News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Microsoft attempts to spin its role in counterfeiting case by syshum on Saturday April 28, 2018 @06:35AM (#16947026)
And for that you believe he should be put in prison for 15 months?

At most this should be a civil issue between 2 private parties where monetary damages are awarded, not a criminal case where a person faces prison times.

Re:Microsoft attempts to spin its role in counterfeiting case by DanBC on Saturday April 28, 2018 @06:41AM (#16947046)
He shouldn't be in prison, but it's a well established bit of law that copyright infringement as a business is a criminal offence, and not just a civil tort. This is present is several jurisdictions.
Re:Microsoft attempts to spin its role in counterfeiting case by amelius on Saturday April 28, 2018 @07:51AM (#16947236)
> it's a well established bit of law that copyright infringement as a business is a criminal offence, and not just a civil tort

Can we have this kind of law for privacy infringement too, please?

Re:Microsoft attempts to spin its role in counterfeiting case by hedora on Saturday April 28, 2018 @01:02PM (#16948540)
We do have criminal laws protecting privacy, and they are enforced as long as the victim is a corporation or the government.
Re:Microsoft attempts to spin its role in counterfeiting case by retrogradeorbit on Saturday April 28, 2018 @09:17AM (#16947504)
It was once civil, but corporations successfully externalised their enforcement costs on the tax payer by lobbying and rewriting the law to make it criminal.
Re:Microsoft attempts to spin its role in counterfeiting case by syshum on Saturday April 28, 2018 @06:53AM (#16947073)
The fact that something is "well established" does not make it ethical, moral or right.

I personally find it abhorrent when people use the justification of "well it is well established law" as if the law is written in stone, unchangeable, the word of a god and we just have to accept it.

No the law is wrong, the law should be changed, and this is an example if why it should be changed.

Copyright law need to be massively reformed and curbed. Intellectual Privilege is no longer with in its constitutional remit, i.e to Promote useful Arts and Sciences, and instead used to destroy those very things

---Edit: thanks for the downvotes I love how every day HN becomes more and more of a echo Chamber where anyone that disagrees with the popular (generally Pro Large Tech Company) narrative gets downvotes and has their voice suppressed since once a post get negative votes the "You are posting to fast" throttle kicks in and prevents the person from responding

Re:Microsoft attempts to spin its role in counterfeiting case by djsumdog on Saturday April 28, 2018 @08:27AM (#16947331)
Please don't comment on downvotes. It is what it is, and it can change if you wait.

In response, yes laws change. It was once well established that separate but equal was equal; and blacks could have their own bathrooms and drinking fountains. It was once legal to employee 13 year old boys as factory workers.

Disney's big items are well past their trademark expiration dates. Mickey Mouse should be public domain soon, but Disney is large enough they keep lobbying for laws that extend their IP well beyond what it should be.

We do need copyright reform, especially in cases like this where the physical disks aren't even made anymore.

[dead]
Re:Microsoft attempts to spin its role in counterfeiting case by djsumdog on Saturday April 28, 2018 @09:46AM (#16947605)
No, it's in the guidelines:

> Please don't comment about the voting on comments. It never does any good, and it makes boring reading.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:Microsoft attempts to spin its role in counterfeiting case by aje403 on Saturday April 28, 2018 @07:28AM (#16947157)
Blah blah blah, okay, but yes he should be in jail. He can choose not to counterfeit when he gets out if he wants to stay out
Re:Microsoft attempts to spin its role in counterfeiting case by syshum on Saturday April 28, 2018 @11:56AM (#16948209)
Prison should be reserved only for those that are a Physical Danger to others, not to punish people that may harm Corporate profits
Re:Microsoft attempts to spin its role in counterfeiting case by shmed on Thursday May 03, 2018 @07:57PM (#16991056)
What about thieves? If I break into a bank or a jewelry store and leave with million dollars worth of gold, then get caught. Should I just "restitute" the stolen goods and go back home? My only crime was to harm corporate profits, I didn't put anyone under physical danger. What about if I steal someone's car (not a corporation)? Does it change based on who you target (rather than based on the crime itself)? And if the only punishment is monetary, rather than jail time, does that mean committing a crime becomes a question of "can I afford to commit the crime and simply pay the fine?". Let's say I'm a millionaire that get its thrill from breaking into museum and stealing valuable art pieces. Are we just gonna ask him to give them back (if he ever get caught) and pay a "stealing" fee?
[dead]
Re:Microsoft attempts to spin its role in counterfeiting case by syshum on Saturday April 28, 2018 @01:15PM (#16948579)
>>I think it's great that our country has strong deterrents against people clearly and deliberately going out of their way to make a living off copyright infringement.

and I think copyright itself is unethical and should be abolished completely, I am willing to accept/comprise and support a copyright of extreme limited duration covering an very small subset of useful arts and sciences for a duration of no more than 14 years to the original creator only (no corporations)

>The lazy entitled pseudologic neckbeard hivemind of this site is painful sometimes. Please stop.

I am a clean shaven libertarian that has never had a beard or any facial hair let alone a neckbeard.

>What if I decide to be a polite burglar who doesn't have any intention of hurting you? Can you leave me out of jail too?

Yes, if a person steals property that property can be replaced / victim made hole via restitution, it holds no value to society or the victim to place that person in a cage, a cage that also must be paid for by taking property of others in the form of taxation.

If someone takes $1,000 from me, I would much rather have $1,500 in restitution than $0 and the person go to jail

Re:Microsoft attempts to spin its role in counterfeiting case by aje403 on Saturday April 28, 2018 @01:25PM (#16948634)
But it sure as shit might stop the next guy if all his friends keep getting put in jail, something very rare in white collar crime.

If I were Microsoft or any business needing to protect my IP rights, I would not care about a small reparation, I would care about it not having to go to court every 5 minutes because everyone and their mom is printing off fake CDs because it's not getting adequately deterred by the justice system.

Seriously, if you want to bitch about our justice system or even our copyright laws you have WAY WAY lower hanging fruit than this to base a coherent argument around

Nvm: re-read your posts, Windows should not have a copyright on these disks, I do not exist in the same universe as you

Re:Microsoft attempts to spin its role in counterfeiting case by syshum on Saturday April 28, 2018 @04:49PM (#16949346)
>>If I were Microsoft or any business needing to protect my IP rights

And this is the main disconnect, I do not accept the concept of "intellectual property" or believe it is a right.

Microsoft should not be given a "right" by the government to control in what order I instruct my hard drive or cd burner to arrange a series of 1's and 0's. Doing so is an actual violation of my physical property rights as the owner of said hard drive

Re:Microsoft attempts to spin its role in counterfeiting case by aje403 on Sunday April 29, 2018 @07:08AM (#16951531)
Let's make it clear that Microsoft has rights on Windows, their brand and suite of products, not operating systems in general. The problem comes from when a malicious 3rd party explicitly paints Windows on the disc full of 0s and 1s to fool the consumer deliberately into believing its a genuine product. Microsoft not only loses revenue but it assumes brand liability

You did not invent a single thing you are using right now and the delusional dream world with no ip in which people like you wish to exist, a hard drive was never invented in the first place. If you want to argue some of them need to be reformed, sure, that's obvious to everyone who reads the news once in awhile, but everything else indicates you are the originally intended reason for why the electoral college exists

Re:Microsoft attempts to spin its role in counterfeiting case by dang on Sunday April 29, 2018 @02:02PM (#16953106)
You've repeatedly posted uncivil and unsubstantive comments, engaged in flamewars, and now crossed into personal attack. We've already had to warn you repeatedly about this.

If you can't or won't stop, we're going to ban you, so would you please (re-)read https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html and stop doing these things on HN?

Re:Microsoft attempts to spin its role in counterfeiting case by dredmorbius on Saturday April 28, 2018 @08:17AM (#16947302)
Who writes that law?
Re:Microsoft attempts to spin its role in counterfeiting case by DanBC on Saturday April 28, 2018 @10:39AM (#16947835)
You shouldn't be downvoted for stating something that's obviously true: the IP industry has huge amounts of influence and they've been sucessful at driving legal change.

This includes making commercial copyright violation a criminal, rather than civil, offence. It also includes things like making circumvention of technical protection measure illegal.

It's wide ranging, it removes freedoms, it causes economic harm.

Re:Microsoft attempts to spin its role in counterfeiting case by zeusk on Saturday April 28, 2018 @11:29AM (#16948100)
> This includes making commercial copyright violation a criminal, rather than civil, offence. It also includes things like making circumvention of technical protection measure illegal.

> It's wide ranging, it removes freedoms, it causes economic harm.

And how exactly is that? The government didn't go after him because he was distributing pirated media or software to his friends but he set up a manufacturing unit, deceived customs to profit off the operations. Not to "recycle and reduce waste", not to help you or me.

Re:Microsoft attempts to spin its role in counterfeiting case by DanBC on Saturday April 28, 2018 @12:27PM (#16948347)
You want to carrier-unlock your phone? Might be illegal where you are.

You want to back-up DVD or bluray discs? Might be illegal where you are.

You want to format shift CD to MP3? Might be illegal where you are.

You bought thousands of CDs, and want to pay a service to format shift them to MP3? Probably illegal.

etc etc etc.

Re:Microsoft attempts to spin its role in counterfeiting case by zeusk on Saturday April 28, 2018 @12:40PM (#16948404)
For most jurisdictions, an act is "criminal" if you have mens rea (malicious intent) and actus reus (malicious act).

You never see someone getting locked up or fined for copying discs for personal use. All of the cases that I'm aware of involved distribution and profiting.

The measures were intended to deter those profiting off the work of others like in this case. Although, I agree that the legal approach sets a bad precedent and unfortunate collateral damage to people who genuinely buy something and face the same deterrence when they really don't have any malicious intent.

Re:Microsoft attempts to spin its role in counterfeiting case by DanBC on Saturday April 28, 2018 @05:40PM (#16949546)
> You never see someone getting locked up or fined for copying discs for personal use. All of the cases that I'm aware of involved distribution and profiting.

Because in most places there's a distinction between copyright infringement done as part of trade and copyright infringement for personal use - which is what I said in parent post.

Re:Microsoft attempts to spin its role in counterfeiting case by dredmorbius on Saturday April 28, 2018 @10:01PM (#16950394)
Thanks. Agreed on all points.
Re:Microsoft attempts to spin its role in counterfeiting case by ThoAppelsin on Saturday April 28, 2018 @08:34AM (#16947352)
It is not useful to discuss about the law on a forum on the internet, at least not yet. Still...

Counterfeiting is an act that is similar to theft, apparent from the fact that this guy has succeeded in making money from what Microsoft gave birth to, and therefore owned [1]. The relation between the guy and Microsoft is clearly a parasitic one.

Microsoft would be compensated justly if they were simply just awarding the monetary damage back by the damaging parties, here Eric Lundgren and his co-defendants. However, it would not be just against the community* (which includes Microsoft, but also everyone else) to let the damaging parties go away without deterring them from doing such actions further. Otherwise, the damaging parties may continue living off their lives through damaging, simply because it is almost certain that there will be cases where they will make profit without being detected and required to award the damages back.

Another way to explain the situation is this: If they are not made to pay more than the damage they have caused, their worst-case (for them, not us/community) profit is 0, and for all the other cases they will be making profit. Should this really be the justice cast upon the individuals causing monetary damage?

[1]: Declaring creators as the (copyright) owners benefits the community, hence we do. The relevant example Windows is a product of Microsoft that benefits the community, evident from the fact that it has a userbase. Microsoft would not create and offer Windows to the public, if the law allowed everyone to freely redistribute their products, and compete with Microsoft using their creation, as it would render their novel efforts meaningless against the much simpler effort of copying products created by the others.

[*]: Edited from "robbery".

Re:Microsoft attempts to spin its role in counterfeiting case by jake_the_third on Saturday April 28, 2018 @08:57AM (#16947434)
With all due respect, your view is biased to the point of delusion.

Counterfeiting never was and never will be similar to robbery. Robbery results in someone being deprived of their property. No one has been deprived of their property. In fact, as information, the victim in this case couldn't deprive Microsoft and OEMs of their property unless he deleted every single copy of the software.

Furthermore, the "counterfeit" software is an exact replica of what is provided by OEMs. There was no harm done to society.

I agree with others here: Any prison time is too long, let alone 15 months. Our society needs to take a long hard look at our laws because frankly, we're well on our way within the realm of the absurd.

Re:Microsoft attempts to spin its role in counterfeiting case by ThoAppelsin on Saturday April 28, 2018 @10:21AM (#16947749)
> No one has been deprived of their property.

On the contrary, money is a means to property, and Microsoft loses $3.5 (minus the production cost) for each copy Eric sells to his buyers, since otherwise Microsoft would be the one earning that money. The crime of theft, however, predates even this buying & selling.

Software is a non-depleting product. It is like the fruits that immediately regrow when plucked off of its tree. Now, just because Microsoft doesn't lose any fruits when somebody plucks a fruit from their tree without permission, shouldn't make this person not guilty of their theft. Eric, I would say, has committed this crime of theft at the point of copying the software. Microsoft may not have been deprived of their property, but that is merely due to the fact that their miraculous tree was capable of immediate replenishment, not because a fruit from it was not stolen.

Eric later benefited from his crime by selling it, which damaged Microsoft by saturating the demand for their product as a side-effect.

In the end, it really is hard not to think counterfeiting as a form of stealing, when any form of counterfeiting most definitely devaluates the properties owned by the genuine owners. I am not an expert on law, economics, or business, but I would say counterfeiting in any form would most likely indirectly equal to stealing, and doesn't look like it at the first sight because the translation is too convoluted.

Re:Microsoft attempts to spin its role in counterfeiting case by icebraining on Saturday April 28, 2018 @01:25PM (#16948635)
Microsoft loses $3.5 (minus the production cost) for each copy Eric sells to his buyers, since otherwise Microsoft would be the one earning that money

Considering that Microsoft wasn't selling those disks before he came around, and isn't selling them now, how can they be losing money on the disks?

If I managed to find someone to pay to get a copy of your post, would that mean you'd lose money?

Re:Microsoft attempts to spin its role in counterfeiting case by ThoAppelsin on Saturday April 28, 2018 @05:42PM (#16949556)
> If I managed to find someone to pay to get a copy of your post, would that mean you'd lose money?

Indeed, I would be losing a non-negative amount (call it X) of money that I could have earned, if you were to commit that crime. You should rather ask me for my permission. I will then have my options to lend you my copyright either for free (X = 0), for $y (X = $y), or not allow you to do so at all. If you do it anyway, then my losses would be at least the amount you sell it for; I might have been planning to sell it for more when the demand rises.

I am not sure if I am immediately granted such a copyright for my comments here, though.

Re:Microsoft attempts to spin its role in counterfeiting case by icebraining on Saturday April 28, 2018 @06:05PM (#16949653)
But you are already distributing your comments for $0! How can selling them for any amount be harmful to your future goal of selling them, compared to that? And the same applies to MS, who distributes the CD images for free on their site.

PS: You are granted copyright over your comments, as per the Berne convention.

Re:Microsoft attempts to spin its role in counterfeiting case by plufz on Saturday April 28, 2018 @09:02AM (#16947450)
I think comparing counterfeiting to robbery is just plain wrong. The definition of robbery is taking something by force/threat of force/fear. Comparing counterfeiting to theft is at least closer even though I think comparing IP crimes to theft is a bit dubious (not saying IP crimes are any less of a crime for that matter!).
Re:Microsoft attempts to spin its role in counterfeiting case by ThoAppelsin on Saturday April 28, 2018 @10:29AM (#16947792)
Excuse me for choosing the word robbery. I was not aware that it meant something different than theft. Did not realize that the different words for stealing implied different contexts. I have edited my comment accordingly.
Re:Microsoft attempts to spin its role in counterfeiting case by pnutjam on Saturday April 28, 2018 @09:34AM (#16947555)
Re:Microsoft attempts to spin its role in counterfeiting case by tomxor on Saturday April 28, 2018 @12:18PM (#16948304)
> The relation between the guy and Microsoft is clearly a parasitic one.

You could say the same about anyone trying to repair or extend the life of products... Does that mean that it should be punishable? Should the law really be protecting Microsoft's bottom line at all cost?

It is clear to anyone not distracted by pedantic legal interpretations and who can actually comprehend the difference between information and material goods, that the accusation of "counterfeiting" is a tenuous and misleading one.

Take a moment to go beyond the premise of "counterfeit == damages" and find out what that really means in this context, it doesn't take much effort: these are recovery discs, any real monetary "damage" done to Microsoft's bottom line would be the same as if every one of Microsoft's customers were ensured their right to restore the software to their computer when it failed, disregarding misplacing or never receiving or it being relegated to a long since corrupted partition (yes people can download it but most people are not technically competent and it's not in Microsoft's interest to spell it out to them)... this was already paid for by the license, they have every right to that disc and the disc alone does not give anyone the ability to install without a license.

These are the only substantial monetary damages, and this flimsy verdict is damning because it could potentially be interpreted as a precedent to attack anyone helping people to repair computers... but ya know... how dare you hurt M$ bottom line.

And before anyone brings up the straw man of "he profited"... on 25c per disc? really? after flying to china and back and putting all the work in to get them mass produced? I doubt he would have ever broke even, at best he might have made a meagre living, it's not exactly counterfeiting Rolex. I don't claim to know the intent of this guy but it can only be one of two: He was trying to help extend the life of countless computers needlessly thrown away every year, OR he was an idiot with delusions of grandeur, because there is no money in this (but don't confuse that with the ability to harm M$ bottom line, a cardinal sin). Don't get me wrong, I think what he did was pretty stupid, but what Microsoft is doing right here is sending a message of "If you hurt our bottom line, we will hurt you personally", regardless of their legal or moral right to do so.

Re:Microsoft attempts to spin its role in counterfeiting case by ThoAppelsin on Saturday April 28, 2018 @06:31PM (#16949774)
> And before anyone brings up the straw man of "he profited"... on 25c per disc?

Sorry, I could not find any resource where it says that he was profiting 25c per disc. I have found some others stating that he would be covering his expenses if he were to sell them for 25c each, and then the blog post from Microsoft states that he was selling them for $3.5 each. It really makes more sense that each disc costs 25c when mass-duplicated in China, than $3.25.

You already have already shunned this argument with your "straw man" talk. Would be a shame to step back just because you've laid that trap-threat to whoever replies. Here it goes: From what I've found, I'd say he profits $3.25 per disc and not 25c. The blog post from Microsoft also states that he made a revenue of $92,000 from this counterfeiting business. Here comes your straw man: $92,000 * ($3.25 / $3.50), approximately $85.500 is what he profited.

I don't know how much an average HN user is gaining, but that is a lot of money for me.

The argument on him being a selfless recycler is impossible to believe in, as the evidence shows that he labelled those discs to look like original Dell recovery discs. This leaves us either nothing but him being an "idiot with delusions of grandeur" as you've said, or he really was simply just making money out of this.

Re:Microsoft attempts to spin its role in counterfeiting case by tomxor on Saturday April 28, 2018 @07:54PM (#16950046)
Fair enough I only saw the 25c price not the "$3.25", however I cannot find the $92,000 figure, where did they pull that from? i'm wondering if they are mincing "business revenue" with "counterfeit revenue", they seemed happy enough to mix physical goods fraud terms to IP and not the reverse so I wouldn't put it past them.

In the article the only reference to making more than 25c per disc is:

> Records, however, show that Lundgren had sold several thousand to one buyer for $3-4 each

But "several thousand" * ~$3 doesn't sound much like 92k.

> I don't know how much an average HN user is gaining, but that is a lot of money for me.

Me too, but note that the term revenue is often used ambiguously and does not necessarily refer to net income, often people abuse this to inflate or deflate the number to help their narrative. _If_ that is the case here then 90k gross for a sole proprietor could be quite a low income depending on the margin... then again if this figure is really all about the discs, then ~90k - (flights + manufacturing run + shipping) could be quite profitable.

I can't find the real figures, happy if someone can enlighten us.

To be honest I don't have much empathy with this guy i'm just playing devils advocate now... My main argument was against your implication that hurting a business's revenue is automatically illegal, which is very close to saying capitalism is law. Perhaps you didn't realize you were implying that. The fact that this guy may or may not have profited from this is separate from the legality of the impact of restoring bought and paid for software against microsoft's profits, it's an important distinction.

Again just to be clear: Microsoft's loss should have no bearing on this case (because they are legal), the case is about someone potentially making money off something they shouldn't, much like selling GNU software (I know that comparison seems rediculous but I'm trying to highlight the separation of illegal profit from legal losses).

Re:Microsoft attempts to spin its role in counterfeiting case by syshum on Saturday April 28, 2018 @11:56AM (#16948212)
>>Microsoft would not create and offer Windows to the public, if the law allowed everyone to freely redistribute their products, and compete with Microsoft using their creation, as it would render their novel efforts meaningless against the much simpler effort of copying products created by the others.

So you believe Microsoft does not create any software that is allowed to be Freely redistributed and Open Source software does not exist at all, anywhere in the world.

>>Counterfeiting is an act that is similar to robbery

No it is not an act or even remotely similar to robbery. Further creating a Restore CD is not an act of Counterfeiting.

>apparent from the fact that this guy has succeeded in making money from what Microsoft gave birth to, and therefore owned

That is not the definition of counterfeiting, thus the fact the guy "succeeded in making money from what Microsoft gave birth to" does not establish counterfeiting. Hell if that was the definition every person that ever made money supporting, installing, etc the windows operating system would be "counterfeiting" it given they "succeeded in making money from what Microsoft gave birth to"

>Microsoft would be compensated justly if they were simply just awarding the monetary damage back by the damaging parties, here Eric Lundgren and his co-defendants.

Microsoft was justly compensated when they sold the orginal licence for the orgianal computer on which the Restore CD's where designed to Restore.

Microsoft now however wants to Double Dip and charge refurbishers for a 2nd license on for the same hardware, that is not just compensation that IMO should be considered fraud, and be illegal.

When Dell, HP, Lenovo ect sell a windows computer, they buy and resell a license to use that version of windows for the lifetime of the product/computer. A person restoring that system back to its OEM state should not have to rebuy that license from MS to preform that restoration. MS wants these recyclers to pay them $25 for a license the OEM already paid MS for.

Re:Microsoft attempts to spin its role in counterfeiting case by tomxor on Saturday April 28, 2018 @01:26PM (#16948637)
> Microsoft now however wants to Double Dip and charge refurbishers for a 2nd license on for the same hardware, that is not just compensation that IMO should be considered fraud, and be illegal.

This part i missed... is this true? do Microsoft actually charge refurbisher? Aren't licensed supposed to be for machines not people. They seem intent on stamping the damn thing on the side of all machines.

Re:Microsoft attempts to spin its role in counterfeiting case by syshum on Saturday April 28, 2018 @04:44PM (#16949326)
Yes, as stated in thier blog https://blogs.microsoft.com/on-the-issues/2018/04/27/the-fac... >>When a refurbisher installs a fresh version of Windows on a refurbished PC, we charge a discounted rate of $25 for the software and a new license – it is not free. Thousands of refurbishers participate in this program legally without confusion, and the program works.