News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tesla needs to sell more expensive Model 3s so the compan... by otalp on Tuesday May 22, 2018 @12:11PM (#17126997)
Summary of Tesla's situation:

- Tesla currently has 2.67 billion in cash.

- About 1.1 billion of this is in loans that need to be returned early next year

- Around 40% of their cash in hand is from refundable deposits, from people who thought they would get a $35k car

- Tesla cannot make $35k M3s at a profit(this is widely accepted, and even Tesla hinted at it), they'll lose money even making $42k cars. They need to make $50k cars to earn a decent profit

- When asked in the earning call last week about reservations and how many people chose to cancel/take up their car once offered, Musk stunningly called the question "boring" and "boneheaded" and went on take questions from a youtuber for 20 mins. This was considered unprecedented and bizarre and stock dove.

- Tesla is losing about 800-900 million a quarter, so they will run out of money without a cash infusion. Literally everyone knows that Tesla will need to raise capital this year.

- Musk though, has insisted that Tesla will not need to raise cash because they will be "profitable by Q3 or Q4". Reminder that they lost 780 million in Q1, and even small profits won't be enough to prevent running out of cash. In order to make profits they need to sell 10,000 cars a week. They were supposed to produce 5000 cars a week in 2017. They have just now been able to produce 2500/week.

- Even bulls say that Musk is bluffing and he will eventually raise cash this year. Moody's downgrade of Tesla to essentially junk stocks makes it harder to raise cash at good interest rates. Moreover, there is speculation and some evidence that the reason Tesla haven't already done so, is that they are under SEC investigation which would prevent them from raising cash without disclosing a lot of details harmful to them.

- Tesla has access to standard credit lines for about 500 million, but they recently had to pledge their Fremont factory to just maintain these credit lines.

- A lot of Tesla's financial executives have left the company - a red flag to many including Jim Chanos, who famously shorted Enron due to similar indicators. The head of autopilot left and the head of engineering left 'for vacation' last week.

- Tesla's autopilot is complete false advertising. Their original autopilot was developed by MobilEye. MobilEye hated tesla's exaggeration of the system's capabilities and withdrew their supply after a person died using autopilot. Tesla responded that mobileye was jealous of Tesla's superior "Enhanced Autopilot" which has hardware capable of full self driving. It is universally accepted that enhanced autopilot is worse than mobileye's system right now, and in general both are basically lane-keeping system with AEB. Waymo and GM/Cruise are far ahead with their FSD capabilities than Tesla(again, widely accepted)

- Part of Tesla's debt comes from bailing out Solar City, a completely unprofitable company loaded with debt that was run by Musk's cousins.

- Starting from 2019 and 2020, all the major automakers are bringing out electric models. This will further damage Tesla's competitiveness, since they have the wost QA and build quality due to their haphazard and panicked development process

Despite all this, the market cap of tesla is larger than Ford, Fiat and nearly equal to GM. Their inflated market cap(which even Musk admits is inflated) is fuelling their funding which inflates the market cap even more as they lose more money trying to make bigger promises. A classic example of a huge bubble.

What does Tesla have to it's advantage? Tremendous marketing and brand value. They're probably inching towards or even surpassing Apple

What does Tesla have against it? The realities of running a business and actually making the products.

Re:Tesla needs to sell more expensive Model 3s so the compan... by Nokinside on Tuesday May 22, 2018 @01:42PM (#17127861)
Good analysis.

Tesla's market value is based on the combination of the brand value and the 'skateboard' that is technically far ahead of others.

Munro Associates did completely Model 3 teardown and report for some customer. Munro said in a interview that had Tesla outsourced the manufacture and design of of the car minus the scateboard to a company like Magna they would have hit every target and even Toyota would be crapping their pants now. If the traditional mechanical parts of the car would have been even decent, Tesla would have mopped the floor with everybody.

If Tesla gets into money troubles, car companies are willing to pay a big chunk of money to get the brand and skateboard and build their own car around it.

Toyota has over 53.84B in cash and short term investments, GM has 21.37B. Either one can buy Tesla (the brand and the skateboard) Musk fumbles. Tesla price has air in it, but the brand has value even if Musk is gone.

Re:Tesla needs to sell more expensive Model 3s so the compan... by audionemesis on Tuesday May 22, 2018 @12:26PM (#17127153)
> - Around 40% of their cash in hand is from refundable deposits, from people who thought they would get a $35k car

Do you have a source on the amount of people who "thought they would get a $35k car?" Autopilot itself has always been an add-on feature that costs money.

> It is universally accepted that enhanced autopilot is worse than mobileye's system right now, and in general both are basically lane-keeping system with AEB. Waymo and GM/Cruise are far ahead with their FSD capabilities than Tesla(again, widely accepted)

What? It's generally accepted that AP2/2.5 is now in general better than AP1. From first hand experience, the lane keeping and the ability to perform on local roads/ramps is far better than what AP1 cars can do. I believe the only thing that AP1 does that AP2/2.5 does not yet do is read speed limit signs. AP1 also shows cars adjacent lanes on the dash, which AP2/2.5 does just fine when you use the turn indicators to do an Auto Lane Change

Re:Tesla needs to sell more expensive Model 3s so the compan... by otalp on Tuesday May 22, 2018 @01:07PM (#17127498)
>It's generally accepted that AP2/2.5 is now in general better than AP1

Not in most forums/amongst most owners

https://www.reddit.com/r/teslamotors/comments/83vtk8/autopil...

Most tests show that AP 2 does a few things better, but is less reliable overall.

>the amount of people who "thought they would get a $35k car?"

That is not publicly available data. However on Twitter Musk said that he refused to answer the analyst question about reservations because it would make Tesla look bad as people were still waiting for different models. I think it's more likely most people are waiting out for a cheaper car than a more expensive one.

Re:Tesla needs to sell more expensive Model 3s so the compan... by FireBeyond on Tuesday May 22, 2018 @12:33PM (#17127204)
> What? It's generally accepted that AP2/2.5 is now in general better than AP1.

As of when? As recently as 3-6 months ago, forums were decrying how much worse it was, YouTube videos famously show the car swerving on clearly marked roads, etc.

Re:Tesla needs to sell more expensive Model 3s so the compan... by audionemesis on Tuesday May 22, 2018 @12:38PM (#17127235)
Re:Tesla needs to sell more expensive Model 3s so the compan... by addicted on Tuesday May 22, 2018 @01:03PM (#17127453)
The tweet and the responses only talk about how much of an improvement it is over the previous Tesla Autopilot. There is no mention of how it compares to the MobileEye version.
Re:Tesla needs to sell more expensive Model 3s so the compan... by Zarel on Tuesday May 22, 2018 @05:19PM (#17129504)
That tweet links to this article:

https://electrek.co/2018/03/16/tesla-autopilot-update-first-...

Which contains the line:

> In general, most drivers now seem to agree that Tesla’s Autopilot 2.0 has surpassed the Autopilot 1.0 powered by Mobileye – something that has been debated for the better part of a year now.

Re:Tesla needs to sell more expensive Model 3s so the compan... by Shivetya on Tuesday May 22, 2018 @12:43PM (#17127275)
I thought they lumped all deposits together from all pending products, so how much of that is from the semi and new sports car? Is there a breakout on each deposit that an investor can see?

edit: the tesla sportscar was a 250k (5k up front +245 wire transfer) reservation for 1000 accounts. All those past 1000 have to reserve at 50k. Semi deposits are 5k each

Re:Tesla needs to sell more expensive Model 3s so the compan... by devy on Tuesday May 22, 2018 @01:07PM (#17127500)
Despite of all these realities/bubbles you described above (assuming most of them are true/accurate), Tesla led the way of electrification of transportation industry and showed us that EVs are the future of sustainable transportation. I am sure all the Tesla fanboys all have their own nuanced reasons to support Tesla and Elon Musk, but if I had $100k to spare, I'd support this noble goal (aforementioned, sort of a success at this point) and bet big on Tesla and Elon. Perhaps that's Tesla's strength - the vision and a goodwill. Everything else is secondary.
Re:Tesla needs to sell more expensive Model 3s so the compan... by resolaibohp on Tuesday May 22, 2018 @01:25PM (#17127680)
If you really believe in Tesla to bet big on them you do not need 100k. You can buy 4 $275.00 call contracts for approx 26k that expire in 2020. This would be equivalent to ~$110k worth of tesla stock. And if you are really a believer you can just pick up a bunch of way out of the money contracts making the initial cash requirements even lower.

But this is exactly why TSLA is worth so much right now as so many people think the same way as you. They all want to bet big on Tesla and Elon. It is the most interesting stock to watch as it hemorrhages money and just keeps going up and up.

Re:Tesla needs to sell more expensive Model 3s so the compan... by devy on Tuesday May 22, 2018 @03:18PM (#17128624)
I don't own any stocks/secruities directly other than 401k, can you explain a little more on the call contracts and which broker do you use?

PS: the $100k reference I had there was meant for the purchase of a mid-range configuration Model S, not TSLA stock.

Re:Tesla needs to sell more expensive Model 3s so the compan... by mathinpens on Tuesday May 22, 2018 @04:33PM (#17129190)
I think he is teasing you-before researching this I didn't think a reputable broker would sell a retail investor 26k of options. But apparently they do...who knows why.

If I were you I would definitely not actually buy anything he mentions. He is making fun of your non-quantitative beliefs by urging you to lose money since like...these options contract price risk into them and discount future returns. Moreover you are ignoring the substance of the comment-which is that tesla is overvalued (because of the actions of retail investors buying the equity itself because they think elon is the lovechild of jesus and steve jobs) but the options market is probably a better discriminator of the future value of tesla since its more institutional.

Looking at this comment I was pretty sure he was a financial person and he is (found a comment for his fintech company). In effect he is making fun of you for thinking with your gut instead of trying to make a more quantitative evaluation.

Re:Tesla needs to sell more expensive Model 3s so the compan... by resolaibohp on Tuesday May 22, 2018 @09:22PM (#17130856)
To be clear I was not trying to make fun of the OP. I frequently hear people say that they would invest if they had some certain amount of money. I always like to point out that there are plenty of ways to invest without huge amounts of capital, however with much more risk. It is kind of a temperature gauge to see how serious they are about their words.
Re:Tesla needs to sell more expensive Model 3s so the compan... by devy on Wednesday May 23, 2018 @10:34AM (#17134491)
Let me reiterate as well, the $100k price tag is for purchasing a mid spec Tesla Model S or a base model Model X with some options or 2 Model 3s(if they could deliver in time before going under), not investing on stocks/securities
Re:Tesla needs to sell more expensive Model 3s so the compan... by mathinpens on Wednesday May 23, 2018 @07:15PM (#17139355)
just an fyi an option isnt a stock or a security. it is a contract
Re:Tesla needs to sell more expensive Model 3s so the compan... by resolaibohp on Tuesday May 22, 2018 @09:23PM (#17130859)
Don't invest into option contracts if you are not already familiar with them. They come with much more risk. But most all brokers offer them, even robinhood.
Re:Tesla needs to sell more expensive Model 3s so the compan... by xkjkls on Tuesday May 22, 2018 @01:46PM (#17127902)
And I think a lot of us would be investors if their market cap were ~8 billion rather than ~50 billion. For a number of people who care about the electrification of vehicles, watching Elon angrily bite a short sellers who are skeptical really depresses us.

Most of Tesla's wounds are self inflicted. They made an egregious decision to purchase Solar City and subsume all of it's debt, despite neither company being cash flow positive. They seem to lack concentration in what is the most important part of their business: creating a production line for electric vehicles; throwing up a smoke screen of distractions for other things that might work in the future (self driving cars, trucks).

They also haven't given any realistic plans and have repeatedly exaggerated what they can accomplish.

Sure, the car business is brutal to enter into, which is why there hasn't been a new car company decades, but there is also shooting yourself in the foot.

Re:Tesla needs to sell more expensive Model 3s so the compan... by shashanoid on Tuesday May 22, 2018 @04:20PM (#17129071)
He is asking you to buy Options. Call option means you're bullish on $TSLA - A call option is an agreement that gives an investor the right, but not the obligation, to buy a stock. Unlike stocks, options have an expiry date 7 somewhat lose their value with time ( time decay ). A $275 call option/contract for instance which expires in 2020 means if $TSLA stock is trading above $275 in 2020, you'll make ton of money. It gives you the right to buy $TSLA at $275 in 2020 but you can sell your contract (1 contract represents 100 shares ) before the expiration date. If you don't do anything, the option/contract will expire wothless which means you'll lose the price you initially paid to buy that contract or you'll lose if the stock is trading below $275 or whichever strike price you bought it for. For simple call option, losses are constrained (the premium you paid to buy the contract ) but profits are unlimited. Options work exactly how insurance works, you can do the opposite as well and ofcourse there are several strategies on options as well. Beaware, this is dangerous.
Re:Tesla needs to sell more expensive Model 3s so the compan... by prklmn on Tuesday May 22, 2018 @10:10PM (#17131023)
The cost of the option you point to isn’t negligible. It’s trading at $69 as of today, meaning your break even point is $344, not $275.
Re:Tesla needs to sell more expensive Model 3s so the compan... by atonse on Tuesday May 22, 2018 @01:23PM (#17127656)
For the record, I am with you on this. For all these reasons, I hope Tesla pulls through (and also practically, that if I'm going to buy one of their cars next spring, I'd like for them to be alive for the life of that car).

But sadly that doesn't change the reality of their financial situation. I hope investors are able to see the potential and give them more runway to get through this very difficult time.

Elon's weird performance at the investor call didn't help.

Re:Tesla needs to sell more expensive Model 3s so the compan... by devy on Tuesday May 22, 2018 @03:20PM (#17128640)
I concur
Re:Tesla needs to sell more expensive Model 3s so the compan... by freyir on Tuesday May 22, 2018 @01:16PM (#17127596)
> Everything else is secondary

Including solvency? Noble goals don't keep debt collectors at bay.

Re:Tesla needs to sell more expensive Model 3s so the compan... by BryantD on Tuesday May 22, 2018 @12:19PM (#17127078)
This is a superb writeup. Question about brand value: the consequence of a programming error for Tesla includes collisions and death, whereas Apple bugs usually don't kill people. (Insert comment about Maps here.) Is Tesla's brand value more fragile?
Re:Tesla needs to sell more expensive Model 3s so the compan... by xkjkls on Tuesday May 22, 2018 @12:53PM (#17127370)
Definitely, both because they have less of unique position in the auto industry than Apple does in the phone industry (Apple is the only real integrated mobile phone player), and unlike Apple they've barely been around a decade. Apple has close to 50 years of corporate mystique at this point and probably is only beaten in brand recognition by Coca-Cola.
Re:Tesla needs to sell more expensive Model 3s so the compan... by Zarel on Tuesday May 22, 2018 @05:23PM (#17129537)
> Waymo and GM/Cruise are far ahead with their FSD capabilities than Tesla(again, widely accepted)

As far as I can tell, I can't buy a car from Waymo or GM/Cruise.

I don't mean this as a rebuttal/challenge, but I'm actually legitimately curious: Is it possible to buy a car with better "self-driving" (i.e. lane-keeping, AEB, auto lane changing, etc) than a Tesla right now?

Re:Tesla needs to sell more expensive Model 3s so the compan... by Bedon292 on Tuesday May 22, 2018 @01:22PM (#17127649)
If I am doing my math right, and Tesla is burning 8-900M / quarter, I am not so sure they would need new cash. Even if they are only selling only 2500 / week (and I believe they hit 3500 now didn't they?) that is $125M / week at $50k each average. And I think it is currently higher that each. And once they hit 5000 / week that is $250M. Over the course of a quarter that would be $3.2B. Which would more than cover that loss of $8-900M.

Not saying they definitely won't, but it seems plausible to not need more cash.

Re:Tesla needs to sell more expensive Model 3s so the compan... by otalp on Tuesday May 22, 2018 @02:54PM (#17128467)
To be precise, they are having a net loss of 800 million a quarter. Their negative cash flow last quarter was over a billion.

Even the biggest Tesla bulls, like Adam Jones of Morgan Stanley, expect Tesla to raise cash this year. I have not seen any major analyst say otherwise: to the contrary, all of them do say they need a major cash raise. Goldman Sachs thinks it should be in excess of 3 billion, and up to 6 billion.

Re:Tesla needs to sell more expensive Model 3s so the compan... by xkjkls on Tuesday May 22, 2018 @01:30PM (#17127747)
That's assuming that each of those cars can be produced without any costs, which they require large amounts of raw materials and labor, and that Tesla also doesn't need to spend large amounts of capital on R&D to improve manufacturing or new product lines.
Re:Tesla needs to sell more expensive Model 3s so the compan... by O_H_E on Tuesday May 22, 2018 @12:55PM (#17127391)
The good thing that I see is that they were the ones who pushed other companies to start/revive their EV lines.

It's a tragedy. They created competition and are -about to- fail to compete.

Re:Tesla needs to sell more expensive Model 3s so the compan... by sjm-lbm on Tuesday May 22, 2018 @01:03PM (#17127460)
It's honestly less a tragedy than lots of problems that have hit first-movers.

They are facing issues due to the fact that they are unable to make quality cars that people want at a price people will pay. They aren't losing out due to (for example) dealer networks being locked in with existing car makers.

Re:Tesla needs to sell more expensive Model 3s so the compan... by bobthepanda on Tuesday May 22, 2018 @01:11PM (#17127533)
It's basically how industry works; Ford was neither the first person to create the automobile, nor the first person to introduce mass production techniques.
Re:Tesla needs to sell more expensive Model 3s so the compan... by sgnelson on Tuesday May 22, 2018 @04:15PM (#17129035)
Also don't forget he failed many times at starting a car company before finally succeeding.
Re:Tesla needs to sell more expensive Model 3s so the compan... by vanattab on Tuesday May 22, 2018 @04:22PM (#17129088)
Thanks for taking the time to write this. You were able to articulate in a clear way what I have been trying(and failing) to explain to my friends for a while now. I think people are final starting to understand how I can support the vision of musk while also thinking that the hype train is insane and some of Musk's marketing practices are immoral(looking at you 'autopilot'). Just like with Holmes the move fast/break things/embellish is all well and good until you start talking about human lives.
Re:Tesla needs to sell more expensive Model 3s so the compan... by ghfdh6546 on Tuesday May 22, 2018 @01:18PM (#17127609)
> this is widely accepted...

> Literally everyone knows that...

> again, widely accepted...

Ah yes, the "make wild claims and then say everyone agrees" tactic.

Re:Tesla needs to sell more expensive Model 3s so the compan... by bllguo on Tuesday May 22, 2018 @02:08PM (#17128082)
Refute said "wild" claims or don't post, please. Your comment contributes nothing.
Re:Tesla needs to sell more expensive Model 3s so the compan... by somecontext on Wednesday May 23, 2018 @07:22AM (#17133160)
The post in question includes the following:

> When asked in the earning call last week about reservations and how many people chose to cancel/take up their car once offered, Musk stunningly called the question "boring" and "boneheaded" ...

The following excerpt is the one instance of the words "boring" or "boneheaded" in the earnings call, as you can see in a transcript at https://seekingalpha.com/article/4169027-tesla-tsla-q1-2018-...

> Antonio M. Sacconaghi - Sanford C. Bernstein & Co. LLC: And so where specifically will you be in terms of capital requirements?

> Elon Reeve Musk - Tesla, Inc.: Excuse me. Next. Boring bonehead questions are not cool. Next?

The question was not about reservations or people cancelling their car, and there was no context to that effect.

Re:Tesla needs to sell more expensive Model 3s so the compan... by ghfdh6546 on Tuesday May 22, 2018 @02:41PM (#17128356)
The onus is on the one making the claims.
Re:Tesla needs to sell more expensive Model 3s so the compan... by pwinnski on Tuesday May 22, 2018 @02:58PM (#17128491)
To respond to someone with a green username? I don't think so.
Re:Tesla needs to sell more expensive Model 3s so the compan... by madengr on Tuesday May 22, 2018 @12:30PM (#17127183)
“Tesla cannot make $35k M3s at a profit(this is widely accepted, and even Tesla hinted at it), they'll lose money even making $42k cars. They need to make $50k cars to earn a decent profit.”

Which means those extra options are extremely marked up over cost, compared to the base M3.

Re:Tesla needs to sell more expensive Model 3s so the compan... by mikeash on Tuesday May 22, 2018 @12:50PM (#17127335)
That should be really obvious. They’re selling $8,000 of software options whose unit cost is zero, after all.
Re:Tesla needs to sell more expensive Model 3s so the compan... by zaroth on Tuesday May 22, 2018 @12:48PM (#17127324)
Some of the options (e.g. autopilot) are software flags. Doesn’t get higher margin than that.

It costs an extra $1,000 if you want to add the software license later, but you can do it.

Re:Tesla needs to sell more expensive Model 3s so the compan... by mxschumacher on Tuesday May 22, 2018 @12:24PM (#17127125)
taking all this into account the current valuation of $47bn is remarkable!
Re:Tesla needs to sell more expensive Model 3s so the compan... by paulcole on Tuesday May 22, 2018 @12:24PM (#17127132)
This is good for Bitcoin— er I mean Tesla.
[dead]
Re:Tesla needs to sell more expensive Model 3s so the compan... by snowwrestler on Tuesday May 22, 2018 @02:27PM (#17128227)
Is this really Kyle Vogt?
Re:Tesla needs to sell more expensive Model 3s so the compan... by dang on Wednesday May 23, 2018 @09:55PM (#17140377)
Evidence suggests no, so I've banned the account.

When people mess with HN like this we eventually ban their main account as well.