News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Carbon dioxide toxicity and climate change: a serious una... by Fej on Sunday June 03, 2018 @11:04PM (#17224251)
Abstract:

> "As atmospheric levels of carbon dioxide continue to escalate and drive climate change, the issue of CO2 toxicity is not recognised as a global risk. The toxicity of CO2 for breathing has been well defined for high concentrations but it remains effectively unknown what level will compromise human health when individuals are perpetually exposed for their lifetime. There is evidence from the few studies of long-term low-level exposure that permanent exposure, to CO2 levels predicted by the end of the century, will have significant effects on humans. Other studies of slightly higher CO2 levels may offer clues to effects that may occur when humans experience lifelong exposure. Unhealthy blood CO2 concentrations have been measured from people in common office environments where reduced thinking ability and health symptoms have been observed at levels of CO2 above 600 ppm for relatively short-term exposures. Although humans and animals are able to deal with elevated levels of CO2 in the short-term due to various compensation mechanisms in the body, the persistent effects of these mechanisms may have severe consequences in a perpetual environment of elevated CO2. These include threats to life such as kidney failure, bone atrophy and loss of brain function. Existing research also indicates that as ambient CO2 increases in the near-future, there will be an associated increase in cancers, neurological disorders and other conditions. Research is urgently required to clearly identify the severity and proximity of this risk, associated with the primary human function of breathing, being a potential major aspect of climate change."

---

Every day, I grow more and more convinced that we are just utterly screwed. Global warming (I am starting to favor the Stallmanism "global heating") has us fucked left, right, and sideways. And the leaders of the world do little about it.

It's already too late to reverse course, hasn't been possible for a while. Even then, mitigation isn't coming, not fast enough. There is not enough political will, and a magic carbon-reducing invention is... unlikely (if unpredictable).

From whence cometh hope? (Because I'm almost out of it.)

Re:Carbon dioxide toxicity and climate change: a serious una... by maxbond on Monday June 04, 2018 @01:37AM (#17224950)
I work close to this space (I'm an algae cultivation technician), and this is the peace I have come to with it. Hope it helps.

> ...a magic carbon-reducing invention is... unlikely (if unpredictable).

The technology to remove CO2 from the atmosphere isn't magic; you feed algae and you let them grow. There's work being done on piping flue gas from power plants through algae to scrub the carbon as it leaves. Even without scrubbing the flue gas, the only real problem with releasing CO2 into the atmosphere is when you dig it up from the ground first, and the technology for turning organic waste into natural gas is very mature.

It is certainly too late to stop climate change, but it's not too late for us to survive climate change. We know how to make energy and chemicals from fresh biomass instead of ancient biomass transformed into petroleum (such as with pyrolysis), we can even sequester carbon while we do it (as biochar), but we don't necessarily know how to integrate all of the required technologies and some of them aren't ready for prime time (hydrothermal liquefaction and cellulosic ethanol come to mind). But research into things like algae cultivation and thermal processing of biomass has been going on since the 80s and the 40s, respectively, and they're actually fairly mature.

The two biggest problems are managing massive amounts of complexity and the lack of political will around actually funding & fielding these solutions. If there were sufficient political will, the first problem would simply be a matter of time and money.

Hope springs eternal because humans are not. We will begin in earnest to rework our global economy and to fix our environment when enough of the old guard have died that their viewpoint is no longer relevant. There's an adage which goes, "progress is made one funeral at a time." If they don't die quickly enough, our climate will collapse which should provide them with sufficient encouragement. It's not something to celebrate but it is something to reckon with.

In short, our bed is made and we're going to lie in it. But tomorrow is a new day.

Re:Carbon dioxide toxicity and climate change: a serious una... by WhompingWindows on Monday June 04, 2018 @10:37AM (#17228120)
Are those two the biggest problems when it comes specifically to biomass? I hear biomass advocates all over the place saying they're the solution, saying: "we'll run entirely on carbon-neutral corn-derived ethanol and the poo from our vegan diets". Wow, that'd be great, but where are the numbers? Many of these claims go without physics-first principles and real numbers to back them up. For instance, using algae, we'd need an incredibly massive commitment of funds to install scrubbers on all the plants across the world. Even if we did that over the next 30-50 years, which we really can't yet because the tech isn't ready, even if a miracle occurred and we did that, that doesn't solve the existing CO2 heating the planet or the negative feedback loops.

IMO, the real problem with biomass is the sheer scale of the energy system, it's far too large of an industrial base already for algae scrubbers to be effective. IMO, we need planet-cooling measures, increasing cloud cover, increasing albedo, somethjing to prevent heating and the vicious feedback loops in the arctic and elsewhere. Then, we also need to deal with the CO2, which will still be around even if we reduce insolation and heating. I don't know if algae or CCS or some other method will be used for that, but I see that as secondary to the "easier" cooling mechanisms.

Re:Carbon dioxide toxicity and climate change: a serious una... by maxbond on Friday June 08, 2018 @11:54PM (#17271455)
To summarize my thoughts on the topic, no we cannot use food crops and arable land for energy production, no biomass is not sufficient, and a nexus of solutions will be required. Managing and integrating those solutions is where the complexity comes into play. If you're deploying a nexus of solutions it doesn't matter as much if some of the technologies are immature, you can structure them to cover each other's deficiencies (similar to the computer security concept of defense in depth).

I was mostly responding to the original poster's feeling of hopelessness and arguing that solutions are possible and are being developed.

Re:Carbon dioxide toxicity and climate change: a serious una... by dredmorbius on Monday June 04, 2018 @11:26AM (#17228651)
For waste-stream based fuels, consider first that the upper bound on potential is the incoming feedstock, that is, food, and nets to something like 25% of its energy potential.

And the feedstock is bounded by net primary primary productivity, also referred to as the photosynthetic ceiling. It turns out that humans already lay claim to 20% of this. Replacing fossil fuels (a prerequisite to acheiving net zero emissions) would require another 20% of NPP, an unlikely scenario.

Using crop yields and land area, one quickly realises that under all but the rosiest scenarios, more land is required for biomass fuel production than exists in major technological and industrial nations.

So, no, biomass is not sufficient to sustain present per-capita energy use and populations.

https://old.reddit.com/r/dredmorbius/comments/2cvap7/the_int...

Re:Carbon dioxide toxicity and climate change: a serious una... by aoner on Wednesday June 06, 2018 @09:14AM (#17246823)
you can also use the sea with wastewater as feedstock: https://www.nasa.gov/centers/ames/research/OMEGA/index.html
Re:Carbon dioxide toxicity and climate change: a serious una... by dredmorbius on Wednesday June 06, 2018 @10:17AM (#17247314)
Interesting, though still bounded by the photosynthetic ceiling, and you're competing with all other marine life.
Re:Carbon dioxide toxicity and climate change: a serious una... by amelius on Monday June 04, 2018 @08:12AM (#17227002)
> lack of political will

Why wouldn't emissions trading ([1]) solve this? If there is economic incentive to remove CO2, then why wouldn't it happen?

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Emissions_trading

Re:Carbon dioxide toxicity and climate change: a serious una... by Retric on Monday June 04, 2018 @09:54AM (#17227815)
Cap and trade gives highly valuable resources away for free. It hands them to industries who already heavily pollute and based on current usage patterns and adoption curves might slow down adoption of cleaner energy sources.

Worse even talking about it directly slows clean tech as companies are better off waiting to get a larger amount of credits for free.

Re:Carbon dioxide toxicity and climate change: a serious una... by pjc50 on Monday June 04, 2018 @08:38AM (#17227122)
What's the economic incentive to build, enforce and pay for the emissions trading setup?

Realistically if it works it will be at a huge cost to the oil-exporting countries of the world, so they're going to delay it as much as possible.

Re:Carbon dioxide toxicity and climate change: a serious una... by snarf21 on Monday June 04, 2018 @10:40AM (#17228165)
I really appreciated your response. People keep saying humanity is going to go extinct and it seems like we have too much time and technology for that to happen. I still wonder if the thing we need even more than tech to reduce CO2 is agreements to stop and reverse population growth. I don't think Earth can sustainably support more than 4B people. It feels like we need as much time as possible to truly move to renewables but population explosion just reduces the time available.
Re:Carbon dioxide toxicity and climate change: a serious una... by plankers on Monday June 04, 2018 @11:23AM (#17228612)
On the other hand, the more humans that exist, the more people are available to solve these problems (and solve them faster!)
Re:Carbon dioxide toxicity and climate change: a serious una... by Gravityloss on Monday June 04, 2018 @05:24PM (#17232638)
So, you burn coal, then feed the CO2 to algae and together with solar energy, it binds it back to some relatively storable form.

What's the quantitative difference compared to not building a coal plant, a coal mine, transportation network and the algae plant, and instead building solar panels and wind turbines and feeding the electricity to the grid?

Re:Carbon dioxide toxicity and climate change: a serious una... by maxbond on Saturday June 09, 2018 @12:05AM (#17271478)
I don't have numbers for you, and I don't buy "clean coal", but I would counter with this question; is it better to build a solar or wind farm, or to retrofit a coal fired power plant to burn algae? And then to recycle that carbon into more algae? Isn't that a kind of solar power plant?

(Getting your hands of negatively-value nutrients in order to make the system work is left as an exercise. Or I just don't have all the answers.)

Re:Carbon dioxide toxicity and climate change: a serious una... by aoner on Monday June 04, 2018 @02:28AM (#17225130)
I have been thinking about these problems for a long time and have some ideas regarding carbon sequestration (biochar), algea and a possible method that is profitable. Can I send you an email with some questions? You would help me out a lot!
Re:Carbon dioxide toxicity and climate change: a serious una... by jabl on Monday June 04, 2018 @03:45AM (#17225447)
> From whence cometh hope?

Yes, it's most likely too late to hit the 1.5C, and 2C as well unless our beloved leaders suddenly step up to the plate with, you know, actions; we've had enough of flowery words already thank you very much.

But, it's not black and white. Everything we can do, helps make it less bad.

From Kate Raworth:

- Don't be a pessimist, if it makes you give up.

- Don't be an optimist, if it makes you laid back.

- Be an activist!

The urgency of the climate issue is one of the main reasons I support nuclear power, in addition to renewables. Heck, although I've long seen CCS as a boondoggle, there are some recent promising results there as well which we ought to look seriously into (lookup "Net Power" and their "Allam cycle" tech). We need a crash program to build every zero-carbon source we can!

Re:Carbon dioxide toxicity and climate change: a serious una... by oldcynic on Monday June 04, 2018 @04:31AM (#17225678)
> Everything we can do, helps make it less bad

Well sometimes.

Recycling turns out to be more energy intensive than deposit and reuse.

All the moves to efficiency, LED and CCFL lighting, and can be offset by permitting a single additional fracking or shale oil site.

Makes it difficult not to logically become a pessimist who gives up when the idiots have orders of magnitude more leverage.

Re:Carbon dioxide toxicity and climate change: a serious una... by jabl on Monday June 04, 2018 @05:29AM (#17226021)
> Well sometimes.

Perhaps I should have explicitly written "Everything we can do [to reduce GHG emissions]". Of course there's lots of things we do that makes the situation worse!

> Recycling turns out to be more energy intensive than deposit and reuse.

Sometimes, sometimes not. Say, smelting recycled steel produces a lot less GHG emissions than producing fresh steel with a blast furnace, particularly if the local electricity grid has low carbon intensity.

But yes, there are other considerations in the world than GHG emissions. And in some cases increasing GHG emissions might be worth it (say, lifting 3rd world countries out of energy poverty). I'm just saying that GHG reductions should have a lot higher weight in policymaking than what it has now.

> All the moves to efficiency, LED and CCFL lighting, and can be offset by permitting a single additional fracking or shale oil site.

Maybe. But, it would be even worse if we hadn't done the efficiency, LED etc. stuff and instead permitted two additional wells! Everything, well if not actually helps, at least makes it less bad.

> Makes it difficult not to logically become a pessimist who gives up when the idiots have orders of magnitude more leverage.

I agree, it's hard. Have to keep trying!

Re:Carbon dioxide toxicity and climate change: a serious una... by agumonkey on Monday June 04, 2018 @06:50AM (#17226508)
That's true albeit I think we need another level.

Don't be an activist, things are too large for one person.

Be a socialist

jokes aside, we all can start doing something, but

1) what exactly ?

2) how to coordinate

3) without falling into politics hell

----

1) I really wonder how we could help purify air. More plants ? that might absorb some CO2, what about other molecules ? What about vacuums in sewer pipes ? enough to cause a little depression near ground that would suck part of the exhaust gas in places where they can be processed.

2) see above for planting and tweaking cities then 3) .. have no idea

Re:Carbon dioxide toxicity and climate change: a serious una... by ThomPete on Monday June 04, 2018 @07:16AM (#17226674)
Its worth noting that the world on average is 14% more green today than 20 years ago.

http://www.bbc.com/news/science-environment-36130346

The reality is that no one really know whats going to happen. Maybe we are doomed maybe we will do just fine, maybe an astroid will hit earth before we find out.

Personally i dont think there is much we can do other than to charge on, keep growing our economies and develop new technologies and solutions to the problems nature always have presented us with.

Re:Carbon dioxide toxicity and climate change: a serious una... by ageofwant on Monday June 04, 2018 @08:18AM (#17227030)
No, we are pretty sure what is going to happen. You work with the evidence you have, what you know, not what you don't know. We cannot continue to 'grow' our economies, our economies need to fundamentally change. Unconstrained growth is economic cancer.

The third industrial revolution will by necessity change what we currently understand economies to be:

https://impact.vice.com/en_us/article/bj5zaq/watch-vices-new...

Re:Carbon dioxide toxicity and climate change: a serious una... by ThomPete on Monday June 04, 2018 @09:02AM (#17227283)
We are sure that the planet is warming we are not sure how much humans affect this and what it will mean.

If you want to stand a chance against whether you fear the environment will do to you need growth to be able to pay for the development of new technologies.

Here is the paradox you are dealing with.

We also know that growth and free markets help those who have access to it get out of poverty and much more prosperity. That means at least a couple of billion more people are hoping to get what you and I have.

Are you going to tell them they can't have what you have? And if you are what are you going to offer them in return that they would care about. They don't care about the environment in any shape or form that you or me or any other westerner does.

This is the paradox we are dealing with. If there is a third industrial revolution it certainly won't be based on the sharing economy that's not how humans work.

Re:Carbon dioxide toxicity and climate change: a serious una... by zajd on Monday June 04, 2018 @09:25AM (#17227498)
> We also know that growth and free markets help those who have access to it get out of poverty and much more prosperity.

Growth and free markets are what is driving overconsumption

Re:Carbon dioxide toxicity and climate change: a serious una... by ThomPete on Monday June 04, 2018 @10:06AM (#17227862)
They also drive prosperity and have provided us with plenty of ways to deal with mother nature who's always been rough on us.

If you think that living 200 years ago was a better life for most people just because they had more nature and couldn't consume as much I think you would be mistaken.

You can't have your cake and eat it.

Growth and prosperity comes with its own problems and challenges but I take those any day over an antigrowth philosophy.

Re:Carbon dioxide toxicity and climate change: a serious una... by ageofwant on Monday June 04, 2018 @07:30PM (#17233604)
You really need to deal with your straw-man fixation, or at least reserve it for people that may be impressed with it.

'Growth' as you are defining it, is unsustainable. Do you you know what 'unsustainable' means? It means it must stop. Not 'has to', 'would be nice to' but 'must'. It has a hard physical thermodynamic ceiling. Your philosophy has no future.

Re:Carbon dioxide toxicity and climate change: a serious una... by ThomPete on Monday June 04, 2018 @07:54PM (#17233751)
First of all you need to learn what a strawman is.

Second of all my philosophy of using technology to solve the problems that nature presents to us has no future? I am not sure what you are doing here using a computer then or why you are wasting time and energy on a website debating with strangers.

Re:Carbon dioxide toxicity and climate change: a serious una... by ageofwant on Monday June 04, 2018 @07:22PM (#17233549)
We know that the planet is warming, we know humans are responsible for the vast majority of that change, and we know what it will mean for the biosphere and the things that depend on that, i.e you and I. I'm not sure why you think we do not. There is 20km of air between the ground and space, you can breathe in the first 5km of that. We have been pumping billions of tons of C02 into that 5km for the last 200 years, what did you thing was going to happen, nothing ?

The next bit of your post exemplifies exactly the king of thinking that brought us to this point in human history. And then you end with the silly strawmen, seriously ? Do you really think 3rd world countries are going to repeat the same mistakes, why will they build coal plants when they can have of the shelf solar plants for a fraction of the price ?

Re:Carbon dioxide toxicity and climate change: a serious una... by ThomPete on Monday June 04, 2018 @07:50PM (#17233734)
I think first you need to learn what a strawman actually means.

Yes the 3rd world absolutely wants the prosperity we have. You might disagree with that (and you would be hard-pressed to find many countries who don't aspire) but it's certainly no strawman. But hey keep telling yourself that so you don't have to deal with the facts.

With regards to whether humans are responsible for that vast majority of the change again it's not as clear cut as I am sure you would like to portray it. None the less even if that was the case it's certainly not going to be solved by stopping countries from aspiring for more prosperity for their citizens.

Re:Carbon dioxide toxicity and climate change: a serious una... by plankers on Monday June 04, 2018 @11:37AM (#17228856)
I'll probably come off as a spoiled Westerner here, but that's not my intent.

Isn't it a bit presumptuous to assume that everyone in impoverished parts of the world even _want_ the kind of prosperity we have? It seems to be taken for granted that all the drawbacks to modern civilization are outweighed by the benefits. But then, isn't this the same mindset that has set us on this course of man-made global heating?

I suppose I'm advocating for leaving other countries to decide their own paths and not trying to push our prosperity onto them. If that makes me a greedy Westerner, so be it. I don't exactly enjoy my society, anyway.

Re:Carbon dioxide toxicity and climate change: a serious una... by agumonkey on Tuesday June 05, 2018 @07:47AM (#17236750)
I'm a westerner. But I lived a bit in tropical parts who where very different in lifestyles. I'm also an ex tech-lover (my generation was fed on it). Nowadays, I think I'd enjoy a bit of green between 10 to 1000x more than a UHD Qdot LCD and fiber connection.

I think that our lifestyles is toxic, especially for other places (africa, asia), for us too (stress, sadness, different diseases).. anyway, we replaced one kind of life struggle with another one.

And I do feel sad that 3rd world is somehow envying, even though it's not surprising, western life is pure eye candy, and designed to be so.

And I heard a few people leaving big western cities to go into medium ones, for the difference of pace and life quality (more space, more green).

Re:Carbon dioxide toxicity and climate change: a serious una... by ThomPete on Tuesday June 05, 2018 @08:26AM (#17236984)
If you have children I am pretty sure you would agree that modern society is the best place to be without any real competition.
Re:Carbon dioxide toxicity and climate change: a serious una... by ThomPete on Monday June 04, 2018 @01:24PM (#17229998)
So somehow magically all the countries who are rich today are the countries that want it and the other countries somehow magically don't or what is your point?

Even if there were a few countries that didn't want their kids to survive simple diseases have enough food to feed their family or not have to worry about the safety of their family I am fairly certain that most countries want that.

I am also fairly certain that you are not willing to trade all these "drawbacks" of modern society for a life in an unmodern society and even if you were it would most likely be a very short-lived desire.

Which countries exactly is it you think don't want the kind of growth we have in the west?

Not sure I understand what you are trying to show here.

Re:Carbon dioxide toxicity and climate change: a serious una... by plankers on Wednesday June 06, 2018 @12:06PM (#17248261)
I'm not trying to "show" anything, just advocating for allowing other societies the opportunity for self-determination rather than pushing on them what we think is best.

Self-determination is a long and arduous process. It took the U.S. over 250 years to get to where we are (much longer if you consider how much we borrowed from Britain). We've paid a hefty price in mental health along the way.

We can provide healthcare and other benefits of modern society through trade without forcing these things on them, although that would admittedly take longer. It could be that poorer countries decide they value traditional culture and avoiding wastefulness (and the climate impacts this brings with it) to convenience and glamor. I don't know, it's not my place to say.

Re:Carbon dioxide toxicity and climate change: a serious una... by ThomPete on Wednesday June 06, 2018 @12:24PM (#17248443)
Other societies HAVE that opportunity they just didn't choose it and those who can't choose it are desperate to get invited to the club.

So not sure what makes you think other societies don't want the kind prosperity to their citizens we have in the west.

Not sure what you mean with providing healthcare for them as if it wouldn't be better they themselves were able to provide healthcare.

I would urge you to rethink your position. Not because I want to decide what you think but because it's not really founded in anything of thise world.

Re:Carbon dioxide toxicity and climate change: a serious una... by gimmeDatCheddar on Monday June 04, 2018 @01:44PM (#17230190)
He doesn't really have a point except to try to justify tanking the standard of living. As a preemptive attempt to justifying literal communism in 2018. Communists know that they cannot implement their vision while maintaining the current standard of living, so they want to tank it.
Re:Carbon dioxide toxicity and climate change: a serious una... by agumonkey on Monday June 04, 2018 @07:47AM (#17226853)
Maybe it's a rate ratio. 14% more green but 50% more toxic particles ?

Not knowledgeable.

Anyway, I could tolerate a lot more green anyway :)

Re:Carbon dioxide toxicity and climate change: a serious una... by ThomPete on Monday June 04, 2018 @09:07AM (#17227315)
That's the point. We don't know and any claim to knowing exactly what's going to happen is simply charletanian.

We know that earth is warming, we know humans have some effect but not how much, we know that it can have consequences that the oceans are rising but so far we haven't really been able to predict how it's going to affect things (there is natural erosion from the oceans which is unrelated to humans)

I think the debate could be a lot more rational if people didn't paint themselves into corners such as the "climate catastrophist" and "climate deniers" in reality there is a lot of things we all agree on but these extreme views are taking everyone hostage to the point were I can't even comment on this without being downvoted (instead of pointing to where someone disagree). The debate certainly has gotten 50% more toxic :)

Re:Carbon dioxide toxicity and climate change: a serious una... by pjc50 on Monday June 04, 2018 @09:15AM (#17227408)
> how we could help purify air

Really you have to solve the politics first; unless you can persuade people to care about others and that the problems are worth solving, more so than increasing their personal wealth, it's not going very far.

Re:Carbon dioxide toxicity and climate change: a serious una... by agumonkey on Monday June 04, 2018 @11:49AM (#17229038)
I believe in local organic self motivated test fiesta. The rest may follow
Re:Carbon dioxide toxicity and climate change: a serious una... by specialist on Monday June 04, 2018 @10:52AM (#17228265)
Solar & wind have already over taken nuclear.

Even so, we need to eliminate stockpiles, waste. Traveling wave reactors (TWR) seems like the best technical bet. Maybe we'd get some electricity out of it.

(I'm not clear why we don't drop radioactive waste onto the Marianas Trench and let the earth eventually devour it.)

Re:Carbon dioxide toxicity and climate change: a serious una... by jabl on Monday June 04, 2018 @02:26PM (#17230605)
> Solar & wind have already over taken nuclear.

Solar and wind have rapidly come down in price, which is awesome. However, due to their variable nature, they do suffer from the problem of declining value as their grid penetration increases.

So there is a place for dispatchable capacity. If your country has enough dispatchable renewables like hydro or geothermal, awesome. If not, there's not that many good options. Nuclear, and maybe fossil and/or biofuels (in general, I'm very skeptical wrt large-scale biofule use, so this ought to be very limited) with CCS. Batteries and demand shifting are good for short-term bursts, and will likely replace gas in that role, but for large scale shifting they are way too expensive.

I'm very much a fan of the work Jesse Jenkins is doing in power systems modeling, see e.g.

https://kleinmanenergy.upenn.edu/events/getting-zero-pathway...

> Even so, we need to eliminate stockpiles, waste. Traveling wave reactors (TWR) seems like the best technical bet. Maybe we'd get some electricity out of it.

Last I read, the company behind the TWR (TerraPower) is mostly focusing on a fast spectrum molten salt reactor nowadays. Which is cool, I'm a big fan of the fast MSR as a concept. That being said, while breeding would allow us to increase the utilization of nuclear fuel by about two orders of magnitude, at the moment uranium is so cheap that it's not seen as economically worthwhile.

But, if nuclear is going to play a major role in the world's energy supply, breeders will eventually be necessary. So I do think we should develop them.

> (I'm not clear why we don't drop radioactive waste onto the Marianas Trench and let the earth eventually devour it.)

The waste problem is more political than technical. Burying the waste deep in bedrock is perfectly good.

Re:Carbon dioxide toxicity and climate change: a serious una... by hackerman12345 on Monday June 04, 2018 @01:38PM (#17230133)
If the container leaks, radionuclides might seep out which could be bad news (flowing with currents or ingested by fish).

Solving the political issues at Yucca would be a great permanent solution to waste.

Re:Carbon dioxide toxicity and climate change: a serious una... by specialist on Tuesday June 05, 2018 @09:57AM (#17237590)
I sort of expected everything to be turned into glass (vitrification) by now.

I'm terrified of what's happening in at the Hanford Nuclear Reservation. My friends (who work on this issue) tell me that when the toxic plum seeps thru the water table all the way to the Columbia River, everything down stream becomes uninhabitable. That's Portland, Vancouver (WA), etc.

I really want someone to figure out how to turn all that crap into glass trinkets and then drop into deepest ocean.

Re:Carbon dioxide toxicity and climate change: a serious una... by tim333 on Monday June 04, 2018 @11:33AM (#17228775)
>more and more convinced that we are just utterly screwed

Some arguments to chill out:

CO2 was 10x higher in the past. Life bloomed https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carbon_dioxide_in_Earth%27s_at...

Renewables are getting cheaper exponentially, fossil fuels are not. The cross over is about now https://www.forbes.com/sites/dominicdudley/2018/01/13/renewa...

Climate change and sea level change happen all the time - the sea is 120m higher than 16,000 years ago and no one noticed pretty much https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sea_level_rise

Anyway we'll probably be immortal cyborgs by the time it kicks off ;)

Re:Carbon dioxide toxicity and climate change: a serious una... by WorldMaker on Monday June 04, 2018 @12:57PM (#17229777)
> CO2 was 10x higher in the past. Life bloomed

Just not mammalian life, or most of the higher order life we know and love. ;)

Re:Carbon dioxide toxicity and climate change: a serious una... by adrianN on Monday June 04, 2018 @03:33AM (#17225395)
The ultra low tech version of carbon scrubbing is planting forests, cutting them down and turning the wood into charcoal. When you bury the charcoal it's stable for at least a few millennia and (in moderate quantities at least) it improves soil quality. You could even make a bit of money selling the energy you get from the wood gas. There is at least one guy on HN who did some math regarding the feasibility of this approach: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16957397
Re:Carbon dioxide toxicity and climate change: a serious una... by AstralStorm on Monday June 04, 2018 @03:41AM (#17225427)
It is much too slow and would eat arable land which we already do not have enough of.

To make replanting successful you would have to reverse desertification of Africa and then replant perhaps. That is over 100 years timeframe.

If you need something now and green, the about only option is algae. That still takes huge capital investment.

Re:Carbon dioxide toxicity and climate change: a serious una... by jacobush on Monday June 04, 2018 @06:58AM (#17226556)
Reverse desertification is very doable, IMHO. From the ocean shores - a combination of passive water trapping engineering, akin to what the British did here:

https://news.nationalgeographic.com/2017/05/ascension-island...

edit: as well as active Seawater greenhouses at the shores with humid air pumped: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Seawater_greenhouse

Attacking the sand dunes themselves - pin them down so less sand gets blown around. Solar powered rovers can roam the dunes and sinter (with concentrated light) long reams in a pattern in the dunes. This will slow down dune movement both in the short term - what is held down by the sintered reams of glass, can not blow around -

but also in the long run -

when new sand inevitably blows over the reams of glass, the reams will remain inside the dune, acting as a structural enforcement - rebar in effect, stabilizing the whole dune.

Rinse, repeat. Perhaps the roaming rovers can even etch mini-structures into the sand giving local shadow which can trap moisture.

Re:Carbon dioxide toxicity and climate change: a serious una... by Symmetry on Monday June 04, 2018 @10:28AM (#17228037)
You can't get more carbon out of an acre that way than you could by using that acre to produce biofuel and use that to displace fossil fuel production. We don't have enough acres of arable land to sustain our current civilization's energy consumption that way, so I think this wouldn't actually solve the problem. Though replacing mono-culture farmland with forests is nice from a biodiversity and aesthetic standpoint.
Re:Carbon dioxide toxicity and climate change: a serious una... by adrianN on Monday June 04, 2018 @10:38AM (#17228133)
You assume that the crop -> biofuel process is as efficient as the crop -> biochar process.
Re:Carbon dioxide toxicity and climate change: a serious una... by Symmetry on Monday June 04, 2018 @11:02AM (#17228377)
Yes, is there any reason to think that there'll be more than a factor of 2 difference? Fossil fuels will tend to have a higher hydrogen to carbon ratio than charcoal but the energy per carbon isn't that different.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Emission_intensity

Re:Carbon dioxide toxicity and climate change: a serious una... by dredmorbius on Monday June 04, 2018 @11:34AM (#17228791)
Bogs are, hectare for hectare, more productive than forests.
Re:Carbon dioxide toxicity and climate change: a serious una... by asfasgasg on Monday June 04, 2018 @08:08AM (#17226974)
I would not panic over this just yet. It is deeply concerning, but there are some mitigating factors:

    - Population growth is slowing.
    - Per capita CO2 emissions are falling.
    - Good reason to believe this trend will continue.
Another issue is the magnitude of the effects postulated in the paper. 600->1000 ppm showed 10-20% decreases in cognitive scores on tests during short term exposure. That's huge, but it's important to remember that it took almost 40 years to go from 350->400 (which is roughly where we are today). Emissions growth has been slowing, and I guess despite the US President's best efforts, will probably start falling some time in the next few years. So it may take even longer to get to 500, 600.

http://www.acer-acre.ca/resources/climate-change-in-context/...

This includes some projections, and the graph looks scary, but make sure to look at the bottom of the page to see what each scenario entails, and try to judge what you think is most likely.

Re:Carbon dioxide toxicity and climate change: a serious una... by antisthenes on Monday June 04, 2018 @01:18PM (#17229951)
Most of the cognitive work is done inside buildings, where concentrations are higher anyway, so looking at atmospheric CO2 is almost irrelevant.

You can have a properly ventilated building at 1000 atmospheric CO2, and end up with an indoor concentration of 1200ppm; likewise many buildings today have concentrations of 2000+ppm with atmospheric CO2 hovering around 400.

That's not to say it's not going to get worse and much worse. But it will take a few human generations to get to that point.

Re:Carbon dioxide toxicity and climate change: a serious una... by creaghpatr on Monday June 04, 2018 @09:01AM (#17227274)
Couldn't we measure this against aggregate trends in cognitive scoring across different regions over time?
Re:Carbon dioxide toxicity and climate change: a serious una... by tgtweak on Monday June 04, 2018 @08:51AM (#17227217)
Even a few percentage points should be enough to cause concern at a global scale.
Re:Carbon dioxide toxicity and climate change: a serious una... by KnightOfWords on Monday June 04, 2018 @04:27AM (#17225656)
I'm a little more optimistic than you. Former sceptics/deniers are waking up and significant mitigation action is taking place, both on a personal and global level. More people are realising they can reduce their carbon footprint significantly without seriously affecting their quality of life.

The frustration is that the action we're taking isn't proportional to the scale of the problem. We aren't going to come through this unscathed but we still have some room to maneuver.

Here's some better news: http://www.scmp.com/news/china/society/article/2148684/comin...

I certainly wouldn't assume we can innovate our way out of trouble, but we may be able to solve some of the problems climate change is going to cause us.

Re:Carbon dioxide toxicity and climate change: a serious una... by m_mueller on Monday June 04, 2018 @05:27AM (#17226007)
Do you have any evidence of deniers waking up? I haven't yet seen as much, especially at policy maker level, it rather seems to have gotten worse with the Trump election.
Re:Carbon dioxide toxicity and climate change: a serious una... by creaghpatr on Monday June 04, 2018 @09:38AM (#17227639)
There are plenty of pragmatists ready to endorse actionable climate initiatives that don't involve the transfer of wealth and sovereignty of the US to a collective ruling body like the UN. But when we encounter someone who slurs the opposition with the 'denier' label, it's unconvincing that your interests are truly with improving the climate rather than proving a political point.
Re:Carbon dioxide toxicity and climate change: a serious una... by m_mueller on Monday June 04, 2018 @09:47AM (#17227746)
It's one thing to see climate management as a fight between nations or political parties, but it's another to claim that climate is not a problem we should care about at all. The latter stance is IMO prevalent in current USGov - I'd love to be proven wrong though. If this holds then I don't see how the 'denier' label doesn't fit.
Re:Carbon dioxide toxicity and climate change: a serious una... by Brakenshire on Monday June 04, 2018 @07:22AM (#17226708)
> From whence cometh hope? (Because I'm almost out of it.)

The hope is that the core technologies necessary for rapid decarbonization, wind, solar, batteries, smart grid are all rapidly falling into place, and it seems likely that they will end up cheaper than the current technology, it's just a question of whether that happens over 5 years or 20 years. And also that there are enough decent countries or states putting in enough effort to push those technologies over that hump.

Re:Carbon dioxide toxicity and climate change: a serious una... by c12 on Monday June 04, 2018 @05:54AM (#17226178)
What I'm getting from this is that in the next century or so people are going to gradually get dumber and dumber as the CO2 increases cause the loss of brain function.
Re:Carbon dioxide toxicity and climate change: a serious una... by ItsMe000001 on Monday June 04, 2018 @06:40AM (#17226438)
I would be (I am) more worried about heavy metals such as lead and mercury.

This comes from my own experience, I was diagnosed with a "gray area" amount of chronic mercury poisoning, meaning the measured amount was just enough for the doctor to recommend chelation treatment (DMPS, DMSA). Note that chronic poisoning is not well understood and there are no reliable tests for it, the tests only measure what's in the blood, but after long-term chronic exposure the problem is what's stored in various tissues throughout the body and blood levels are quite low. So I was "lucky" in a way that I actually had it in the blood (and hair) in significant amounts.

Anyway, the reason why I'm worried is that I found that levels that have a noticeable effect are far, far lower than thought. This is actually consistent with what you can see in the history of research on lead, by now the official medical opinion is that the only safe level is zero. Mercury is far worse - and there once was an LD (lethal dose) study on rats where they measured both but also combined the two, and lethality went through the roof (I think the combination was a thousand times more lethal than either metal alone). Combinations are almost never studied (not surprising given the unstudiable amount of them).

By using chelators for years, on and off, while having a pretty constant unexciting and mostly stress-free life I noticed a lot of things, and my conclusion is what I said, noticeable effects occur at levels deemed completely uninteresting by the medical field these days (apart from the general recommendation that "zero is best"). I also had quite a few spectacular proven results, such as a decades-old thyroid nodule simply disappearing (the tissue in that area was very active for a few weeks after DMPS chelation), but I found the brain effects far more spectacular. Unfortunately they are also much harder to convey, or even prove.

I make a claim that I cannot prove, that even very low levels far below threshold levels of heavy metals have an effect on the brain at least, from mood to intelligence to stress resistance.

Re:Carbon dioxide toxicity and climate change: a serious una... by kgc on Monday June 04, 2018 @07:54AM (#17226890)
Where do you live?
Re:Carbon dioxide toxicity and climate change: a serious una... by nonbel on Monday June 04, 2018 @09:37AM (#17227629)
>"Every day, I grow more and more convinced that we are just utterly screwed."

Have you ever experienced "doom porn", fomo, etc? I suspect not, because it sounds like that is what you are going through. Once you have that experience under your belt you won't be so ready to believe wild speculations.

Re:Carbon dioxide toxicity and climate change: a serious una... by antisthenes on Monday June 04, 2018 @01:11PM (#17229900)
I would venture to say that the last realistic change of course needed to happen before the vast majority of HN audience were born

Life on Earth isn't fucked, but our lifestyles certainly will be.

Re:Carbon dioxide toxicity and climate change: a serious una... by commandlinefan on Monday June 04, 2018 @11:33AM (#17228769)
> leaders of the world do little about it

Well... what would you have them do? Air conditioning is (ironically) the biggest contributor to climate change. Should it be outlawed?

Re:Carbon dioxide toxicity and climate change: a serious una... by IanDrake on Monday June 04, 2018 @08:26AM (#17227065)
“Global warming ... has us fucked left, right, and sideways.”

That is a big claim that requires adequate proof to which none was offered.

Besides click bait articles which attempt to suggest everything is caused by GW, there is actually very little evidence to suggest we seen any detrimental effects of GW so far.