News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:GitLab is open core, GitHub is closed source (2016) by miguelrochefort on Monday June 04, 2018 @06:12AM (#17226275)
What if Microsoft open sources GitHub?
Re:GitLab is open core, GitHub is closed source (2016) by veidr on Monday June 04, 2018 @06:23AM (#17226348)
I am sad this HN topic isn't trending up more, because THAT would change EVERYTHING.

(By which I mean everything whiny MS-skeptics have said today (myself included).)

It would be a knockout PR move, suddenly sucking all the wind out of the sails of all knee-jerk-antiMicrosoftism surrounding this acquisition.

Satya, bro, you should really take a page out of Apple's playbook, and announce right now that you are going to.

(That way, whether you really do[1], or you don't[2], most people won't remember the idea anyway...)

[1]: https://swift.org

[2]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/FaceTime

Re:GitLab is open core, GitHub is closed source (2016) by jasonkostempski on Monday June 04, 2018 @08:48AM (#17227194)
I think the people having these reactions aren't going fall for any PR stunts, no matter how grandiose. Even with the OSS they have, they're constantly undermining the spirit with opt-out telemetry, some even forced, in fundamental tools, and they are unapologetic about it. Even if they announced they were taking all that out, I wouldn't trust it to last, or that they wouldn't use that PR to leverage something even worse.
Re:GitLab is open core, GitHub is closed source (2016) by bradrydzewski on Monday June 04, 2018 @11:09AM (#17228464)
fwiw gitlab also has opt-out telemetry that includes identifiable data such as instance hostname https://docs.gitlab.com/ce/user/admin_area/settings/usage_st...
Re:GitLab is open core, GitHub is closed source (2016) by cup-of-tea on Monday June 04, 2018 @08:14AM (#17227016)
I've hated Microsoft for much of my life. I try not to make it a religious issue, but I'm worried about github. If they open sourced it I would no longer be worried.

They won't, though. They won't open Windows or Office either.

Re:GitLab is open core, GitHub is closed source (2016) by snowwrestler on Monday June 04, 2018 @09:35AM (#17227608)
Why are people worried about Github? I mean, I use it and I like it, but I also have local copies of my code. If I stop liking Github, I feel pretty confident I could set up another workflow with Gitlab or even self-hosted git if I had to.

I mean--I used to use Skype all the time, but now I use something else. If MS breaks Github, there are options.

Re:GitLab is open core, GitHub is closed source (2016) by sjs382 on Monday June 04, 2018 @09:51AM (#17227789)
GitHub is more than just a place to upload code for a lot of people.

They use it to manage issues, wikis, releases, orgs & commit permissions, etc. Some of that stuff is easier to migrate than others...

Re:GitLab is open core, GitHub is closed source (2016) by nfoz on Monday June 04, 2018 @11:22AM (#17228596)
I wouldn't know how to migrate that between any systems. Maybe what's missing -- more than open source code -- is open formats for that sort of data? Like we just need a button to export that from github more than I think I'd need Github's server code.
Re:GitLab is open core, GitHub is closed source (2016) by OJFord on Monday June 04, 2018 @01:35PM (#17230100)
GitLab has that button - of course, it can't import a community, but it can import issues et al. - and it's been busy today..!

https://monitor.gitlab.net/dashboard/db/github-importer

Re:GitLab is open core, GitHub is closed source (2016) by oblio on Monday June 04, 2018 @08:42AM (#17227145)
Github is very unlikely to be a massive cash cow, unlike those other two. And even if they make it Open Source, who's going to compete with them? If Microsoft revs up the enterprise sales machine, there's only a handful of companies that can compete with them. And none of those will want to build a company on FOSS tech owned by a direct rival.

This is not a case of Red Hat EL vs Oracle Linux. Microsoft has a mean enterprise sales machine and it's huge. All those Microsoft sales folks want to hear from a competitor is "oh, by the way, our enterprise SCM offering is based on a Microsoft solution".

Re:GitLab is open core, GitHub is closed source (2016) by keypress on Monday June 04, 2018 @08:35AM (#17227105)
It's a shame code doesn't drop into the public domain after a decade...

But windows must be a colossal mass of who knows what at this point. I'd be embarrassed to open that cupboard for all and sundry to inspect. And likely a double edged sword in terms of security.

Re:GitLab is open core, GitHub is closed source (2016) by exikyut on Monday June 04, 2018 @09:02AM (#17227287)
I remember a quote by a philosopher that said corporations should be dissolved after 10 years.

The idea - in any form - really does make one think, and kinda hard. The world would indeed be a very different place. I wonder what kind of innovation such a move would stifle?

Hmm, maybe superscalar/moonshot-level competition would be defined by and buoyed by 10-year disclosure! That would be kinda fun...!

Regarding Windows, those who poked around the Win2K and WinNT leaks regarded the code as reasonably well-written, so there's that. The Windows Research Kernel is somewhat more straightforwardly accessible; "wrk-1.2" will find innumerable copies rehosted on GitHub.

Regarding security, yes, it would be a payday loan. The NSA tool leak had some pretty old things in it that still did a fair chunk of damage.

Re:GitLab is open core, GitHub is closed source (2016) by WorldMaker on Monday June 04, 2018 @12:41PM (#17229626)
Satya's choice of CEO for GitHub in Nat Friedman seems to point to a previous precedent on the matter. When Microsoft acquihired Nat Friedman he was the CEO of Xamarin, and Microsoft open sourced all of Xamarin within several months of the acquisition.

Obviously there are few if any guarantees here, but if Satya is going to find a way to open source all or most of GitHub, placing Nat Friedman in charge is certainly a sign.

Re:GitLab is open core, GitHub is closed source (2016) by sverhagen on Monday June 04, 2018 @07:18AM (#17226683)
Not an Apple follower, could you explain the "Apple's playbook" reference?
Re:GitLab is open core, GitHub is closed source (2016) by veidr on Monday June 04, 2018 @07:22AM (#17226709)
Oh, it's in those two footnotes: Apple pre-announced that they were going to open source Swift, and then they did, and they did a great job and there was much rejoicing.

But there was some skepticism, because Steve Jobs had previously announced they were going to open-source their FaceTime technology so non-Apple platforms could adopt it and it could become a cross-platform communications system... but they never did.

Both announcements got people excited, though.

EDIT: Okay, my bad; I stand corrected. I remembered him saying that in 2012, but I googled it after lowtolerance disputed my claim, and what he actually said was, "We’re going to the standards bodies, starting tomorrow, and we’re going to make FaceTime an open industry standard.”

Re:GitLab is open core, GitHub is closed source (2016) by lowtolerance on Monday June 04, 2018 @08:01AM (#17226929)
Apple never said anything about open-sourcing FaceTime. Jobs said they were going to make it an open standard. That’s very different, but it doesn’t matter because they didn’t do that, either. My understanding is that patents got in the way of the plan, but according to engineers at Apple, there was never any actual “plan” to do this. Jobs’ introduction of FaceTime was the first they’d heard about making FaceTime an open standard, too.
Re:GitLab is open core, GitHub is closed source (2016) by mikece on Monday June 04, 2018 @07:45AM (#17226843)
Apple open-sourcing Swift doesn't really do much though. Sure, Swift is a nice language but allowing IBM or others to start using Swift for making mainframe or web frameworks doesn't make a difference to Apple from a sales perspective. Now if they either open-sourced iOS or started a program by which OEMs could sell devices with iOS then that would be huge -- but that's not going to happen because Apple has been rather up-front that they are a consumer electronics company now so anything that diminishes their ability to sell hardware is counter to their prime directive. Google, on the other hand, makes money by having more information to index, analyze, and develop marketing profiles. They would be just fine with Microsoft putting Android on a Surface Phone as long as hooks to Google Cloud products remained... otherwise they wouldn't be able to call it Android (eg: why Amazon's Fire devices don't officially run Android even though 99% of the APIs are the same).
Re:GitLab is open core, GitHub is closed source (2016) by test6554 on Monday June 04, 2018 @01:34PM (#17230093)
I don't think taking the wind out of critic's sails is worth over 7 billion. In fact, if whatever MS does is not worth at least 7 billion, then the shareholders are not going to be happy with Microsoft's executives.
Re:GitLab is open core, GitHub is closed source (2016) by kakwa_ on Monday June 04, 2018 @12:51PM (#17229708)
I'm not sure it would be really useful.

Github is more a service than a software, you need tons of components to make it work (Elastic Search, a DB, haproxy or nginx, a lot of ruby, a few C/C++ libraries, a few python libraries, etc) it's a big beast.

I know they provide VM images for Github Enterprise, but IIRC, it was quite a big beast, requiring at least 16GB of RAM a fast CPU with many cores and a large disk last time I looked (3 or 4 years ago). And there was a lot of stuff in that image.

If I had the source code, I'm not sure I would be able to properly deploy it and maintain, even with some documentation. Too many moving parts. And I feel a lot of sysadmins would be in the same situation.

There are some services that open source there code. Travis-ci is the one I've in mind, yet I don't know of any deployments outside of travis-ci.

Re:GitLab is open core, GitHub is closed source (2016) by giancarlostoro on Monday June 04, 2018 @07:31AM (#17226760)
I too wonder if they would. It would be for the best if they did. They have a lot more to gain if they did and GitHub already has an enterprise self hosted option so I assume its already generic enough code wise to be redeployed anywhere.
Re:GitLab is open core, GitHub is closed source (2016) by tedeh on Monday June 04, 2018 @06:22AM (#17226344)
May be hard to explain to stock holders looking for return on the acquisition...
Re:GitLab is open core, GitHub is closed source (2016) by veidr on Monday June 04, 2018 @06:56AM (#17226541)
My take on that is:

a.) A huge part of GitHub's value is their default-ness. Anybody can build a website UI to git, although it is a lot of engineering work. Gitlab and Bitbucket are somewhere in that equation.

People uneasy about MS are all over the Internet talking about moving off of GitHub today. MS announcing that they are open-sourcing GitHub would instantly evaporate a lot of that doubt/resentment/NOFUCKYUOM$!!!!URRRGH.

b.) They could also open-core it, not totally open-source it, just like GitLab. Thereby keeping basically all of the more-lucrative enterprise business (that's probably way more comfortable with Microsoft anyway).

Re:GitLab is open core, GitHub is closed source (2016) by test6554 on Monday June 04, 2018 @01:40PM (#17230153)
The main thing github gives microsoft is a pool of people it can try to push into Azure. Azure means that Microsoft no longer needs to care whether you develop apps for windows or linux or mac, or the web. As long as you make and deploy apps to Azure, you can use whatever stack you like.

For that reason, they have a strong incentive to keep people happy and on github, and they have a huge incentive to make it easy to deploy from github to azure with a single click or something similar.

Re:GitLab is open core, GitHub is closed source (2016) by jasonlotito on Monday June 04, 2018 @10:33AM (#17228084)
> They could also open-core it

So, literally not open sourcing it, which defeats the purpose.

Re:GitLab is open core, GitHub is closed source (2016) by chemicalcrux on Monday June 04, 2018 @11:03AM (#17228387)
That defaultness is huge. I often catch myself conflating "Git" and "GitHub" because they've been so tightly coupled for me for years.
Re:GitLab is open core, GitHub is closed source (2016) by peterwwillis on Monday June 04, 2018 @08:41AM (#17227140)
It ties in nicely with the other open source (compatible) solutions they're trying to make money off of right now. The money is in GitHub Enterprise, and in how they can roll the product's workflow, issue management, and huge developer base seamlessly into their cloud offerings.

They don't lose any customers by open sourcing it. Nobody's going to use GitLab if they can just download GitHub, and companies will still pay for Enterprise because they still need support for their massive investment in GitHub's extended features.

Re:GitLab is open core, GitHub is closed source (2016) by jbigelow76 on Monday June 04, 2018 @06:33AM (#17226403)
The code maintainers that (now) want an open source hosting solution are leaving anyway. Microsoft also already owns a git-as-a-service solution in Visual Studio Team Services. My take is this is another way to get closer to people and orgs that will probably need cloud services of some sort, so make it as easy as possible to choose Azure. I think the OP makes an excellent suggestion, as a dev and a (infinitesimally small) shareholder I would be for it 100%.
Re:GitLab is open core, GitHub is closed source (2016) by fnord123 on Monday June 04, 2018 @06:41AM (#17226447)
One click GitHub Enterprise deployment for Azure.
Re:GitLab is open core, GitHub is closed source (2016) by mnky9800n on Monday June 04, 2018 @06:26AM (#17226360)
Msft has been doing a good job of giving a return while also open sourcing everything.
Re:GitLab is open core, GitHub is closed source (2016) by tedeh on Monday June 04, 2018 @07:45AM (#17226840)
Say what? Open sourcing everything?
Re:GitLab is open core, GitHub is closed source (2016) by unreal37 on Monday June 04, 2018 @01:45PM (#17230196)
Microsoft is the largest public user of GitHub, with the most number of checkins to open source projects. Gasp!

[1] https://medium.freecodecamp.org/the-top-contributors-to-gith...

Re:GitLab is open core, GitHub is closed source (2016) by Aardwolf on Monday June 04, 2018 @08:41AM (#17227138)
That won't help with the hosting, the github.com URLs of tons of public projects, the community, followers, etc...
Re:GitLab is open core, GitHub is closed source (2016) by exikyut on Monday June 04, 2018 @09:08AM (#17227327)
Oh boy the amount of language and infrastructure tooling that's going to change from "code hosting" to "supports github and gitlab"

GitLab should treat GitHub as S3 and copy everything. I don't mean the git part, I mean the GitHub API bits that run on top.

Re:GitLab is open core, GitHub is closed source (2016) by Aardwolf on Monday June 04, 2018 @10:15AM (#17227917)
I don't fully understand what you mean, please help me understand. Why would the generic term "code hosting" change to two brand names, and what does S3 have to do with all this?
Re:GitLab is open core, GitHub is closed source (2016) by exikyut on Monday June 04, 2018 @11:14PM (#17234702)
Sure, sorry.

By "code hosting" I mean that most places say "we support code hosting" but in reality their systems are only setup to work with/use github.com; the domain at the very least, and possibly the API on top of that. Now places are going to have to generalize a bit, at the very least by thinking of multiple domains.

There are undoubtedly going to be tiny differences between how gitlab handles things; those will surface over time. They probably won't make headlines, but they'll cause tiny localized headaches.

As for S3, I mean that the GitHub API (issue tracking, etc) is all non-git proprietary stuff. GitLab should copy that so people's workflows Just Work™. I have no idea if they've already done this, I'm sure they've considered it.

Re:GitLab is open core, GitHub is closed source (2016) by dis-sys on Monday June 04, 2018 @07:26AM (#17226742)
ballmer will have a heart attack.