IMO, the real problem with biomass is the sheer scale of the energy system, it's far too large of an industrial base already for algae scrubbers to be effective. IMO, we need planet-cooling measures, increasing cloud cover, increasing albedo, somethjing to prevent heating and the vicious feedback loops in the arctic and elsewhere. Then, we also need to deal with the CO2, which will still be around even if we reduce insolation and heating. I don't know if algae or CCS or some other method will be used for that, but I see that as secondary to the "easier" cooling mechanisms.
I was mostly responding to the original poster's feeling of hopelessness and arguing that solutions are possible and are being developed.
And the feedstock is bounded by net primary primary productivity, also referred to as the photosynthetic ceiling. It turns out that humans already lay claim to 20% of this. Replacing fossil fuels (a prerequisite to acheiving net zero emissions) would require another 20% of NPP, an unlikely scenario.
Using crop yields and land area, one quickly realises that under all but the rosiest scenarios, more land is required for biomass fuel production than exists in major technological and industrial nations.
So, no, biomass is not sufficient to sustain present per-capita energy use and populations.
https://old.reddit.com/r/dredmorbius/comments/2cvap7/the_int...
Why wouldn't emissions trading ([1]) solve this? If there is economic incentive to remove CO2, then why wouldn't it happen?
Worse even talking about it directly slows clean tech as companies are better off waiting to get a larger amount of credits for free.
Realistically if it works it will be at a huge cost to the oil-exporting countries of the world, so they're going to delay it as much as possible.
What's the quantitative difference compared to not building a coal plant, a coal mine, transportation network and the algae plant, and instead building solar panels and wind turbines and feeding the electricity to the grid?
(Getting your hands of negatively-value nutrients in order to make the system work is left as an exercise. Or I just don't have all the answers.)
> ...a magic carbon-reducing invention is... unlikely (if unpredictable).
The technology to remove CO2 from the atmosphere isn't magic; you feed algae and you let them grow. There's work being done on piping flue gas from power plants through algae to scrub the carbon as it leaves. Even without scrubbing the flue gas, the only real problem with releasing CO2 into the atmosphere is when you dig it up from the ground first, and the technology for turning organic waste into natural gas is very mature.
It is certainly too late to stop climate change, but it's not too late for us to survive climate change. We know how to make energy and chemicals from fresh biomass instead of ancient biomass transformed into petroleum (such as with pyrolysis), we can even sequester carbon while we do it (as biochar), but we don't necessarily know how to integrate all of the required technologies and some of them aren't ready for prime time (hydrothermal liquefaction and cellulosic ethanol come to mind). But research into things like algae cultivation and thermal processing of biomass has been going on since the 80s and the 40s, respectively, and they're actually fairly mature.
The two biggest problems are managing massive amounts of complexity and the lack of political will around actually funding & fielding these solutions. If there were sufficient political will, the first problem would simply be a matter of time and money.
Hope springs eternal because humans are not. We will begin in earnest to rework our global economy and to fix our environment when enough of the old guard have died that their viewpoint is no longer relevant. There's an adage which goes, "progress is made one funeral at a time." If they don't die quickly enough, our climate will collapse which should provide them with sufficient encouragement. It's not something to celebrate but it is something to reckon with.
In short, our bed is made and we're going to lie in it. But tomorrow is a new day.