News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:NFL Releases Finite Element Helmet Models by matte_black on Tuesday May 15, 2018 @01:12PM (#17075576)
Only thing safer helmets will do is encourage players to hit harder and harder, until someone really gets killed.

I hope one day I will get to see the end of football. Why would any parent enroll their child in this sport?

Re:NFL Releases Finite Element Helmet Models by gldalmaso on Tuesday May 15, 2018 @01:22PM (#17075687)
There are several sports than can be dangerous and involve risk of death, like basically all forms of racing, climbing, endurance, etc. As long as practitioners are educated and consenting, I don't see a problem.

The problem is if the those responsible for the athletes are not upfront on the risks, or if the athlete is not able to make a proper judgement to consent, like a child.

Re:NFL Releases Finite Element Helmet Models by jacobsenscott on Tuesday May 15, 2018 @01:29PM (#17075750)
In all the sports you named - brain injury is not a regular part of the sport - it happens when something goes wrong. In football players suffer mild traumatic brain injury in every game, as a regular part of game play.
Re:NFL Releases Finite Element Helmet Models by rkangel on Wednesday May 16, 2018 @06:21AM (#17081252)
While this seems to be the likely scenario, this isn't actually known for sure yet. We know that every concussion causes cumulative damage, but it is unclear what level of sub-concussive hit causes cumulative damage? It's almost certainly not 'none', but we don't know whether it's a light tap, or an almost concussive hit. For example, it could be that concussion is a red herring and certain angles and acceleration profiles are the issue and these don't correlate at all with concussion.
Re:NFL Releases Finite Element Helmet Models by privacypoller on Tuesday May 15, 2018 @01:39PM (#17075880)
Yes, there are risks in all these activities, the problem with full-contact football, or hockey & lacrosse is that there is no way to be educated and consenting for an aspect that is inherent to the very nature of the activity, especially if you're a kid.

Up in Canada the pro-contact hockey crowd loves to talk about "teaching kids how to hit properly" which I'd suspect is a similar attitude to those coaching 5-yr-olds in full-pads football. But what does this mean? They seem to think that by addressing the technique of what is at it's a core a violent and damaging activity you can somehow mitigate the effects. I'm not buying it. Football is even worse; it's not the highlight reel tackles but the every single play collisions at the line that lead to long term, consistently demonstrated traumatic head injuries.

Frankly I feel that the NFL working to address the root causes of head injuries is like asking Facebook to take care of personal information and privacy protection. They are entirely incompatible.

Re:NFL Releases Finite Element Helmet Models by soperj on Tuesday May 15, 2018 @08:35PM (#17079092)
you don't even start contact in hockey until your teens.

Hitting properly means using your shoulders and hitting the player in the shoulders or chest.

Re:NFL Releases Finite Element Helmet Models by dingaling on Wednesday May 16, 2018 @09:28AM (#17082181)
Specifically ice hockey, I assume?

Field hockey ( just called hockey in Europe ) doesn't involve bodily contact.

Re:NFL Releases Finite Element Helmet Models by Cerium on Tuesday May 15, 2018 @01:28PM (#17075736)
The problem with sports like football is that they are an accumulative damage sport as opposed to a safe until accident sport.
Re:NFL Releases Finite Element Helmet Models by jsgo on Tuesday May 15, 2018 @02:55PM (#17076647)
Racing is the closest, but with climbing and endurance, you're battling the environment and yourself. In football, the person going after you provides a factor you really can't plan for.
Re:NFL Releases Finite Element Helmet Models by ggg9990 on Tuesday May 15, 2018 @01:18PM (#17075641)
The US has a violence fetish, the same way that the UK has a class fetish. The football quarterback is the highest status kid in the school because he is the leader of an organization demonstrated to deliver and endure violence.
Re:NFL Releases Finite Element Helmet Models by adventured on Tuesday May 15, 2018 @01:34PM (#17075813)
Your premise is very weak in relation to US sports being a supporting argument.

It comes across as though you've never actually played football or been on a football team. Players on one team largely go out of their way to avoid injuring players on the other team. The vast majority of the game is free motion, not the application of violence. Another large fraction of the game is what can best be described as aggressive shoving and using your body to push or block, not super violent at all.

The quarterback, further, doesn't lead the defense. The job of the offense, which the QB leads, is to score. Ideally that occurs with the minimum amount of violence necessary, not the maximum amount. Offensive players mostly want to avoid that whenever possible. The quarterback does not inherently lead the team and does not lead the defense at all (ie the primary appliers of violence).

The quarterback is popular because he's the center of the offense, which does the scoring, which is exciting. Not because he leads a violent machine. Basketball players in high school that are talented, are equally popular, because scoring points is exciting in every sport.

Hockey is occasionally a quite violent sport. Gretzky wasn't one of the most popular players in hockey history because he was violent - it was because he scored at a rate nobody else ever has. The same goes for Mario Lemieux and countless other scorers.

Baseball is particularly not violent. You know, America's pastime sport that tens of millions of people go to see every year and is wildly popular.

Basketball is no more violent than soccer.

Re:NFL Releases Finite Element Helmet Models by privacypoller on Tuesday May 15, 2018 @01:47PM (#17075988)
You sound like maybe you've played football. If so, you must recognize that it's nothing particular about any sort of violent acts that makes it so dangerous, but the technique where action at the line teaches driving up from the shoulders to the head which leads to repetitive contact.

The big open-field head-on-head hits are horrific but not the ones that lead to every single brain that's been analyzed showing evidence of CTE.

The NFL will live with having to handle the freak accidents; they can't exist in a world where playing football => long term traumatic brain injury

Re:NFL Releases Finite Element Helmet Models by ggg9990 on Tuesday May 15, 2018 @03:00PM (#17076679)
Perhaps a military metaphor is best —- the QB role is no more violent than Army general, and the players and soldiers are the ones who are most sickened by the violence and injury. That doesn’t change the fact that both football and war have fans who watch on TV and love to see the biggest hits and biggest bombs.
Re:NFL Releases Finite Element Helmet Models by kolbe on Tuesday May 15, 2018 @04:15PM (#17077496)
>Perhaps a military metaphor is best

Perhaps an actual argument that supports your claim would be better. You haven't even established for a fact that the US likes violent entertainment more than other nations. So start there before moving on to 1980's teenage comedy notions of high school popularity to explain it.

Re:NFL Releases Finite Element Helmet Models by salvar on Tuesday May 15, 2018 @03:49PM (#17077219)
Given how strongly you talk about football here you must have a good understanding of the sport. How much experience have you had with football, either playing or watching?
Re:NFL Releases Finite Element Helmet Models by ggg9990 on Tuesday May 15, 2018 @04:05PM (#17077385)
A lot of watching, and my claim is only about the fans, not the players, so I’m not sure how any playing experience would help me here. I know that millions of people have watched Lawrence Taylor’s career ending tackle of Joe Thiesmann while Lawrence Taylor has himself never watched it.
Re:NFL Releases Finite Element Helmet Models by Sohcahtoa82 on Tuesday May 15, 2018 @08:11PM (#17078979)
In case anyone hasn't seen it:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mznBvAGScdg

Re:NFL Releases Finite Element Helmet Models by tgb on Tuesday May 15, 2018 @01:31PM (#17075771)
Surely this is better explained as just another instance of best-player-of-most-popular-sport-is-popular? The same dynamic happens in countries where the considerably less violent of the two "footballs" is played. And star basketball players also are extraordinarily popular. Maybe the only distinction in American football being that a single individual gets to make nearly all the scoring plays and is designated with a specific role so that everyone knows who they are.
Re:NFL Releases Finite Element Helmet Models by jedberg on Tuesday May 15, 2018 @03:44PM (#17077170)
> Why would any parent enroll their child in this sport?

For the poor, it is a way out. Even if you don't hit the pro level, being good at football can get you a full ride scholarship to a great school.

One of my friends at Berkeley was in exactly this situation. He grew up very very poor, played football at the local high school, and managed to get a football scholarship to Berkeley. He wasn't very good at football, and rarely played at all, but he did get a full ride scholarship that covered tuition, housing, food, books, and a small stipend for living expenses. He also got a job working in the residence halls, which also came with free housing and food, so he basically made money in college.

Then he graduated with a PhD in Education. He could have never afforded that without football.

Re:NFL Releases Finite Element Helmet Models by bgroins on Tuesday May 15, 2018 @03:55PM (#17077278)
If only we used all of that money spent on football programs to pay for higher education for poor kids. Wishful thinking I know.
Re:NFL Releases Finite Element Helmet Models by jedberg on Tuesday May 15, 2018 @04:18PM (#17077515)
There's an argument to be made that football helps a lot more than just the football players. At most big football schools, the money they make from football pays for all of the athletes in all sports, men and women (along with the basketball profits to some extent).

That's a lot of student athletes getting scholarships, and most of them don't continue in their sport after graduation.

Re:NFL Releases Finite Element Helmet Models by forapurpose on Tuesday May 15, 2018 @05:51PM (#17078194)
The reality is that many football programs are subsidized by their universities. The elite schools may profit, but there are hundreds of schools with football programs.

There are major downsides too: The kids are often used; they work incredibly hard, get paid nothing, and then get tossed in the gutter unless they make the NFL. Literally, I've read many stories where the coach stops talking to the kid (remember, 18, 19 years old often) and then someone gives him a bus ticket home - so much for education. The great majority of those who stay don't make the NFL; they leave with a lifetime of injuries, poor education (because they were discouraged from taking serious classes and often don't graduate), and no skills or prospects. The school, however, made tens or hundreds of millions, the coach made millions, TV networks made millions (billions?) ... a great business having free labor.

Also, the money and the intense loyalty invites incredible corruption; almost every leading program has had major corruption problems, with Penn State being the worst (systematic child rape covered up for years, so that the football program wouldn't be disrupted).

EDIT: Major edits

Re:NFL Releases Finite Element Helmet Models by kolbe on Tuesday May 15, 2018 @04:09PM (#17077426)
Football enriches most universities, giving them extra funds to do things like provide scholarships.
Re:NFL Releases Finite Element Helmet Models by joshuas on Tuesday May 15, 2018 @05:02PM (#17077839)
This is not true, most universities lose money on their sports programs.
Re:NFL Releases Finite Element Helmet Models by Someone on Tuesday May 15, 2018 @05:22PM (#17077981)
I don’t know whether it is true, but “Football enriches most universities“ is not inconsistent with that. Football may bring in less money than the other sports cost.
Re:NFL Releases Finite Element Helmet Models by nkozyra on Wednesday May 16, 2018 @09:27PM (#17087931)
> For the poor, it is a way out.

Which, frankly, makes the fact that you cannot enter the NFL at 18 even more egregious. It's a mutually beneficial scenario for the NCAA and the NFL at the expense of (often disadvantaged) people at or near the physical peak of their career.

Re:NFL Releases Finite Element Helmet Models by francisofascii on Tuesday May 15, 2018 @01:36PM (#17075846)
Simply play two hand touch or flag. Football is a fun game to watch and play without tackling.
Re:NFL Releases Finite Element Helmet Models by privacypoller on Tuesday May 15, 2018 @01:42PM (#17075918)
I agree with you that this addresses the game of football, but certainly not the business of football.

Which one do you think the NFL cares more about?

Re:NFL Releases Finite Element Helmet Models by jsgo on Tuesday May 15, 2018 @03:05PM (#17076736)
In the modern era, people bemoan that officials are extra protective of quarterbacks relative to previous generations due to and specifically for Tom Brady. Common refrain, right?

But the thing is: they still watch. Yeah, there'd be calls of it being "soft" or "these guys couldn't play with the greats from yesteryear" or the like as there are now, but they'd still watch. The second biggest sport in the US that I can think of (could very well be wrong) is the NBA and it isn't really known for violence being beneficial to the players/game (after the 90s, a lot of what would fly before stopped). Yeah, there are flops or drawing flags by intentionally getting into a play, but it seems the preferred method to force fouls at the end of the game isn't to blindside your opponent but to draw the ref's attention and hold/grab the opposing player.

I was a bit bummed with the "boycott" over the knee taking as I had actually stopped watching around the same time due to all of the CTE research that came out around the same time. Hated the feeling that somehow me not watching due to that was going to get tallied in with people who are anti-protest. I do think if they could solve this problem (CTE), I'd be game to watch again, but I honestly think it isn't solvable.

Re:NFL Releases Finite Element Helmet Models by r00fus on Tuesday May 15, 2018 @02:13PM (#17076233)
NFL players are like the modern gladiator. They look resplendent in their armor.

It's core to the image of Football.

Re:NFL Releases Finite Element Helmet Models by francisofascii on Tuesday May 15, 2018 @02:16PM (#17076274)
If the NFL switched to two hand touch 10 years from now, people would still watch. The violence is not essential. The competition, strategy, amazing throws and catches, speed, team aspect, drama, and unpredictability make it fun to watch.
Re:NFL Releases Finite Element Helmet Models by awgm on Tuesday May 15, 2018 @03:34PM (#17077069)
I would be very surprised if football survived at the level of popularity it enjoys now without the violent hits
Re:NFL Releases Finite Element Helmet Models by atommclain on Tuesday May 15, 2018 @01:58PM (#17076100)
Risk compensation. For those interested, here is the relevant Wikipedia article: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Risk_compensation
Re:NFL Releases Finite Element Helmet Models by kaycebasques on Tuesday May 15, 2018 @03:14PM (#17076844)
Universal Principles Of Design [1] mentions this, as well. Rather counterintuitively, the solution for reducing brain injuries in football may be to remove helmets altogether.

[1] https://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/ASIN/1592535879/amsi-20

Re:NFL Releases Finite Element Helmet Models by jpindar on Tuesday May 15, 2018 @08:42PM (#17079125)
There was a time when American football players didn't wear helmets, or wore only soft leather ones. Men DIED on the field from head injuries. In 1905 there were 19 fatalities.
Re:NFL Releases Finite Element Helmet Models by megaman22 on Tuesday May 15, 2018 @01:39PM (#17075885)
Because it's a blast to play. And treating children like they are made of glass is a terrible way to raise them.
Re:NFL Releases Finite Element Helmet Models by post_break on Tuesday May 15, 2018 @05:50PM (#17078187)
At what point do we stop banning things because someone else doesn't like it?
Re:NFL Releases Finite Element Helmet Models by 0xffff2 on Tuesday May 15, 2018 @06:48PM (#17078589)
Who said anything about banning something? It looks entirely plausible to me that football will die out within my lifetime simply because people don't want to play or watch it anymore.
Re:NFL Releases Finite Element Helmet Models by briffle on Tuesday May 15, 2018 @01:16PM (#17075608)
So your advocating for an abstinence only education, when it comes to football?
Re:NFL Releases Finite Element Helmet Models by komali2 on Tuesday May 15, 2018 @01:20PM (#17075657)
Or, to not have helmets at all, or much thinner helmets. Much like bare-knuckle or thin-padded gloves contribute to less "hard" hits being thrown in UFC than in boxing, or how Rugby players don't get the kind of brain injuries because they aren't smacking their heads into eachother as hard as football players are.
Re:NFL Releases Finite Element Helmet Models by slg on Tuesday May 15, 2018 @01:47PM (#17075984)
Helmets were introduced because a dozen plus kids were dying every year playing it due to things like skull fractures. Football is an inherently violent game and it is because of the rules not the helmets.
Re:NFL Releases Finite Element Helmet Models by lloydde on Wednesday May 16, 2018 @12:09PM (#17083502)
UFC: study that supports that assetion verses other factors like less money/rewards, shorter careers and full body contact? Different weight classes? Boxing vs Muay Thai? Yes, intuitively smaller gloves should contribute to less slow damage, but should also cause more acute and immediate injuries.
Re:NFL Releases Finite Element Helmet Models by sakuronto on Tuesday May 15, 2018 @01:39PM (#17075876)
Yes, in the same way I'd argue for an abstinence-only education when it comes to repeatedly bashing your own head against the wall.
Re:NFL Releases Finite Element Helmet Models by bcohen5055 on Tuesday May 15, 2018 @01:31PM (#17075766)
Yes, because seat belts and airbags only encourage people to drive faster and more reckless
Re:NFL Releases Finite Element Helmet Models by blueatlas on Tuesday May 15, 2018 @03:37PM (#17077094)
But there's no legal or financial liability for a football player running faster or hitting harder. He can pretty much do it without recourse and actually have people cheer him for his impressive speed and strength.
Re:NFL Releases Finite Element Helmet Models by jessaustin on Thursday May 17, 2018 @01:49PM (#17093606)
Ask a cyclist about that. Risk compensation is real.