Re:US Supreme Court strikes down federal law prohibiting spo...
by d0lph on Monday May 14, 2018 @02:29PM
(#17068104)
That always seemed wrong to me, isn't politics about the separation of powers, why do we allow them to exert control like that?
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:US Supreme Court strikes down federal law prohibiting spo...
by Kalium on Monday May 14, 2018 @04:00PM
(#17068930)
Congress has the power of controlling funding they choose to hand out, and this doesn't meet the test of being "irresistibly coercive" to states. And states really want that highway funding...
Re:US Supreme Court strikes down federal law prohibiting spo...
by d0lph on Monday May 14, 2018 @04:12PM
(#17069040)
Wouldn't you expect to see some states to not comply then?
Interesting case law the above poster is referencing I think: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/South_Dakota_v._Dole
Notably one of the dissenting judges said this: "establishment of a minimum drinking age of 21 is not sufficiently related to interstate highway construction to justify so conditioning funds appropriated for that purpose."
It did however pass the supreme court at 7-2.
Re:US Supreme Court strikes down federal law prohibiting spo...
by Kalium on Monday May 14, 2018 @05:33PM
(#17069648)
> Wouldn't you expect to see some states to not comply then?
Not necessarily. Pretty much every state had to ask themselves the same question: "Do we care more about highway funding or the very small number of people 18-21 who vote?"
It's actually a very easy question in political calculus terms.
Re:US Supreme Court strikes down federal law prohibiting spo...
by gowld on Monday May 14, 2018 @04:14PM
(#17069062)
It's still clearly bad law, a ruling that's more based in the power politics of Legistative vs Judiciary, and Federal vs State, than it is about logic of Constitutional analysis.
Re:US Supreme Court strikes down federal law prohibiting spo...
by dragonwriter on Monday May 14, 2018 @07:19PM
(#17070284)
> isn't politics about the separation of powers
No.
Our political system involves some specific separations of powers, but politics is not fundamentally about thst.
Re:US Supreme Court strikes down federal law prohibiting spo...
by d0lph on Thursday May 17, 2018 @04:11PM
(#17095157)
I think it's a fundamental principle, but definitely not the only one. For example it is also a monopoly on violence.
Re:US Supreme Court strikes down federal law prohibiting spo...
by dsfyu404ed on Monday May 14, 2018 @03:36PM
(#17068701)
Because most people look the other way when it's something they agree with.