News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why does a spray bottle work? by vanilla-almond on Saturday June 09, 2018 @02:16PM (#17274228)
A few years ago, a British inventor appeared on a TV show called Dragon's Den (UK version of Shark Tank) and pitched his idea of an improved spray bottle called the Anyway Spray.

Instead of a normal plastic tube inside a bottle with an opening at the end, he designed a tube with millions of tiny perforations along its length. This meant the spray bottle could operate at any angle (even upside down) and could empty all liquid in a bottle with no leftover.

Here is a 1 min demo of the spray: https://vimeo.com/195318537

Here's an explanation of how it works https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xXk46rvzdpY

And here's the original pitch he made on Dragon's Den https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RjOvyjeZyIw

Re:Why does a spray bottle work? by kazinator on Saturday June 09, 2018 @08:22PM (#17275745)
If it was simply perforations, it wouldn't work when the bottle is upright because those perforations would let the air into the top of the straw. Rather, the straw is made of a membrane which lets water through while blocking gas.
Re:Why does a spray bottle work? by mackman on Saturday June 09, 2018 @08:47PM (#17275815)
I’m not sure you can make a membrane that does that? I get the sense there is a membrane that wicks the fluid around the surface of the tube so you always have to pull in liquid before the gas? Maybe that’s the same thing.
Re:Why does a spray bottle work? by m-p-3 on Sunday June 10, 2018 @11:11AM (#17278454)
You can retrofit it into an existing spray bottle with some flexible tubing and something to weight down the end, like some stainless-steel nuts. That way, the end of the tube follows gravity along with the liquid and ensure it remains submerged.
Re:Why does a spray bottle work? by kazinator on Sunday June 10, 2018 @03:43PM (#17279835)
I don't think there is any idea here other than retrofitting this innovative straw into existing spray bottles.
Re:Why does a spray bottle work? by hanniabu on Saturday June 09, 2018 @11:18PM (#17276254)
You need to let air through or else it creates a vacuum. What's happening is it just slows the flow of air enough to be able to get suction from the fluid. Having fluid in the tube also helps.
Re:Why does a spray bottle work? by kazinator on Sunday June 10, 2018 @12:36AM (#17276550)
You need to let air through into the bottle to replace the volume of ejected water. No air should ideally be entering the straw.
Re:Why does a spray bottle work? by fouc on Saturday June 09, 2018 @02:57PM (#17274448)
Seems like he managed to license it to Tesco's range of label products. Good for him.
Re:Why does a spray bottle work? by nothrabannosir on Saturday June 09, 2018 @05:27PM (#17275098)
Good for us! :)
Re:Why does a spray bottle work? by MichaelApproved on Saturday June 09, 2018 @03:18PM (#17274535)
Why isn't this in everything? I'd easily pay an extra few cents to have this in spray bottles. It's such a frustrating problem.
Re:Why does a spray bottle work? by logicallee on Saturday June 09, 2018 @08:48PM (#17275820)
In my quick analysis (could be mistaken, I welcome corrections), if this is one-time disposible then it only makes sense if the value to the consumer of the amount of product not thrown out as a result, is less than the extra cost of licensing and manufacturing this and this cost can be passed onto the consumer somehow.

In other words, if this costs 5¢ more then it is worth spending an extra 5¢ on if you keep from throwing at least 5¢ of product out. Below this it is better to throw a little product away. (However, consumers might overvalue being able to use the last little bit of product. Perhaps they value at 25¢ to not throw the last 1/30th of the product away, even though they paid less than $7.50 for the whole package. i.e. perhaps they paid $5.00 but would pay $5.25 to keep from throwing away the last 1/30th of the product. However this seems unlikely!)

More likely, if it costs 25¢ it is more economical to throw away, for example, 5¢ of product instead, by not having it.

However this analysis assumes that the 25¢ is passed onto the consumer. If the consumer is very price-sensitive (for example there is a standard price and very standard volume, as is the case with milk, though that isn't dispensed this way) then adding this as a competitive advantage would benefit the consumer, while the supplier eats the costs as a cost of acquiring this consumer.

This is my quick analysis.

Re:Why does a spray bottle work? by MichaelApproved on Saturday June 09, 2018 @10:26PM (#17276089)
It's nice that it would end up using all the product but I'm thinking more about convenience. I often hold a bottle sideways and, while there's plenty of liquid, I can't get the spray to work in that orientation. So frustrating.
Re:Why does a spray bottle work? by chewxy on Saturday June 09, 2018 @11:46PM (#17276360)
Here's a cheaper and faster hack: soft tube + weighted end.

The weighted end will tend to go towards where the liquids are. Imagine a bottle being held lengthwise. The weighted end will be in the same location as where the liquid is.

Turn the bottle upside down... the weighted end drops to where the top of the bottle is, along with where the water is.

Standard pressure thingies still work - you still get a spray. No need for custom membranse.

Re:Why does a spray bottle work? by fencepost on Sunday June 10, 2018 @02:22AM (#17276874)
What it really comes down to is the question of the actual goal and the costs of reaching that goal. For a huge percentage of things "good enough" is in fact good enough. It's also important to not confuse the goal and proposed solutions for reaching that goal.

For the example above, is the goal to be able to spray upside down? To ensure that the sprayer is able to spray a higher percentage of what's in the bottle? How large is that percentage improvement (90% up to 95%?), what's the incremental cost of increasing that percentage, and what is the actual worth of 5% of the contents of the bottle?

A draw tube that is flexible enough to fold in half, strong enough to not kink, sturdy enough to not collapse when bursts of suction are applied, weighted enough to stay in liquid, strong enough to assemble quickly and easily, etc. is probably also expensive enough to just not be an economical solution.

By the way, if you don't purchase cleaning supplies regularly you may have missed that a lot of those tubes have gone away - they're now molded as part of the bottle so just tipping the bottle will put all remaining liquid at the intake point.

Re:Why does a spray bottle work? by PhasmaFelis on Sunday June 10, 2018 @02:01AM (#17276809)
I saw an instructional thing about that. They did it with a bit of silicone tubing the same diameter as the original, and a steel nut with matching inside diameter. Swap out the tube and screw the nut over the end.

I'm not sure you could actually make it work upside-down without crimping, but at any normal usage angle it works great.

Re:Why does a spray bottle work? by exikyut on Sunday June 10, 2018 @10:33AM (#17278286)
What cheap alternatives to small bits of metal could be used for the weight?

Metal could interact with and damage a lot of different things.

Re:Why does a spray bottle work? by mygo on Sunday June 10, 2018 @11:36AM (#17278582)
the metal doesn’t need to be exposed to the contents in order to serve its purpose. It just needs to be on location.. could it not be enclosed by the same material of the straw?
Re:Why does a spray bottle work? by mcguire on Sunday June 10, 2018 @10:41AM (#17278318)
Downside: it's harder (read more expensive) to prevent a soft tube from collapsing under the vacuum.
Re:Why does a spray bottle work? by gxs on Saturday June 09, 2018 @03:38PM (#17274610)
Jumping to the conclusion that everything a company does is calculated and delibarate is a mistake I see a lot of people make, but in this case it’s accurate.

In a business that operates at a scale of 100s of thousands if not millions of bottles sold annually, cents matter and can make up a significant portion of revenue.

With this in mind, there is a huge incentive to get people to buy sooner rather than later and more often. Forcing a small amount to remain in a used up bottle is definitely a benefit to the company even if the product is going to waste. This doesn’t include the cost of implementing something new. I’d imagine a company would do extensive survey based research to understand if the additional customer satisfaction would outweigh the costs/downsides.

If it’s not a conscious decision, it’s a nice coincidental benefit to them.

Re:Why does a spray bottle work? by akg_67 on Saturday June 09, 2018 @06:59PM (#17275474)
I am not sure why you were downvoted. There are several examples of the behavior you described.

Potato chip companies reducing the quantity of chips in a bag but keeping the size and price same. Because they were unable to raise prices with older packaging. Typically customers didn’t look at weight, just size of package. It was in the news for quite a while and IIRC there is a business case study.

It has been happening in beverages and other items too. Why do you see now package weights of odd numbers like 11.5 or 14.5 oz instead of standard number like 12 oz or 16 oz with typically no price reduction.

Recently I encountered same behavior with toothpaste tube in Japan. To keep the form/shape of the toothpaste tube with usage the nozzle was designed to suck in air to fill new space in the tube. My wife claimed we are out of toothpaste and wanted to throw away the tube. The toothpaste tube was perfectly formed but I noticed tube was still little heavier than I would expect for a empty plastic tube. But when you squeeze the tube mostly Air was coming out with little bit of spray of paste. Reducing the air space with paper clip, we were able to use paste from same tube for another 2 weeks. Typical behavior would be most probably what my wife was going to do to throwaway old one and open a new one.

Re:Why does a spray bottle work? by markkanof on Saturday June 09, 2018 @04:20PM (#17274779)
Maybe, but it seems more likely this isn't due to malice but just stupidity/apathy. Maybe most companies just aren't aware of this technology, or they don't want to implement something new because of uncertainty about the potential problems with the new technology. For example, maybe 1 out of a 100 of these bottles gets completely clogged and won't dispense anything at all. That looks bad for the company and maybe even requires a recall. It's easier to just stick with what they are doing and no-one is complaining loudly about the small bit of wasted product.
Re:Why does a spray bottle work? by manigandham on Saturday June 09, 2018 @07:23PM (#17275549)
Large companies are constantly doing research and development which handles all of this. They definitely aren't stupid and aren't waiting around for youtube videos to learn about things.

They have teams that actively engage with new suppliers and inventors and are also getting pitched constantly with new ideas. It's most likely that extensive testing and consideration showed that this wasn't worth the costs. You even described such a scenario so I'm not sure why you think that's stupid or apathetic, when it's actually quite calculated.

Re:Why does a spray bottle work? by richie5um on Saturday June 09, 2018 @04:26PM (#17274797)
Yup.

Business benefit supersedes customer benefit. Always.

Re:Why does a spray bottle work? by ikurei on Saturday June 09, 2018 @05:21PM (#17275077)
I wonder how the economic and environmental costs of the extra tubing (the tube in Anyway Spray bottles is longer than a straight, conventional one) compares to the costs of those few last drops for most sprayed products...
Re:Why does a spray bottle work? by loopdoend on Saturday June 09, 2018 @07:05PM (#17275485)
This improvement would cause the manufacturer to sell less product by volume.
Re:Why does a spray bottle work? by ollieshmollie on Saturday June 09, 2018 @10:25PM (#17276086)
I noticed the video described him as MBE, so I looked him up. He also invented a water filter and was named Member of the British Empire for it: https://ideas.ted.com/since-the-ted-talk-michael-pritchard-o...
Re:Why does a spray bottle work? by thomk on Saturday June 09, 2018 @08:19PM (#17275738)
That episode of Dragons Den is infuriating. Here is a guy who has invented something with a widespread, common appeal. He invented a product that potentially fixes a real problem in 1,000,000,000 units per year and he has to give away 20% of his invention to get support.
Re:Why does a spray bottle work? by GordonS on Sunday June 10, 2018 @02:55AM (#17276949)
The investors on Dragon's Den always want too much equity - I would imagine that anyone going on the show would know that.

I also think some people go on the show knowing that they're not going to get investment at a sensible equity level, and are really on there as a way of marketing their idea to a wider audience.

Re:Why does a spray bottle work? by acjohnson55 on Saturday June 09, 2018 @10:31PM (#17276105)
He had the option to reject the deal, no? It's a free market for venture capital, so if that deal is so bad and the opportunity is so good, he should have been able to find a better one.

From my perspective, having a great idea is not enough. Even having a proof of concept is not enough. There's a lot more that goes into building a successful business. Investors have to price in the chances of all the things that can go wrong in the process against the perceived value of the product.

Likewise, as a founder, you often need at least some investors that can help propel you forward in some way. That can be worth a lot more than dumb money.

I haven't watched the episode you mention, but generally this is how I think about it.

Re:Why does a spray bottle work? by annabellish on Sunday June 10, 2018 @08:14AM (#17277758)
>Likewise, as a founder, you often need at least some investors that can help propel you forward in some way.

Which is the infuriating part, when the "investors" contribute nothing to the project but a tiny slice of money they didn't work for to begin with, and get vastly disproportional returns for it.

Re:Why does a spray bottle work? by acjohnson55 on Sunday June 10, 2018 @06:34PM (#17280546)
I feel like you've missed my point.

There are a limited number of good opportunities to invest in, so it's not like investors get to unilaterally set the terms of these deals. They have to compete with each other, at least on the most attractive deals. A savvy founder turns down money on bad terms.

Re:Why does a spray bottle work? by annabellish on Monday June 11, 2018 @06:30AM (#17283148)
I got your point, I just don't agree with it! I think that's a consistent logical position to take, but I don't think it's undeniably _ethical_ because of that.
Re:Why does a spray bottle work? by acjohnson55 on Wednesday June 13, 2018 @03:00AM (#17300891)
I guess I'm missing what it is to disagree with. Are you arguing that people with good ideas should simply be entitled to the capital to pull them off, to avoid the need to compete in capital markets?
Re:Why does a spray bottle work? by annabellish on Thursday June 14, 2018 @01:48PM (#17313653)
I mean, sure, that'd be great. I think it'd need one heck of a societal overhaul to achieve, though.

If we wanna keep it in terms of a capitalist market, the problem is that investors are essentially selling a service just like anyone else, but because wealth inequality is where it is, there's relatively little competition in that "market". Thus, what you get is very high "prices" for relatively poor "service". This is a problem.

In an ideal free market, investors are just another kind of business, and would compete both on price and their offering such that everyone was getting a good deal and everything moved along efficiently. In the real world, investment is a very concentrated market, meaning that the deals are shoddy and inefficient.

Re:Why does a spray bottle work? by mcguire on Sunday June 10, 2018 @10:44AM (#17278330)
Welcome to venture capital.
Re:Why does a spray bottle work? by annabellish on Sunday June 10, 2018 @12:42PM (#17278893)
That it is common makes it neither more nor less just.
Re:Why does a spray bottle work? by thomk on Monday June 11, 2018 @11:07AM (#17284856)
Yes, exactly.
Re:Why does a spray bottle work? by thomk on Monday June 11, 2018 @11:08AM (#17284874)
I see your point and I appreciate your perspective however, he didn't just have a proof of concept, he had a product. It is completed and working.
Re:Why does a spray bottle work? by uneven on Sunday June 10, 2018 @12:43PM (#17278895)
Based off of a Daily Mail article about it [1], it looks like the deal fell through anyways, so (hopefully) he was able to retain full ownership in the deal with Tesco. I love the idea and wish Mr. Pritchard the best. Hopefully they can get it over to the US soon!

[1] http://www.dailymail.co.uk/sciencetech/article-4335468/Briti...

Re:Why does a spray bottle work? by ebikelaw on Saturday June 09, 2018 @08:59PM (#17275861)
I have a spray bottle that I bought to clean windows, because it can shoot a stream about 20 meters which is great. It is also labeled "sprays upside-down!" which is really misleading. I thought it sprayed in any orientation but it doesn't. It only sprays when held straight up or straight down. There's an inlet on the base of the handle for the inverted case, and a valve that prevents the main pickup from drawing in air.
Re:Why does a spray bottle work? by ggg9990 on Saturday June 09, 2018 @10:01PM (#17276025)
That’s not “really misleading,” it’s “barely misleading” or perhaps “slightly misleading.”
Re:Why does a spray bottle work? by esrauch on Sunday June 10, 2018 @04:25AM (#17277146)
I think most people would assume the marketing meant "can spray at any angle, even the hardest case of upside down".

I knew I did when reading this thread until I saw this comment.

Re:Why does a spray bottle work? by ggg9990 on Sunday June 10, 2018 @02:56PM (#17279610)
To be clear, there are two products: one labeled “anyway spray” which sprays in any direction and one labeled “sprays upside down” which sprays right side up or completely upside down. Seems fair to me.
Re:Why does a spray bottle work? by exikyut on Sunday June 10, 2018 @10:40AM (#17278313)
Considering the replies this has gathered, I'll add this (half-obvious) anecdata FWIW: you can, in I'd say 70-85% of cases, recover all of the product in a spray or pump if you don't mind (potentially repeatedly) fiddling with the hose.

Just pull the hose out and bend/twist it really hard in a specific direction. If it's not utterly stiff, winding it tightly around a pencil (or your finger, or just twisting the hose to that tight of a bend radius) is ideal. Hopefully this much flexing means that after naturally uncurling the curl will still "stick" to a useful degree for longer than a single usage.

One non-obvious extra detail: if the product is in a non-transparent spray bottle, before replacing the lid, rotate the spray pump so it faces the direction you've bent/curled the hose. Now a) you know which direction the hose is pointing and can eliminate "where is it in the bottle", and b) you just have to face it forward for it to work, which is intuitive.

Re:Why does a spray bottle work? by SheinhardtWigCo on Saturday June 09, 2018 @03:29PM (#17274571)
I know it's for TV but that was a great pitch.
Re:Why does a spray bottle work? by mmmBacon on Saturday June 09, 2018 @10:23PM (#17276084)
Cool. Looks like the guy got his stuff into products. He got raped by the investors in my view.

http://www.dailymail.co.uk/sciencetech/article-4335468/Briti...