News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:US Supreme Court strikes down federal law prohibiting spo... by raiyu on Monday May 14, 2018 @12:11PM (#17066679)
The main idea is that Congress can decide if it is legal or not, but to say it's illegal everywhere except for Nevada makes it a non-federal statute as they are arbitrarily deciding that some state gets an exception, making it non constitutional.

That is why it was stricken. If it said it was illegal everywhere, then the supreme court would have upheld that.

Re:US Supreme Court strikes down federal law prohibiting spo... by pdabbadabba on Monday May 14, 2018 @01:14PM (#17067279)
I don't think this is correct. As I read it, the issue was that, as others have said, the federal government attempted to regulate what laws a state could pass (which is related to a broader body of law about federal laws that compel states* to enact certain laws or to implement federal laws). Note, however, that this not to say that congress can't make its own laws and that, if it does, they would override state laws.

Maybe one way of summing this up that makes more sense of the distinction is this: Congress can make laws that regulate behavior as a general matter (subject to other constitutional restrictions), but cannot regulate directly the behavior of state governments themselves.

It's unusual for congress to do the former but not the latter, but that appears to have been the case here.

Re:US Supreme Court strikes down federal law prohibiting spo... by kenjackson on Monday May 14, 2018 @03:37PM (#17068716)
Why would Congress do this? Is it because there is some other constitutional requirement they would be in violation of if they just made it illegal at the federal level?
Re:US Supreme Court strikes down federal law prohibiting spo... by pdabbadabba on Tuesday May 15, 2018 @03:28AM (#17072251)
Expanding a bit on some of the reasons others have given, in this case I think it was also an attempt to grandfather a few states where sports betting was legal. There would have been obvious problems with banning sports betting in, e.g., every state but Nevada. But banning state legislatures from authorizing it (if it wasn't authorized already) seemed, perhaps, less problematic.

The classic problematic rationale, that the court discusses in cases like Printz [1] is also dislocation of the political costs of enforcement away from federal officials onto state officials.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Printz_v._United_States

Re:US Supreme Court strikes down federal law prohibiting spo... by wnoise on Monday May 14, 2018 @06:49PM (#17070122)
1. There would be a backlash for outlawing it where it was already legal, and hence had an industry depending on it. In fact, there was an option to even legalize it in places so long as they did it within a year.

2. Enforcing it at the federal level costs money. It's easier to pass a ban where you force the states to pay the costs.

Re:US Supreme Court strikes down federal law prohibiting spo... by mobilefriendly on Monday May 14, 2018 @06:53PM (#17070143)
Yes, the Tenth Amendment reserves powers not explicitly given to the federal government to the states and the people. Local sports and poker betting is already regulated by the states and a federal interstate commerce claim to regulate it is fairly weak.
Re:US Supreme Court strikes down federal law prohibiting spo... by _acme on Monday May 14, 2018 @08:05PM (#17070524)
Pursuant to Gonzales v. Raich, which ruled that Congress could criminalize the production and use of homegrown marijuana for personal use, the interstate effect of gambling in any form on any activity is almost certainly sufficient for Congress to regulate or prohibit any or all gambling activity.

In addition, the Ninth Circuit has held that Congress has Commerce Clause authority to criminalize possession of homemade machine guns.

Congress has chosen to allow states to regulate gambling to a certain extent, which explains its legality in various forms in the various states.

Re:US Supreme Court strikes down federal law prohibiting spo... by dragonwriter on Monday May 14, 2018 @07:12PM (#17070248)
> Why would Congress do this?

To transfer enforcement costs, including for hosting civil actions outside of the situations where state law claims get into federal court, to state law enforcement and courts.

Re:US Supreme Court strikes down federal law prohibiting spo... by jessriedel on Monday May 14, 2018 @12:30PM (#17066837)
> they are arbitrarily deciding that some state gets an exception, making it non constitutional. > ...That is why it was stricken

Do you have quote from the decision to support this? It seems to conflict with what I excerpted and the analysis I've seen.

Re:US Supreme Court strikes down federal law prohibiting spo... by T-hawk on Monday May 14, 2018 @01:33PM (#17067455)
It wasn't arbitrary. The states that had pre-existing laws kept them. The original decision prevented states from passing new laws to enable gambling, but didn't strike down or repeal existing laws, thus those states essentially got grandfathered in.

Media reports like to spin it as "sports gambling is illegal except in XYZ states", to make it look like favoritism and the story inciteful, but really the only thing distinguishing those states is legacy code.

Re:US Supreme Court strikes down federal law prohibiting spo... by jessriedel on Monday May 14, 2018 @02:12PM (#17067936)
I think you're disagreeing with raiyu, not me?
Re:US Supreme Court strikes down federal law prohibiting spo... by mobilefriendly on Monday May 14, 2018 @06:46PM (#17070108)
Your comment has no basis in fact. The decision has nothing to do with some type of equal protection for states and in no way addressed whether or not Congress even has the power to ban gambling everywhere.
Re:US Supreme Court strikes down federal law prohibiting spo... by gowld on Monday May 14, 2018 @04:09PM (#17069012)
When did that Constitutional interpretation change?

State-specific laws have an infamous history: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Missouri_Compromise