The illegal act was a copyright violation: he made and distributed copies of copyrighted material without the consent of the copyright owner. I would be inclined to argue that his use was fair use, but based on what I know about copyright law, that argument is probably a stretch, and he didn't raise it in his defense. He plead guilty to the charges.
As to sentencing, the sentencing guidelines make the value of the illegally distributed goods the primary factor in determining the sentence. There is no objectively correct answer to this question, because no one sells license-less restore disks for any price. The three closest comparisons are
(1) The free restore disk image download offered by Microsoft. This is the same intellectual property, but doesn't come with a physical disk.
(2) OEM Windows disks that Microsoft sells for $25. These come with a license (unlike the defendant's disks) but do come with a physical disk.
(3) The original restore disks that come with a new computer. These match perfectly the intellectual property and the physical form, but they only come bundled as a small part of an expensive package, so it's hard to get a fair price from looking at this.
The defendant argued the free download was the better comparison, the prosecution argued the OEM disks were better. The judge sided with the prosecution, and assigned a value of $25/disk, which resulted in a stiff sentence.
I'm confused, what exactly are these, where can a private individual buy one? A Windows license key with (no media) is priced around $120, while an OEM license with no support is in the $50-$90 area, depending on the business relationship with Microsoft. If individuals were able to legally get a Windows license by "restoring" it for $25, it would be a riot, nobody would pay the retail price.
But if that $25 option is not available to consumers, then it makes the comparison to the free disks even more tenuous, and the fair use issue stronger, especially in light of the electronic waste issue. There is a fundamental social value that is being protected.
>The original Microsoft (COA) attached to the PC does not allow you to reload Microsoft Windows software when no original recovery media is present.
https://blogs.msdn.microsoft.com/mssmallbiz/2011/10/05/looki...
So the $25 doesn't come with a license. It gives you the physical media to comply with the license that came with the computer.
Dang. I should be treating those as more precious.
To be clear, I think the overall result here is an despicable perversion of justice, and I think US copyright law desperately needs to be reformed to include a more expansive version of fair use. I'm just explaining the way it works under current law.
That is correct. You still need a licence key to install Windows using those disks. Without the key the disk is worthless. They aren't and never were a way for people to get "free" copies of windows.
The value of Windows installation media is the cost of the disk it is burned to + the time it takes to burn unless there's an associated license (or a crack bundled that would let you bypass activation, which got laughably easy post-Windows 8 because of the new SLIC activation scheme).
Unfortunately, copyright law doesn't care - the copies were made, and the copies were distributed, unless the license explicitly allowed such copying Lundgren was in the wrong in the eyes of the law. Ironically, the same thing applies to the Windows 8/10 installation media you can download directly from the Microsoft website - though you can get it for absolutely free the license still prohibits distribution.
That's the cost, not the value. If value = cost, no one will ever make a profit.
Was this counterfeiting? Most certainly not in spirit, nobody was trying to say "here's a free/discounted copy of Windows" - there were no cracks on the media and you still needed a license to get Windows to activate, but the cold hard truth is the license agreement prohibits copying/redistribution of the installation media.
Lesson of the day: copyright law is stuck in the 1800's in many ways, so don't test your luck and ask Congress to fix it if you think it's broken.
If you had to restore a PC 10 years ago, your only options were to obtain a restore disk from the PC manufacturer, use a restore partition on the HDD (assuming it was intact) or buy Windows.
In the past, I had to get restore disk images on BitTorrent to fix friends computers.
It's just like you can offer some content on your website for free to anyone, but sue anyone who redistributes it for copyright infringement.
Presumably customers not receiving a restore image can now reclaim $299 from Microsoft as that is judged the value of the disc that was not included with their license purchase. Or indeed send back the install disc for at least a 50% refund.
Just think how much money MS would make buying back install discs for $150. /s (yes, that's right, at least -$150 per disc).
Crazy. That judge needs firing, or the person who put them in charge of this case does.
Windows is subject to copyright. There doesn’t need to be a license for you to agree to—that would be a contract.
Copyright gives the creator the final say on creating copies of their work. Just because someone gives it away for free-as-in-beer does not grant you a license to create and sell copies. Try recording and selling music from the radio if you dont believe me.
While there are exemptions to the rules like fair use, none of them applied here. If you’re unhappy with the judge, take it up with Congress. Because there is absolutely nothing wrong in the court’s application of current law.
They freely (libre and gratis) provide the files for download, the additional terms are laid out in contract. There's lots of precedent for assumed consent on web provided content.
They weren't selling the content they were selling facilitation of access to it. The discs provide a convenient means for people who are already licensed users of the content. Saying this is copyright infringement is like charging a router manufacturer or ISP with infringement.
In any case, this increases the value of MS Windows for those users, so actual damages are negative.
Given no end user ever acquired the media via this means the puniary damages are extraordinarily harsh. Add to that the rejection of expert witness, and the choice to assume provision of install media - that can't be used without a license - amounts to the full costs of a software product and I fail to understand how you can possibly consider this to be an even handed application of the USC.
They did not provide it “Libra”, and there is absolutely no precedent for assuming everything online is public domain. This is also a completely different argument than “fair use”.
> Saying this is copyright infringement is like charging a router manufacturer or ISP with infringement
That’s obviously different, or you would not make the analogy. ISPs transmit, they do not copy. There’s also an exemption in the DMCA for ISPs.
Why not actually look at the four factors of fair use:
The purpose and character of your use
the nature of the copyrighted work
the amount and substantiality of the portion taken
the effect of the use upon the potential market.
They did not transform the work in question, the work was one of the most extensive IP works ever, they copied it wholesale.That’s three factors that couldn’t be more unfavorable to their actions. Since MS does offer replacement restore disks for 25$, there’s also clearly some impact on the market.
Stop arguing from the result you want backwards. Lobby for different copyright laws, but don’t go around insulting the last reputable institution in the country, i. e. the courts, with your willful and frankly far too obvious misinterpretations.
Right below "more download options" is this text: *Your use of the media creation tools on this site is governed by the Microsoft Terms of Use for this website.
In the linked Microsoft Terms of Use there's this: "Notice Specific to Software Available on this Website" [...] WITHOUT LIMITING THE FOREGOING, COPYING OR REPRODUCTION OF THE SOFTWARE TO ANY OTHER SERVER OR LOCATION FOR FURTHER REPRODUCTION OR REDISTRIBUTION IS EXPRESSLY PROHIBITED, UNLESS SUCH REPRODUCTION OR REDISTRIBUTION IS EXPRESSLY PERMITTED BY THE LICENSE AGREEMENT ACCOMPANYING SUCH SOFTWARE.
There's definitely a hole in that quote "to any other server or location" means you can duplicate from the initial download location, surely. It wouldn't pass an analysis based on intent, but I don't think contract law in USA cares about intent except in cases of obvious error.
Thanks for the note anyhow, never noticed the link there, pretty sure I picked up ISO links on a different page in the past, maybe on Technet.
I've given people access to a pre-written disc with such a download on, which they then enter their license details for. Presumably the judge would consider me guilty of copyright infringement if I were in USA.
Reusing licenses is a different problem, and one that also plagues full install disks.
The only way to turn that disk into an actual counterfeit OS would be to crack the activation or use a keygen.
Say I buy a computer with windows pre-installed that means the OS license cost is bundled in to the price of the machine.
Say I have a computer without windows, or maybe an older cheaper version of windows. Is it correct that these restore disks arent a utility to get a free new copy of windows?
Just trying to understand