News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Kitty Marion: an actress who became a suffragette who pla... by whack on Sunday May 27, 2018 @01:59PM (#17168163)
You bring up a very thought provoking question. Looking at the many social movements in the past century, we have often lionized those who pursued non-violent methods, while downplaying those who pursued armed resistance.

But would the former have succeeded without the latter's help? Would MLK have succeeded without Malcolm X? Would Gandhi have succeeded without Subhas Chandra Bose? Would Nelson Mandela have succeeded without his willingness to use violence?

When looking at movements such as the American revolutionary war, the American civil war, and the Allies' resistance against Nazi occupation, the use of violence to achieve political goals, is both accepted and seen as necessary for the greater good. I've yet to meet anyone who deplored armed resistance in the above conflicts.

https://www.independent.co.uk/world/the-forgotten-violence-t...

http://www.latimes.com/world/worldnow/la-fg-wn-nelson-mandel...

Re:Kitty Marion: an actress who became a suffragette who pla... by artificial on Sunday May 27, 2018 @02:14PM (#17168225)
It is a thought provoking question. Take Gandhi, he succeeded because of British sensibilities, the same strategy wouldn’t have been as effective against the Nazis for example. A great deal of it depends on the adversary.
Re:Kitty Marion: an actress who became a suffragette who pla... by wz1000 on Sunday May 27, 2018 @03:15PM (#17168583)
Gandhi didn't "succeed" in a vacuum, and especially not due to "British sensibilities". The British Empire as a whole was an unwieldy and increasing unprofitable venture(not in small part to the threat of revolt and Civil Disobedience from occupied regions) for a country that had been devastated through the damages and effort of fighting the largest war in human history.

If colonised countries had not been actively(and violently) trying to get rid of their colonisers, the British Empire could have persisted indefinitely.

Violence is much more effective than non-violence in trying to get rid of any oppressor. Consider this: any State can deal with 5-10% of its population not working/paying taxes and "non-violently" resisting(these days even property crime can get you counted as a violent protestor). States would be much more hard pressed to deal with even 1% of their population in active, armed revolt against them.

Re:Kitty Marion: an actress who became a suffragette who pla... by loggedinmyphone on Sunday May 27, 2018 @03:32PM (#17168684)
All of these instances of violence are regrettable. The aims of the American War of Independence and the Civil War almost certainly could have been achieved without firing a shot. The Nazi regime could have been prevented if the victors of the first World War hadn't imposed harsh punitive measures to destroy the German economy.
Re:Kitty Marion: an actress who became a suffragette who pla... by lsc on Sunday May 27, 2018 @05:52PM (#17169296)
>The aims of the American War of Independence and the Civil War almost certainly could have been achieved without firing a shot.

Maybe? I mean, the war of independence is a little different... clearly, we were not a real threat to the British; we just needed to be seen to be resisting, without getting crushed, until the war with France heated up enough that the British couldn't spare the troops to keep us down. from that perspective? it was almost a minimal violence kind of war. The "Fabian strategy" - which only worked against an army as good at logistics as the British because they were also fighting a serious war with France at the time. Really, we needed to remain a threat, but except for proving that we could inflict such damage, one could argue that the actual violence wasn't super necessary.

The ACW, on the other hand, I... kinda don't think there was a peaceful resolution there. I mean, it wasn't like the southerners were arguing for a British style 'emancipation with compensation to the former owners' and the war was just haggling over the price. The Confederacy pretty much immediately rebelled after it was clear that we'd have an abolitionist-leaning president... long before any actual abolitionistic action was taken, long before it was clear that such action would be taken.

I kinda don't see how the ACW could have been avoided or made less violent. By advanced nation standards of the time, we were pretty far behind on the abolition schedule already, and while the slaughter of the ACW was shocking, so was slavery.

Re:Kitty Marion: an actress who became a suffragette who pla... by walshemj on Monday May 28, 2018 @06:34AM (#17171683)
The AWI could have been avoided the UK kept shooting its self in the foot if you avoid the AWI its interesting what happens does the USA take the same route Canada did?

If say the American colonies where given all the rights UK citizens under the same legal system had then Somerset v Stewart becomes interesting as that case outlawed chattel slavery in the UK in 1772.

Re:Kitty Marion: an actress who became a suffragette who pla... by loggedinmyphone on Sunday May 27, 2018 @07:31PM (#17169760)
I don't think the South loved owning slaves as much as they found it an expedient economic model, which was less true in the North. So I believe they could have been moved by economic pressure. We can't know for sure, but we can say there's more than one way to skin a cat and if you can do it without getting blood on the walls so much the better.
Re:Kitty Marion: an actress who became a suffragette who pla... by lsc on Monday May 28, 2018 @12:53AM (#17170659)
>I don't think the South loved owning slaves as much as they found it an expedient economic model

The economic model is strong in some ways; the value of all the slaves in the south, as I understand it, was greater than the value of all the farmland in the south.

There are weaknesses in the economic model, too, though. Nobody is saying that the southern enlisted man was hesitant to fight, and few of the enlisted (as opposed to officers) owned slaves.

For that matter, your average enlisted southerner would probably have been significantly better off, economically speaking, without slavery, just because if you are trying to sell your own labor, it's significantly more difficult to do so when you are competing with literal slaves.

So while you can use the economic model to explain the behavior of the southern elite, the economic model does not explain why the average southerner fought.

Re:Kitty Marion: an actress who became a suffragette who pla... by maxerickson on Sunday May 27, 2018 @03:57PM (#17168814)
A different resolution to slavery in the US almost certainly would have involved the ongoing deaths of slaves. So just less violence.

(even one that somehow rapidly ended slavery without slave owners waging war)

Re:Kitty Marion: an actress who became a suffragette who pla... by loggedinmyphone on Sunday May 27, 2018 @04:10PM (#17168886)
Yes, less violence is the goal.
Re:Kitty Marion: an actress who became a suffragette who pla... by anigbrowl on Sunday May 27, 2018 @05:21PM (#17169164)
It might be your goal, but it's not everyone else's. You don't get to tell people they can't have freedom because it might involve more violence than leaving them in captivity.
Re:Kitty Marion: an actress who became a suffragette who pla... by loggedinmyphone on Sunday May 27, 2018 @05:38PM (#17169238)
Neither the notions of nonviolence nor autonomy are absolutes. We always have to struggle to make good choices.
Re:Kitty Marion: an actress who became a suffragette who pla... by lsc on Sunday May 27, 2018 @05:36PM (#17169231)
>The Nazi regime could have been prevented if the victors of the first World War hadn't imposed harsh punitive measures to destroy the German economy.

I think you could make just as strong an argument that the Nazi regime would not have lasted long if those harsh punitive measures were actually enforced. I mean, if you have a strongman leader, the best thing for him is an enemy who snarls real good, but who backs down immediately upon confrontation.

I think the truth of the matter is that after world war one, the allies didn't have the political will to properly enforce the sanctions or to expend the money and effort for a marshal plan type response. I think that's why we got what we did, harsh punitive measures that were ignored whenever Germany pushed on them. - but I think that's also the best case for an expanding fascistic government... It sure looked, to the non-jewish german people, that every time Hitler "stood up for them" hitler got what they wanted. It was like the allies set up a paper tiger for Hitler to look strong against.

I'm not saying that's what should have been done, just that the "the Nazis would have not risen if there weren't punitive measures" and "The Nazis would not have held on to power if those punitive measures were actually enforced" are counterfactuals; theories about what could have been. I argue that there is just as much evidence for my theory as yours.

Re:Kitty Marion: an actress who became a suffragette who pla... by loggedinmyphone on Sunday May 27, 2018 @05:51PM (#17169293)
I think there were multiple ways Nazism could have been prevented or dealt with. It's just regrettable that it ended in so much violence. Probably what happened was neither the best nor the worst conceivable outcome.
Re:Kitty Marion: an actress who became a suffragette who pla... by SimbaOnSteroids on Sunday May 27, 2018 @04:13PM (#17168892)
The second world war resulting from the first world war's punitive damages is largely a myth propagated by the Nazi's on their rise to power. In actuallity the second world war was a result of piss-poor monetary and fiscal policy combined with the rise of fascism across Europe. AskHistorians thread that talks about this and cites their sources https://www.reddit.com/r/AskHistorians/comments/89u5t9/in_a_...