)
It's not weird - the vast majority of long term contracts I've seen (for services my company provides) are several years long but requires the other party to renew the contract at periodic intervals.

So the contract was negotiated at a specific price point for (say) three years but every X months the other party can opt out by not renewing. They only commit for a certain term.

Re:The Machine Fired Me by fouc on Wednesday June 20, 2018 @02:08AM (#17352971)
Perhaps he should've written it as an "adding" instead of "renewing" since it's an existing contract with the merged company that needed to be properly added to the take over company.
Re:The Machine Fired Me by lmm on Wednesday June 20, 2018 @04:27AM (#17353530)
Probably informally thought of as a three year contact but legally written as a shorter one for tax etc. purposes.
Re:The Machine Fired Me by paulie_a on Wednesday June 20, 2018 @01:12AM (#17352744)
How do you think you will enforce that contract? Hire a lawyer? You might as well go to the ATM grab as much cash as you possible. Then put it all in a garbage can and light a match. It will be far less costly and more productive then attempting pursue that contract.
Re:The Machine Fired Me by hcknwscommenter on Wednesday June 20, 2018 @02:39AM (#17353095)
Sue in small claims court for week 1. Win. Obtain judgment. File lien against company assets. Sue in small claims court for week 2. Win. Obtain judgment. File lien against company assets. Repeat as necessary. Offer settlement in return for not suing anymore.
Re:The Machine Fired Me by rspeer on Wednesday June 20, 2018 @04:55AM (#17353641)
Is this just wishful thinking that, if something went wrong with your paycheck, the world would be just and there would be an easy legal remedy waiting for you?

From what I understand, you can only sue for $1000 or less in small claims court. An IT contractor who is making $1000 or less per week has bigger problems.

Re:The Machine Fired Me by probably_wrong on Wednesday June 20, 2018 @05:24AM (#17353754)
I have good news for you: the small claims limit varies by state and, according to data from this website[1], the average upper limit is $8K (median is $6K, with the lowest being $2.5K).

[1] https://www.nolo.com/legal-encyclopedia/small-claims-suits-h...

Re:The Machine Fired Me by rspeer on Wednesday June 20, 2018 @02:23PM (#17358126)
Thanks, I stand corrected.
Re:The Machine Fired Me by isostatic on Wednesday June 20, 2018 @08:40AM (#17354800)
Separate claim for each lost day then.
Re:The Machine Fired Me by walshemj on Wednesday June 20, 2018 @01:19PM (#17357390)
Or has been done in the UK send bailiffs to the company head office :-)

Of course you'd shop around for the Bailiff company with the worse reputation and get them to send the lads who moonlight at that dodgy night club as Bouncers.

Re:The Machine Fired Me by paulie_a on Wednesday June 20, 2018 @05:26AM (#17353760)
In reality it would be: spend court fees..sue in small claims court. Win. Good luck collecting in many cases. Filing for a lien? Good luck with that pointless venture...
Re:The Machine Fired Me by s73v3r_ on Wednesday June 20, 2018 @01:23PM (#17357446)
Once you have a judgement, you contact the Sheriff to help you collect. With a judgement, you are able to take things from them in order to make your judgement. Usually once that actually starts happening, the company will cut you a check pretty quick.
Re:The Machine Fired Me by alistairSH on Wednesday June 20, 2018 @02:56PM (#17358539)
In most states, the fee to file in small claims is somewhere between $30-$100. Filing for a lien with the local sheriff is another $100 or so. Well worth it for 3 weeks wages.
Re:The Machine Fired Me by walshemj on Wednesday June 20, 2018 @01:20PM (#17357404)
Cant you send in bailiffs in to recover the costs?
Re:The Machine Fired Me by gambiting on Wednesday June 20, 2018 @03:44AM (#17353366)
I don't know, does US not have a small claims court? In UK you'd pay £90 to file a case, you'd get a judgement in about a week and the company would be ordered to pay. Like I really don't understand this entire issue. Did he even ask HR to be compensated for this time? I feel like the whole article is missing some crucial information.
Re:The Machine Fired Me by alistairSH on Wednesday June 20, 2018 @02:59PM (#17358555)
Yes, the US has small claims courts. They are run at the state/county level, so fees and maximum recovery values vary. Fees generally run $30-$100 and max. recovery somewhere around $5k. After winning a case, filing a lien with the sheriff is another $100 or so.