Re:Kitty Marion: an actress who became a suffragette who pla...
by loggedinmyphone on Sunday May 27, 2018 @04:07PM
(#17168867)
I see, so this is the "trolling" theory of social justice. Are you saying Malcolm X and BLM act to bait the system into discrediting itself through violence? One would think if the system were violent enough, it could be be baited into overt violence through nonviolent means alone.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Kitty Marion: an actress who became a suffragette who pla...
by anigbrowl on Sunday May 27, 2018 @05:19PM
(#17169155)
It's actually John Boyd's theory of moral conflict as the most determinative level of warfare. Nonviolent tactitions very often organize to bait an oppressive system into violent over-reaction.
Re:Kitty Marion: an actress who became a suffragette who pla...
by loggedinmyphone on Sunday May 27, 2018 @05:35PM
(#17169224)
I'm aware of this, and it goes back even further to the New Testament. I'm questioning the part about employing violent tactics Alameda Malcolm X.
Re:Kitty Marion: an actress who became a suffragette who pla...
by anigbrowl on Sunday May 27, 2018 @05:47PM
(#17169270)
I'm not, because it is effective. Passive resistance is only effective to the degree that more powerful actors are conscientious.
Re:Kitty Marion: an actress who became a suffragette who pla...
by loggedinmyphone on Sunday May 27, 2018 @05:55PM
(#17169306)
Violence can certainly bring about short term gains for the perpetrators. I'm personally interested in changing the cycle of violence itself, more than replacing one violent actor by another.
Re:Kitty Marion: an actress who became a suffragette who pla...
by DoreenMichele on Sunday May 27, 2018 @08:51PM
(#17170019)
Is there a specific area of interest here? Are you working on anything in particular?
Re:Kitty Marion: an actress who became a suffragette who pla...
by loggedinmyphone on Sunday May 27, 2018 @09:55PM
(#17170191)
I do have specifically marginalized groups of people who I try to help. But my most important project is being a decent human to those around me every day. It's not as easy as it sounds. It's second nature for all of us to pass on our past trauma and frustrations. In some ways it's easier to make a heroic and noble effort for some great cause than to put in the sustained effort every day to help the people around us. That's what I'm trying to do, certainly failing much of the time but trying to get back on my horse each time.
Re:Kitty Marion: an actress who became a suffragette who pla...
by maxerickson on Sunday May 27, 2018 @04:25PM
(#17168931)
MLK chose places to protest where he knew the sheriff was likely to react with violence!
Re:Kitty Marion: an actress who became a suffragette who pla...
by loggedinmyphone on Sunday May 27, 2018 @04:33PM
(#17168970)
Exactly. So employing violent tactics should not be necessary.
Re:Kitty Marion: an actress who became a suffragette who pla...
by empath75 on Sunday May 27, 2018 @07:20PM
(#17169697)
It actually depends on whether the populace at large or the government in power are willing to maintain power through force.
If you’re dealing with a democracy and a populace like the US or the UK, there happens to be a limit of how much brutality they’re willing to stomach in defense of the system. In a lot of cases it’s much more than we’d like to admit.
If you’re dealing with an authoritarian government or a theocracy, that limit is much higher or non-existent.
Re:Kitty Marion: an actress who became a suffragette who pla...
by loggedinmyphone on Sunday May 27, 2018 @08:47PM
(#17170009)
What I am betting on is precisely that reluctance of the populace to stomach brutality. Whatever political victories are achieved through escalating violence are ultimately empty until a fundamental rejection of brutality is achieved.
Re:Kitty Marion: an actress who became a suffragette who pla...
by x0x0 on Sunday May 27, 2018 @05:28PM
(#17169194)
So basically your takeaway from the fact that most of these successful social movements had a violent component to them is that social movements shouldn't be violent?
Re:Kitty Marion: an actress who became a suffragette who pla...
by loggedinmyphone on Sunday May 27, 2018 @05:37PM
(#17169232)
Most successful enterprises of any nature had elements of violence - "every fortune is built on a crime". I'm not questioning their success, just asking if we can do better.