News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Theranos investors cannot pursue class action: U.S. judge by whatshisface on Friday June 01, 2018 @02:22PM (#17208423)
>“It is easy to imagine, for example, that someone invested simply because a friend suggested it, or because all that percolated down the grapevine was vague insight that Theranos was a fast-growing company, or had promising (but unspecified) technology,”

How would it ever be possible to convict anyone on these grounds, period? Even if I had the fraudulent claims in my internet history I wouldn't be able to prove that they were specifically what misled me. This precedent sounds like a blanket license to lie to investors through any channels other than official communications.

Re:Theranos investors cannot pursue class action: U.S. judge by amarkov on Friday June 01, 2018 @02:48PM (#17208706)
The question at this stage of the lawsuit isn't whether the investors actually did rely on the fraudulent claims, but whether each of the investors should have to show they did. The judge isn't saying that "well maybe it was a friend" contradicts their case.
Re:Theranos investors cannot pursue class action: U.S. judge by andrewla on Friday June 01, 2018 @02:59PM (#17208806)
Exactly -- this does not prohibit each defrauded investor from pursuing their own case, but their reliance on the fraudulent claims has to be individually established rather than automatically assumed.
Re:Theranos investors cannot pursue class action: U.S. judge by dv_dt on Friday June 01, 2018 @04:48PM (#17210105)
Wouldn't all these investors be considered accredited investors and thus be expected to make their own assessments and take their own risks?
Re:Theranos investors cannot pursue class action: U.S. judge by MR4D on Friday June 01, 2018 @07:16PM (#17211348)
Regardless of investor accreditation (AI, QC, or even QP), you still can't lie to investors.

Other than minimum levels of wealth, it just establishes different reporting and structures for the investments (usually things like K-1s, non-traded vehicles, and little to no liquidity).

Madoff is a great example of this - he took advantage of his investors by lying to them about results. He went to prison for securities fraud (I'm summarizing here), and the investors pursued various lawsuits to get their money back.

In the Madoff case, JPMorgan was not only fined over a billion dollars [1], but also sued (and settled) for over 2 billion with defrauded shareholders [2]. This was basically for their knowing about the fraud and not informing shareholders (again, a legalistic simplification).

[1] https://dealbook.nytimes.com/2014/01/07/jpmorgan-settles-wit...

[2] https://www.cnbc.com/2014/01/06/jpmorgan-to-pay-26-billion-t...

Re:Theranos investors cannot pursue class action: U.S. judge by s73v3r_ on Friday June 01, 2018 @05:31PM (#17210561)
Is "the company flat out lied to everyone" usually considered one of the risks you have to take?
Re:Theranos investors cannot pursue class action: U.S. judge by jacquesm on Friday June 01, 2018 @05:40PM (#17210648)
No, but that is why you do due diligence.
Re:Theranos investors cannot pursue class action: U.S. judge by crb002 on Friday June 01, 2018 @07:02PM (#17211252)
This will get appealed. Putting false material info in the public sphere in itself lends to punitive damages as a class even if compensatory damages are more nuanced. I dont recall anything like this in the Madoff ponzi.
Re:Theranos investors cannot pursue class action: U.S. judge by crb002 on Friday June 01, 2018 @07:03PM (#17211256)
Also, how deep did the Theranos lies go? This could be RICO which is it's own animal.
Re:Theranos investors cannot pursue class action: U.S. judge by jimbokun on Friday June 01, 2018 @02:40PM (#17208621)
That is the same stupid quote that jumped out at me.

The friend may have suggested investing it because of the false technology claim.

The vague insight percolating through the grapevine may have been initially triggered by the false technology claim.

So even if the individual investor did not know about the specific false technology claim, they were still harmed by the lie.

This sentence is so aggressively stupid, it makes me wonder about this judge's impartiality.

Re:Theranos investors cannot pursue class action: U.S. judge by dnautics on Friday June 01, 2018 @04:09PM (#17209641)
If the investor was harmed by the lie as you describe, i would think they would still have grounds to sue, just not as part of a class action?
Re:Theranos investors cannot pursue class action: U.S. judge by duxup on Friday June 01, 2018 @02:46PM (#17208686)
There has to be more than that... because I don't know how any class action could climb over that bar.
Re:Theranos investors cannot pursue class action: U.S. judge by nkw on Friday June 01, 2018 @05:15PM (#17210395)
If anyone wants it, I put a copy of the actual order here: https://www.woodlaw.com/casedocs/gov.uscourts.cand.305531.24...

Even though it is marked as an opinion (and should be free) I don't see an easy way to access N.D.Cal. opinions from their webpage without a pacer login unless it is whatever they deem a "Case of Interest".

I also downloaded it with the RECAP extension[1] so it should be available on CourtListener[2] soon.

[1] https://free.law/recap/

[2] https://www.courtlistener.com/

Re:Theranos investors cannot pursue class action: U.S. judge by toomuchtodo on Friday June 01, 2018 @06:02PM (#17210837)
Thank you!
Re:Theranos investors cannot pursue class action: U.S. judge by throwaway13456 on Friday June 01, 2018 @03:53PM (#17209448)
I don't understand American law. Why isn't Elizabeth Holmes behind bars yet? She's been accused of massive fraud by SEC and yet, she's still serving her role in Theranos?
Re:Theranos investors cannot pursue class action: U.S. judge by gautamdivgi on Friday June 01, 2018 @04:44PM (#17210055)
Because you are innocent until proven guilty in a court of law. The SEC is not a court of law.
Re:Theranos investors cannot pursue class action: U.S. judge by astura on Saturday June 02, 2018 @09:12AM (#17214441)
The SEC doesn't have the power to jail people or bring about criminal charges, they only enforce securities law, and have the right to levy punishment related to violations in securities law.

Criminal charges are brought about by the Dept of Justice. The burden of proof for criminal cases is much higher so it takes more time to do the investigation and prepare the case. You also only get one shot at criminal charges - if you bring about a case that's too flimsy and the defendant is found not guilty in court they can't be tried again for the same crime no matter how much rock solid evidence is found later. As far as I am aware, the criminal investigation is still ongoing.

The SEC can report their findings to the DoJ to assist with criminal cases.

Re:Theranos investors cannot pursue class action: U.S. judge by iosDrone on Friday June 01, 2018 @03:59PM (#17209522)
The criminal investigation is still underway. I will be shocked if she does not end up in prison.
Re:Theranos investors cannot pursue class action: U.S. judge by lovich on Friday June 01, 2018 @05:25PM (#17210504)
I'll be shocked if she does. When was the last time a CEO went to jail for something they did as part of their business? There is one set of rules for the rich and business owners and one set for everyone else
Re:Theranos investors cannot pursue class action: U.S. judge by mpd on Friday June 01, 2018 @05:28PM (#17210536)
Martin Shkreli
Re:Theranos investors cannot pursue class action: U.S. judge by tehlike on Friday June 01, 2018 @06:49PM (#17211145)
He went too far on the direction that disturbed everyone though :)
Re:Theranos investors cannot pursue class action: U.S. judge by AmericanChopper on Friday June 01, 2018 @10:59PM (#17212401)
He was simply unpopular. I don’t think you could argue he did anything worse than Holmes. But since she was a media darling, and the model female CEO, it’s kinda hard to see her being brought to justice. I’m not defending Shkreli, but it’s not very comforting to see the justice system as a popularity contest.
Re:Theranos investors cannot pursue class action: U.S. judge by saryant on Friday June 01, 2018 @05:31PM (#17210565)
Enron?

Her father did work there after all...

Re:Theranos investors cannot pursue class action: U.S. judge by faramarz on Friday June 01, 2018 @03:58PM (#17209512)
I beleive it's not in the SEC's mandate/scope to pursue civil cases. They simply enforce Securities laws.
Re:Theranos investors cannot pursue class action: U.S. judge by hackcasual on Friday June 01, 2018 @04:00PM (#17209535)
https://www.popehat.com/2013/03/18/is-anyone-down-update-the...

tl;dr Especially at the Federal level, cases can take a very long time, but they do happen.

Re:Theranos investors cannot pursue class action: U.S. judge by existencebox on Friday June 01, 2018 @04:33PM (#17209926)
Is this a great example? I tried to google around to see what the postmortem was on the founders discussed in that article, and it seems like _not only_ was the punishment a slap on the wrist, and no larger sentencing arose (at least per my brief search, feel free to correct me, I'd regain some faith in humanity if I were wrong).

Not only that, but the more vocal of the two founders is now running for a senate seat.

If anything you seem to be supporting the unfortunate conclusion that there _is_ no real recompense. I tend to agree with the OP, even as an american, the structure of the law seems unequivocally built to support those with the power to navigate it. Bernie Madoff was the exception, not the rule, and by his own words, even this may not be the level of punishment one might wish (re: imprisonment) "They call me either Uncle Bernie or Mr. Madoff. I can't walk anywhere without someone shouting their greetings and encouragement, to keep my spirit up. It's really quite sweet, how concerned everyone is about my well being, including the staff […] It's much safer here than walking the streets of New York."[0]

[0]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bernard_Madoff#cite_note-134

Re:Theranos investors cannot pursue class action: U.S. judge by gnicholas on Friday June 01, 2018 @05:02PM (#17210264)
> Michael Mugmon, a lawyer for Theranos, said the company was pleased with the ruling “as it brings the company a step closer to resolving its outstanding legal issues.”

Either that, or one step closer to a clusterf--- of individual lawsuits. The fact that the class was not approved doesn't mean there are fewer lawsuits left — it probably means there will be more lawsuits, not fewer.

Re:Theranos investors cannot pursue class action: U.S. judge by harry8 on Friday June 01, 2018 @08:55PM (#17211888)
How can a class action by shareholders against the company they hold shares in /ever/ be a sensible thing for anyone other than lawyers?

You own a proportion of the assets you are suing for. $100 worth of company assets you own becomes say $20, with $80 being returned to you as your class action win. But of course the lawyer fees come out so you get $30 of your $80 so $100 of assets just became $50. Your win is a huge loss.

Is this class action by investors against the company just the lawyers capturing the system to their profit? Can there ever be anything like justice at all with this?

Re:Theranos investors cannot pursue class action: U.S. judge by repsilat on Friday June 01, 2018 @09:50PM (#17212161)
You should be able to sue if you sold after the story broke. In that case you were wronged, but you are not shooting yourself in the foot by suing.

Also: if the net worth of the company is less than its book value (possible), suing could increase your net worth.

Re:Theranos investors cannot pursue class action: U.S. judge by harry8 on Saturday June 02, 2018 @03:02AM (#17213181)
So the person buying from you factors in the discount for losing the law suit and you are not ahead. The lawyers are, investors are worse off.

I can't imagine many companies with a market cap less than disposal value of their assets. That's free money for any corporate raider it other acquirer. You do find money putting in the street but rarely and it doesn't stay there long.

These class actions are just an abject disaster for everyone. Except the lawyers, who make bank while enhancing their reputations in all the wrong ways. And it costs tax dollars to run the courts for them to vampire like so.

Insane. The money is gone, giving the remnants to lawyers won't bring any back. The correct remedy is jail for those who committed fraud acting as a deterrent j in the future.

Re:Theranos investors cannot pursue class action: U.S. judge by JumpCrisscross on Friday June 01, 2018 @02:26PM (#17208466)
Does anyone have a link to the actual decision?
Re:Theranos investors cannot pursue class action: U.S. judge by ciscoriordan on Friday June 01, 2018 @02:30PM (#17208493)
Re:Theranos investors cannot pursue class action: U.S. judge by JumpCrisscross on Friday June 01, 2018 @04:30PM (#17209884)
This appears to be from April 2017. Do we know how it was resolved?
Re:Theranos investors cannot pursue class action: U.S. judge by gweinberg on Friday June 01, 2018 @04:19PM (#17209758)
So small investors get screwed, because they'll never get enough in an individual action to pay the litigation costs.
Re:Theranos investors cannot pursue class action: U.S. judge by gnicholas on Friday June 01, 2018 @05:07PM (#17210311)
I'd be curious to know how small the "small investors" are.

Also, smaller investors can ride the coattails of larger lawsuits, if those are successful. Findings that Theranos fails to refute in those trials can be used against Theranos by subsequent parties, under the res judicata doctrine (specifically, collateral estoppel).

Re:Theranos investors cannot pursue class action: U.S. judge by tracker1 on Friday June 01, 2018 @05:08PM (#17210325)
How is the FTC/SEC not involved?
Re:Theranos investors cannot pursue class action: U.S. judge by Mononokay on Friday June 01, 2018 @02:25PM (#17208454)
Cheaters never lose, and losers never cheat.
Re:Theranos investors cannot pursue class action: U.S. judge by colechristensen on Friday June 01, 2018 @05:01PM (#17210253)
There is evolutionary pressure towards a non-zero but limited proportion of cheaters in any system.

The 'reward' for cheating goes up as the proportion of cheaters goes down, and goes down as the proportion of cheaters goes up. There is an optimum somewhere in the middle.

It takes energy to detect cheaters and that amount of energy dictates how many there are.

Re:Theranos investors cannot pursue class action: U.S. judge by Thriptic on Friday June 01, 2018 @05:00PM (#17210242)
Holmes will never be able to start a company ever again and has basically been black listed out of the medical industry. The whole industry hates her.
Re:Theranos investors cannot pursue class action: U.S. judge by whatshisface on Friday June 01, 2018 @02:26PM (#17208461)
Unless nature has a say.
Re:Theranos investors cannot pursue class action: U.S. judge by lisper on Friday June 01, 2018 @04:54PM (#17210175)
The U.S. really has turned into a banana republic. This, together with Monday's SCOTUS decision barring employee class actions (EPIC SYSTEMS CORP. v. LEWIS), means that if you aren't playing for sufficiently high stakes to make it worthwhile to hire your own legal team, you're pretty much fair game for those who can.