If I'm lucky, there will be a limited-time Undo button after doing the action (GMail has this on some actions but not others!), but if I hesitate too long or accidentally click on anything but it, it goes away permanently. I'm sure I've lost some important email to the depth of time because of a few fatfinger mistaps.
A 'peek' already provides a preview of an item -- it just isn't used for action buttons. 'Peeking' into the name and description of an icon would be a fairly straightforward extension of the idea.
It just... isn't used that way.
Well, anything that isn't a text/content editor (or a file system manager, which I had forgotten to mention), so basically the vast majority of computer usage. Settings in applications, navigation state of applications, state of the OS/window manager itself (I'm not aware of a desktop environment where moving or closing a window or application supports an undo feature), etc. Web browsers and most file managers do support back and forward navigation, if you want to count that as "undo."
The comment I was initially replying to talked about being afraid to press buttons in modern UIs because of the lack of undo. My claim is that, except for buttons that change formatting in text/content editors or buttons that make changes in some file system managers, undo functionality has really never existed to my knowledge.
Not in practice, as this feature is universally broken by modern web developers, making it totally unreliable.
You have a good point about undo - it was universally a feature for reverting operations on edited data, not on application state itself. But then again, it was compensated by buttons having reliable tooltips, and most options available in textual menus.
Firefox's tab history seems quite deep, I can CTRL-SHIFT-T many times.
iPhone implemented shake to undo back with iPhone 3.0
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Undo
http://osxdaily.com/2009/08/21/undo-button-iphone-shaking-mo...
Of course you can Undo something like Archiving a message. That's the Mac way, since 1984.
But after a decade of using gmail, it's not even something I would think to do.
What I am less confident of is what happens when that notification goes away.
In the real world we shakes things to mix them up, not to revert to a previous state i.e. shaking increases entropy.
I wonder who at Apple decided otherwise and why. Perhaps someone with a doctorate in cosmology who is fighting against heat-death.
The whole point of icons is that you don't need to "discover" what they do. They're supposed to be intuitive.
To me an arrow pointing down means "download," not "select all."
If you can't convey your meaning inside a 16x16px monochrome block, then perhaps that's not the best choice for the task at hand.
Time to innovate.
Also, Google's choice to deviate from every other mobile menu icon on the planet (the hamburger menu) is a sign of hubris, not an effort to help the customer.
Once you've hovered over the icon and learned its meaning then you can recognize it by the picture.
Underline anywhere.
Paragraph justification.
Copyboard for paste.
Fill bucket for fill.
These are intuitive for most people for whom they were targeted.
Three bars for a menu is not intuitive.
Cut has a whole heap of connotations that don't relate to the editing "cut" operation. Google suggests incision, wound, to separate into parts, "remove (something) from something larger by using a sharp implement". Editing cut doesn't do any of this.
There is a very specific link in that relocating text /could be/ thought of as snipping it off a page and pasting it somewhere else, except no-one would ever do that when writing seriously. They erase and rewrite.
So the scissors icon links to the word cut, but cut itself is actually a mystery-meat operation where figuring it out is hard for users that aren't already savvy with interfaces. By extension, the scissors icon has no link to the actual operation that the button performs.
In image programs there is literally a white gap where to object was. Word processors would redo line breaks and hide the original location.
In a few years, three bars will be just as intuitive to most users, and probably be the intuitive icon we use as a reference when complaining that the icon to switch on ranged machine-brain interaction instead of touch interface isn't as intuitive as established iconography.
> Copyboard for paste.
I don't even know what on Earth is a "copyboard". Is this some arcane tool from early XX-century newspaper office?
I miss the days when software people cared about built-in user guides.
Absolutely not true.
The word "icon" originated with religious artwork and was used to tell stories to the people at a time when 99% of the population was illiterate.
Governments spend millions of dollars on research to design important icons that will be completely intuitive for hundreds or thousands of years. Things like the radioactive trefoil, or the biohazard sign. (Google it, there's lots of articles about this.)
Nobody wants to tell some future human, "Oh, sorry you sank into a 4,000-year-old pool of radioactive sludge and died. You should have "learned" it was dangerous ahead of time. At least you "discovered" what it means, now that you're dead."
> millions of dollars on research to design important icons that will be completely intuitive for hundreds or thousands of years.
And the results of that research is that conclusion that such icons are impossible to create. https://99percentinvisible.org/episode/ten-thousand-years/
> Nobody wants to tell some future human, "Oh, sorry you sank into a 4,000-year-old pool of radioactive sludge and died. You should have "learned" it was dangerous ahead of time. At least you "discovered" what it means, now that you're dead."
Of course not. They tell some future human: "I'm glad you stayed out of that pool. It's great that you learned what the skull+crossbones icon meant during your childhoold."
However, it may just be a misunderstanding. The quote that you said was "absolutely not true" had two statements:
> No icon anywhere is intuitive. They're all learned.
I'm not saying that symbols, found in religious icons or elsewhere, can't be "intuitive", in the sense that there's some underlying logic or they're otherwise easier to understand than a set of symbols picked at random. (That said, many of them, like the aforementioned Eastern Orthodox clothing colors, do seem fully arbitrary.) I'm just saying that they're also "learned", i.e. you can't (fully) make sense of them without prior understanding.
By the way, your mention of radioactivity reminds me of the US government's attempt to design markers for nuclear waste sites which can be understood many thousands of years into the future, without a common language – e.g. as described in this article:
https://www.ft.com/content/db87c16c-4947-11e6-b387-64ab0a670...
This is an interesting problem precisely because it is hard to unambiguously convey abstract concepts using iconography without context – even a concept as simple as "this place is dangerous". Thus, the proposals end up being rather complex.
Here's Charles Baldwin [involved in developing the biohazard symbol] telling you the goals of the project:
> We wanted something that was memorable but meaningless, so we could educate people as to what it means.
And all the research into the latter problem? There'd be a whole lot less of it if the biohazard icon were intuitive.
Instead, in the context of the US Waste Isolation Pilot Plant, we have ideas like a scary looking 'Landscape of thorns' being shut down because interesting looking places could become tourist attractions, the idea of starting a religious tradition around the area being seriously considered, and the conclusion that, ultimately, there's no good solution.
I don't even use Gmail anymore (I've completely switched over to Inbox) but when I opened that article the first thing I did was "read" all the icons on the page. The only ones I had trouble with were "Mark as Read" and "Move to Folder", but even those only took a couple seconds of thought for me to comprehend.
I have it the same even with labels, truth to be told. I hate that nowadays Google seems to shuffle All, Images, Videos, News around, because I learned that Images are always the second one and then it opens Videos on full moon and News on Wednesday. Now I have to always parse before I tap/click.
Well, Inbox shares quite a few of these obscure icons (like the "stop sign with exclamation mark" icon for spam), only they captioned them.
So as an Inbox user you've basically seen the cheat sheet quite a few times. This sort of invalidates your test imho.
I'd argue that an important element of UI is discoverability. Yes, a "A box with downward arrow" is not in and of itself enlightening about what it does. By looking at that icon I am not sure what it does. However, I can discover what it does in very few actions. Clicking on it results in selecting all the emails on the page, and the box changes to checked. Clicking the down icon results in a selection menu with "All", "None", "Read", "Unread" and "Starred"[0]. Clicking on one of those items selects only those items. Given that interaction, can anyone here say they still don't understand what it does? My one criticism is that selecting something like "stared" doesn't filter down to only those items too, so you can now select things that aren't on the page of items you're currently seeing.
Apple's original iOS did not convey a sense of "immediate understanding" that this article demands, but rather focused on discoverability. That is the same mentality that went into make this UI/UX. My point is you can't judge one without the other. Removing all animations from the original iOS would have come close to ruining it. Showing a picture of a Google UI, and criticizing it without allowing it the benefit of discoverability is tantamount to the same lack of context as removing those animations.
Also, following this posts advice:
> Luckily, this menu can be switched to text labels in Settings.
And changing to text button labels[1] doesn't even change that first icon[2], so I'm not sure that post is really for any other purpose than creating material for some echo chamber.
[0] https://i.imgur.com/D8CogSS.png
[1] https://i.imgur.com/jOaTKDs.png
[2] https://i.imgur.com/tkhSoom.png