Professors are being paid below market value for their skills. If tenure came with a replenishing bucket of venture capital, under stipulation of open source/patent sharing, it'd give them real money, autonomy and great internships for their students!
Schools would make bank, too.
https://www.nytimes.com/2018/05/05/style/stephen-schwarzman-...
Oh I see your post earlier - yeah, I think removing incentives from voluntary contributions to (partially) taxpayer funded events would lead to a major increase in inefficiency of those projects seeing the light of day.
I assume so. So there has to be some other force at play, unless the university admins are just maximizing revenue in a brain-dead fashion.
A more relevant analogy is if I offered you $1,200 on the condition you spend that money on a home gym. Could you have other uses for the money? Sure. Could you have higher priorities than exercise? Sure.
Are you going to turn that down? Probably not.
An even more appropriate analogy is if I offered you $2,500, but $1,200 had to be spent on a home gym. The remainder has no conditions. That would be closer to what a lot of big donations are structured as.
Paid with what money? Tuition is probably already set to the highest amount that is competitive with other schools.
If all that money were equally divided between the 1400 faculty members, they'd each get a salary of at most $240k per year, which is really high in the grand scheme of things but kind of low for these specific facebook jobs that we're talking about.
Now consider that much (most?) of that revenue must actually be spent on the 2,500 staff members supporting university operations, building maintenence, etc.
I don't think there is any great mystery to solve here.
Edit: see the replies to this post. It seems the tuition at CMU I'd double what I thought it was. I still don't think the revised numbers are any more mysterious, though.
https://www.cmu.edu/news/stories/archives/2017/january/tuiti...
Still, a mere doubling of the faculty salaries I was describing above is likely still not sufficient to compete with these tech giants when hiring someone like a deep learning expert.
Because the majority of money that a professor controls mostly comes from grants. And you have to fight for grants from an ever shrinking base.
Why fight for grants when you can get paid a dramatically higher salary and can focus on research instead of fundraising?
Until academia figures out how to fix its funding model, this is the new normal--any hot tech area is going to result in a brain drain.
Professors bring in money by teaching, for which they aren't paid any extra, and grants, which often they receive a small monetary incentive, i.e., summer salary of about $10-20K per year for a professor making $100K. It is hard to get much more than that because of caps on grants, so for professors to get paid more by grants the maximum size of a grant from NSF/DoD/etc. would need to be a lot bigger.
A question I have is "Why aren't professors who teach larger and more popular classes paid more for taking on the additional students?" My deep learning classes fill up to the maximum size allowed (50). I could scale it even higher, although finding class space would be hard, but if I do that my university has no explicit mechanism to reward me for doing that. If you teach more people, you would think that you would make more money.
It is interesting to note that in our free-market(ish) society, preparing the next generation of researchers is not as valued as working at a BigCo or a Unicorn. If AI professors are in high demand relative to the supple, basic economics dictate that their prices should spike up. Then why aren't these professors getting paid a lot more to continue teaching?