Consultants get past all three of these challenges to surface a good solution and in the process get buy-in from everyone who needs to agree in order for a major change to be made.
Additional point is that usually there is involvement of industry specific specialists that advise project teams. They put in fewer hours, as they're not needed for the more mundane project work (slide making). Often times they're hyper-specific to the topic at hand, e.g. former CEO of competitor.
1. Poor executive leadership. 2. Poor executive leadership. 3. Poor executive leadership.
When you breed a culture of fear and silence this will always be the result. It's the CEO who says, "I'm not surrounded with people who say 'Yes' to me. I'm surrounded with people who share my vision." The CEO, after having replaced, removed, and reassigned anyone who is willing to call into question a decision made by the CEO, will make decisions without any real feedback from their executive team (an echo chamber).
The alternative?[0] The CEO who lets and encourages everyone to speak their mind. The CEO who rewards those with differing opinions and seeks truth by asking "Why?" instead of shutting down dissent. The CEO who actively seeks out executive leadership that will challenge them to justify their decisions and to keep a written record of those decisions.
[0]https://www.ted.com/talks/ray_dalio_how_to_build_a_company_w...
The reality is that strategy consultants sell services targeted at senior management at large corporations, a category that ~0% of Hacker News falls into.
This isn’t to say that consultants are without agendas. It’s just different agendas.
Also, it's way easier for me to get actionable knowledge talking and surveying people than making models or any complicated stuff. I still have to polish this knowledge and bundle it in a way that executives can consume it, but most of the times it is what I do.
Executives in Spain tend to be very old-fashioned.
You'd be thinking wrong. Companies hire consulting firms _because_ they can't get the same types of insights from their own people... mainly due to the fact that their people have jobs doing other things and can't stop to spend a few months doing nothing but research.
Also sensing some bias here: consulting firms work in teams with a mixture of new graduates and people with "deep industry experience and consequent insight" in order to provide a mix of expertise and exposure to new technologies/techniques coming from academia. If your experience with consultants was as a line employee or middle manager, you likely interacted only with the new grads from the team because they do most basic research and interviewing, so be aware that there may have been more experienced people on the engagement.
I wouldn't overestimate the value of the dedicated research they do. In my experience, the research was mostly interviewing and getting educated about a market and technology that the product managers, etc. were already familiar with.
It felt like sort of a waste of money but it did validate pretty much what we were doing anyway. They created some elaborate financial model which was fairly useless but which was the sort of thing internal business staff liked.
Net net. It was probably useful from an internal political perspective (which is always a consideration) even if it didn't deliver any particularly novel insights.
In some cases, of course, management consultants are hired to give cover to unpopular decisions or even to send a message to one’s workforce. In The Firm, Duff McDonald argues McKinsey in particular “might be the single greatest legitimizer of mass layoffs in history.”
“If you were a CEO and felt you needed to cut 10% of costs but didn’t feel you were getting buy-in from your employees,” he wrote, “the hiring of McKinsey generally got the point across quite clearly.”
> You'd think any well-run company could get the same sort of insight from its own people.
The paradox is many companies disenfranchise their own employees through hierarchy and politics.
* Insights across the companies competitors (because they have / had engagements with them)
* Insights from other industries / markets
* Experience with a certain situation (assuming similar trends happen in different industries at different times)
Employees of the company might have similar knowledge but distributed across many instead of focused in the consultant team.
A big decision looms - a new product, a new market, whatever it is, it requires the full attention of a team of people to just outline the knowledge needed to make rational decisions in it.
You're also worried about tunnel vision of your own team, success tends to bread that.
This is when you hire outside help. Temp workers to research and present a deep topic. They don't decide, you do. But rather than putting people on full payroll and then maybe need to axe them, you have them do a project.
Absolutely valuable, if employed correctly.
And don't underestimate what a McKinsey or BCG can pull in terms of network. Their research can go into places where your team simply can't reach. Good VCs act the same way btw, the value of a16z for a small startup as an advisor and door opener is the same as McK or BCG for a public co.
Their objective is to get paid, so they bypass many of the mechanisms that middle management uses to undermine executive initiatives.
Tax evading?
Let's be clear; I'm not talking here about specialist consultants with deep industry experience and consequent insight. Those make sense to me.
I'm talking about generalist corporate-strategy/management consultants who are peddling what sure looks like a suite of industrial command+control or planning+strategy techniques. How could they possibly be providing enough value to be worth hiring?