News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:In UK universities there is a daily erosion of integrity by Angostura on Tuesday April 24, 2018 @06:28AM (#16911345)
There's also the issue of what has happened now that students have to pay through the nose for courses. They are now customers who expect high grades for their fees. This has certainly changed the dynamic with regard to rigorous marking in some areas
Re:In UK universities there is a daily erosion of integrity by tonyedgecombe on Tuesday April 24, 2018 @06:44AM (#16911412)
I can't help feeling we would be better off if responsibility for grading was taken away from universities as it is for A levels and GCSEs. There are some problems with that but I suspect they would be outweighed by the benefits.
Re:In UK universities there is a daily erosion of integrity by thinkingemote on Tuesday April 24, 2018 @07:30AM (#16911641)
I've anecdotes from two university lecturers on different courses. They both want some form of external moderation. its what happens for Postgraduate degrees after all.

What they report is horrifying:

* Essay writing skills are lacking, "its at GCSE level"

* Students contesting any form of criticism - they go via the official channels to argue why they should get a good grade. All schools are tied up in multiple tribunals with existing staff. Often its easier just to pass the student.

* In some cases, students are SUING the university for poor grades

* Plagiarism is commonplace. There is an automated plagiarism detection mechanism for electronic submissions - but they are turned off or ignored as it's so rampant. People literally copying from Wikipedia or copy and pasting from papers to make their own work. Wikipedia copying is especially used for definitions, e.g. "Hacker News is a social news website focusing on computer science and entrepreneurship...."

* Students don't see that their education is also their own responsibility, and see it as a purchase. Give me what I pay for.

* Students who don't turn up to classes and seminars demand the same grades as those who do.

* Hundreds of students email lecturers asking for help with their work (much more numbers and frequency than in the past).

They both despair as they see education standards falling, and theres not much they can do. They don't want to be sued by the students, nor do they want to spend all their time in tribunals, they are educators first. They see their own institution as being of very poor quality.

To me - I would look at a league table of education quality for UK universities. There isn't one, you cant compare. Previously a good chance of good education was the research output of a department, or the references of the teachers. But this, as my associates report don't mean anything anymore.

Re:In UK universities there is a daily erosion of integrity by pbhjpbhj on Tuesday April 24, 2018 @07:44AM (#16911716)
>People literally copying from Wikipedia or copy and pasting from papers to make their own work. //

My lad is just in UK high-school but I'm surprised at how homework is set with no provision of resources and no mention of plagiarism or need to cite sources. The kids are basically expected to find their own sources, which is ridiculous - making them trust whatever Google gives them.

Once they've been inculcated into the notion that education resides in googling and cutting and pasting, without even reading the content, then it's hard to establish a good research ethic.

On top of this the teachers aren't even teaching good use of online search, or providing access to primary source material that gets referenced.

It's really dire.

Textbooks have their problems but ...

Re:In UK universities there is a daily erosion of integrity by vertex-four on Tuesday April 24, 2018 @08:04AM (#16911823)
In FE college, we had an occasional class (as part of something else, can't remember what) that explained how to use the Internet to research properly, determine trustworthiness, and cite sources, and also how to use the library at a basic level. I'd assume that sixth-form colleges in England and their equivalent elsewhere do the same - but perhaps it's too late by then?
Re:In UK universities there is a daily erosion of integrity by keithpeter on Tuesday April 24, 2018 @10:12AM (#16912699)
I can reassure you that 'research methods' courses are mandatory for all students in the vocational only FE college that I do some teaching in. Taught by LRC staff.

The plagiarism checker is active as well.

Most of the level 3 award tutors set a small assignment within the first few weeks of the course to assess writing level and catch any issues like dyslexia &c.

Re:In UK universities there is a daily erosion of integrity by jbob2000 on Tuesday April 24, 2018 @09:58AM (#16912598)
Funnily enough, this kinda matches how most people do their jobs now. "Just google it" is the solution to many problems in business. It's probably not the best long term strategy, but then again, neither is the stock market...
Re:In UK universities there is a daily erosion of integrity by imtringued on Wednesday April 25, 2018 @07:24AM (#16920487)
I think you got that backwards. The stockmarket is a bad short term investment but a good long term investment.
Re:In UK universities there is a daily erosion of integrity by maze-le on Tuesday April 24, 2018 @07:48AM (#16911741)
2 of my friends work in HR. They tell me, that they see a university degree not as a valuable certification criterion on its own. I mean, the tech industry has always been a bit special in this regard. There are lots of excellent autodidact programmers, that never saw a university and there are a number of people that have specialized in getting good grades, but could not implement 10 lines on their own. Most recruiters are aware of that fact, thats why we have to do stupid whiteboard interviews for senior developer jobs. I suspect, that with the further erosion of principles and standards of universities, this mindset will creep into other domains as well.
Re:In UK universities there is a daily erosion of integrity by drharby on Tuesday April 24, 2018 @01:44PM (#16914776)
If people are considering degree marks for a senior role, they have big things to worry about than if their candidate can whiteboard
Re:In UK universities there is a daily erosion of integrity by jamessb on Tuesday April 24, 2018 @09:54AM (#16912560)
> They both want some form of external moderation. its what happens for Postgraduate degrees after all.

Undergraduate university examinations in the UK already have external examiners [1]. For the national guidance, see Chapter B7 of the QAA's Quality Code [2]. This states:

> External examiners are not normally responsible for, or involved in, the assessment of individual students to the extent that they do not carry out marking of assessed work. However, to fulfil their role external examiners view student work, which ranges from reading essays or examination scripts to viewing performances (live or recorded) or artefacts. The volume of assessment generally means that an external examiner is unlikely to be able to view all the assessed work unless the cohort is small. Samples are of sufficient size to enable him/her to form a view as to whether the internal marking has properly assessed student performance against the appropriate standards.

[1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/External_examiner

[2]: http://www.qaa.ac.uk/assuring-standards-and-quality/the-qual...

Re:In UK universities there is a daily erosion of integrity by peoplewindow on Tuesday April 24, 2018 @08:08AM (#16911839)
That makes it sound like it's all the students fault.

I studied CS at a top tier UK university (not Oxbridge but a tier below). The course was a mess. The professors were useless, often didn't understand their own subjects, marking was random and arbitrary, most of them quite obviously saw teaching as a chore to be disposed of as quickly as possible and many failed hard at even basic principles of teaching, like "if you set coursework, students should all have the same amount of time to complete it in".

There was no effective way for students to complain or get anything fixed. The department ran a student/professor relationships council or something which was a joke, the students on it had volunteered mostly to suck up to the staff and didn't have any idea how bad the teaching was or how hard they were getting stiffed.

If universities were _actually_ real businesses I'd have been furious and demanded my money back, but they aren't so what can you do? I just tell people not to go to university at all these days.

Re:In UK universities there is a daily erosion of integrity by senorjazz on Tuesday April 24, 2018 @09:18AM (#16912281)
> Plagiarism is commonplace. There is an automated plagiarism detection mechanism for electronic submissions - but they are turned off or ignored as it's so rampant. People literally copying from Wikipedia or copy and pasting from papers to make their own work.

this isn't new. People were copying from wikipedia 18+ years ago I can assure you ahem

Re:In UK universities there is a daily erosion of integrity by eesmith on Tuesday April 24, 2018 @10:07AM (#16912671)
"Students contesting any form of criticism ... In some cases, students are SUING the university for poor grades ... Plagiarism is commonplace"

Anecdotally I heard the same stories 25 years ago when I was at university.

Re:In UK universities there is a daily erosion of integrity by gambiting on Tuesday April 24, 2018 @06:56AM (#16911464)
The issue isn't and never was with grading. No one is giving higher grades than they should in those UK universities that I worked with - the issue is specifically with lecturers being instructed to write exams in such a way that most people pass, because doing otherwise is bad for the department and for publicity. Which results in exams which are stupidly easy for anything that doesn't have "engineering" in the name.
Re:In UK universities there is a daily erosion of integrity by tonyedgecombe on Tuesday April 24, 2018 @07:08AM (#16911531)
I envisaged creating exams would come under the remit of an examination board just as it does for A levels and GCSEs.
Re:In UK universities there is a daily erosion of integrity by gambiting on Tuesday April 24, 2018 @07:16AM (#16911568)
I just can't imagine how that would work? Maybe for some "core" modules - sure. But if you have a Russel group university with an industry leading ML course, where the professor behind the course is the leading researcher in the area - who is going to write the exam for it?

The "problem" here is standardization(or lack of it) - and it's actually very good that university courses are not standardized.

Re:In UK universities there is a daily erosion of integrity by stctgion on Tuesday April 24, 2018 @07:27AM (#16911624)
You just paper swap with another uni. Oxford can hand it's engineering paper to Cambridge and see if it's hard enough etc. Not hard to do, it's just peer review for exam papers
Re:In UK universities there is a daily erosion of integrity by pbhjpbhj on Tuesday April 24, 2018 @09:04AM (#16912175)
Exam difficulty can't be assessed solely on the paper, the difficulty is also a function of the curriculum - if they teach to the exam, covering only a few topics which are then examined, then the exam is easier than if it selects questions from a broader curriculum.
Re:In UK universities there is a daily erosion of integrity by pbhjpbhj on Tuesday April 24, 2018 @09:02AM (#16912162)
It's not just one board though, which shifts the problem, then the boards are motivated to make their exams easier because that wins them business from schools who are motivated to get higher grades regardless of the educational outcomes.
Re:In UK universities there is a daily erosion of integrity by sgt101 on Tuesday April 24, 2018 @06:54AM (#16911455)
Tough to do this within the constraints of academic freedom; if an institution wants to offer a new course and they need to get certification by an authority and find externals to mark it... well could stall things by years?
Re:In UK universities there is a daily erosion of integrity by wastedhours on Tuesday April 24, 2018 @08:43AM (#16912027)
You already see this with courses around nursing and healthcare which need to be QA'd by external bodies like the local commissioning authorities. It does delay it, but not by as much as some of the internal processes that need to happen.

There might be more enterprising universities that launch courses quickly (and would probably still reserve the right to do it with things like masters courses), but most undergrad courses take years to develop and deploy anyway, so an external body reviewing the content and assessment criteria wouldn't hold things up much in comparison.

Re:In UK universities there is a daily erosion of integrity by sgt101 on Tuesday April 24, 2018 @12:07PM (#16913812)
For an entire degree program I agree, I've seen lots of agonising about these and many roadblocks. But for a module many universities are pretty agile right now - much to the student's benefit.
Re:In UK universities there is a daily erosion of integrity by tonyedgecombe on Tuesday April 24, 2018 @07:07AM (#16911527)
As I said there are downsides. I will say though that the courses on offer to my children when they went to university looked very similar. I'm not sure this would be a huge problem.
Re:In UK universities there is a daily erosion of integrity by golergka on Tuesday April 24, 2018 @07:22AM (#16911599)
Offer a course without a certification. Then, those students who are only in uni for the grades will not take it, but students who actually value knowledge will opt in for the course.
Re:In UK universities there is a daily erosion of integrity by BenElgar on Tuesday April 24, 2018 @08:01AM (#16911804)
Most people value both though; when I was in university I loved what I did and wanted to continue doing it somewhere excellent afterwards. For that I need to be armed both with the knowledge and the qualifications necessary.
Re:In UK universities there is a daily erosion of integrity by pbhjpbhj on Tuesday April 24, 2018 @07:48AM (#16911736)
Which then will be penalised by mainstream employers, because there's no certification - automated CV scanners will dump your application as it's "not a proper degree".
Re:In UK universities there is a daily erosion of integrity by golergka on Tuesday April 24, 2018 @08:15AM (#16911879)
Which, in turn, will reward no mainstream employers. After 11 years of design/engineering career without a degree, I don't think it's such a big issue.
Re:In UK universities there is a daily erosion of integrity by astrodev on Tuesday April 24, 2018 @07:47AM (#16911733)
PhD selection committees don't give much weight to grades (did they ever?) and instead rely on letters of recommendation. The corporate world doesn't care what one has gained from their degree apart from the social skills which universities don't grade for anyway. So who needs the grades to be rigorous?
Re:In UK universities there is a daily erosion of integrity by Angostura on Tuesday April 24, 2018 @08:13AM (#16911869)
> The corporate world doesn't care what one has gained from their degree apart from the social skills

As someone who interviews people for jobs - nonsense.

Re:In UK universities there is a daily erosion of integrity by ItsMe000001 on Tuesday April 24, 2018 @09:08AM (#16912197)
As someone who has been interviewed numerous times - the only time they ever even checked my university CS degree was for my very first job, and they only wanted it after I had already been accepted, to file it with my papers. The rest of the times I simply had the degree listed in my résumé.

This is IT, where it may be (even?) more lax than in other fields.

However, from following similar discussions for years, for example on reddit and also here on HN, with lots of people commenting who do or have done hiring decisions, the majority opinion seems to be that once you have a work history the particulars ceases to matter. Looking at my own two decades of experience, incl. a small business (sold), now another startup (of 40+ age engineers and business people, software), I would not care either. I had to check young candidates, it never crossed my mind to look at their grades. Talking and then seeing them work was far more revealing.

Related (NY Times opinion piece "The Utter Uselessness of Job Interviews"): https://www.nytimes.com/2017/04/08/opinion/sunday/the-utter-...

Re:In UK universities there is a daily erosion of integrity by gutnor on Tuesday April 24, 2018 @06:57AM (#16911472)
Another point is that immigration of qualified worker is the one that is not only accepted, but seen as desirable.

Universities are selling something for 45,000 GBP that is available for free or much cheaper in other countries and readily accessible to employers. At some point Universities need to give students their money worth in some form or another.

Re:In UK universities there is a daily erosion of integrity by pjc50 on Tuesday April 24, 2018 @07:01AM (#16911489)
Ironically UK university education is something of an export industry: there are a lot of people from non-Western countries who come here and pay full fees for the degrees because of their prestige. The government's gradual tightening of immigration policy is making this less viable.
Re:In UK universities there is a daily erosion of integrity by gaius on Tuesday April 24, 2018 @07:30AM (#16911640)
Ex-poly degree mills are rapidly devaluing this. It’s only a matter of time before British degrees become an anti-brand in China
Re:In UK universities there is a daily erosion of integrity by eptcyka on Tuesday April 24, 2018 @07:28AM (#16911627)
Actually, the high paying customers won't be put off by whatever immigration policy the current government will put in place. It's mostly EU students who will look elsewhere.
Re:In UK universities there is a daily erosion of integrity by pjc50 on Tuesday April 24, 2018 @07:44AM (#16911715)
It's not a question of being "put off" if you're denied entry or deported (wrongly or otherwise) by the Home Office.
Re:In UK universities there is a daily erosion of integrity by iguy on Tuesday April 24, 2018 @09:32AM (#16912394)
It's also a bit of an open question how many universities were effectively selling visas. Clearly anyone with a place at Oxford could find another way to immigrate if they wished. But one wonders how many fee-paying applicants to bottom-tier places were really paying for their basket-weaving lectures.