News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:EU parliaments website in violation of GDPR by repolfx on Thursday May 17, 2018 @10:01AM (#17091273)
This is a reasonable observation but I doubt anyone will care. Moreover it misses the point of GDPR.

The goal is not to improve people's privacy. It's too vague to achieve that. Obviously the EU doesn't care as even its own websites aren't in compliance - assuming this guy's definition of compliance is the same as theirs. How likely is it the rest of the EU's operations are? Zero likelyhood of that.

But that's OK. GDPR doesn't even have a concrete notion of what privacy or personal information actually are. The goal is not to improve privacy, that's just a fig leaf. The goal is to grant the EU large new powers over the private sector and in particular over American tech firms, who will repeatedly be fined and treated as, effectively, a new source of tax income. GDPR is so vague and open ended that there's no way they can ever be compliant, meaning the EU has a new source of cash for years to come. Very useful at a time when they are asking for budget increases despite years of austerity, and facing a budget hole due to Brexit, and member states are getting upset at their financial demands.

GDPR enforcement will be very similar to EU anti-trust policy - deeply political and immediately controversial. It is best understood not as a law but as a political move, sort of like how China uses laws against pornography to justify blocking foreign search engines, or how it uses a law against 'spreading rumours' to censor domestic social media.

Re:EU parliaments website in violation of GDPR by blunte on Thursday May 17, 2018 @10:15AM (#17091363)
I disagree. I believe it is an attempt to put a stop to (mostly) US collection of EU citizen data - or at least to give EU citizens some ability to control what foreign entities are collecting (and monetizing) about them.

The EU uses large fines as a fairly effective threat to dissuade organizations from doing things that the EU believes are not beneficial to its members. Of course it's not perfect, and of course there are political motivations as well... but Europe (and other lower corruption countries, for that matter) have grown tired with the US and its money-above-all behavior.

US citizens will benefit from GDPR because it will force some change in behaviors of profit-seeking entities.

Re:EU parliaments website in violation of GDPR by midasz on Thursday May 17, 2018 @10:25AM (#17091472)
> GDPR is so vague and open ended that there's no way they can ever be compliant

This is nonsense. I really don't see what's so difficult to understand. Personal information is information to which the person can be identified.

Re:EU parliaments website in violation of GDPR by tchock23 on Thursday May 17, 2018 @10:30AM (#17091510)
The definition of personal information is easy to understand (albeit broad). However, the vagueness seeps in other areas of the regulation.

For example, additional restrictions are in place for “large scale” processing of personal information, yet “large scale” is never defined. Is that hundreds, thousands or millions of records?

As the owner of a very small SaaS business (that does not sell personal information of its users) I found it tremendously difficult to figure out how to comply given the vagueness of it all.

Re:EU parliaments website in violation of GDPR by midasz on Thursday May 17, 2018 @10:35AM (#17091584)
Yeah I get that. I googled around a bit and apparently there were concrete figures in the initial draft.

I don't know if the EU has a contactperson to whom you can ask these questions, if they do, you can simply ask them to clarify. If you've done that, you're in the clear because you've put in the effort to comply.

But yeah in this case they should just give you a number.

Re:EU parliaments website in violation of GDPR by pjc50 on Thursday May 17, 2018 @10:49AM (#17091734)
> I don't know if the EU has a contactperson to whom you can ask these questions, if they do, you can simply ask them to clarify.

lol of course there isn't an office you can ring to help you with this! If there were we wouldn't be spending quite so much effort working out what it all means.

Re:EU parliaments website in violation of GDPR by midasz on Thursday May 17, 2018 @11:00AM (#17091847)
Well for my country (NL) we have the AP and with 2 clicks I have their phone number: https://autoriteitpersoonsgegevens.nl/nl/contact-met-de-auto... ....

> If there were we wouldn't be spending quite so much effort working out what it all means

People love drama.

Re:EU parliaments website in violation of GDPR by repolfx on Friday May 18, 2018 @03:47AM (#17099431)
You don't seem to know much about GDPR.

Firstly, no, your national regulators cannot give you binding answers about GDPR. This is one thing the EU Commission has been clear on. They can advise, but their advice has no more weight than this Hacker News thread does - the EU is not required to care about what national regulators said and they have no special powers to interpret the law. Only the EU gets to decide what GDPR means, and they have said explicitly they will not answer questions about it. The only time answers finally come is during legal actions.

Secondly, no, people do not "love drama" in the business context, far from it. Maybe you should consider that your own interpretation of the problem is the issue rather than other people just causing drama for the sake of it.

Re:EU parliaments website in violation of GDPR by midasz on Saturday May 19, 2018 @05:31AM (#17107223)
k
Re:EU parliaments website in violation of GDPR by M2Ys4U on Thursday May 17, 2018 @10:54AM (#17091785)
Each of the 28 member states of the EU has a data protection authority. Those are the people one rings to get advice.
Re:EU parliaments website in violation of GDPR by jacquesm on Thursday May 17, 2018 @10:45AM (#17091691)
> For example, additional restrictions are in place for “large scale” processing of personal information, yet “large scale” is never defined. Is that hundreds, thousands or millions of records?

Hundreds or thousands not, millions definitely yes, somewhere in the middle you get to draw a line which to me is an indication that the closer you get to those millions the more you'll have to work and then those additional restrictions kick in.

There are companies that store billions of profiles (Google, Facebook), and for those the 'large scale' moniker is a no-brainer. If you're a small company that stores a few hundred to a few tens of thousands of records because you are doing direct business with those people then that would most likely still qualify as small. But from 100K and up I'd make sure the house was in order, not just because of the GDPR but because you are becoming a nice, fat & juicy target for miscreants as well.

Re:EU parliaments website in violation of GDPR by tchock23 on Thursday May 17, 2018 @10:53AM (#17091770)
That is the scope I was ballparking mentally (and which fits the scope of processing done in my app), but I just wish they had been explicit about it in the regulation so I could put to rest any apprehension around it.
Re:EU parliaments website in violation of GDPR by jacquesm on Thursday May 17, 2018 @11:06AM (#17091920)
The room built in is to ensure that there is some flexibility regarding for instance financial and health information where those restrictions would probably kick in sooner versus some e-commerce company such as a web store where the need to keep the data around on live systems is much less urgent.

That way one law will allow banks, insurance companies, hospitals and a mid-sized e-commerce company all to figure out for themselves what their comfort zone is, add a little room for safety and you're most likely going to be good, and even if not you can point at the law and say 'it wasn't explicit', so unless you are purposefully mis-interpreting a few million records as 'small scale' you will likely get away with that. Note the 'likely', this isn't a certainty but in my experience to date everybody that is fear mongering about the GDPR is coming up with the wildest of scenarios rather than to just look at the law as if it was intended well (which I really believe it is).

Re:EU parliaments website in violation of GDPR by jcranmer on Thursday May 17, 2018 @11:19AM (#17092032)
> Note the 'likely', this isn't a certainty but in my experience to date everybody that is fear mongering about the GDPR is coming up with the wildest of scenarios rather than to just look at the law as if it was intended well (which I really believe it is).

Bringing up the "parade of horribles" is a standard way of reacting to regulations, and it's normally countered by the regulators just pointing out that the horribles rely on really tortured interpretations that aren't intended. With the GDPR, that hasn't been the response (which has instead been a double-down on "it's just common sense" without confirming or refuting what will happen)--for me, that's some cause for concern.

Re:EU parliaments website in violation of GDPR by jacquesm on Thursday May 17, 2018 @12:12PM (#17092606)
I've rarely seen so much positive effect from a law before the date at which it would be enforced. My inbox is regularly visited by companies that suddenly feel that maybe they should obtain my content to spam me further in spite of me trying - sometimes for years - to get off their lists.

We'll see what happens after may 25th but for now I'm really hopeful that we will finally see some counterbalance to all this ridiculous profile building for marketing purposes.

Re:EU parliaments website in violation of GDPR by jcranmer on Thursday May 17, 2018 @10:36AM (#17091598)
> This is nonsense. I really don't see what's so difficult to understand. Personal information is information to which the person can be identified.

Does that include email addresses and IP addresses? If so, that means things like using email addresses to log in for comments or logging IP addresses for traffic analysis causes all sorts of GDPR to kick in. As the OP points out, this means that things like the EU's own websites are in violation of the GDPR.

Re:EU parliaments website in violation of GDPR by corobo on Thursday May 17, 2018 @10:54AM (#17091777)
Yes it does. Indeed it also does mean the GDPR kicks in (on the 25th)

All you need to be able to do though is say what you're using the information for. If that is "To allow you to log in to your account" and "Your IP and page requests are logged and kept for 2 weeks to for traffic analysis and troubleshooting" you're good to go - just say that on the sign-up form[1]. If you want add the email address to a mail list too you need to add an opt-in consent checkbox and a bit more information on what the checkbox agrees to.

If you want to pass along the information (indirectly, I know) to Google Analytics for example then you have to mention that too, and don't load the GA snippets until the user has accepted that

You also need a way to tell a user what data you have on them and delete the data where appropriate if the user requests it. You do not need to automate this process, chances are you'll never get either of those requests. Do Things That Don't Scale[2] applies when it comes to the user's ability to request info/deletion

It's just another cost of doing business like if you want to take card payments don't store the card number without getting PCI compliant. Don't store user info without getting GDPR compliant.

This whole thing is good for all of us as users of sites and software too

[1] Actually for a signup form you don't need to say you're using the information to sign them in, that's "unambiguous consent", as long as you're not doing anything but registering them and signing them in you can avoid clogging up your form with that information

[2] http://paulgraham.com/ds.html

Re:EU parliaments website in violation of GDPR by frockington on Thursday May 17, 2018 @12:29PM (#17092809)
Won't this just lead to more thousand page long sign up forms that nobody reads? I could easily right 10 pages on the reason behind using an email address at signup and hide in a bunch of seemingly mundane details
Re:EU parliaments website in violation of GDPR by corobo on Thursday May 17, 2018 @01:38PM (#17093478)
No, that's also a part of GDPR - They have to be understandable. 300 page documents with a position:fixed "I agree" button don't cover you

As with all things GDPR you can of course try to skirt the rules but you're risking the 20mil fine if you don't get it absolutely spot on

Re:EU parliaments website in violation of GDPR by jacquesm on Thursday May 17, 2018 @10:41AM (#17091652)
> As the OP points out, this means that things like the EU's own websites are in violation of the GDPR.

Actually, it doesn't. There are plenty of valid reasons to collect those things. Collecting them to track your users and to spam them to death are not on that list.

Re:EU parliaments website in violation of GDPR by ghein on Thursday May 17, 2018 @11:07AM (#17091925)
The presumption is that it's illegitimate but you can provide an affirmative defense of having a valid reason.

Proving this can be expensive and is risky. Who knows what any individual judge in any EU country will decide is "reasonable"?

Companies can easily be destroyed by filing multiple charges against them. Guilt, innocence, or reasonableness doesn't come into it: the process is the punishment.

Look at Amanda Knox (Americans tend to think she's innocent, Brits tend to think she's guilty) - after appeals the Italian Justice System found her not guilty of the murder of her roommate. She still spent almost four years in prison in her early twenties and had to spend a huge amount of money on lawyers to arrive at this result. Just because you eventually get what you see as the right result doesn't mean you won't go through hell to get there.

A major reason why Americans are having such a big problem with GDPR is because the EU system appears to change its interpretations and decisions abruptly, with retrospective effect. You set up companies in certain jurisdictions thanks to their tax rates and how transactions are treated. You follow every aspect of national and EU law. These arrangements are widely known, are accepted as legitimate practice, and they continue for decades. The EU commissioners change - suddenly your corporate arrangements are wildly illegal and you are subject to penalties and back taxes stretching over a decade.

If staff changes and they say that they will interpret a rule differently going forward, you can adjust your behavior to comply. New legislation, sure abide by it. But when the rules change and your behavior 15 years ago is now viewed to be illegal you can't do anything. Retroactivity is accepted in Europe but it is explicitly unconstitutional in the US. It's a major reason why the US is not currently part of the UK.

So the GDPR is terrifying because of the massive discretion granted to judges and prosecutors in every EU country and their habit for changing their interpretations. On its face it's not too threatening, but the fines are massive, there are no hard rules, and you can't be sure that today's interpretation will be tomorrow's.

Facebook and Google will manage - they can write billion dollar checks and get the US government to protect them. Many of us can be completely wiped out by a $20MM fine. Just a court case would be existentially threatening in terms of the resources it requires and its impact on fundraising and gaining customers.

Re:EU parliaments website in violation of GDPR by jacquesm on Thursday May 17, 2018 @11:35AM (#17092206)
More fearmongering. I will simply wait to see what actually is being done and if and when that oversteps the bounds of what I consider reasonable I will definitely make my voice heard but until then this is all totally besides the point and time spent on fearmongering would probably be better spent on studying the law, determining its intent and then doing your best to comply with that intent. The very small chance that some mom & pop shop will be taken to the cleaners by the EU courts 'just because they can' strikes me as not grounded in reality, there is no precedent for anything like that.

And bringing up some unrelated (murder!) case has no effect at all than to point out that justice systems aren't perfect, they are not expected to be perfect and we have lots of evidence to that effect already. That's a totally different discussion.

Re:EU parliaments website in violation of GDPR by ghein on Thursday May 17, 2018 @12:43PM (#17092954)
There's a presumption that every company in the world is violating EU citizens privacy. That storing IP addresses can be construed as illegal. That everyone is liable for a fine of $20MM for any mistake, innocent or malevolent.

The EU itself is hyping up how fearsome this law is to win approval from their citizens and politicians. As well as to strongly encourage firms to take this change seriously.

But I am at fault for taking the EU seriously rather than being blase. I am fearmongering for trying to explain why businesspeople who are not in the EU are afraid of its actions and are afraid of a brand new law that grants a huge amount of discretion to prosecutors and judges.

What I know is that the EU can capriciously change its mind and go after the biggest companies for billions of dollars. I know that I don't have the resources to prove my innocence in a foreign country. I don't even have the resources to understand the charges against me, since legal translation is expensive and I could be faced with actions in any or all of the languages of the EU. If I get a package of documents in Estonian or Bulgarian I won't even know that I'm facing charges!

Claiming universal jurisdiction against every company in the world with a reverse onus of proof is a dangerous and malevolent tactic. Because it's your local government that you have confidence in, you're comfortable with it. I doubt that you would be so blase about a similar approach by the US or Japan.

Re:EU parliaments website in violation of GDPR by jacquesm on Thursday May 17, 2018 @02:56PM (#17094344)
> There's a presumption that every company in the world is violating EU citizens privacy.

That presumption is probably roughly in line with what I've seen in my daily practice over the last decade or so. Some to minor degrees, some in major ways. But overall, very very few companies take the privacy of their customers so serious that they would make choose for their users privacy if ther was a buck to be made, of the top of my head over the last 75 or so companies I looked at two would check that box.

> That storing IP addresses can be construed as illegal.

What's so surprising about that? You see a whole pile of lawsuits that - erroneously - hinge on IP addresses being PII (Copyright lawsuits) and at the same time you expect the law to treat IP addresses as through they are not PII? That simply won't fly. So yes, IP addresses are - in many places - seen as PII.

> That everyone is liable for a fine of $20MM for any mistake, innocent or malevolent.

Bullshit.

> The EU itself is hyping up how fearsome this law is to win approval from their citizens and politicians.

Where have they done so? All I've seen to date is some pretty dispassionate pieces and the text of the law itself.

> As well as to strongly encourage firms to take this change seriously.

Yes, you should take it seriously. Of course you should, it is the law.

> But I am at fault for taking the EU seriously rather than being blase.

No, you're at fault by drawing this out of proportion, just like you are doing in this comment.

> I am fearmongering for trying to explain why businesspeople who are not in the EU are afraid of its actions and are afraid of a brand new law that grants a huge amount of discretion to prosecutors and judges.

Your fearmongering is to exaggerate, to focus on the edge cases rather than on the bulk and then to start assuming that all cases are edge cases. They're not. The bulk of the businesses will be just fine. Those that chose to creatively interpret the law to see how far they can push things will hopefully find out that the EU actually means business.

By your reasoning we never should make new laws to deal with changing conditions. The EU tried a gentle approach aka the cookie law, companies tried hard to work their way around the law rather than to stop tracking users every which way they could so now you get this.

Self regulation -> mild regulation -> strong regulation+

(+ you are here now).

> What I know is that the EU can capriciously change its mind and go after the biggest companies for billions of dollars.

Capriciously? I have not seen the EU act capriciously yet. I've seen them act too slow and too late.

> I know that I don't have the resources to prove my innocence in a foreign country.

Poor you. Well, then better not to commit any crimes. That's a pretty good protection against having to defend yourself, stay well clear of that bright line.

> I don't even have the resources to understand the charges against me, since legal translation is expensive and I could be faced with actions in any or all of the languages of the EU.

More bullshit, the law is written in English and if you want to go so far as to take something to court - which I would highly advise against, it is much easier to comply with the law - you will find that the EU courts are set up to deal in English just fine. Lucky you, as opposed to say someone from Latin America, China or Outer Mongolia who does not speak or write English.

> If I get a package of documents in Estonian or Bulgarian I won't even know that I'm facing charges!

The chances of that happening are nil. Really, could you please stop the fearmongering, it does not serve any purpose.

> Claiming universal jurisdiction against every company in the world with a reverse onus of proof is a dangerous and malevolent tactic.

As opposed to what the US does? See: David Carruthers.

> Because it's your local government that you have confidence in, you're comfortable with it.

Yep.

> I doubt that you would be so blase about a similar approach by the US or Japan.

If the US or Japan has laws that apply to my situation I will take great care to comply with them. One such law (the DMCA) has caused me a lot of work over the years and I see this as a cost of doing business. If you don't want to comply with the law then you are taking your chances. Similar to speeding or deciding to kill someone: it's not what you can get away with that determines what is legal or not and if you are caught breaking the law you can expect trouble. So better don't break the law.

Re:EU parliaments website in violation of GDPR by yulaow on Thursday May 17, 2018 @10:11AM (#17091334)
This is stupid, if they wanted to give the finger to American tech firms they could have wrote the GDPR as affecting only foreign firms using EU citizen data without requiring the same level of control over the EU-based tech firms, far easier.
Re:EU parliaments website in violation of GDPR by menacingly on Thursday May 17, 2018 @10:20AM (#17091423)
That's not at all how these things work in the west. You define them as broadly as possible, then arbitrarily enforce them, because that gives you both plausible deniability and the widest potential application of your political power.
Re:EU parliaments website in violation of GDPR by midasz on Thursday May 17, 2018 @10:26AM (#17091483)
It HAS to be broad. The courts will narrow it down (jurisprudence). And why do you think it will be arbitrarily enforced? It isn't even the 25th of may and people are already feeling violated.
Re:EU parliaments website in violation of GDPR by menacingly on Thursday May 17, 2018 @10:34AM (#17091570)
Oh, I don't have a strong opinion on the GDPR and its intent, I was addressing yulaow's simplistic dismissal of what is actually a well-trodden political playbook
Re:EU parliaments website in violation of GDPR by Xeoncross on Thursday May 17, 2018 @10:14AM (#17091355)
Fining everyone makes sense to me. Why limit income? Cities do the same non-discriminate ticketing/fining as well.
Re:EU parliaments website in violation of GDPR by frockington on Thursday May 17, 2018 @10:18AM (#17091397)
Are there any EU based tech firms? As an American I honestly can't think of any besides Nokia and that's more manufacturing
Re:EU parliaments website in violation of GDPR by diggan on Thursday May 17, 2018 @10:29AM (#17091506)
Makes sense, as Americans tend to live in a bubble :)

Some of them from the top of my head, that you might or might not recognize: Asos, JustEat, Skyscanner, SoundCloud, LastFM, DailyMotion, Raspberry PI (foundation more than company though), Shazam, Mojang, Skype, King, Spotify, Klarna, Trivago, Xing and BlaBlaCar. I'm pretty sure some of these are quite popular in even the US.

(maybe some of them are not having their HQ in EU anymore, but they certainly had at one point)

Re:EU parliaments website in violation of GDPR by orf on Thursday May 17, 2018 @10:38AM (#17091617)
And SAP, with 22 billion Euros in revenue
Re:EU parliaments website in violation of GDPR by repolfx on Friday May 18, 2018 @04:03AM (#17099500)
You probably shouldn't insult Americans and then make statements you already know to be erroneous.

As you are apparently well aware, Skype is owned by Microsoft. It's an American product now (from the perspective of who pays any fines). Mojang sold to Microsoft. It and Minecraft are owned by the Americans now.

Asos is an online fashion and beauty retailer. Having a website doesn't make you a tech firm. Ditto for JustEat.

Raspberry Pi - as you note - isn't even a firm at all, let alone a tech firm.

Shazam is in the process of being bought by Apple, although the EU appear to be trying to block it.

You tried to name tech firms that are based inside the EU and mostly ended up listing firms that either aren't tech firms by any conventional definition, or are now owned by US companies. I think that proves the original point.

Re:EU parliaments website in violation of GDPR by diggan on Friday May 18, 2018 @07:57AM (#17100678)
The companies started out being non-american, then they ended up being bought up by US companies. I don't think that says "there is no EU based tech firms" but rather "There are EU based tech firms! But some of them get bought up by US companies and some stay, but at one point they were all EU based". So doesn't at all prove the original point.
Re:EU parliaments website in violation of GDPR by repolfx on Friday May 18, 2018 @02:45PM (#17103916)
In context it is equivalent. This thread is about why the EU wouldn't write a law that only affects US based tech firms, if that was the intention. Someone answered that there's no need because there are no EU based tech firms worth anything (no significant employment or tax revenue).

That point was correct. The responses all ended up naming either firms that are tiny, or which aren't any longer based in the EU (so there's no need to protect them from the effects of bad laws that primarily affect tech firms). Where they started is irrelevant to the discussion because what matters is who pays fines today.

Re:EU parliaments website in violation of GDPR by summermix on Thursday May 17, 2018 @10:53AM (#17091773)
That's because they use English company/product names for the most part. You probably have heard of some of them unknowingly: AVG, Jetbrains, F-Secure, Suse, Last.fm, Dailymotion, Yubico, Raspberry Pi and many more.
Re:EU parliaments website in violation of GDPR by repolfx on Friday May 18, 2018 @04:04AM (#17099506)
JetBrains is a Russian company (albeit with subsidiaries and offices in various parts of the world). It isn't an "EU firm" by any stretch.
Re:EU parliaments website in violation of GDPR by droidist2 on Monday May 21, 2018 @03:10PM (#17120907)
I thought JetBrains was Czech.
Re:EU parliaments website in violation of GDPR by swebs on Thursday May 17, 2018 @10:32AM (#17091538)
Spotify

Skype (Before it was bought and killed by Microsoft)

Rovio

Supercell

Those are all of the big ones off the top of my head. Most founders opt to start in the US since there are less taxes and greater profits.

Re:EU parliaments website in violation of GDPR by Vogtinator on Thursday May 17, 2018 @10:21AM (#17091431)
Quite a lot. Most sell software and support and not cloud services or similiar though.
Re:EU parliaments website in violation of GDPR by marbu on Thursday May 17, 2018 @10:53AM (#17091769)
For example few major anti virus companies are founded in europe, eg. avast, avg, avira, f-secure ...
Re:EU parliaments website in violation of GDPR by chunkyslink on Thursday May 17, 2018 @10:23AM (#17091458)
Some music based ones that I use daily

- spotify.com

- soundcloud.com

- mixcloud.com

Others

- Raspberry Pi

- Wix.com

Re:EU parliaments website in violation of GDPR by pjc50 on Thursday May 17, 2018 @10:37AM (#17091606)
This is rather paranoid: remember that enforcement is done by national authorities like the ICO not europe-wide ones. It's not as radically different from the previous data protection principles as people seem to think, and how much enforcement of those was actually seen?

> EU anti-trust policy - deeply political and immediately controversial

[citation needed]; it's not as if American industrial policy is apolitical and uncontroversial, e.g. https://www.theguardian.com/business/2018/jan/26/bombardier-...

Re:EU parliaments website in violation of GDPR by repolfx on Friday May 18, 2018 @04:08AM (#17099518)
It's well known that the Obama administration felt the EU was using anti-trust law to implement protectionism:

https://www.wired.com/story/google-big-eu-fine/

For his part, President Barack Obama called the EU's actions protectionism. "[Americans] have owned the Internet. Our companies have created it, expanded it, perfected it in ways that [European companies] can’t compete," Obama said in an interview with Recode in 2015. "And oftentimes what is portrayed as high-minded positions on issues sometimes is just designed to carve out some of their commercial interests."

Re:EU parliaments website in violation of GDPR by grey-area on Thursday May 17, 2018 @10:47AM (#17091716)
The goal is to grant the EU large new powers over the private sector and in particular over American tech firms, who will repeatedly be fined and treated as, effectively, a new source of tax income.

No, it really is intended to provide greater control for citizens over their privacy and data stored by corporations.

Re:EU parliaments website in violation of GDPR by rossdavidh on Thursday May 17, 2018 @10:17AM (#17091377)
Another interpretation: IT is really hard, especially for people who don't do it for a living, who thus have less time to learn about it. Writing legislation about IT is equally hard, if not more so. The EU may honestly care about the impact of IT on privacy, but not have the technical ability to write adequately precise legislation about it, or even insure that their own institutional IT is in compliance (assuming it really isn't, and I am not a lawyer).

Do not ascribe to conspiracy, what is adequately explained by incompetence.

Re:EU parliaments website in violation of GDPR by PunchTornado on Thursday May 17, 2018 @10:15AM (#17091361)
Do you have any examples of cases where American companies were fined unjustly by EU?

These companies can attack any fines they receive in the courts.

Re:EU parliaments website in violation of GDPR by englishrookie on Thursday May 17, 2018 @10:31AM (#17091532)
I'm pretty sure the GDPR is enforced at the national level, by national data protection agencies. The one in the Netherlands is severely understaffed and no match for the lawyers of the likes of Google and Facebook.
Re:EU parliaments website in violation of GDPR by frockington on Thursday May 17, 2018 @10:16AM (#17091372)
I have no idea how European court systems work so sorry in advance for what may be stupid questions. What is stopping any company they try to sue from levying investigations against the EU itself if they are not compliant? Does the EU have any sort of executive power that would investigate companys or will it be another VW incident where each company will check the box saying they comply regardless of actual status
Re:EU parliaments website in violation of GDPR by midasz on Thursday May 17, 2018 @10:23AM (#17091455)
Companies cannot sue over GDPR violations (neither can individuals). People can report violations to the GDPR watchdogs who will investigate and could eventually hand out fines.
Re:EU parliaments website in violation of GDPR by ozim on Thursday May 17, 2018 @10:51AM (#17091753)
I think you actually can sue for whatever reason you like but court can say it does not make sense and they will not run the case. It is your responsibility to get enough evidence but it is hard and no one cares enough.

If your data was used without your knowledge you might have had some damage and you could request compensation, removal or other way of fixing damage - with court help of course. GDPR violations can be used as base for court case. So GDPR does not really bring anything new because I believe you already could sue companies for selling your data, but in practice it is not possible to get evidence, prove damage, put price on damage, and it takes too long.

What changes is that if you don't have all data usages listed for user to view it is enough for some action so offended users can suspect something. If watchdog goes and checks you might be in problem with fines and then with court cases from offended users.

Re:EU parliaments website in violation of GDPR by Someone on Thursday May 17, 2018 @03:07PM (#17094477)
”I think you actually can sue for whatever reason you like but court can say it does not make sense and they will not run the case.”

True.

”It is your responsibility to get enough evidence but it is hard and no one cares enough.”

In this case, every “doesn’t comply with the GDPR” case a company starts will be immediately dismissed because:

a) you can’t start a lawsuit on the GDPR. The only way is through a national data protection authority.

b) even if you could, companies wouldn’t be interested parties in such a case.

(By the way, I think the national data protection authorities are the sore spot in the GDPR. I don’t think it is good that they are both prosecutor, jury, and executioner)

Re:EU parliaments website in violation of GDPR by ozim on Thursday May 17, 2018 @06:21PM (#17096590)
I would think of scenario:

"I received unsolicited marketing information from company X, with contact information which was obtained from company Y. I did not agree on sharing my information by company Y. My wife noticed I receive 'grow my manly parts' advertisements from company X. Because of this she concluded I am cheating on her and requested divorce. For such humiliation I request company Y to reimburse damages. Noted by protection authority AU, company Y did not comply to GDPR."

Re:EU parliaments website in violation of GDPR by Someone on Thursday May 17, 2018 @07:15PM (#17097020)
I am not a lawyer, but I don’t think that would fall under prosecuting under the GDPR.

If a speeding car driver hits and injures you, you aren’t going to try and sue him for speeding, either, are you?

You probably would sue under something like “Reckless behavior causing injury” (with the bonus that that even is possible if the driver wasn’t speeding)

Re:EU parliaments website in violation of GDPR by frockington on Thursday May 17, 2018 @12:33PM (#17092848)
So google (or whoever) can just tell stonewall investigators and/or inform them they are GDPR compliant and that's good enough? Are the investigators going to be allowed to examine intellectual property? Sorry for all the questions I am failing to see how this will be able to be enforced
Re:EU parliaments website in violation of GDPR by Bizarro on Thursday May 17, 2018 @10:46AM (#17091705)
The goal is to grant the EU large new powers over the private sector and in particular over American tech firms, who will repeatedly be fined and treated as, effectively, a new source of tax income

I'm guessing the rest of the world will just pull their operations out of the EU and then ignore the law. It obviously has no jurisdiction outside of the EU...despite what EUrocrats and some propaganda here on HN would have you believe.

The rest of the world could also impose sanctions on the EU for illegally claiming global jurisdiction.

Re:EU parliaments website in violation of GDPR by pjc50 on Thursday May 17, 2018 @10:51AM (#17091750)
The US claims global jurisdiction over e.g. Megaupload without sanctions.