News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Sequoia Capital China Said To Invest In Bitmain's $400M R... by devoply on Tuesday June 12, 2018 @03:14PM (#17296906)
So what do they want with the fraction of that as an investment? Is it a political play?
Re:Sequoia Capital China Said To Invest In Bitmain's $400M R... by andrestan on Tuesday June 12, 2018 @03:23PM (#17297004)
Most likely credibility, publicity, connections and mentorship that major VCs provide.
Re:Sequoia Capital China Said To Invest In Bitmain's $400M R... by dopamean on Tuesday June 12, 2018 @03:43PM (#17297252)
What kind of mentorship would the management of a company that is doing $4B/year in sales need? I don't mean that sarcastically. I would have thought, "clearly these people figured it out."
Re:Sequoia Capital China Said To Invest In Bitmain's $400M R... by wmf on Tuesday June 12, 2018 @03:50PM (#17297323)
It's funny you should say that. Bitmain has dealt very poorly with western miners and developers and repeatedly blamed those "misunderstandings" on "cultural gaps". In the short term they don't need to solve this problem, but one day I expect the pitchforks to catch up with them.
Re:Sequoia Capital China Said To Invest In Bitmain's $400M R... by andrestan on Tuesday June 12, 2018 @03:56PM (#17297376)
A great example of an executive who has led the rapid development of a business but drastically needed more mentorship would be Travis Kalanik formerly of Uber. Running a large and successful company well is much, much more than just generating revenue and valuation.
Re:Sequoia Capital China Said To Invest In Bitmain's $400M R... by johnmorrow on Tuesday June 12, 2018 @08:14PM (#17299225)
Didn't Sequoia invest in them too? You might be right but this is not the best example lol
Re:Sequoia Capital China Said To Invest In Bitmain's $400M R... by joering2 on Tuesday June 12, 2018 @08:28PM (#17299284)
Second that. Outside of HN an average person, or probably north of 95% Uber riders, neither heard nor care/cared about internal problems at Uber. None of those problems really reflected on qualty of services they provide to the final consumer.
Re:Sequoia Capital China Said To Invest In Bitmain's $400M R... by andrestan on Wednesday June 13, 2018 @07:27PM (#17307912)
That's untrue. Uber lost huge amounts of market share due to the scandals in 2017.
Re:Sequoia Capital China Said To Invest In Bitmain's $400M R... by gkanai on Wednesday June 13, 2018 @02:34AM (#17300765)
Sequoia (US) and Sequoia China are separate funds. They share the same brand and work together on some areas, but the funds are separate and the LPs are not the same (some LPs may invest in both funds but not necessarily.)
Re:Sequoia Capital China Said To Invest In Bitmain's $400M R... by rajacombinator on Wednesday June 13, 2018 @05:57AM (#17301700)
How did that mentorship work out...
Re:Sequoia Capital China Said To Invest In Bitmain's $400M R... by baybal2 on Tuesday June 12, 2018 @08:48PM (#17299357)
>Running a large and successful company

Loosing money buy truckloads every day === success?

Re:Sequoia Capital China Said To Invest In Bitmain's $400M R... by paulie_a on Wednesday June 13, 2018 @01:48AM (#17300571)
Being evil. This is the group that invested in LinkedIn, PayPal and now recently Facebook after the scandals. If they went out of business, all I would say is, lol
Re:Sequoia Capital China Said To Invest In Bitmain's $400M R... by justicezyx on Tuesday June 12, 2018 @03:45PM (#17297268)
I randomly speculated that this might help them evade some of the financial control inposed by the government?
Re:Sequoia Capital China Said To Invest In Bitmain's $400M R... by pcr0 on Wednesday June 13, 2018 @06:03AM (#17301730)
Given 1) China's recent push for domestic hardware after the ZTE wake up call 2) Impending slow down in crypto mining hardware sales, the VC's connections will be invaluable for diversifying into other hardware products.
Re:Sequoia Capital China Said To Invest In Bitmain's $400M R... by tome on Wednesday June 13, 2018 @05:49AM (#17301660)
Something to get them to $40B/year?
Re:Sequoia Capital China Said To Invest In Bitmain's $400M R... by 21 on Tuesday June 12, 2018 @08:56PM (#17299396)
Maybe they need cash to pay for electricity and hardware, so that they don't spend bitcoin now when it's down.
Re:Sequoia Capital China Said To Invest In Bitmain's $400M R... by sgspace on Tuesday June 12, 2018 @09:34PM (#17299578)
They most likely went short on Bitcoin when the price was high. This is Bitmain they are not just guessing what the price will be they certainly have projections and they know what a crypto bear market is like. Its a very safe position to short Bitcoin when you have the Bitcoin to cover the shorts if the price goes up.
Re:Sequoia Capital China Said To Invest In Bitmain's $400M R... by rspeer on Tuesday June 12, 2018 @11:56PM (#17300119)
Maybe there's some subtlety I'm missing. If you have a lot of Bitcoin and you want to short Bitcoin, isn't that just called "selling Bitcoin"?
Re:Sequoia Capital China Said To Invest In Bitmain's $400M R... by goldenkey on Wednesday June 13, 2018 @12:03AM (#17300151)
They most likely are underwriting rolling options, most of which expire unused.
Re:Sequoia Capital China Said To Invest In Bitmain's $400M R... by KMag on Wednesday June 13, 2018 @05:07AM (#17301459)
Can you currently buy puts on Bitcoin where your counterparty risk isn't highly correlated to the price of Bitcoin?
Re:Sequoia Capital China Said To Invest In Bitmain's $400M R... by goldenkey on Wednesday June 13, 2018 @03:32PM (#17306224)
Wouldn't that be the case for the above if the option underwriter is guaranteeing possession of the underlying bitcoin?
Re:Sequoia Capital China Said To Invest In Bitmain's $400M R... by KMag on Sunday June 17, 2018 @09:17AM (#17332230)
That is only the case for call options, which isn't the case where you're concerned about counterparty risk correlation with the underlier. For put option, they'll need to guarantee enough cash (or cash equivalents) on hand to pay you out if Bitcoin reaches zero.

The carrying cost (or at least opportunity cost) is high for holding large inventories of cash, so it's not very attractive from a business perspective to do so unless there's either a market or regulatory demand to do so.

Re:Sequoia Capital China Said To Invest In Bitmain's $400M R... by rebelidealist on Tuesday June 12, 2018 @07:35PM (#17299030)
For when bitcoin mining cease to be profitable. Bitcoin mining rewards halves ever so often.
Re:Sequoia Capital China Said To Invest In Bitmain's $400M R... by bertil on Wednesday June 13, 2018 @05:45AM (#17301640)
I would think of their hardware as cryptographic rather than exclusively currency related: even without cryptocurrencies around, you might need that hardware to operate strong encryption, either on your laptop or as a service. I’m not very clear on what are the next requirement and algorithm coming, but it sounds like a reasonable area to invest in.

If you look at it slightly differently: this is a company who was able to be successful in the cut-throat B2B hardware integration business. Even if some of the key aspects of that hardware might not be relevant, they have demonstrated agility at scale, which is valuable. Every company with the same scale in China has been able to negotiate full pivots repeatedly: maps become platform, search engines conversation agents, integrators turn into high-street brands, etc.

Re:Sequoia Capital China Said To Invest In Bitmain's $400M R... by thinkmassive on Wednesday June 13, 2018 @12:04PM (#17304329)
The block reward halves approximately every 4 years, and it's currently halfway through the 12.5 BTC reward period. Based on this schedule there will be a mining reward until the year 2140.

In addition to the block reward, the miner who finds each block also gains a fee from every transaction in that block. Ideally this fee stays low, but it depends on network congestion (and what miners are willing to accept, since they choose the transactions that make it into each block). The transaction fee has already hit the equivalent of $50 per transaction, back in late 2017.

Even with improvements such as batching, segwit, and lightning, there is still likely to be sufficient returns to incentivize miners for the foreseeable future.

Re:Sequoia Capital China Said To Invest In Bitmain's $400M R... by trophycase on Tuesday June 12, 2018 @09:49PM (#17299637)
Bitmain sells a lot of mining hardware. Bitcoin, Litecoin, Dash, and many others.
Re:Sequoia Capital China Said To Invest In Bitmain's $400M R... by hanniabu on Wednesday June 13, 2018 @08:22AM (#17302357)
Expand mining operations. Miners have cash flow issues do and often resort to loans
Re:Sequoia Capital China Said To Invest In Bitmain's $400M R... by rajacombinator on Wednesday June 13, 2018 @05:56AM (#17301695)
Definitely a political play and a smart one too.
Re:Sequoia Capital China Said To Invest In Bitmain's $400M R... by Alex3917 on Tuesday June 12, 2018 @03:21PM (#17296988)
> Is it a political play?

Given that it's mathematically impossible for BTC to succeed until they change their POW, this doesn't make sense as a political play. Most likely Sequoia is just paying for BTC in advance to get a deeper discount than they'd normally get for buying in volume. It's also possible that they're just selling the BTC as they go and hoping for a short payback period, but while this makes sense financially it's unclear how it would relate to their overall portfolio strategy.

Re:Sequoia Capital China Said To Invest In Bitmain's $400M R... by icelancer on Tuesday June 12, 2018 @03:47PM (#17297286)
>> mathematically impossible for BTC to succeed until they change their POW

Citation desperately needed, and not random rantings, please.

Re:Sequoia Capital China Said To Invest In Bitmain's $400M R... by Alex3917 on Tuesday June 12, 2018 @04:14PM (#17297549)
> Citation desperately needed, and not random rantings, please.

It's just math. The amount of electricity needed to secure the network is directly proportional to the price (or more technically, the profitably of mining). This is because if you don't arbitrage out the profitability of mining, then the network is open to a 51% attack because the marginal cost of adding more hash power makes it profitable to keep adding more miners until you have control of the network. Basically the way the current POW is designed, BTC is only secure as long as it isn't obvious in advance whether or not mining at scale will be more profitable than buying BTC after it's been mined.

So given that for BTC to become a successful reserve currency it would need to be worth at least 100x what it's worth today, that means it would need to use at least 100x as much electricity. But that's more electricity than currently exists, and there's no way it would be feasible for BTC to even use a fraction of that.

This means that BTC can't actually ever reach those price levels, because if it did then it would no longer be secure, so would need to immediately drop back down in price in order to account for (and mitigate) the security risk.

Re:Sequoia Capital China Said To Invest In Bitmain's $400M R... by bdcravens on Tuesday June 12, 2018 @05:35PM (#17298259)
> it would need to be worth at least 100x what it's worth today, that means it would need to use at least 100x as much electricity

Price and electricity usage ARE NOT perfectly elastic. Electricity usage is a product of total hashes mined and difficulty rate. These continue to go up, even when Bitcoin price is falling (see 2014-2015). Additionally, the electricity used did not rise 19x in 2017 even as the price did so.

Re:Sequoia Capital China Said To Invest In Bitmain's $400M R... by cornholio on Wednesday June 13, 2018 @05:21AM (#17301517)
Hashing generates a certain fixed number of bitcoins per hour, irrelevant of bitcoin or electricity prices. When the price of bitcoin goes 100x up, the potential mining revenue goes 100x in fiat, so rational investors will compete for that by increasing the hash rate of their rigs and buying more hardware that draws more electricity.

The algorithm will compensate and the difficulty will adjust so that the same number of bitcoins is generated, but the new equilibrium will happen at a point where 100x more electricity will be wasted compared to the original state.

The only thing that can change this equilibrium is the halving of the block reward happening every 4 years, or short term adjustments like the ones you mention, where the market is slowly building capacity or does not have enough trust in a price increase to invest in new capacity. On the long run, in a given 4 year window, these even out so that 100x price means 100x electricity.

Re:Sequoia Capital China Said To Invest In Bitmain's $400M R... by lisnake on Tuesday June 12, 2018 @05:03PM (#17297965)
> it would need to be worth at least 100x what it's worth today, that means it would need to use at least 100x as much electricity

I'm afraid I can't understand how you made such a conclusion. Why bitcoin can't be worth 100x than now using only 2x more electricity?

Re:Sequoia Capital China Said To Invest In Bitmain's $400M R... by SimonPStevens on Tuesday June 12, 2018 @05:55PM (#17298430)
He is arguing that if BTC price went up 100x, it would be so much more profitable to attack it that it would require a comparable increase in the hash rate (and therefore electricity usage) to deter would be attackers. So either hash rate increases, or BTC loses it's security.

Or the same thing, but stated the other way round, as the profitability of mining increases (due to price rises), more participants are attracted to the market, raising the hash rate and bringing profitability of mining back down to the marginal equilibrium.

Essentially the argument is that cost of mining/attacking is always in rough equilibrium with price, because whenever it isn't someone will take advantage of that in a way which will have the feedback of narrowing the gap again.

Re:Sequoia Capital China Said To Invest In Bitmain's $400M R... by mrb on Tuesday June 12, 2018 @07:18PM (#17298948)
«So given that for BTC to become a successful reserve currency»

Your premise is wrong to start with... BTC could be very successful without necessarily being a major worldwide reserve currency!

«But that's more electricity than currently exists»

Not true. Bitcoin currently uses only about 0.2% of the world's electricity consumption (http://blog.zorinaq.com/bitcoin-electricity-consumption/#upd...). 100× would be 20%. Some miners are currently building their own power plants for their mining farms. Getting to 20% is definitely possible.

Re:Sequoia Capital China Said To Invest In Bitmain's $400M R... by beaner on Tuesday June 12, 2018 @11:22PM (#17299980)
Doesn't this argument ignore the basic supply and demand of electricity? Even if the supply of electricity remained the same, if the price went up 100x, then that would allow for (1) current energy use of bitcoin, and (2) 100x price of bitcoin, which you said was impossible. That was simple.

Obviously the price of electricity is unlikely to 100x, but I think it's entirely reasonable that jurisdictions start placing taxes on electricity use for crypto miners specifically, which would have the same effect, without affecting the rest of the economy.

Miners will also probably start investing in, and operating, cheaper power sources that are not connected to the grid, if/when those taxes get too burdensome.

Re:Sequoia Capital China Said To Invest In Bitmain's $400M R... by icelancer on Tuesday June 12, 2018 @10:29PM (#17299781)
>> It's just math.

Good way to start off this rebuttal.

>> The amount of electricity needed to secure the network is directly proportional to the price

OK, this is a good argument, actually. But you are neglecting future improvements in energy, adoptions in solar, and the fact that electricity is not a statically-defined generation amount; there are many, many megawatts available that are not being tapped into - particularly in hydro - due to infeasibility of transmission. This is trivially evident in the number of people moving to Chelan County, Washington, as well as Quebec, amongst other initiatives and movements.

Your "just math" argument neglects... a lot of math, which is what I figured.

Re:Sequoia Capital China Said To Invest In Bitmain's $400M R... by jordanthoms on Tuesday June 12, 2018 @06:09PM (#17298534)
Not sure if I totally buy it, but the economic argument here [1] is interesting. Essentially the claim is that proof of stake actually takes just as much resources as proof of work (marginal cost = marginal revenue), as no participant in the market is able to extract a rent.

1 - http://www.truthcoin.info/blog/pow-cheapest/

Re:Sequoia Capital China Said To Invest In Bitmain's $400M R... by AndrewBissell on Tuesday June 12, 2018 @04:58PM (#17297927)
> But that's more electricity than currently exists

This is not a variable that will remain constant once it starts becoming profitable to invest in power generation solely for the purpose of bitcoin mining.

Re:Sequoia Capital China Said To Invest In Bitmain's $400M R... by dboreham on Tuesday June 12, 2018 @05:42PM (#17298320)
Ahh... the Dyson Sphere is nigh...
Re:Sequoia Capital China Said To Invest In Bitmain's $400M R... by jacobush on Tuesday June 12, 2018 @06:40PM (#17298728)
This is why we can’t have nice things.
Re:Sequoia Capital China Said To Invest In Bitmain's $400M R... by wmf on Tuesday June 12, 2018 @07:00PM (#17298862)
I don't know; Dyson spheres are pretty damn cool.
Re:Sequoia Capital China Said To Invest In Bitmain's $400M R... by jacobush on Friday June 15, 2018 @12:39PM (#17321170)
I meant, what’s the point of having them when they’ll be used for bitcoin mining?
Re:Sequoia Capital China Said To Invest In Bitmain's $400M R... by rcxdude on Wednesday June 13, 2018 @10:21AM (#17303296)
Does spending >51% of world energy on a finance system not seem excessive?
Re:Sequoia Capital China Said To Invest In Bitmain's $400M R... by Nuzzerino on Wednesday June 13, 2018 @04:27PM (#17306641)
You may think that it's "just a finance system" but literally everything you touch except dirt and rocks got to where it was because of finance systems.
Re:Sequoia Capital China Said To Invest In Bitmain's $400M R... by rcxdude on Thursday June 14, 2018 @05:47AM (#17310504)
Yeah, but the current finance systems use far less energy. No single aspect of modern society uses that large a share of energy.
Re:Sequoia Capital China Said To Invest In Bitmain's $400M R... by fredgrott on Tuesday June 12, 2018 @05:52PM (#17298409)
Plus you have the physical limits of making mining special chips more energy efficient...

This is why Ethereum founder calls bitcoin deadcode...as it will continue its decline unless it moves to PoS

Re:Sequoia Capital China Said To Invest In Bitmain's $400M R... by asdionio on Tuesday June 12, 2018 @04:09PM (#17297511)
4 transactions per second is not very many.

8 gigawatts is a lot.

Re:Sequoia Capital China Said To Invest In Bitmain's $400M R... by wmf on Tuesday June 12, 2018 @04:11PM (#17297529)
But that's an artificial limit that has nothing to do with POW.
Re:Sequoia Capital China Said To Invest In Bitmain's $400M R... by asdionio on Tuesday June 12, 2018 @04:24PM (#17297637)
So you move to Bitcoin Cash, which can do 60 transactions a second. Big deal. It's still orders of magnitude slower than it has to be to be useful.

Blockchains don't scale. Period. If you know of a way to make them scale, publish it and you'll find instant fame and fortune.

The power consumption will continue to increase, and that is purely the fault of POW.

Re:Sequoia Capital China Said To Invest In Bitmain's $400M R... by wmf on Tuesday June 12, 2018 @04:32PM (#17297702)
Blockchains don't scale. Period.

If that's your position then changing the POW won't help.

(I know no one cares, but there could be a pragmatic scaling path where you increase on-chain throughput while you do sharding/layer 2 research.)

Re:Sequoia Capital China Said To Invest In Bitmain's $400M R... by Jommi on Tuesday June 12, 2018 @09:48PM (#17299635)
Can you elaborate?
Re:Sequoia Capital China Said To Invest In Bitmain's $400M R... by icelancer on Tuesday June 12, 2018 @10:30PM (#17299789)
The Lightning Network is one such initiative for BTC.
Re:Sequoia Capital China Said To Invest In Bitmain's $400M R... by icelancer on Tuesday June 12, 2018 @10:30PM (#17299787)
>> Blockchains don't scale

They don't need to scale linearly with off-chain transmissions acting as a secondary transmission network.

Re:Sequoia Capital China Said To Invest In Bitmain's $400M R... by constantlm on Wednesday June 13, 2018 @05:17AM (#17301500)
Does segwit and (eventually) lightning not solve the TX shortcoming?
Re:Sequoia Capital China Said To Invest In Bitmain's $400M R... by JumpCrisscross on Tuesday June 12, 2018 @03:33PM (#17297141)
> It's also possible that they're just selling the BTC as they go and hoping for a short payback period

Sequoia's China team is has more bankers than Sequoia's U.S. team. The investment may have been made with cash-yielding convertible debt.

Re:Sequoia Capital China Said To Invest In Bitmain's $400M R... by charlesdm on Tuesday June 12, 2018 @03:37PM (#17297184)
Or their LP agreement might not allow them to invest in crypto directly, only in companies (generating crypto)