mgmtconsultant
The reality is that strategy consultants sell services targeted at senior management at large corporations, a category that ~0% of Hacker News falls into.
(a) Return the investors money? (b) Compensate the founders for the opportunity cost of their time?
If so, then the acquiring company valued the startup as being worth more than the resources that went into it, so the startup created value.
With most acquihires, I think the answer to both (a) and (b) is "no", so it's not fair to call the startup a success.
There are other considerations - the value the startup created for customers, the enjoyment of the founders, the treatment of the startup employees, and so forth. But if you burnt investor money and / or didn't make back the cost of your time, it's hard to call it a success.
Why do I read HN? Mostly, because I like and enjoy working in the technology space (defined broadly) and hope to build a career in tech. HN is great at giving me a view over the other side of the fence.