That is why it was stricken. If it said it was illegal everywhere, then the supreme court would have upheld that.
Maybe one way of summing this up that makes more sense of the distinction is this: Congress can make laws that regulate behavior as a general matter (subject to other constitutional restrictions), but cannot regulate directly the behavior of state governments themselves.
It's unusual for congress to do the former but not the latter, but that appears to have been the case here.
The classic problematic rationale, that the court discusses in cases like Printz [1] is also dislocation of the political costs of enforcement away from federal officials onto state officials.
2. Enforcing it at the federal level costs money. It's easier to pass a ban where you force the states to pay the costs.
In addition, the Ninth Circuit has held that Congress has Commerce Clause authority to criminalize possession of homemade machine guns.
Congress has chosen to allow states to regulate gambling to a certain extent, which explains its legality in various forms in the various states.
To transfer enforcement costs, including for hosting civil actions outside of the situations where state law claims get into federal court, to state law enforcement and courts.
Do you have quote from the decision to support this? It seems to conflict with what I excerpted and the analysis I've seen.
Media reports like to spin it as "sports gambling is illegal except in XYZ states", to make it look like favoritism and the story inciteful, but really the only thing distinguishing those states is legacy code.
State-specific laws have an infamous history: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Missouri_Compromise
The Professional and Amateur Sports Protection Act (PASPA) makes it unlawful for a State or its subdivisions “to sponsor, operate, advertise, promote, license, or authorize by law or compact . . . a lottery, sweepstakes, or other betting, gambling, or wagering scheme based . . . on” competitive sporting events, 28 U. S. C. §3702(1), and for “a person to sponsor, operate, advertise, or promote” those same gambling schemes if done “pursuant to the law or compact of a governmental entity,” §3702(2). But PASPA does not make sports gambling itself a federal crime. Instead, it allows the Attorney General, as well as professional and amateur sports organizations, to bring civil actions to enjoin violations.
That is, rather than say sports gambling shall be declared illegal, they made it a civil offense for a state to pass a law legalizing sports gambling.
Either way, it looks pretty clearly unconstitutional, since it's making a "constitution-level" rule about how State governments operate.
1) “Congress may not simply ‘commandeer the legislative process of the States by directly compelling them to enact and enforce a federal regulatory program.’”
and
2) "The distinction between compelling a State to enact legislation and prohibiting a State from enacting new laws is an empty one. The basic principle—that Congress cannot issue direct orders to state legislature—applies in either event."
3) "... since the Constitution “confers upon Congress the power to regulate individuals, not States,” ... "There is no way that the PASPA anti-authorization provision can be understood as a regulation of private actors. It does not confer any federal rights on private actors interested in conducting sports gambling operations or impose any federal restrictions on private actors."
My understanding of this case:
Congress can say ‘sports betting is illegal’, but they didn’t. They said ‘states much make sports betting illegal’. Congress doesn’t have the power to force states to pass laws, so the law is unconstitutional.
They could have done what they did in the alcohol situation (or many others) and said ‘if you don’t make sports betting illegal you don’t get law enforcement money from the feds’ or something like that.
That would have been (presumptively) constitutional. If the terms are too onerous the law could have been struck down.
But instead they used a power they clearly don’t have.
Interesting it survived this long.
Does anyone know why they didn’t just ban it directly instead of trying to make states do it? Was that the only way to give Nevada an exemption?
Not just interesting but discouraging, in my opinion. This unconstitutional rule affected billions of dollars of commerce for a quarter century. The legislators who passed it and the president who signed it (G.H.W. Bush) face no repercussions, so there's no disincentive for future law-makers to do similar things in the future.
I'm not sure I'd support something so extreme as having court review of unchallenged law, but it makes me consider it...
So many laws scrape through as the result of extreme "lobbying" and "productive donations". This investment of time and money is rewarded by the fact that once laws are passed they are extremely rarely overturned. Expiring laws would also help work against this sort of corruption. It would also help with things like the 'Patriot Act.' That bill was passed when the country was in a state of mindless panic, yet it lingers today. The government doesn't want to get rid of it since it massively expands their power, but at the same time - if they actually had to vote on it again, it would be extremely difficult to justify.
And finally it might make our legal code begin to be somewhat comprehensible. That you, without question, need to be a professional just to understand our legal code. And that even within that profession there are countless areas of expertise -- that is quite absurd. How can people be expected to obey (or critique) a system of law that they are in no way expected to have even the faintest grasp of, other than in the most broad meaningless strokes?
Is this some kind of sarcasm I'm not getting? PATRIOT Act in fact had expiring provisions, and government in fact did vote to extend it, three times actually.
I guess the question this proposal raises is if congress would actually review the laws, or just blanket renew everything, except when they're exceptionally dysfunctional. If the renewal comes late, does it still count as a renewal or is a new law, starting at 2 years?
NJ has been fighting this for almost 10 years. They were facing their biggest opposition from the sports leagues. It just goes to show the political sway the NFL, NCAA and MLB have over the government.
And the established gambling industry. They could have simply made sports betting illegal, instead of passing a law that enables current donors to continue doing it, but forces new e-businesses, frequently incorporated outside of the country, to stop.
I believe that there is a requirement that the money the Federal government threatens to withhold has to be for things related to the thing the Federal government wants the state to regulate.
The purported motivation for the Federal government wanting the drinking age to be 21 is to increase highway safety, so they can tie Federal highway funds to drinking age via highway safety.
This is also why most of the Federal aid cuts that the current administration threatened so-called "sanctuary" cities with did not worry the cities. Most of them were not in areas that could reasonably be tied to enforcing immigration law.
I would guess that most Federal law enforcement aid is for things sufficiently unrelated to sports gambling related crime that conditioning it on states changing sport betting laws would not fly.
The federal government used a bit of a loophole here. Instead of regulating individual states, they simply set a drinking age of 21 as a requirement, else they'll lose 10 percent of their federal highway funds.
Interesting case law the above poster is referencing I think: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/South_Dakota_v._Dole
Notably one of the dissenting judges said this: "establishment of a minimum drinking age of 21 is not sufficiently related to interstate highway construction to justify so conditioning funds appropriated for that purpose."
It did however pass the supreme court at 7-2.
Not necessarily. Pretty much every state had to ask themselves the same question: "Do we care more about highway funding or the very small number of people 18-21 who vote?"
It's actually a very easy question in political calculus terms.
No.
Our political system involves some specific separations of powers, but politics is not fundamentally about thst.
https://www.theatlantic.com/politics/archive/2014/07/four-ti...
Trump has tried to restrict federal funding to "sanctuary cities" as a way to coerce them into prosecuting illegal immigrants. It was struck down as not passing the South Dakota test, but he may try again.
http://www.cbc.ca/news/world/trump-executive-order-sanctuary...
The federal government also prohibits states from stopping federal funding of Planed Parenthood, which arguably cross-subsidizes (though does not directly fund) abortion.
https://qz.com/863101/title-x-obama-enacts-a-law-mandating-t...
What's this? Google just returns a bunch of results for the South Dakota DMV exam.
It is worth noting that alcohol regulations might be a bit of a special case. It not merely a federal crime but is unconstitutional for a corporation or individual to transport alcohol into a state in violation of the laws of that state.
To me, how case law enshrines coerced decisions in the court, is something that should be addressed.
Basically that Congress is able to pass a federal law to prevent sports gambling but does not have the power to force states to pass and enforce state laws against sports gambling.
>but they can't restrict what laws states pass?
Restricing a state from passing a law is quite different from federally mandating a state to pass a law.
It's not clear Congress has that power. The much more pertinent fact is that Congress can induce states to pass laws by withholding funding.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/South_Dakota_v._Dole
> Restricting a state from passing a law is quite different from federally mandating a state to pass a law.
From the decision:
"The distinction between compelling a State to enact legislation and prohibiting a State from enacting new laws is an empty one. The basic principle—that Congress cannot issue direct orders to state legislature—applies in either event."
This is SCOTUS throwing down a gauntlet. Sports gambling, virtually all of which being online, is ripe for commerce clause regulation. Congress knows how it can take the reigns if it wants to. SCOTUS is saying it isn't going to accept half-hearted attempts to regulate in this area... in full knowledge that a serious legislative effort in this area is near-impossible in the current climate. This is the supreme court asserting itself, showing that with the legislature so weakened it can exercise control over national policies. imho.
Like that a group of people who spent their entire academic and professional careers studying how subtle shifts in texts adjust balance of power, and how ambiguous rulemaking leads to unintended consequences have a deep and overwhelming interest in how people entertain themselves online.
If your business is making rules about rules, then you're going to see everything else as parochial, you're playing a game with slightly higher stakes.
It's like someone proposing a change in an instruction set and everyone's focused on possible impacts on UX for a handful of websites.
> You can always interpret any SCOTUS decision in terms of ... immediate outcomes [but generally shouldn't]
> This isn't such a case. The court is not basing its opinion on immediate outcomes.
I think we agree? I must have completely misread your original post, where I thought you said that SCOTUS was making a policy decision.
Uh, that's mostly not what judges spend their professional careers doing or what lawyers spend their academic careers doing.
It's what academic political scientists focussing on judicial and regulatory politics do, but that's not a background that tends to get you nominated for the Supreme Court.
I disagree, based on my academic experience preparing to be a lawyer and my nerdy conversations with my friends who are judges.
You could just learn the rote practice and skip jurisprudence entirely, but everyone on the supreme court understands the phrase "canon of construction" by this point in their career, along with various other meta-rulemaking principles.
In general, I don't find unified personifications of groups of disagreeing humans to be very illuminating. Do you have any evidence this particular ruling is a coordinated action by the justices of the Supreme Court to communicate anything beyond their explicit decision to anyone? Or are you just speculating?
The federal government can make it illegal for people to place sports bet or run a gambling ring, because it has authority and sovereignty over the people in the United States.
The federal government has rather wide authority. For example, Congress could make it illegal for American citizens to gamble in Canada (In the same way, it used to be illegal to do business with Cuba). However, Congress cannot pass a law saying that Canada cannot legalize gambling, because the government of the United States has no authority over the sovereign government of Canada.
Similarly, the federal government can make it illegal for its residents to gamble. However, it cannot exercise authority not directly given to it over the state governments, because the federal government has no authority over the sovereign state governments. The state governments and the feds share sovereignty over the boundaries of each state, but the state government retains all aspects of sovereignty not explicitly given to the feds. Gambling is one of those things that the states retain sovereignty over.
There is a much stronger interstate commerce clause claim for a very broad prohibition here (say, effecting any betting either on any competition involving an interstate or international sports league, or where the bet crosses state or national borders, or using regulated wire or broadcast communication channels) than for many things that have survived challenge the whole way through the Supreme Court, so while I recognize that many people have narrow personal interpretations of the Commerce Clause power, I don't think that is actually a real practical barrier here.
That is my personal interpretation of the constitution. But if you read the supreme court decision, the majority opinion states that they can.
> Congress can regulate sports gambling directly, but if it elects not to do so, each State is free to act on its own. Our job is to interpret the law Congress has enacted and decide whether it is consistent with the Constitution. PASPA is not. PASPA “regulate[s] state governments’ regulation” of their citizens.... The Constitution gives Congress no such power.
https://www.supremecourt.gov/opinions/17pdf/16-476_dbfi.pdf
I don't quite understand what they're saying here...I guess the idea is that Congress can regulate gambling -- assuming some constitutional justification like the commerce clause -- but they can't restrict what laws states pass? (Of course, per drinking ages, they can tax states citizens and then release that tax money back to the states conditional on state s enacting certain laws.)
Here is extensive coverage on the excellent SCOTUSblog
http://www.scotusblog.com/case-files/cases/murphy-v-national...
Other HN submission (Bloomberg article):
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17065652