News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Has there been progress in philosophy? by lmm on Friday May 25, 2018 @11:15AM (#17154461)
> To illustrate: there is common belief that metaphysics became irrelevant -- that it was replaced by science. This is, in itself, a metaphysical position

That argument doesn't seem valid. The notion that fairies don't exist is, in itself, a fairyological position; still, few would accept that fairyology is a legitimate field of endeavour.

> I am only claiming that it is accepted by most people without any reflection.

Many things are accepted by most people without much reflection. Often that's because they really are as simple as they look.

> Some boundaries of scientific knowledge are quite visible. For example, consciousness. You might argue that consciousness emerges from matter interacting in a complex way (emergentism), and you might be right, but this is accepted as a serious scientific theory although it has zero content -- no way to falsify empirically, no explanatory mechanism proposed.

What are the outstanding empirical questions about consciousness? As soon as you go down to an empirical level, you find that no mysticism is necessary: there are valid, interesting questions to be asked and answered, but they are no more outside science than questions about how, say, protein folding works.

Re:Has there been progress in philosophy? by TelmoMenezes on Friday May 25, 2018 @11:29AM (#17154632)
> That argument doesn't seem valid. The notion that fairies don't exist is, in itself, a fairyological position; still, few would accept that fairyology is a legitimate field of endeavour.

You are using Popper's criterion for what constitutes a valid scientific theory, but I think you misunderstand me.

My claim is that saying that theoretical physics is the ultimate explanation of reality is a metaphysical position. Cosmology describes the big bang but it does not answer the question "why is it so?". Maybe there is no answer. Maybe it is not knowable. Maybe theoretical physics cannot have the total picture. These are all metaphysical questions that seem perfectly legitimate to me. If you are not allowed to ask or talk about these questions, I would say that you just accepted a religious faith. I am not trying to sell you anything except doubt and curiosity :)

> Many things are accepted by most people without much reflection. Often that's because they really are as simple as they look

Perhaps. Perhaps not.

> What are the outstanding empirical questions about consciousness? As soon as you go down to an empirical level, you find that no mysticism is necessary: there are valid, interesting questions to be asked and answered, but they are no more outside science than questions about how, say, protein folding works.

You are implicitly making the strong claim that knowledge can only be attained through empiricism. This is clearly not the case. I know that I am conscious and I assume that you are, but I cannot use empiricism to test this hypothesis, not can you use it to verify that I am, indeed, conscious. So there is something very fundamental -- in fact the only thing I know with 100% certitude -- that cannot be empirically tested.

Your use of the word "mysticism" betrays the current bias against such questions. I am not proposing any woo. I'm just curious. Even being curious about certain topics nowadays gets you labelled and a "mystic". I think this illustrates the point that I wanted to make in the beginning.

Re:Has there been progress in philosophy? by biswaroop on Friday May 25, 2018 @03:13PM (#17156964)
But you were talking about the mechanism of consciousness, not verifying whether someone is conscious or not.

It may be impossible to verify if someone is conscious in the same way that I know I am, but we can associate a set of behaviors with an intelligent creature. If we empirically prove that those behaviors emerge from a collection of neural impulses, then it takes a simple assumption (almost a cognitive axiom) that the creature exhibiting those behaviors is conscious, to conclude that emergentism has been empirically verified.

I feel like your position that emergentism is empirically impossible to verify is itself a strong position, and attempts to define a boundary on science when your stated goal is to place doubts on where the boundaries are. Yes it requires a few assumptions, and yes those assumptions are impossible to verify empirically. But then so are the mathematical axioms. We don't go around saying "physics is impossible to empirically verify because mathematical axioms are impossible to prove and are incomplete"

Re:Has there been progress in philosophy? by mcguire on Friday May 25, 2018 @05:55PM (#17158336)
"...we can associate a set of behaviors with an intelligent creature. If we empirically prove that those behaviors emerge from a collection of neural impulses,..."

Beware! Here be the dragon of pure behaviorism, which potentially denies that "consciousness" is a valid noun.

On the other hand, mathematics is the last refuge of the hardcore platonist (and worse, allows them to run around loose); the rest of us are true formalists who realize it's all a game whose basic rules happen to coincide with reality suspiciously well.

Re:Has there been progress in philosophy? by CuriouslyC on Friday May 25, 2018 @05:43PM (#17158269)
Try imagining yourself as a system of molecules all responding to their environment. It is reasonable that your complexity might be a good indicator of your potential for intelligent responses. I don't think that holds for your consciousness though. If it did, that would imply either consciousness is a spectrum or the universe has a hard coded on/off switch for consciousness. The on/off hypothesis has problems with conservation of information, and if consciousness is defined as "having an internal experience" it isn't clear how that could be non-binary.
Re:Has there been progress in philosophy? by nickpsecurity on Friday May 25, 2018 @08:01PM (#17159191)
Re:Has there been progress in philosophy? by CuriouslyC on Friday May 25, 2018 @11:38PM (#17160059)
That area may be important for higher brain functioning and memory. I don't think those are equivalent to consciousness though.
Re:Has there been progress in philosophy? by nickpsecurity on Saturday May 26, 2018 @12:09PM (#17162767)
I think it's likely an emergent phenomenon. Still, being able to turn it on and off with specific components hints they're either the source of conciousness or a big part of it.
Re:Has there been progress in philosophy? by lmm on Friday May 25, 2018 @12:12PM (#17155111)
> Cosmology describes the big bang but it does not answer the question "why is it so?". Maybe there is no answer. Maybe it is not knowable. Maybe theoretical physics cannot have the total picture. These are all metaphysical questions that seem perfectly legitimate to me. If you are not allowed to ask or talk about these questions, I would say that you just accepted a religious faith. I am not trying to sell you anything except doubt and curiosity :)

I see no reason to assume that question is beyond the reach of empiricism, which has been (both by its own standard and by naive common sense) effective in a way that alternatives have not. Non-empirical approaches may be able to construct self-consistent theories, but there is an infinitude of self-consistent theories, the overwhelming majority of which are useless under naive common sense. I trust empiricism because I was able to get there in Neurath's boat fashion from the everyday naive common sense that we all live by in practice.

> You are implicitly making the strong claim that knowledge can only be attained through empiricism. This is clearly not the case. I know that I am conscious and I assume that you are, but I cannot use empiricism to test this hypothesis, not can you use it to verify that I am, indeed, conscious.

I don't accept your claim. To the extent that "consciousness" refers to something meaningful, it refers to something empirical. (At least, my experience - under formal empiricism, naive common sense, and along the path between them - is that theories that involved entities detached from empirical consequences were misleading, and less effective than theories that did without such entities).

Re:Has there been progress in philosophy? by foldr on Friday May 25, 2018 @12:48PM (#17155495)
> To the extent that "consciousness" refers to something meaningful, it refers to something empirical.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Verificationism

You are taking a very strong (and controversial) philosophical position without perhaps realizing it.

Re:Has there been progress in philosophy? by lmm on Friday May 25, 2018 @01:03PM (#17155669)
I'm aware. I've not found the counterarguments listed there convincing. Quine's argument seems to be that since he can't see how to make the analytic/synthetic distinction rigorous it must be impossible to do so, which simply doesn't follow. And since I take the position not as an a priori principle but based on my empirical experiences of what kind of theorising has been effective or ineffective, it isn't self-defeating at all.
Re:Has there been progress in philosophy? by foldr on Friday May 25, 2018 @01:09PM (#17155725)
>And since I take the position not as an a priori principle but based on my empirical experiences of what kind of theorising has been effective or ineffective, it isn't self-defeating at all.

That is the same defense Ayer used. It doesn't amount to much, since if you don't mean to say that non-empirical statements are meaningless in some kind of objective sense, then saying that they're meaningless is just a highfalutin way of saying that you personally disapprove of them.

Re:Has there been progress in philosophy? by lmm on Friday May 25, 2018 @01:24PM (#17155931)
Non-empirical statements are meaningless in the same sense that fairies don't exist. It's not a priori impossible that a non-empirical but constructive/valuable/useful statement could exist - a black swan - just as it's not impossible that a fairy could exist - but it seems very unlikely and I'd put a very low weight on someone's claim to have seen one, given how often such claims have turned out to be false. When I dismiss something as non-empirical, that's the same kind of dismissal as saying something's a conspiracy theory - formally I'm not claiming that it's outright impossible, just unlikely (though in everyday language I might say "impossible", just as we do for conspiracy theories or fairies).
Re:Has there been progress in philosophy? by foldr on Friday May 25, 2018 @02:30PM (#17156601)
The strained analogy with fairies is obscuring your point. You seem to be using "meaningless" in a very unusual sense.

Whether or not non-empirical statements can be constructive or valuable is a separate question. Mathematics is non-empirical and strikes me as pretty constructive and valuable. But those terms are, ironically, so vague as to be almost meaningless in any case.

Re:Has there been progress in philosophy? by jabgrabdthrow on Friday May 25, 2018 @04:18PM (#17157527)
Maybe conspiracy theory is a bad example because they’re true often enough to not be like fairies or black swans at all.

Domestic mass surveillance is a debunked conspiracy theory, remember

Re:Has there been progress in philosophy? by marcv81 on Saturday May 26, 2018 @12:53PM (#17162994)
Re:Has there been progress in philosophy? by jabgrabdthrow on Friday June 08, 2018 @09:14AM (#17264935)
Do you think you contributed to the conversation or that anyone might have been missing part of the picture but you pointing out that black swans are a literal thing that are not uncommon unlike fairies that don’t exist or “black swans” (like “bull runs”) that are by definition extremely rare?

I once said “there’s no such thing as a bull run” in some context with a group of friends. Do you think you would have chimed in to say that there’s a big one in Madrid every year?

Re:Has there been progress in philosophy? by benl on Saturday May 26, 2018 @12:14AM (#17160172)
> "Non-empirical statements are meaningless"

This is a non-empirical statement, given that you probably don't believe that you can demonstrate the truth of it empirically.

Putting it another way, perhaps you might agree with the following statement?

"All legitimate knowledge is gained empirically."

But how do you know this? Did you reach this conclusion empirically?

So there must be some things that you know through non-empirical means.

Re:Has there been progress in philosophy? by lmm on Sunday May 27, 2018 @12:17AM (#17165417)
> But how do you know this? Did you reach this conclusion empirically?

Yes I did, that was my point. I haven't solved and am not claiming to have solved the problem of induction - the generalisation from "a bunch of empirical knowledge turns out to be valuable/effective/legitimate and all the supposed non-empirical knowledge I've seen turns out not to be valuable/effective/legitimate" to "all valuable/effective/legitimate knowledge is empirical" rests on potentially shaky ground. But that's a problem that already exists when making ordinary, object-level generalisations about the universe; it doesn't render the conclusion any weaker than ordinary scientific conclusions.

Re:Has there been progress in philosophy? by benl on Monday May 28, 2018 @08:56PM (#17175676)
That sounds like you're saying something like this:

"I believe empiricism is true because empiricism seems to be true."

We strive to live our lives based on reason, so we should look for ways to understand the world that go beyond a circular argument.

Such lines of thinking exist. They have been well argued and debated and have much going for them. Plenty of places to start learning about them, but maybe start with Aristotle.

Re:Has there been progress in philosophy? by lmm on Tuesday May 29, 2018 @08:21AM (#17178445)
> We strive to live our lives based on reason

I don't think we do. Reason is a means to an end, not a goal in itself.

> so we should look for ways to understand the world that go beyond a circular argument.

I don't see it as circular, but even if it were, my point is it's impossible to do better: all of us accept everyday common sense before we can even begin to argue technical philosophy, and if we're willing to set it aside then there are infinitely many self-consistent things we could think and no reason to prefer one over another. So no amount of sophistry will ever get you away from having to believe in everyday common sense.

> Such lines of thinking exist. They have been well argued and debated and have much going for them. Plenty of places to start learning about them, but maybe start with Aristotle.

Please. You're dismissing rather than engaging. If you're not willing to actually contribute to the discussion then don't post at all.

Re:Has there been progress in philosophy? by benl on Tuesday May 29, 2018 @11:25AM (#17179981)
I'm sorry you thought I was being dismissive. I felt I had reached the limit of my own pursuasiveness on the question and wanted to point you to somewhere better than me.

One final point I will try to make is that in thinking about how we know things, there's no suggestion that we need to set aside common sense. It's about starting with common sense and then seeing what we can add to it.

Re:Has there been progress in philosophy? by foldr on Monday May 28, 2018 @06:36AM (#17171690)
That's only an empirical generalization if you can cache out "valuable/effective/legitimate" in genuinely empirical terms (at minimum, in terms of observer-independent observations free from value judgments).
Re:Has there been progress in philosophy? by lmm on Tuesday May 29, 2018 @08:15AM (#17178388)
> That's only an empirical generalization if you can cache out "valuable/effective/legitimate" in genuinely empirical terms (at minimum, in terms of observer-independent observations free from value judgments).

I can cash it out empirically as "generates accurate empirical predictions and suggests fruitful avenues for future investigation" (fruitful in the sense of ultimately leading to more detailed and accurate empirical predictions). That the measure of a theory is the accuracy of its predictions is of course a subjective human position (there are an infinity of possible measures on which to evaluate theories, and a priori no reason to prefer one over another), but again that's (a cautious Neurath's boat extension of) the common-sense way that we all evaluate theories in practice in everyday settings.

Re:Has there been progress in philosophy? by foldr on Thursday May 31, 2018 @11:34AM (#17197077)
No, that's not even close to cashing out the generalization in empirical terms. To do this you'd need to specify exactly which observations would confirm or disconfirm it. Without the parenthesized parts, your gloss of the generalization remains vague and value-laden. With the parenthesized parts it is virtually tautological, since it's in the nature of empirical knowledge to generate accurate empirical predictions. It's surely not news to anyone that if forms of knowledge which lead to detailed empirical predictions are superior to other forms of knowledge, then empirical knowledge is superior to other forms of knowledge.

What you really seem to want to do, then, is argue from the nature of empirical knowledge itself to the conclusion that it is better than other methods of empirical knowledge. But that requires rational argument to back up the italicized statement above, not (just) an inductive generalization. And then we come back to the problem that it is impossible to find suitable premises for such an argument which can themselves be known empirically.

(For reference, the generalization we're talking about here is that "a bunch of empirical knowledge turns out to be valuable/effective/legitimate and all the supposed non-empirical knowledge I've seen turns out not to be valuable/effective/legitimate".)

Re:Has there been progress in philosophy? by lmm on Monday June 11, 2018 @02:58PM (#17287328)
> But that requires rational argument to back up the italicized statement above, not (just) an inductive generalization.

Why? Everyone evaluates ordinary, everyday knowledge in terms of its empirical predictions, so everyone seems to accept the italicised statement in practice, even if they'd argue for some sophisticated alternative in the abstract.

Re:Has there been progress in philosophy? by matt-attack on Saturday May 26, 2018 @12:49AM (#17160266)
Just want to say that I'm enjoying reading this discussion greatly. Please keep up the civil discourse!
Re:Has there been progress in philosophy? by mannykannot on Friday May 25, 2018 @04:21PM (#17157551)
> I'm just curious.

Yet you attack the scientific study of consciousness. I am not sure that you are as open-minded as you are presenting yourself.

Re:Has there been progress in philosophy? by roenxi on Friday May 25, 2018 @07:06PM (#17158882)
Things like Newton's Laws are, in a strict technical sense, not true. We still use them because they are very nearly true. But, strictly, they are approximations of something more fundamental. That extends to a great number of very intelligent figures of the past who described reality as they saw it but, in the end, turned out not to have sufficient measuring technology to be as correct as we would understand it now.

It is an extremely reasonable position that large swathes of what we believe today is also going to be wrong in this sense. For example, the great debate about whether reality is discrete or continuous (currently I think the evidence is discrete, but philosophically maybe we are a simulation run in a continuous universe).

We should try and work to the current state of knowledge of the researchers, but we all know that there is a high risk of something big and impressive being discovered that changes the name of the game, like when they split the atom. We just don't know what happens next.

Our understanding of consciousness also depends on who controls the dictionary and defines consciousness and surrounding terms.

Re:Has there been progress in philosophy? by mannykannot on Friday May 25, 2018 @07:59PM (#17159184)
> Our understanding of consciousness also depends on who controls the dictionary and defines consciousness and surrounding terms.

I think that arguing over dictionary definitions is something of an anti-pattern in philosophical (-like) discussions. If we have a common agreement that there is something that we call consciousness, but it is a thing that we do not really understand, then pedantic arguments about exactly what the word does and does not denote are putting the cart before the horse when it comes to understanding the thing itself. It substitutes a lexicographical dispute for an examination of the thing itself, and it is not uncommon for such arguments to be used to talk around the issue by attempting to take certain positions off the table.

As for scientific theories not being strictly true, that hardly distinguishes science from philosophy in general (logic excepted), where there are at least two opinions on every issue of note.

Re:Has there been progress in philosophy? by mythrwy on Friday May 25, 2018 @03:56PM (#17157316)
The amount of woo that usually follows that line of reasoning though is probably why the prejudice exists.

It's kinda like this: "Sure, blockchain has potential but 98% of the space is blatant scams at the moment".

Re:Has there been progress in philosophy? by wu-ikkyu on Friday May 25, 2018 @03:41PM (#17157187)
>there are valid, interesting questions to be asked and answered, but they are no more outside science than questions about how, say, protein folding works.

Questions about consciousness are much different than protein folding, because protein folding can be objectively observed and tested.

Consciousness cannot be objectively tested, because in order to test consciousness, you must use your consciousness to do so -- there's no way to control for that variable.

Fire doesn't burn itself, and water doesn't wet itself, maybe consciousness cannot understand itself -- just like our eyes cannot directly see themselves.

If hard science is based on objective observations, perhaps the limits of science are at that which we use to make those observations -- our consciousness.

Re:Has there been progress in philosophy? by mannykannot on Saturday May 26, 2018 @12:58PM (#17163016)
> just like our eyes cannot directly see themselves.

And yet, with a mirror, we can work around that difficulty - or we can study someone else's eyes.

Analogies, by themselves, are not an argument for anything, and without a basis to justify the comparison, they are just appeals to intuition.

In this case, the whole argument collapses when we realize that one mind can study others - and plenty of people have been doing that.

Re:Has there been progress in philosophy? by wu-ikkyu on Sunday May 27, 2018 @10:19AM (#17166957)
>one mind can study others - and plenty of people have been doing that.

Of course, but that's not objective, hard science like biology (and protein folding) is.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hard_and_soft_science

"psychiatric diagnosis still relies exclusively on fallible subjective judgments rather than objective biological tests"

-Allen Frances

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Allen_Frances

Re:Has there been progress in philosophy? by mannykannot on Sunday May 27, 2018 @12:23PM (#17167618)
Even if we accept the questionable assertion that no study of any aspect of the mind so far has been objective, you have provided no argument that it cannot be so in principle.

I notice that the link you provide on 'hard' vs. 'soft' sciences contains passages that cast doubt on whether the distinction is significant. Biology is classified as less objective than physics, yet biology explains many things very well, and, in fact, actually better than a reduction to the underlying physics would (evolution, for example, or genetics.) By your original argument, however, human biology could not be an objective science.

Re:Has there been progress in philosophy? by wu-ikkyu on Monday May 28, 2018 @12:42PM (#17173354)
>Even if we accept the questionable assertion that no study of any aspect of the mind so far has been objective, you have provided no argument that it cannot be so in principle.

Perhaps if we had aliens or god study our minds, then it could be objective and not influenced by the biases of our own human minds. There's no argument that they can't exist in principle.

Re:Has there been progress in philosophy? by mannykannot on Monday May 28, 2018 @09:59PM (#17175915)
So do you consider the discipline of human biology to be the work of aliens or of gods, or do you consider it to be devoid of objectivity?
Re:Has there been progress in philosophy? by wu-ikkyu on Monday May 28, 2018 @11:56PM (#17176369)
Seems like a false dichotomy. Quantum physics has shown that the mere act of observing fundamental reality changes it's state, so perhaps our consciousness of reality is much more subjective than we thought.

https://plus.maths.org/content/physics-minute-double-slit-ex...

Re:Has there been progress in philosophy? by mannykannot on Tuesday May 29, 2018 @08:41AM (#17178571)
Yes, it is a false dichotomy, but the point is that it is one that follows directly from your argument: all your 'just like' comparisons apply as well to human biology as they do to the study of the mind, and if a thing studying itself is hopelessly compromised by subjectivity, then, by your argument, this must be so for human biology.

History is another example of human self-study that is not rendered impossible by subjectivity. In this case, there is a term, 'whig history', for one form in which the investigator's bias is applied to his analysis of past events. The fact that this term exists, and that the phenomenon it labels can be identified and corrected for, shows that it is possible to work around the subjectivity of self-study.

As for quantum mechanics, it seems there is indeed a good deal of subjectivity, at least in the Copenhagen interpretation. By your argument, that should have destroyed physics as an objective science, yet physics has been extraordinarily fruitful since the discovery of QM. Here is an example of Luboš Motl dealing, in his characteristic style, with subjectivity, and, in fact, discussing the topic "Why subjective quantum mechanics allows objective science."

https://motls.blogspot.com/2012/11/why-subjective-quantum-me...

It is somewhat ironic that all your arguments for the impossibility of understanding the mind, on account of a lack of objectivity, are themselves subjective.

You are, of course, free to hold the opinion that there is something about consciousness that will put it forever beyond our understanding, and I cannot prove that there is not, but until we run into that barrier, I prefer to apply Occam's razor to the proposition.

Re:Has there been progress in philosophy? by lmm on Tuesday May 29, 2018 @08:25AM (#17178465)
The more sensible interpretation of the available facts is not that making observation changes reality, merely that we are ourselves part of reality. In any case the precise, constrained observations of QM are by no means a license to make arbitrary assumptions about "consciousness".
Re:Has there been progress in philosophy? by humanrebar on Friday May 25, 2018 @02:30PM (#17156595)
> As soon as you go down to an empirical level, you find that no mysticism is necessary

There are plenty of things that cannot be observed. There are plenty of things that should not be observed. There are plenty of things that can be observed but cannot be understood well enough to achieve the goals we want.

I don't find it controversial to claim there are limits to empiricism. The fact that we expect juries and judges to rule on incomplete information is a concession to that reality.

And because there are limits on empiricism, there are limits on science.

Re:Has there been progress in philosophy? by mannykannot on Friday May 25, 2018 @04:48PM (#17157824)
> The fact that we expect juries and judges to rule on incomplete information is a concession to that reality.

I think that arises from practical difficulties in finding all the relevant information, not from a certainty that it is, in principle, undiscoverable.

I notice how you slip easily from a personal opinion in your penultimate paragraph to the pronouncement of a universal truth in the final one. This seems to be characteristic in philosophy, as displayed, for example, in Searle's 'Chinese Room' paper.

Nevertheless, I agree with the general position that there are unobservable things (that's just my opinion, of course.) I also believe that there are limits to reason alone as a means for discerning truth, and consequently I believe there are limits to what philosophy can achieve (though I see no limits on how much discussion it can generate.)

Re:Has there been progress in philosophy? by humanrebar on Saturday May 26, 2018 @01:07AM (#17160329)
> ...not from a certainty that it is, in principle, undiscoverable.

In principle if we have to violate rights to obtain all of the relevant information, then some information must be undiscoverable.

In a more scientific bent, you have the Heisenberg Uncertainty Principle and the existence of intractable computers science problems to support the idea that there opinion-free realms where science cannot provide solutions.

And I find labeling claims as opinion to dismiss them a bit facile. The underlying point is that there we conceded that there are practical considerations that make us act on incomplete information. Therefore we concede on a practical level that all things cannot be knowable. Conjecture and guesswork pervade everyday life.

Re:Has there been progress in philosophy? by mannykannot on Saturday May 26, 2018 @09:41AM (#17161953)
It is interesting that you present the rights issue, as, while it is a valid response to the claim I made, it works just as well as the claim I made as a counter to your original claim about what the instructions to jurors tell us about the limits of knowledge.

Similarly, your use of quantum uncertainty is valid, but its discovery did not put a stop to physics - on the contrary, the discovery of QM has led to vast new areas of knowledge, and has even had metaphysical and epistemological implications (such as the constraints on realism that follow from Bell's inequality) that were never imagined in millennia of navel-gazing. Therefore, if anything, quantum uncertainty tends to stand as a counter-example to the apparent premise behind your claim that incomplete knowledge sets limits on science (I weasel-worded that sentence because I do believe that it could ultimately become a problem, if humanity survives long enough.)

I am not labeling a claim as opinion to dismiss it - in fact, if I cannot offer a definitive counter-argument, then my own position on the matter is an opinion - it is the transition from opinion to certainty that I find interesting. Searle's Chinese Room paper, for example, is an elaborate argument ultimately hung on the unexamined premise that syntax cannot give rise to semantics, and the non-sequitur that a model of a thing is not the thing itself, yet he declares that he has proven that a digital computer can never have a mind. This passing off of opinion as certainty may just be an issue of style within philosophy, but if so, it is an unfortunate one, as it makes it difficult to keep track of what has definitively been established and what remains as conjecture or premise. Certainly, there are many people who think Searle proved something in that paper, yet there is disagreement within that group as to what exactly that is.

Conjecture and guesswork pervade everyday life, science, and even philosophy.

Re:Has there been progress in philosophy? by giggles_giggles on Friday May 25, 2018 @02:40PM (#17156695)
An example of the limit of empiricism: how do you measure the moral of a story, when you read a good novel? Because you cannot measure it, does the moral not exist?
Re:Has there been progress in philosophy? by tlb on Friday May 25, 2018 @04:09PM (#17157443)
You devise a test for obeying the moral, and administer the test to a bunch of subjects before and after reading the story. For example, if the story is Hamlet, you can give an opportunity to back-stab their boss in order to get yet another promotion. Are they less likely to do it after seeing how badly it went for the young thane? Not an easy test to do, but possible in principle.

Joshua Greene's lab at Harvard (http://www.joshua-greene.net/) measured subjects making major moral decisions and found, for example, that people who'd received training in medical ethics made more utilitarian decisions about life and death. You could apply the same methods to morals of stories in a randomized trial by having some subjects read them and some not.

Re:Has there been progress in philosophy? by humanrebar on Saturday May 26, 2018 @01:11AM (#17160342)
That's not measuring the existence of morality though. It's measuring whether certain things can influence behavior. And because it's a lab study, the behavior tends to be fairly trivial in practice.

Besides studying whether people behave morally is begging the question if the question is "do morals exist?".

Re:Has there been progress in philosophy? by p1esk on Friday May 25, 2018 @04:21PM (#17157561)
I'm confused, what about things that can be deduced based on other things that can be observed? If I see someone's shadow, and deduce that there's a person there, whom I can't see directly, casting that shadow, will my claim "there's a person, casting a shadow" be outside of the "limits of empiricism"?
Re:Has there been progress in philosophy? by humanrebar on Saturday May 26, 2018 @01:20AM (#17160366)
If all you've seen is a shadow, all you've seen is a shadow. How do you know it's not someone's twin? Or some sort of puppet facsimile?

Now, that's a contrived example. More realistically, I doubt we'll ever be able to get enough detailed measurements to really understand how genetics, nutrition, exercise, and environment all play together to affect human health. Clearly each is complex enough on its own and to combine them together quickly magnifies the observation problem to be entirely intractable. We can imperfectly generalize and work with populations to come up with various guidelines that seem to work well with populations. We can break down the problems, measuring particular cells or organs. But to recompose all the experimentation and observation into a full system view is much more complex than solving chess or go. It's much more complex than predicting the earnings forecast of a single company. The complexity of the problem space is just ridiculous.

So we try to push the boundaries of the complexity we can deal with, but there are diminishing returns over time. And clearly there are outer bounds we will never be able to approach.

Re:Has there been progress in philosophy? by lmm on Tuesday May 29, 2018 @08:29AM (#17178498)
True enough, but I don't see how any of that is specific to empiricism? This doesn't sound like a case where empiricism overcomplicates and a non-empirical approach could do better; rather it seems like reality is just that complex, and our only options are to deal with it or to simplify and accept a coarser picture (which is perfectly compatible with empiricism).
Re:Has there been progress in philosophy? by skybrian on Friday May 25, 2018 @02:00PM (#17156301)
Metaphysics is basically a question of axioms. Reasoning can't get off the ground without some unproven assumptions. We can certainly talk about our assumptions without proving them!

I would argue that most axioms used by thinking brains ultimately derive from evolutionary processes. But again, this is different from proving them, and brain development is far from simple.

Re:Has there been progress in philosophy? by lmm on Sunday May 27, 2018 @12:33AM (#17165443)
I'd argue that in practice everyone believes in everyday common sense - even philosophers who claim to follow some philosophy that's radically contradictory to it (in a similar sense to the economist's notion of "revealed preferences"). So someone who relies on a novel set of axioms is relying on a bigger and more dubious foundation than someone who's able to "Neurathian bootstrap" starting with just the everyday common sense that we are already all relying on.
Re:Has there been progress in philosophy? by some_account on Friday May 25, 2018 @02:07PM (#17156381)
>> I am only claiming that it is accepted by most people without any reflection.

> Many things are accepted by most people without much reflection. Often that's because they really are as simple as they look.

I think it's because people are used to some 'credible' person telling them what to think. People are trusting science way too much in my opinion.

Re:Has there been progress in philosophy? by kinsomo on Friday May 25, 2018 @04:14PM (#17157488)
> People are trusting science way too much in my opinion.

Scientism is also rampant.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scientism