HSF is easily 100x higher tolerances.
Some stuff, you have to live with, some stuff (like the panels and the o-rings) is too far fetched for even NASA to think up beforehand. And if you've ever been to The Cape, you know they will never forgive themselves. They try their very best to think it all up. They really really do. NASA may be full of brains, but damned if they aren't all real heroes there on the ground. Those folk have heart more than anything else.
Per Aspera Ad Astra does not fucking cut it.
Were a known weakness.
Can you break down this calculation? Where did 75% come from? I think your parent poster's point is this: no one really knows where these numbers are coming from.
That was actually explained in the (excellent) comment. Snippet below, but please re read the comment or example how resistors are actually tested in batches to give real failure rates.
>Each resistor on a PCB, each explosive bolt, each screw and panel. All of it has a lifetime curve, typically a Bathtub plot, to an extreme degree
That's the same kind of mistake NASA made, just multiplying stuff like it was a high school textbook question.
What if the very things that make a rocket explode also make the escape capsule fail?
NASA's problem was their two failures did not result from any one component of the original design failing. One was used out of spec and the foam had been changed from the initial design.
I agree that a very effective escape system, as it appears the f9 has, makes the rocket far safer. However understanding failure probabilities is much complex than this thread is making it sound. For instance you could have a escape system failure that triggers the exploding rocket or a software system failure which causes both the rocket to explode and the escape system to fail. Take a look at 'Engineering a safer world' for an idea of how NASA and other parties actually calculate these probabilities: https://mitpress.mit.edu/books/engineering-safer-world
If you have the actual probabilities, which include cascade failures and one of the systems is a safety backup system not in normal use then multiplication is reasonably though not completely accurate. Though, you do need to consider the failure of the safety system when the normal system is operating correctly, but that's also much easier to avoid so likely very very low.
Cascade failures are a far more complex situation and thus harder to predict. So again, it depends on what the failure rate is describing not just what the number is.
No, you can perfectly well calculate component-by-component and come up with the 1 in 500 number. That's what NASA did (at great expense). What they failed to realize was this was only considering known-unknowns, and actual experience using the stack is required to learn about the unknown-unknowns which dominated the analysis.
You can use an inside-view analysis to get a minimum risk assessment. Something would have been very wrong in the analysis if we didn’t lose 1 in 500, since that’s the risk we expected from known factors.
And the outside view can give you a reasonable handle on maximums: objectively the risk of shuttle loss was about 1:75 or so, because that is what actually happened. If we were to have continued the shuttle program instead of cannibalizing it for the now defunct Constellation, we could have confidence that failures going forward would be at least 1:75 or better as we fix things, assuming regressions are rare.
The failure by NASA was in treating the inside view known-unknowns risk assessment as a maximum (“risk of loss is NO MORE THAN...”) when it was really a minimum (“risk of loss is AT LEAST...”).
But SpaceX necessarily WILL be safer because they're using a proven vehicle and a more robust capsule. Plus a launch abort system. Shuttle flew crewed on the very first launch.
Falcon 9 is planned to launch maybe twice a year crewed, compared to 20 or 30 uncrewed launches (including like 2 or 3 uncrewed Dragon launches), meaning any new systemic problems with the launch vehicle will almost certainly pop up in an uncrewed launch before they result in loss of crew. Shuttle ONLY launched uncrewed, therefore any systemic problem which resulted in a loss of vehicle necessarily resulted in loss-of-crew.
Don't you mean that shuttle only launched crewed? Either that or I think I do not have the same definition as you do for "uncrewed" -- I take it to mean that there is no crew on board?
When did the shuttle main engine fail?
And STS-93 had a pretty bad close call, too, with some of the engine coolant lines rupturing in-flight (leading to early shutdown) due to a oxidizer post plug coming undone as well as an electrical short taking down some of the engine controllers. That was pretty early in flight, so would've been incredibly risky in the case of an abort. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/STS-93
Falcon 9 has higher levels of first stage redundancy than Shuttle (can lose a first stage engine immediately at lift-off and reach orbit just fine, and lose multiple engines later in flight), and uses just a single upper stage engine, reducing probability of failure.
Over the life of the shuttle[0], there were 355 astronauts who flew, 14 died. So for every ~25 astronauts who flew on the shuttle, 1 died..
0) https://www.space.com/12376-nasa-space-shuttle-program-facts...
Accounting for repeats, there were 833 individuals that flew on the shuttle and 14 died. The ratio there is about 60:1 which is predictably comparable to the ratio of successful:failed flights.
Also the context of that 1 in 12 in the quote is important. They’re saying that was the chance on the first flight in retrospect. The shuttle and it’s supporting facilities and processes didn’t stay static, they improved over time.
Erm, over a large sample size, yes this is exactly how things work. Sure 15/5 may be too small, but 150/50 isn't. That's well after the point where its reasonable to believe that your coin is rigged.
As the other user mentioned, if you don't have the prior that the coin is fair, a 15/5 outcome may (and does) indeed imply that heads are more likely than tails. In fact, 15/5 would imply a less than 1% chance of a fair coin, given uniform priors. (Beta[15, 5] -> 1st percentile is 50.175)
Now, once you've answered that question, you can integrate to get a probability that the next coin is heads, but with a single flip you can't even answer the first question. You need to have gotten heads and tails each at least once.
When a or b is very large and the other is zero, you can treat it as 1 and get a decent approximation, but it'll be a an estimate that biases towards the center.
If your rocket has a 50% chance of being explosion proof and a 50% chance of blowing up half the time (you could imagine this as any number of situations, like two otherwise identical rockets which you use), any given launch has a 25% chance of rapid unplanned disassembly.
You can do the same thing over a continuous random variable.
You built the rocket, launched it once, and it did not blow up. What should be integrated to get the probability of rapid unplanned disassembly?
The beta distribution[1] is a cool statistical distribution defined by BetaDist{a,b} (or alpha, beta, but that's too much work), where a is the number of successes and b is the number of failures you've sampled.
It has a number of cool properties, chief among them that given X = BetaDist{a,b}, then cdf(X, x) = the probability that the mean of the distribution you are approximating is less than x. It has a bunch of other nice properties too (like E[X] = a / (a + b), which should be obvious), but those aren't as relevant here.
So let's say that you assume a uniform prior. This is defined as BetaDist{1,1} [2]. this is probably the wrong prior. So you might have a better idea. If, for example, you believe there is a 10% chance of your rocket exploding based on some calculations you've done, you might use a differently tuned beta distribution, like BetaDist{9,1} or BetaDist{4.5,.5} if you were feeling uncertain (but in general it would likely be better to use {8,2} in that situation iirc). But let's assume {1,1} for now.
So you launch your rocket. Everything goes great. You update your distribution. Its a success. So you get BetaDist{2,1} [3]. So what is the chance your rocket explodes? Well the cdf of your beta distribution is the probability that the mean is less than x. So the pdf of the beta distribution is the probability that the mean is exactly x. So then
The integral from 0 -> 1 of `(1 - x) * pdf(X, x) dx` is the estimated probability that your rocket explodes on its next launch, since that's "for every value x, the likelyhood of the distribution being that one multiplied by the chance your rocket explodes given that distribution". For the one rocket case, this happens to be equal to E[X] = a / (a + b), so it's 1/3.
For the two rocket case, you apply reinforcement learning/k-armed bandit strategies like UBC1[4] or Thompson Sampling[5]. These are algorithms that will result in you picking the best rocket with as few unnecessary explosions as possible, provably.
You can see some related discussion I've had on HN about these algorithms [6].
[1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Beta_distribution
[2]: http://www.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=beta+distribution+(1,1)
[3]: http://www.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=beta+distribution+(2,+1...
[4]: http://banditalgs.com/2016/09/18/the-upper-confidence-bound-...
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rule_of_succession
[2] http://users.stat.ufl.edu/~aa/articles/agresti_coull_1998.pd...
But my point was you cannot look at a historical event and say "Well this happened, so that was the chance." That's the basis for the silly internet joke "The chance is 50/50, either it happens or it doesn't."
Which is what the people I replied to were doing.
If the event happens repeatedly, you absolutely can! If someone attempts something 20 times, and it works 10 of them, you can conclude that there's an approximately 50% chance of success. You have a sample size! The exact same thing is true for a statement like "the chance of an astronaut dying is approximately 1 in 25". We have the sample size to show that.
>That's the basis for the silly internet joke "The chance is 50/50, either it happens or it doesn't."
No, that's totally different. That's a misunderstanding of priors. What you're doing is more like forgetting that the law of large numbers is a thing.
It only means that’s your chance if you have the technology from quantum leap (the tv show) and you randomly land in the body of one of the participants.
as I said already the shuttle and everything around it evolved. The crews changed. Trying to say “the actual chance of death was this based on how many people died.” is silly.
No, then the event already happened, so you know the outcome with certainty.
> The actual shuttle missions were not a statistical experiment or a consistent action where you can say “well this is what happened so that was the chance of death on an individual shuttle flight.”
Indeed there are confounding factors that make the error nontrivial. This doesn't invalidate the entire experiment.
>Trying to say “the actual chance of death was this based on how many people died.” is silly.
Its exactly as silly as saying "the actual chance of getting heads is based on how many heads you get". The problem with your argument is that that isn't silly. To calculate how likely getting heads is, you flip the coin a bunch of times, see how many heads you get, and then you have your answer (and a confidence level). Its the opposite of silly.
In other words, there's no big difference between "We'll flip a bunch of coins to see how likely we are to pull heads" and "we'll launch a bunch of people into space to see how likely they are to end up dead". The second isn't as rigorously controlled as the first, but that's fine as long as you account for it.
A rocket or space shuttle launch is like a thousand coin flips, where any one result, sequence of results or other combination of events results in death. As an added bonus, any number of unknown external events, from Ambient temperature, to bird strike, to sabotage can render the model useless and kill you in some unforeseen way.
Say you launch your rocket 50 times, out of which 3 times it explodes - first time because of a bird, second time because of the legendary ULA Sniper, third time because of internal problems. That 3/50 is still closer to the truth than just assuming "I really don't know" (1/2) or refusing to answer the question - it has huge error bars, but implicitly captures some of the phenomena that make launches go wrong.
My perspective was probably a little impacted from spending the first truly beautiful day of the summer dealing with a failed "high availability" system. :)
Isn't it the best you can say, though? 20 is a small number but when it's all you have, there's nothing you can do about it. Of course we know the "real" probability is a 1/2 because we know how coin tosses work, but if we didn't know it and coin tosses were black boxes, we'd have to go with this 3:1 chance.
And yet, through all of that the underlying machinery would be identical and that is the thing we're trying to evaluate here.
So even though you can compute that particular number it is not a very useful number to calculate.
A better way would be to look at the 2/135 number to determine vehicle safety and to use the number of astronauts on board to get to a generic figure and for each individual astronaut to use the 2/135 multiplied by the number of flights they took to figure out their chances.
Of course these are still very low numbers and the error bars will therefore be large.
>Engineers at marshal estimate it as 1/300, while NASA management, to whom these engineers report, claims it is 1/100,000. An independent engineer consulting for NASA thought 1 or 2 per 100 a reasonable estimate
The estimates seem to depend on who is estimating https://science.ksc.nasa.gov/shuttle/missions/51-l/docs/roge...
He had to fight publish that:
>Feynman was so critical of flaws in NASA's "safety culture" that he threatened to remove his name from the report unless it included his personal observations on the reliability of the shuttle, which appeared as Appendix F.
The entire problem with rockets is that you can't fit many such systems into them. So the accidents happen.
I believe in such super complicated systems there will be a long list of tail risks, probably too hard to compute.
Also at this stage of space exploration we should be focusing on rapid development of technology while keeping humans safe but not putting too much emphasis on safety that we might want to see in our cars.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UyFF4cpMVag
This is probably how SpaceX imagines astronauts would be saved in case of a fueling problem.
> Before the very first shuttle flight, NASA estimated that the chance of death was between 1 in 500 and 1 in 5,000. Later, after the agency had compiled data from shuttle flights, it went back and came up with a very different number. The chance of death was actually 1 in 12.
The fact is, these numbers are made up because the systems are too complicated to calculate based on individual components. Until they have something like 50+ launches (after the kinks are worked out), we wont really know the actual chances of blowing up a rocket are. Further, how well do the escape capsule(s) work? If they work the majority of the time (saving astronauts from he explosion), that'd also dramatically drive down the risk.
If say, there was a 1 in 30 chance of a rocket exploding using the method described, but the escape capsule failed to save the astronauts 1 out of 10 times. Then the real risk of killing the astronauts is 1 in 300. Unfortunately, we simply don't have either of those numbers, so the actual "risk" level is essentially made up.