News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Kitty Marion: an actress who became a suffragette who pla... by rayiner on Sunday May 27, 2018 @01:17PM (#17167913)
Sanitizing history like this has a very negative consequence. We are taught to believe that there is such a thing as bloodless revolution. And that makes it easy to dismiss movements like blacklivesmatter any time someone commits violence in the name of the movement. After all, if the suffragettes got justice without firing a shot, why can’t everyone else?
Re:Kitty Marion: an actress who became a suffragette who pla... by roywiggins on Sunday May 27, 2018 @01:56PM (#17168144)
The anti-apartheid movements in South Africa is another one whose violence has been nearly elided from the history people know. It was not an entirely nonviolent struggle, even if the eventual regime change happened peacefully. History is awfully messy, and so is the present.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Church_Street_bombing

Re:Kitty Marion: an actress who became a suffragette who pla... by aaron-lebo on Sunday May 27, 2018 @02:06PM (#17168195)
Interesting that one of the figures we see most positively went from believing in violence to believing in nonviolence.

De Klerk similarly had a great moderating influence. The alternative to the nonviolence of him and Mandela would have been a racial civil war in which tens of thousands died.

Re:Kitty Marion: an actress who became a suffragette who pla... by RodericDay on Sunday May 27, 2018 @04:23PM (#17168924)
Mandela never renounced violence. In 1985, Mandela was offered a conditional release if he were to renounce violence; he refused.

Rick Stengel on Mandela, via FAIR:

> One of most interesting things he ever said to me was this idea of nonviolence. Remember, we compare him to Gandhi, we compare him to Martin Luther King. He said: “I was not like them. For them, nonviolence was a principle. For me, it was a tactic. And when the tactic wasn’t working, I reversed it and started” –that’s a very important difference.

Re:Kitty Marion: an actress who became a suffragette who pla... by vidarh on Monday May 28, 2018 @05:16AM (#17171451)
Of note is also that one of the reasons Mandela gave for supporting Castro until the end was Cuba's extensive military support in Angola, that Mandela credited as a substantial source of hope for the ANC and a demoralising event for the South African military, and as a major contributing cause in the independence of Namibia.

After his release in '90, he visited Castro and heaped praise on him for that among other things. There's no indication that he regretted that support for Cuba's direct military involvement in open warfare later, as far as I know.

Here's an excerpt (with links to the full speech) of Mandela's speech on the subject at a commemoration of the start of the Cuban revolution in 1991:

https://www.democracynow.org/2013/12/11/nelson_mandela_on_ho...

(I have plenty of issues with Castro, but it's worth understanding why he was seen as we seen by African leaders, and how we was seen by people like Mandela also elucidates those leaders own views)

Re:Kitty Marion: an actress who became a suffragette who pla... by sangnoir on Monday May 28, 2018 @09:56AM (#17172398)
Mandela was asked why he didn't share the West's view on Castro and Gadaffi in a Q&A, fortunately that was captured on video[1] so we can make our own judgements.

1. https://youtu.be/RwwxcVTjt3Q

Re:Kitty Marion: an actress who became a suffragette who pla... by sangnoir on Monday May 28, 2018 @09:59AM (#17172414)
> Mandela never renounced violence. In 1985, Mandela was offered a conditional release if he were to renounce violence; he refused.

Renouncing violence against a nuclear-bomb-equiped adversary is beyond foolish, strategically speaking. At the micro end, the same regime was not beyond shooting dead (unarmed) protesting high-schoolers less than a decade before the offer. Renouncing violence wasn't a viable option, but perhaps they hoped 2 decades imprisonment with labor had softened Mandela.

Given South Africa's geography, why do you think the apartheid government had (prior to the offer) developed its nuclear program? Hint: there was no parallel program for long-distance nuclear-payload delivery.

Re:Kitty Marion: an actress who became a suffragette who pla... by TangoTrotFox on Monday May 28, 2018 @12:52AM (#17170656)
The most important distinction between movements like pro suffrage, anti slavery, etc and most modern movements was a well defined win condition. The end of the pro suffrage movement was one law. The end of anti-slavery was more complex but still fundamentally came down a change of law. The end of BLM is...?

In a way modern movements tend to be like modern wars such as 'The War on Drugs' or 'The War on Terror.' These are neverending wars that can never be won, nor lost. And when violence begins to become associated with these movements, then it's infinitely more damning since that means there will also be no end to it and you'll invariably breed a counter-movement, which can lead to a long term divide in society which, again, has no end.

Re:Kitty Marion: an actress who became a suffragette who pla... by dmurray on Sunday May 27, 2018 @06:12PM (#17169378)
It's an important tactic for governments: glorify and inflate the achievements of peaceful activists, write the violent activists out of history, or - if that's impossible - whitewash their violent past. Then bend just enough to the demands of modern peaceful activists to make the public think they are not ineffective.

For achieving major political change, the two most effective means really are violence and the threat of violence.

Re:Kitty Marion: an actress who became a suffragette who pla... by whack on Sunday May 27, 2018 @01:59PM (#17168163)
You bring up a very thought provoking question. Looking at the many social movements in the past century, we have often lionized those who pursued non-violent methods, while downplaying those who pursued armed resistance.

But would the former have succeeded without the latter's help? Would MLK have succeeded without Malcolm X? Would Gandhi have succeeded without Subhas Chandra Bose? Would Nelson Mandela have succeeded without his willingness to use violence?

When looking at movements such as the American revolutionary war, the American civil war, and the Allies' resistance against Nazi occupation, the use of violence to achieve political goals, is both accepted and seen as necessary for the greater good. I've yet to meet anyone who deplored armed resistance in the above conflicts.

https://www.independent.co.uk/world/the-forgotten-violence-t...

http://www.latimes.com/world/worldnow/la-fg-wn-nelson-mandel...

Re:Kitty Marion: an actress who became a suffragette who pla... by artificial on Sunday May 27, 2018 @02:14PM (#17168225)
It is a thought provoking question. Take Gandhi, he succeeded because of British sensibilities, the same strategy wouldn’t have been as effective against the Nazis for example. A great deal of it depends on the adversary.
Re:Kitty Marion: an actress who became a suffragette who pla... by wz1000 on Sunday May 27, 2018 @03:15PM (#17168583)
Gandhi didn't "succeed" in a vacuum, and especially not due to "British sensibilities". The British Empire as a whole was an unwieldy and increasing unprofitable venture(not in small part to the threat of revolt and Civil Disobedience from occupied regions) for a country that had been devastated through the damages and effort of fighting the largest war in human history.

If colonised countries had not been actively(and violently) trying to get rid of their colonisers, the British Empire could have persisted indefinitely.

Violence is much more effective than non-violence in trying to get rid of any oppressor. Consider this: any State can deal with 5-10% of its population not working/paying taxes and "non-violently" resisting(these days even property crime can get you counted as a violent protestor). States would be much more hard pressed to deal with even 1% of their population in active, armed revolt against them.

Re:Kitty Marion: an actress who became a suffragette who pla... by loggedinmyphone on Sunday May 27, 2018 @03:32PM (#17168684)
All of these instances of violence are regrettable. The aims of the American War of Independence and the Civil War almost certainly could have been achieved without firing a shot. The Nazi regime could have been prevented if the victors of the first World War hadn't imposed harsh punitive measures to destroy the German economy.
Re:Kitty Marion: an actress who became a suffragette who pla... by lsc on Sunday May 27, 2018 @05:52PM (#17169296)
>The aims of the American War of Independence and the Civil War almost certainly could have been achieved without firing a shot.

Maybe? I mean, the war of independence is a little different... clearly, we were not a real threat to the British; we just needed to be seen to be resisting, without getting crushed, until the war with France heated up enough that the British couldn't spare the troops to keep us down. from that perspective? it was almost a minimal violence kind of war. The "Fabian strategy" - which only worked against an army as good at logistics as the British because they were also fighting a serious war with France at the time. Really, we needed to remain a threat, but except for proving that we could inflict such damage, one could argue that the actual violence wasn't super necessary.

The ACW, on the other hand, I... kinda don't think there was a peaceful resolution there. I mean, it wasn't like the southerners were arguing for a British style 'emancipation with compensation to the former owners' and the war was just haggling over the price. The Confederacy pretty much immediately rebelled after it was clear that we'd have an abolitionist-leaning president... long before any actual abolitionistic action was taken, long before it was clear that such action would be taken.

I kinda don't see how the ACW could have been avoided or made less violent. By advanced nation standards of the time, we were pretty far behind on the abolition schedule already, and while the slaughter of the ACW was shocking, so was slavery.

Re:Kitty Marion: an actress who became a suffragette who pla... by walshemj on Monday May 28, 2018 @06:34AM (#17171683)
The AWI could have been avoided the UK kept shooting its self in the foot if you avoid the AWI its interesting what happens does the USA take the same route Canada did?

If say the American colonies where given all the rights UK citizens under the same legal system had then Somerset v Stewart becomes interesting as that case outlawed chattel slavery in the UK in 1772.

Re:Kitty Marion: an actress who became a suffragette who pla... by loggedinmyphone on Sunday May 27, 2018 @07:31PM (#17169760)
I don't think the South loved owning slaves as much as they found it an expedient economic model, which was less true in the North. So I believe they could have been moved by economic pressure. We can't know for sure, but we can say there's more than one way to skin a cat and if you can do it without getting blood on the walls so much the better.
Re:Kitty Marion: an actress who became a suffragette who pla... by lsc on Monday May 28, 2018 @12:53AM (#17170659)
>I don't think the South loved owning slaves as much as they found it an expedient economic model

The economic model is strong in some ways; the value of all the slaves in the south, as I understand it, was greater than the value of all the farmland in the south.

There are weaknesses in the economic model, too, though. Nobody is saying that the southern enlisted man was hesitant to fight, and few of the enlisted (as opposed to officers) owned slaves.

For that matter, your average enlisted southerner would probably have been significantly better off, economically speaking, without slavery, just because if you are trying to sell your own labor, it's significantly more difficult to do so when you are competing with literal slaves.

So while you can use the economic model to explain the behavior of the southern elite, the economic model does not explain why the average southerner fought.

Re:Kitty Marion: an actress who became a suffragette who pla... by maxerickson on Sunday May 27, 2018 @03:57PM (#17168814)
A different resolution to slavery in the US almost certainly would have involved the ongoing deaths of slaves. So just less violence.

(even one that somehow rapidly ended slavery without slave owners waging war)

Re:Kitty Marion: an actress who became a suffragette who pla... by loggedinmyphone on Sunday May 27, 2018 @04:10PM (#17168886)
Yes, less violence is the goal.
Re:Kitty Marion: an actress who became a suffragette who pla... by anigbrowl on Sunday May 27, 2018 @05:21PM (#17169164)
It might be your goal, but it's not everyone else's. You don't get to tell people they can't have freedom because it might involve more violence than leaving them in captivity.
Re:Kitty Marion: an actress who became a suffragette who pla... by loggedinmyphone on Sunday May 27, 2018 @05:38PM (#17169238)
Neither the notions of nonviolence nor autonomy are absolutes. We always have to struggle to make good choices.
Re:Kitty Marion: an actress who became a suffragette who pla... by lsc on Sunday May 27, 2018 @05:36PM (#17169231)
>The Nazi regime could have been prevented if the victors of the first World War hadn't imposed harsh punitive measures to destroy the German economy.

I think you could make just as strong an argument that the Nazi regime would not have lasted long if those harsh punitive measures were actually enforced. I mean, if you have a strongman leader, the best thing for him is an enemy who snarls real good, but who backs down immediately upon confrontation.

I think the truth of the matter is that after world war one, the allies didn't have the political will to properly enforce the sanctions or to expend the money and effort for a marshal plan type response. I think that's why we got what we did, harsh punitive measures that were ignored whenever Germany pushed on them. - but I think that's also the best case for an expanding fascistic government... It sure looked, to the non-jewish german people, that every time Hitler "stood up for them" hitler got what they wanted. It was like the allies set up a paper tiger for Hitler to look strong against.

I'm not saying that's what should have been done, just that the "the Nazis would have not risen if there weren't punitive measures" and "The Nazis would not have held on to power if those punitive measures were actually enforced" are counterfactuals; theories about what could have been. I argue that there is just as much evidence for my theory as yours.

Re:Kitty Marion: an actress who became a suffragette who pla... by loggedinmyphone on Sunday May 27, 2018 @05:51PM (#17169293)
I think there were multiple ways Nazism could have been prevented or dealt with. It's just regrettable that it ended in so much violence. Probably what happened was neither the best nor the worst conceivable outcome.
Re:Kitty Marion: an actress who became a suffragette who pla... by SimbaOnSteroids on Sunday May 27, 2018 @04:13PM (#17168892)
The second world war resulting from the first world war's punitive damages is largely a myth propagated by the Nazi's on their rise to power. In actuallity the second world war was a result of piss-poor monetary and fiscal policy combined with the rise of fascism across Europe. AskHistorians thread that talks about this and cites their sources https://www.reddit.com/r/AskHistorians/comments/89u5t9/in_a_...
Re:Kitty Marion: an actress who became a suffragette who pla... by loggedinmyphone on Sunday May 27, 2018 @03:27PM (#17168655)
This assumes it was the bomb-planting that led to concessions for the suffragists. Violence usually prompts a violent counter-response, or at least for the "adversary" to become more entrenched. Consensus is the answer, which is why the politics of accusation and anger creates a negative cycle perpetuating violence.
Re:Kitty Marion: an actress who became a suffragette who pla... by maxerickson on Sunday May 27, 2018 @03:53PM (#17168802)
This assumes it was the bomb-planting that led to concessions for the suffragists.

No, it doesn't.

It (correctly) notes that the bomb-planting didn't doom the movement. What it doesn't do is give credit to the bombings for advancing the movement (rayiner's short comment is mute on that aspect).

Re:Kitty Marion: an actress who became a suffragette who pla... by loggedinmyphone on Sunday May 27, 2018 @04:05PM (#17168857)
"if the suffragettes got justice without firing a shot, why can’t everyone else?"

We should indeed seek to get justice without firing a shot. I take exception to the implication that we should condone violence because there's supposedly no such thing as a bloodless revolution.

Re:Kitty Marion: an actress who became a suffragette who pla... by maxerickson on Sunday May 27, 2018 @04:10PM (#17168884)
I'm not sure what your point is with the quote. That part of the comment is about how it can be problematic to misremember history.

And I don't think it is condoning violence to be unsurprised if some people involved in some movement resort to violence.

Re:Kitty Marion: an actress who became a suffragette who pla... by loggedinmyphone on Sunday May 27, 2018 @04:21PM (#17168918)
My point is if you want to defend blacklivesmatter, do so on the basis that they reject violence, not because some historical movement was also associated with violence.
Re:Kitty Marion: an actress who became a suffragette who pla... by maxerickson on Sunday May 27, 2018 @04:29PM (#17168953)
But rayiner isn't making a defense of blacklivesmatter there, he is making a comparison to a present day movement that is largely nonviolent but has had some violence associated with it.

The argument isn't that other movements were violent so violence is fine, it is that falsely painting historical movements as pure creates the problem where the actions of an extreme few can be used to dismiss the work of the many.

Re:Kitty Marion: an actress who became a suffragette who pla... by Fnoord on Sunday May 27, 2018 @05:25PM (#17169182)
Also, those "extreme few" could be undercover for a different party with a different agenda (e.g. secret police but not exclusive to that). Wouldn't be the first time.
Re:Kitty Marion: an actress who became a suffragette who pla... by loggedinmyphone on Sunday May 27, 2018 @06:17PM (#17169397)
If anyone wants to dismiss a movement because a few of its adherents are violent, that's obviously unjustified, because no one can control who agrees with them. Just like we can't condemn the entire anti-abortion movement because a few people bomb clinics. I think the more interesting and larger point is to reject violent tactics.
Re:Kitty Marion: an actress who became a suffragette who pla... by PhasmaFelis on Sunday May 27, 2018 @09:43PM (#17170161)
> If anyone wants to dismiss a movement because a few of its adherents are violent, that's obviously unjustified, because no one can control who agrees with them.

Exactly. That was rayiner's point from the beginning, so I'm not sure what you were disagreeing with there.

Re:Kitty Marion: an actress who became a suffragette who pla... by loggedinmyphone on Sunday May 27, 2018 @10:05PM (#17170229)
I (perhaps mis-)read the subtext as being that violence is a historical, hence tolerable and perhaps even inextricable, part of reform movements. The literal point seemed obvious, so it didn't occur to me as a possible topic of discussion. In retrospect it's not obvious, as leaders of movements are regularly blamed for the shortcomings of a few followers.
Re:Kitty Marion: an actress who became a suffragette who pla... by musage on Sunday May 27, 2018 @06:49PM (#17169541)
> If anyone wants to dismiss a movement because a few of its adherents are violent, that's obviously unjustified

Nevertheless, that's what the comment referred to. For you it's an obvious non-issue, but not objectively so, and they were referring to that issue.

If you find something else more interesting, make that point without twisting what someone else said. Otherwise that whole stuff about rejecting violence sounds kind of hollow.

Re:Kitty Marion: an actress who became a suffragette who pla... by empath75 on Sunday May 27, 2018 @03:35PM (#17168702)
Provoking a violent response by the system isn’t necessarily something to be avoided. Even people engage in non-violence often provoke violent responses.

Violent action makes people engaged in non-violent action seem reasonable when before they may have seemed extremist. MLK became someone the middle could deal with because they saw that the alternative would have been a violent insurrection. Same with ghandi.

Re:Kitty Marion: an actress who became a suffragette who pla... by loggedinmyphone on Sunday May 27, 2018 @04:07PM (#17168867)
I see, so this is the "trolling" theory of social justice. Are you saying Malcolm X and BLM act to bait the system into discrediting itself through violence? One would think if the system were violent enough, it could be be baited into overt violence through nonviolent means alone.
Re:Kitty Marion: an actress who became a suffragette who pla... by anigbrowl on Sunday May 27, 2018 @05:19PM (#17169155)
It's actually John Boyd's theory of moral conflict as the most determinative level of warfare. Nonviolent tactitions very often organize to bait an oppressive system into violent over-reaction.
Re:Kitty Marion: an actress who became a suffragette who pla... by loggedinmyphone on Sunday May 27, 2018 @05:35PM (#17169224)
I'm aware of this, and it goes back even further to the New Testament. I'm questioning the part about employing violent tactics Alameda Malcolm X.
Re:Kitty Marion: an actress who became a suffragette who pla... by anigbrowl on Sunday May 27, 2018 @05:47PM (#17169270)
I'm not, because it is effective. Passive resistance is only effective to the degree that more powerful actors are conscientious.
Re:Kitty Marion: an actress who became a suffragette who pla... by loggedinmyphone on Sunday May 27, 2018 @05:55PM (#17169306)
Violence can certainly bring about short term gains for the perpetrators. I'm personally interested in changing the cycle of violence itself, more than replacing one violent actor by another.
Re:Kitty Marion: an actress who became a suffragette who pla... by DoreenMichele on Sunday May 27, 2018 @08:51PM (#17170019)
Is there a specific area of interest here? Are you working on anything in particular?
Re:Kitty Marion: an actress who became a suffragette who pla... by loggedinmyphone on Sunday May 27, 2018 @09:55PM (#17170191)
I do have specifically marginalized groups of people who I try to help. But my most important project is being a decent human to those around me every day. It's not as easy as it sounds. It's second nature for all of us to pass on our past trauma and frustrations. In some ways it's easier to make a heroic and noble effort for some great cause than to put in the sustained effort every day to help the people around us. That's what I'm trying to do, certainly failing much of the time but trying to get back on my horse each time.
Re:Kitty Marion: an actress who became a suffragette who pla... by maxerickson on Sunday May 27, 2018 @04:25PM (#17168931)
MLK chose places to protest where he knew the sheriff was likely to react with violence!
Re:Kitty Marion: an actress who became a suffragette who pla... by loggedinmyphone on Sunday May 27, 2018 @04:33PM (#17168970)
Exactly. So employing violent tactics should not be necessary.
Re:Kitty Marion: an actress who became a suffragette who pla... by empath75 on Sunday May 27, 2018 @07:20PM (#17169697)
It actually depends on whether the populace at large or the government in power are willing to maintain power through force.

If you’re dealing with a democracy and a populace like the US or the UK, there happens to be a limit of how much brutality they’re willing to stomach in defense of the system. In a lot of cases it’s much more than we’d like to admit.

If you’re dealing with an authoritarian government or a theocracy, that limit is much higher or non-existent.

Re:Kitty Marion: an actress who became a suffragette who pla... by loggedinmyphone on Sunday May 27, 2018 @08:47PM (#17170009)
What I am betting on is precisely that reluctance of the populace to stomach brutality. Whatever political victories are achieved through escalating violence are ultimately empty until a fundamental rejection of brutality is achieved.
Re:Kitty Marion: an actress who became a suffragette who pla... by x0x0 on Sunday May 27, 2018 @05:28PM (#17169194)
So basically your takeaway from the fact that most of these successful social movements had a violent component to them is that social movements shouldn't be violent?
Re:Kitty Marion: an actress who became a suffragette who pla... by loggedinmyphone on Sunday May 27, 2018 @05:37PM (#17169232)
Most successful enterprises of any nature had elements of violence - "every fortune is built on a crime". I'm not questioning their success, just asking if we can do better.
Re:Kitty Marion: an actress who became a suffragette who pla... by ekianjo on Monday May 28, 2018 @01:32AM (#17170734)
The independence of India was mostly gained thru non violent protests. So yes, it can be done.
Re:Kitty Marion: an actress who became a suffragette who pla... by lostlogin on Monday May 28, 2018 @03:17AM (#17171021)
The protests may have been mostly non violent but the process was far from bloodless and included some of the most appalling examples of colonialism. Separating it from the partition of India is also not easy, and that had somewhere from hundreds of thousands of casualties to millions. Where do you stop and start counting the casualties the process caused? Taking a narrow view reduces it rather markedly.
Re:Kitty Marion: an actress who became a suffragette who pla... by cooper12 on Sunday May 27, 2018 @01:50PM (#17168116)
Unfortunately, those in charge of writing history are very prone to sanitizing unappealing details. Take Helen Keller for example. We learn a lot of minor details of her history. But students never learn how she was a loud socialist. Information like that would be uncomfortable, inconvenient, or too challenging for those learning history.

> During the lifetime of great revolutionaries, the oppressing classes constantly hounded them, received their theories with the most savage malice, the most furious hatred and the most unscrupulous campaigns of lies and slander. After their death, attempts are made to convert them into harmless icons, to canonize them, so to say, and to hallow their names to a certain extent for the “consolation” of the oppressed classes and with the object of duping the latter, while at the same time robbing the revolutionary theory of its substance, blunting its revolutionary edge and vulgarizing it.

Re:Kitty Marion: an actress who became a suffragette who pla... by DoreenMichele on Sunday May 27, 2018 @06:38PM (#17169497)
Take Helen Keller for example.

We remember Helen Keller because by all rights she should have been basically an institutionalized animal and not had a career of any kind whatsoever. What exactly she did is of less significance than that she did anything at all with her life.

This scene from "The Miracle Worker," a movie about her relationship to the teacher who taught her sign language and basic manners against very long odds, never fails to bring me to tears:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lUV65sV8nu0

Re:Kitty Marion: an actress who became a suffragette who pla... by oh_sigh on Sunday May 27, 2018 @01:54PM (#17168135)
People are interested in HK because of the adversity she overcame, not because of her political viewpoints. I'm sure if she was a staunch libertarian, we would not hear much about those viewpoints either - because it isn't relevant to the interesting part of her life story.
Re:Kitty Marion: an actress who became a suffragette who pla... by cooper12 on Sunday May 27, 2018 @01:59PM (#17168158)
To Keller the politics had a lot to do with blindness:

> I was appointed on a commission to investigate the conditions of the blind. For the first time I, who had thought blindness a misfortune beyond human control, found that too much of it was traceable to wrong industrial conditions, often caused by the selfishness and greed of employers. And the social evil contributed its share. I found that poverty drove women to a life of shame that ended in blindness.

If we're only telling her story as an allegory and divorce her from her personal viewpoints, we might as well tell fables.

Re:Kitty Marion: an actress who became a suffragette who pla... by oh_sigh on Sunday May 27, 2018 @06:26PM (#17169439)
She was already nationally famous before she became a political activist. And the reason she was famous was because of the adversity she overcame as a child, not because she had pretty run of the mill viewpoints on socialism.
Re:Kitty Marion: an actress who became a suffragette who pla... by simplicio on Sunday May 27, 2018 @02:32PM (#17168333)
I dunno, we say she "overcame adversity", but that doesn't really make sense unless you at least reference that she became a famous political activist. Otherwise, in what sense did she "overcome" her adversity?

Deafblindness isn't particularly unknown outside her case, and she wasn't the first person to be successfully taught to communicate despite it. But her ability to become a nationally prominent political activist despite her handicap made her unique.

Re:Kitty Marion: an actress who became a suffragette who pla... by oh_sigh on Sunday May 27, 2018 @06:22PM (#17169414)
> Otherwise, in what sense did she "overcome" her adversity?

Well, she learned how to communicate and even speak. That seems pretty big. Clearly schoolchildren all over America, when they learn about this, are amazed by HK and her teachers. No one hears that story and says "Well, so what?" if they don't hear the part about how she became a socialist later in life.

> But her ability to become a nationally prominent political activist despite her handicap made her unique.

She was already nationally prominent before she became a political activist. It's not like she became a social activist, and then people said "Hey, we should look into her past and see what her upbringing was like", and then the Hellen Keller story emerged.

Re:Kitty Marion: an actress who became a suffragette who pla... by forkLding on Sunday May 27, 2018 @01:58PM (#17168155)
Its not that whitewashed, Helen Keller as a party member of Socialist party of America is on the first page of her Wikipedia, anybody having to look her up would have figured out and took way less effort than the female researcher with Kitty Marion.

And whats so controversial about being a socialist. The Europeans would be laughing at how "controversial" it is, seeing as the Socialist Party is the largest party in France and used to produce several French presidents.

Re:Kitty Marion: an actress who became a suffragette who pla... by ryanmarsh on Sunday May 27, 2018 @02:23PM (#17168275)
I think “white washed” means left out of the textbooks used to teach us in the government schools.
Re:Kitty Marion: an actress who became a suffragette who pla... by aaron-lebo on Sunday May 27, 2018 @01:54PM (#17168134)
To be fair, that does sound like something a mass murderer would say. Maybe a justification for their actions.
Re:Kitty Marion: an actress who became a suffragette who pla... by cooper12 on Sunday May 27, 2018 @01:56PM (#17168145)
The fact that you refer to him as a mass murdered shows he wasn't exactly canonized. I also don't see how you read the quote as a justification unless all you focused on was the name.
Re:Kitty Marion: an actress who became a suffragette who pla... by aaron-lebo on Sunday May 27, 2018 @02:01PM (#17168172)
He had very strong views about revolution. He believed it was necessary and desirable at all costs (hence his actions).

He's lauding the role of the violent revolutionary without further reflection (because he'd already made his choice long ago) whether actions that generated waves of murder and generations of tyrants as a result were actually desirable.

I'd argue that results of his violence are a great argument against much of what he sad because he obviously didn't know how to control it or didn't care. As an example, he didn't want Stalin to come to power, but he was powerless to stop the bloodshed he'd put into motion and people suffered horrendously because of it. Sounds like a short-sighted and evil person.

Re:Kitty Marion: an actress who became a suffragette who pla... by anigbrowl on Sunday May 27, 2018 @05:34PM (#17169220)
As an example, he didn't want Stalin to come to power, but he was powerless to stop the bloodshed he'd put into motion

A series of debilitating strokes reduced Lenin to the status of an invalid, and Trotsky naively took Stalin's good faith for granted and avoided attacking him publicly despite Lenin's request for him to denounce Stalin's political opportunism. Omitting major causal factors doesn't say much for the quality of your argument.

Re:Kitty Marion: an actress who became a suffragette who pla... by aaron-lebo on Sunday May 27, 2018 @05:41PM (#17169248)
Yes, a stroke was part of "not having control".

The foolishness of violence is assuming you can put it back in the bottle. That's part of the argument.

Re:Kitty Marion: an actress who became a suffragette who pla... by anigbrowl on Sunday May 27, 2018 @05:48PM (#17169272)
Bullshit.
Re:Kitty Marion: an actress who became a suffragette who pla... by DmenshunlAnlsis on Sunday May 27, 2018 @05:39PM (#17169243)
No Malcolm X in my history text, why's that? 'Cause he tried to educate and liberate all blacks. Why is Martin Luther King in my book each week? He told blacks, if they get smacked, turn the other cheek...

From ‘Words of Wisdom’ by Tupac Shakur, who made a very good point.

Re:Kitty Marion: an actress who became a suffragette who pla... by angersock on Sunday May 27, 2018 @01:39PM (#17168044)
So, are you arguing that violence is acceptable in cases like BLM?
Re:Kitty Marion: an actress who became a suffragette who pla... by rayiner on Sunday May 27, 2018 @01:47PM (#17168099)
My home country exists as the result of an independence war. One of the first salvos was “my side” killing tens of thousands of people of suspected questionable loyalty, followed by a counter-attack from the other side killing hundreds of thousands of people.

Was the violence “acceptable?” To me it’s not a useful question. Violence is one of the ways people interact with each other; any large scale social movement will involve some violence. Was the outcome of self determination worthwhile despite some deaths? Undoubtedly.

Re:Kitty Marion: an actress who became a suffragette who pla... by aaron-lebo on Sunday May 27, 2018 @01:52PM (#17168126)
Undoubtedly to you posting to a message board, maybe , but maybe not so undoubtedly were you one of the victims or long line of people directly affected by it. That's a utilitarian argument and it assumes that independence could not or would not have been achieved some other way.

Violence is one of the ways that people interact with others, but so is greed, envy, racism and hatred. One of the great things about being humans is we can choose to discard or tempter behaviors that are destructive.

Are you for racism and bigotry because that's a part of nature? I know you aren't. Why is violence different? If we've made international laws which we've decided as a species that certain actions are unacceptable, why is violence so sacred?

Re:Kitty Marion: an actress who became a suffragette who pla... by rayiner on Sunday May 27, 2018 @02:02PM (#17168177)
> That's a utilitarian argument and it assumes that independence could not or would not have been achieved some other way.

You cannot have movements involving millions of people fighting for justice and not have some of those people turn to violence. Demanding that such movements be completely non-violent means de facto endorsing the status quo.

> Are you for racism and bigotry because that's a part of nature? I know you aren't. Why is violence different?

I don't think a larger movement that is otherwise just is discredited just because some subset is driven by racism or bigotry, or engages in violence. E.g. I strongly support British peoples' exercise of their right of self determination through Brexit, even if a lot of people were motivated by xenophobia. Likewise Irish self determination, even though it involved a lot of violence and religious sectarianism. There is a huge difference between discouraging racism/bigotry/violence at an individual level, and discrediting the efforts of groups of people merely because some portion of them cannot overcome those human tendencies.

To use an example: Do you think that the Irish should've lived under the thumb of the British until such a time that it could've achieved independence in a way that did not involve violence or Catholic/Protestant animosity?

Re:Kitty Marion: an actress who became a suffragette who pla... by aaron-lebo on Sunday May 27, 2018 @04:59PM (#17169076)
> You cannot have movements involving millions of people fighting for justice and not have some of those people turn to violence. Demanding that such movements be completely non-violent means de facto endorsing the status quo.

Of course not, but it also doesn't mean that we suggest that violence is a positive thing or necessary for progress.

Resorting to violence in many cases minimizes your argument. You turn aggressors into victims and give them a reason to fight back. You deny those abusers the same thing you want (peace and safety), which distorts the argument. And demagogues will distort it.

This is ignoring the completely innocent victims that are often harmed in incidents like this. How can humanists support the maiming and death of innocents?

To use an example: Do you think that the Irish should've lived under the thumb of the British until such a time that it could've achieved independence in a way that did not involve violence or Catholic/Protestant animosity?

I don't know. I do know that progress, though slow, was being made without violence. The Irish were given Home Rule by the British HoC in the 1910s. Surely this kind of progress would have continued. In contrast, violence was avoided at other times (the UVF arming to reject Home Rule).

If in any of these incidents you say that violence was a given, necessary, or justified, you are very possibly making it so, and not only that, but starting conflict which may never end. Surely people are capable of progress without our most animal of instincts? Many people have believed that.

Violence is cowardly and brute. If you want to be a martyr, be a martyr as you've made that choice for yourself, but don't be a murderer.

“The ultimate weakness of violence is that it is a descending spiral; begetting the very thing it seeks to destroy. Instead of diminishing evil, it multiplies it. Through violence you may murder the liar, but you cannot murder the lie, nor establish the truth. Through violence you may murder the hater, but you do not murder hate. In fact, violence merely increases hate. So it goes. Returning violence for violence multiplies violence, adding deeper darkness to a night already devoid of stars. Darkness cannot drive out darkness: only light can do that. Hate cannot drive out hate: only love can do that.”

http://www.patheos.com/blogs/paperbacktheology/2016/01/ten-g...

Re:Kitty Marion: an actress who became a suffragette who pla... by anigbrowl on Sunday May 27, 2018 @05:27PM (#17169190)
I don't know. I do know that progress, though slow, was being made without violence. The Irish were given Home Rule by the British HoC in the 1910s. Surely this kind of progress would have continued. In contrast, violence was avoided at other times (the UVF arming to reject Home Rule).

It was not being made without violence. The British didn't give Irish Home Rule out of the goodness of their hearts - what an absurdly paternalistic argument, and one which ignores all the violence involved in upholding a particular political order.

As a parallel in this thread, people are wringing their hands about the violent potential of BLM but none of those people seem put out by the extensive use of violence by police on a daily basis, because that seems like such a part of social infrastructure that many have become blind to it..

Re:Kitty Marion: an actress who became a suffragette who pla... by icebraining on Monday May 28, 2018 @09:10AM (#17172211)
people are wringing their hands about the violent potential of BLM but none of those people seem put out by the extensive use of violence by police on a daily basis, because that seems like such a part of social infrastructure that many have become blind to it.

"The headlong stream is termed violent

But the river bed hemming it in is

Termed violent by no one."

-- Brecht

Re:Kitty Marion: an actress who became a suffragette who pla... by aaron-lebo on Sunday May 27, 2018 @05:35PM (#17169222)
There was violence at times, but Home Rule was granted before the revolution.

I'm against violence across the board, for the record. The problem with violence against the police is it doesn't improve your position, it only confirms negative biases people have of the movement. It's counter-productive.

Re:Kitty Marion: an actress who became a suffragette who pla... by anigbrowl on Sunday May 27, 2018 @05:42PM (#17169253)
Yes, and that ongoing violence was a major factor. You can be against violence across the board, but so what? That's an easy posture to take if your interests aren't directly threatened. On the other hand, telling people they can't use violence to defend themselves against an asymmetrically powerful oppressor implicitly cedes victory to whatever state actor is prepared to employ it. This tends to work out badly for the subjugated population.

Violence is undesirable but you're arguing against people engaging in any kind of self-defense.

Re:Kitty Marion: an actress who became a suffragette who pla... by empath75 on Sunday May 27, 2018 @03:42PM (#17168737)
I think in general that violent resistance should be avoided, and people should work within the system. But if people truly believe that the system is no longer working for them, and that change within the system is impossible, then violent resistance makes sense. After all, what do they have to lose? They’re already the victims of state-sanctioned violence.

When the majority have created an unjust system, and leave no option for reforms by minorities within that system, the only alternative is civil unrest, and that civil unrest has brought reform in the us multiple times in history.

Honestly, though — considering what they’re protesting, I think BLM has been remarkably NON-violent.

Re:Kitty Marion: an actress who became a suffragette who pla... by MichaelGG on Sunday May 27, 2018 @05:27PM (#17169192)
I agree with your first 2 paragraphs. The problem is that people can be convinced that there is an issue where there is none, then resort to violence on weak grounds. It is easy to get people riled up on spurious reasons. I was about to bring up BLM but see you did so:

>considering what they’re protesting, I think BLM has been remarkably NON-violent

Last year only 20 unarmed black people were shot and killed by police vs 30 whites. So far this year the numbers are 8 and 11. Counting all police shootings last year, whites are 457 of them, blacks 223. About twice the number of whites have been shot by police. https://www.washingtonpost.com/graphics/national/police-shoo...

So yes blacks are killed at a higher rate per population. But what about by actual violence? When looking at violence, blacks and whites commit about the same number of homicides despite population differences. Homicide is the most fair stat we have. If we use lesser crimes [like drug possession or other violence], we will see blacks overrepresented due to higher policing and a biased justice system. In fact, as minority areas of cities have a low solve rate, going by homicides may understate the racial difference in crime in favour of blacks.

It sort of looks like, if you want to get racial about it, whites are the ones killed too much by police. And if you look at the numbers for Hispanics, it is even worse. (But that might be an artifact of how race/ethnicity/Hispanic is reported.[1])

Yet that does not stop perception. There was an ad on TV a while back with a black mother having "The Talk"[2] with her teenage daughter about getting stopped by cops and not wanting her killed. Well, let's see: in 2017 one unarmed female black person was shot by police, and that was when a SWAT team raided her and her bf's place. Such ads that portray this as an issue are simple fear mongering. 2018, so far that number is 0. An ad about how to hide in case of lightning storms would be more realistic. Or simply more training about driving. Or avoiding pools. Or practically anything else in the world.

Try it out: Go ask around and see what your friends and others think the true rate is of unarmed people being killed. Ask them what difference in numbers they think exist for black vs white, and ask them about the flip side of civilian violence. My guess is you'll first get some incredibly high statement about how this is just happening non-stop, then when you reveal the numbers you'll get some other excuse about how it is not about the numbers anyways but some other general racial problem.

1: I'm using https://ucr.fbi.gov/crime-in-the-u.s/2014/crime-in-the-u.s.-... for a quick view of homicide stats. The numbers could be off by 2x and it would not change the point much.

2: Found it: https://youtu.be/3s20ePvTaME?t=21 "This is not you about getting a ticket, this is about you coming home" to which the girl says "I'm going to be OK....right?" Obviously a dramatization but if you're somehow implying to your teenage girl that cops are going to pull you over and you'll not "come home", you're the problem.

Re:Kitty Marion: an actress who became a suffragette who pla... by slededit on Monday May 28, 2018 @12:15AM (#17170555)
The problem with police violence is that they fundamentally do not see the murders of unarmed people as a problem. On Netflix's Flint Town, there is an episode where the Flint officers watch the video of a woman in the car with her husband who was shot beside her. None of the officers in the room questioned the obviously emotional police officer, rather clearly there was something to hide because the woman was too calm.

In a situation like that, where one group feels the shooting of unarmed people is justified the absolute numbers are not the whole picture.

Re:Kitty Marion: an actress who became a suffragette who pla... by cooper12 on Sunday May 27, 2018 @01:44PM (#17168081)
It's funny how you committed the exact trap they were writing about in their comment... They didn't advocate for or against violence, they only stated that historically, a lot of major movements have had violent elements and we're mislead to believe that they were completely peaceful. The fact that your immediate reaction was assuming they're supporting violence shows you're also guilty of this myopism.
Re:Kitty Marion: an actress who became a suffragette who pla... by matte_black on Sunday May 27, 2018 @01:48PM (#17168106)
To be fair, he didn’t assume anything, he was asking a question to clarify.
Re:Kitty Marion: an actress who became a suffragette who pla... by cooper12 on Sunday May 27, 2018 @01:52PM (#17168124)
It's a very pointed question, in the vein of "when did you stop beating your wife"? The original comment wasn't taking any stance on violence, just commenting on how it's discussed. Trying to shift the focus from that to a question on personal politics is disingenuous.
Re:Kitty Marion: an actress who became a suffragette who pla... by angersock on Sunday May 27, 2018 @03:11PM (#17168560)
It was in fact because of the fact that no stance was taken I sought clarification.

I don't really care what the answer was, as personally I think either position is workable. I was just curious what rayiner thought.

Re:Kitty Marion: an actress who became a suffragette who pla... by trophycase on Sunday May 27, 2018 @02:09PM (#17168207)
Of course violence is acceptable? Are we honestly at a point in society where we need to ask this question? Do people really believe the state is entitled to a monopoly on violence? Not all problems can be solved by talking it out or by "working within the system"

Humans are obsessed with violence and conflict. Though sports, movies, video games, debate, and fighting have somewhat sublimated this obsession.