News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:United States v. Microsoft Corp. Dismissed [pdf] by dx034 on Tuesday April 17, 2018 @10:39AM (#16858734)
So if you want your data to remain out of scope for US warrants the only way is to choose non-US companies? Drastically reduces the options, I can only think of OVH and Hetzner that would qualify..

Or are the German data centres of Azure safe as they're run by a German company?

Re:United States v. Microsoft Corp. Dismissed [pdf] by eksemplar on Tuesday April 17, 2018 @11:11AM (#16859036)
It depends on who you are and who you deal with. We house a lot of our stuff in Azure, but we entered into an agreement with an European based Microsoft child company.

If the us wants access to our data, they’ll need to go through the Danish courts.

We spend a lot of money though, but it afford us our own private servers in the Irish farm, that we have physical access to and our data never enters the public part of Azure.

If the US government wants to get access, it probably can, after a few months in various EU courts, but all they’ll find by the in our little vault will be a tape recorder playing twister sisters - we’re not gonna take it on repeat.

Of course American companies will be replaced by an European competitor if the US government doesn’t wise up and stops being dicks. If there was a real alternative to American clouds we’d have left by now.

Re:United States v. Microsoft Corp. Dismissed [pdf] by dx034 on Tuesday April 17, 2018 @11:18AM (#16859104)
Is that still valid even though the European company is controlled by Microsoft? As I understand, the agreement they have in Germany basically hands over all control to Telekom, basically like a franchise model. As long as Microsoft Europe still controls access to the data, can't they be forced by Microsoft US to reveal the data? As I understood, that was the reason why OVH hesitated for so long to build US data centres and then used a separate company for it (not sure if they went through with that plan).

Not a lawyer so pure speculation but would be interested if anyone has details.

Re:United States v. Microsoft Corp. Dismissed [pdf] by eksemplar on Tuesday April 17, 2018 @11:24AM (#16859165)
As far as I know we’re perfectly safe within the setup we run. I haven’t been involved in the legal bits beyond asking for permission to put citizen data in the cloud and being granted permission by our government and the EU.

Maybe this verdict changes things, but if it did, I’m fairly confident that I would’ve known by now considering it’s a sensitive issue.

We do have extensive exit plans at hand, for such an event. Plans that are really just us burning money because the US surveillance state can’t get it’s damn act together.

Re:United States v. Microsoft Corp. Dismissed [pdf] by my123 on Tuesday April 17, 2018 @12:58PM (#16860102)
Microsoft German datacenters are unaffected yeah. They're not connected in any way to the upstream MS Azure network, the only way for MS to control them would be through an infected security update, which they'll never do.
Re:United States v. Microsoft Corp. Dismissed [pdf] by gowld on Tuesday April 17, 2018 @08:11PM (#16863510)
They are legally connected. The data may be protected by a European military, but Microsoft corporation isn't.
Re:United States v. Microsoft Corp. Dismissed [pdf] by ar0 on Tuesday April 17, 2018 @11:00AM (#16858936)
There are a lot of other cloud providers in Europe besides OVH and Hetzner:

- Upcloud (based in Finland)

- Cloudsigma (based in Switzerland)

- Deutsche Telekom TelekomCLOUD (based in Germany)

- Online.net / Scaleway (based in France)

- Aruba Cloud (based in Italy)

- Swisscom (based in Switzerland)

- etc.

Unfortunately none of them offer the breadth of services like Google Cloud, Amazon or Azure, but they most likely will be more than enough for many purposes.

Re:United States v. Microsoft Corp. Dismissed [pdf] by maltalex on Tuesday April 17, 2018 @11:07AM (#16858995)
Aruba Cloud have a 1 eur/month VMware-based VM with one core and a gig of ram in Italy an CZ.

It’s quite nice for tiny projects you don’t want to spend on.

Re:United States v. Microsoft Corp. Dismissed [pdf] by isostatic on Wednesday April 18, 2018 @04:10AM (#16865618)
Wow (or should I say Mamma Mia!), at that price it's rude not to.
Re:United States v. Microsoft Corp. Dismissed [pdf] by sschueller on Tuesday April 17, 2018 @11:51AM (#16859465)
- exoscale.com (based in Switzerland)
Re:United States v. Microsoft Corp. Dismissed [pdf] by perpetualpatzer on Tuesday April 17, 2018 @03:29PM (#16861517)
Your best plan is [1]: a) don't be a US citizen/resident, and b) store your data in a country where disclosure of this information is banned by law.

Under these conditions, the provider can (and has incentives to) challenge the order requiring the production of the data. If the order is quashed, the US government would need to get an order from the local government under MLAT for the data.

As for your German datacenter question... Under the text of the law, it depends on whether that data is within a US electronic communications or remote computing service provider's "possession, custody, or control." In theory, a service provider might contract out the management of these aspects of its operations, but it would be hard to imagine a service provider feeling comfortable moving the data outside of its control.

[1] See p 2205 of bill text for the CLOUD act part. http://docs.house.gov/billsthisweek/20180319/BILLS-115SAHR16...

Re:United States v. Microsoft Corp. Dismissed [pdf] by tathougies on Tuesday April 17, 2018 @06:33PM (#16862874)
I mean... duh? If you don't want your data accessible by a particular sovereign entity, its best to ensure your data is never in the jurisdiction of that sovereign entity. The meaning of sovereign is "We can do whatever crap we want here, and there's no higher authority that can judge us". If you're not okay with that crap, then don't interact with that entity, because -- as the term 'sovereign' implies -- there's no court you can appeal to to settle your dispute in your favor.
Re:United States v. Microsoft Corp. Dismissed [pdf] by lallysingh on Tuesday April 17, 2018 @10:42AM (#16858755)
I don't think #2 (Azure) applies. Your best bet is to store cryptographic keys offsite and leave the data in the cloud. There's a market opportunity for someone who can wrap that up in a reasonable API/library for use on EC2/GCP/Azure.
Re:United States v. Microsoft Corp. Dismissed [pdf] by andremat on Tuesday April 17, 2018 @10:51AM (#16858847)
Azure does have sovereign clouds, for instance its Germany cloud. [1] In this case data is handled by a German company and not Microsoft and so is subject to EU law.

[1] https://azure.microsoft.com/en-us/global-infrastructure/germ...

Re:United States v. Microsoft Corp. Dismissed [pdf] by dx034 on Tuesday April 17, 2018 @10:44AM (#16858769)
Why not use a non-US provider then? Maybe this will lead to more support for those. I can imagine that some EU companies will now struggle even more using AWS/GCP/Azure.
Re:United States v. Microsoft Corp. Dismissed [pdf] by lallysingh on Tuesday April 17, 2018 @01:49PM (#16860613)
Depends on where your customers are and the applicable scale/latency costs of not using the biggest providers.
Re:United States v. Microsoft Corp. Dismissed [pdf] by isostatic on Wednesday April 18, 2018 @04:14AM (#16865633)
If you want 20ms latency to customers in the US, you're going to be hosting in North America, damn relativity and all that.
Re:United States v. Microsoft Corp. Dismissed [pdf] by pjc50 on Tuesday April 17, 2018 @11:19AM (#16859109)
> Your best bet is to store cryptographic keys offsite and leave the data in the cloud. There's a market opportunity for someone who can wrap that up in a reasonable API/library for use on EC2/GCP/Azure.

Is there actually a market for this that people would pay for, or is it just something that people would like to exist?

Re:United States v. Microsoft Corp. Dismissed [pdf] by lallysingh on Tuesday April 17, 2018 @01:48PM (#16860605)
Sure, for downstream SAAS to use for customers. I think it'd be a nice add-on for services with customers outside the US who are wary of overreach. So if there are two web email vendors, and one has this protection and the other doesn't, it may be the deciding factor for a customer. The one that has that protection could use this service to do that for them.

Even without the national boundary feature, good crypto APIs not bound to your compute vendor is a nice thing to have.

Re:United States v. Microsoft Corp. Dismissed [pdf] by mtgx on Tuesday April 17, 2018 @10:45AM (#16858781)
It's a matter of herd mentality. The more the issue is raised, the more people will be willing to use services from other countries instead of US-based services, which means more non-US companies will gain prominence for certain services, which will encourage even more users to switch to them.

As long as everyone thinks everything is fine if they keep using the same old US services they've always used, none of those steps will happen. Expect to get a push-back from users who prefer continuing to use US-based services so they can justify their own choice.

Re:United States v. Microsoft Corp. Dismissed [pdf] by dx034 on Tuesday April 17, 2018 @10:47AM (#16858806)
If it really changes the business then I'd guess that one of the smaller providers (DigitalOcean, Linode, Vultr) relocates their headquarters to a EU country to circumvent that. Could at least bring non-US data centres out of scope.
Re:United States v. Microsoft Corp. Dismissed [pdf] by isostatic on Wednesday April 18, 2018 @04:05AM (#16865598)
That's always been the case - US law has had global jurisdiction for decades

To their credit, Microsoft have resisted US Government pressure [0] on this subject in the past.

[0] https://www.washingtonpost.com/world/national-security/micro...

Re:United States v. Microsoft Corp. Dismissed [pdf] by projectramo on Tuesday April 17, 2018 @10:52AM (#16858851)
Hetzner requires a copy of your ID which I find more intrusive. Does OVH?

If there is a way to sign up for Hetzner without giving them a copy of your passport, does anyone know?

Re:United States v. Microsoft Corp. Dismissed [pdf] by lucideer on Tuesday April 17, 2018 @10:53AM (#16858866)
OVH definitely doesn't, but this requirement by Hetzner is news to me. Do you know how long this has been in place?
Re:United States v. Microsoft Corp. Dismissed [pdf] by dx034 on Tuesday April 17, 2018 @10:57AM (#16858901)
I can't remember that I ever provided it but I heard this a lot. They say that it significantly lowers fraud rates. It's not a legal requirement. Interestingly enough, it's debatable if copies of state-issued IDs are even allowed in Germany (there were courts saying that practices like this are illegal). EDIT: apparently that's legal now, see the answer below.

I don't like the practice but believe their argument, hosting services attract a lot of bad actors and this will probably filter out most of them from the start.

Re:United States v. Microsoft Corp. Dismissed [pdf] by germanier on Tuesday April 17, 2018 @11:11AM (#16859045)
Copying ID cards in Germany has been made explicitly legal in July 2017 through a change of the relevant law.
Re:United States v. Microsoft Corp. Dismissed [pdf] by projectramo on Tuesday April 17, 2018 @10:57AM (#16858906)
I saw Hetzner cloud upvoted on here about 3 months ago and I liked the pricing so I tried to sign up, and they asked me to send them a copy of my ID.

So at least 3 months.

Re:United States v. Microsoft Corp. Dismissed [pdf] by jbergstroem on Tuesday April 17, 2018 @11:02AM (#16858948)
I've been using tilaa as a mail host for about ten years now; its a vm/storage provider based out of Amsterdam. I at least tell myself that my data is relatively safe there.
Re:United States v. Microsoft Corp. Dismissed [pdf] by projectramo on Tuesday April 17, 2018 @11:19AM (#16859118)
As others have pointed out, encryption is the only real protection.

Unfortunately, you are not supposed to do it yourself because its complicated so you have to find a trusted third party to do it that has been vetted.

But now you have to come up with a system to vet the vetters.

What a complicated world we live in.

Re:United States v. Microsoft Corp. Dismissed [pdf] by pvg on Tuesday April 17, 2018 @11:11AM (#16859042)
‘Avoiding lawful warrants’ is just not a service you’re easily going to get from a developed Western country.
Re:United States v. Microsoft Corp. Dismissed [pdf] by dx034 on Tuesday April 17, 2018 @11:21AM (#16859139)
It's not about that. Lawful warrants can easily get confirmed by a local judge and the FBI can access the data via local prosecutors. That already works where the crime committed is very clear. It's more about cases where the US government thinks they need access but where the EU would disagree.
Re:United States v. Microsoft Corp. Dismissed [pdf] by pvg on Tuesday April 17, 2018 @11:48AM (#16859424)
What are these cases that affect typical usage? And it’s not where the ‘US government thinks’. They need to show probable cause and get a warrant. Generally, when you get to that point, going from one developed democracy with fairly robust rule of law to another isn’t going to help.
Re:United States v. Microsoft Corp. Dismissed [pdf] by tracker1 on Tuesday April 17, 2018 @05:53PM (#16862651)
FISA court rulings are usually accompanied by gag orders here in the US, under "National Security" flags... This means they'd likely be unwilling and/or unable to consult with a foreign, local law enforcement.

Not that I really agree with it, most of the time the secrecy is for secrecy sake imho, and to advantage government prosecution. It's pretty scary tbh. Does this mean it's ok for a US company operating in China to turn over US information?

Re:United States v. Microsoft Corp. Dismissed [pdf] by pvg on Tuesday April 17, 2018 @09:08PM (#16863807)
None of this is really about FISA anything, so I'm not sure I follow.
Re:United States v. Microsoft Corp. Dismissed [pdf] by dx034 on Wednesday April 18, 2018 @02:01AM (#16865011)
But it could apply to an order by a FISA court as well? Just this specific case wasn't.
Re:United States v. Microsoft Corp. Dismissed [pdf] by pvg on Wednesday April 18, 2018 @07:56AM (#16866560)
No, that doesn't make any sense. If you're doing something in the US that makes you the subject of a FISA warrant and your data ends up overseas, the people who are after your data have a party. This is all, of course, far afield from 'typical case' anyway.

What happened is roughly this: Pursuant a warrant, USG wanted something from Microsoft, Microsoft said it was on a server in Ireland and outside the reach of the warrant, USG and Microsoft went to court to sort it out. Meanwhile US Congress passed a law addressing situations like and mooting this case. That's it. In the grand scheme of things, this didn't really change anything.

Re:United States v. Microsoft Corp. Dismissed [pdf] by neom on Tuesday April 17, 2018 @10:56AM (#16858896)
MLAT would probably allow a US court to ask a foreign entity via a foreign court to provide data of US entity, even if the data and the provider are outside of the US.
Re:United States v. Microsoft Corp. Dismissed [pdf] by dx034 on Tuesday April 17, 2018 @11:07AM (#16859004)
But that requires a local judge to confirm the view. I guess most of us naturally trust their local judiciary system more than that of other countries so that this will go a long way for many.
Re:United States v. Microsoft Corp. Dismissed [pdf] by gowld on Tuesday April 17, 2018 @08:15PM (#16863540)
The concept of "offshore companies" is that local government is a greater threat to freedom than a foreign government.
Re:United States v. Microsoft Corp. Dismissed [pdf] by isostatic on Wednesday April 18, 2018 @04:15AM (#16865641)
Who's freedom?
Re:United States v. Microsoft Corp. Dismissed [pdf] by rb808 on Tuesday April 17, 2018 @10:50AM (#16858838)
Alibaba cloud? Presumably Chinese govt can snoop but not sure how much power US has.
Re:United States v. Microsoft Corp. Dismissed [pdf] by projectramo on Tuesday April 17, 2018 @10:54AM (#16858873)
These are the lowest prices I have seen. Is this new? Surprised not have heard of this before.
Re:United States v. Microsoft Corp. Dismissed [pdf] by dx034 on Tuesday April 17, 2018 @11:01AM (#16858944)
I think they're close to a year old. Still more expensive than Hetzner though?
Re:United States v. Microsoft Corp. Dismissed [pdf] by dx034 on Tuesday April 17, 2018 @11:10AM (#16859032)
@projectramo (cannot reply to that): I have very good experience with Hetzner, speed is very good even if you ignore prices, considering the price it's by far the best I've used. I still have backups at other providers but switched to only using them for everything I do, saved me a lot of money. I already had an account so didn't need to provide ID but wouldn't see that as a deal breaker. You'd need to pay with credit card anyway so they'll get your name sooner or later. And it has helped with the spam problem they apparently used to have (for a while a lot of their IPs were on blacklists).
Re:United States v. Microsoft Corp. Dismissed [pdf] by projectramo on Tuesday April 17, 2018 @11:14AM (#16859069)
I am not mad at them for asking for my ID, but in the US that is (in my opinion) the big sign of intrusiveness.

When they want to scare people, they say "the police will start asking ordinary citizens for ID". Its a huge deal when the pharmacist asks for ID for a controlled substance.

And add to that the privacy culture here (on HN and in tech circles). I would rather pay a few extra bucks for now. But if they dropped the requirement I would use it.

I bet I am not alone and there are many others who feel the same.

Re:United States v. Microsoft Corp. Dismissed [pdf] by dx034 on Tuesday April 17, 2018 @11:23AM (#16859159)
I think that's down to cultural differences. In Germany, everyone has an ID and you need your ID to open any bank account or even as proof of age. Showing your ID to someone is just confirming who you are. In other countries (esp UK, US) that's very different. So asking for ID is not very intrusive for Hetzner (as they're German) but it's perceived very different by others.
Re:United States v. Microsoft Corp. Dismissed [pdf] by projectramo on Tuesday April 17, 2018 @11:36AM (#16859289)
I agree (although in the US, ID is used for bank accounts and proof of age).

I wonder if it would feel different if they didn't ask for a copy of the ID, but just had someone look at it.

I think it also feels different because no one else asks for it (VULTR, AWS, Dig Ocean, etc)

Also a drivers license feels less intrusive (for whatever reason) than a passport, and I believe for foreigners they want a passport.

Re:United States v. Microsoft Corp. Dismissed [pdf] by gowld on Tuesday April 17, 2018 @08:16PM (#16863550)
Ironically, German history is the reason why Americans are wary of National ID cards.

USA uses ID cards for banking and employment though.

Re:United States v. Microsoft Corp. Dismissed [pdf] by isostatic on Wednesday April 18, 2018 @05:21AM (#16865883)
The US seems to uses SSN everywhere.

The problem isn't necessarily a national ID card (after all most people have driving licenses, passports, etc). The problem is the data that's all linked and available to governments.

In today's world, where facebook knows far more than any government can, heroes like René Carmille become more and more important.

Re:United States v. Microsoft Corp. Dismissed [pdf] by skykooler on Tuesday April 17, 2018 @02:09PM (#16860835)
I remember being surprised when visiting Germany that a passport was required to get a prepaid SIM card.
Re:United States v. Microsoft Corp. Dismissed [pdf] by rando444 on Tuesday April 17, 2018 @11:43AM (#16859371)
I tried Hetzner based on other people mentioning it on HN. Total disaster.

They managed to erase my entire environment, not have any way to recover anything, and once my case got escalated within their company the responses I received were the most unprofessional communications I've received in my career.

Honestly, I am amazed that this is a German company at all. You usually expect Germans to be more organized.. but I guess no matter where you go, the old saying is true: you get what you pay for.

Re:United States v. Microsoft Corp. Dismissed [pdf] by chrisper on Tuesday April 17, 2018 @11:35AM (#16859278)
Hetzner has pretty bad peering imho. I was trying to use IPSec but it was impossible because at peak times UDP packets got dropped making my latency go into 200ms.
Re:United States v. Microsoft Corp. Dismissed [pdf] by projectramo on Tuesday April 17, 2018 @11:07AM (#16858994)
You're right. I wish Hetzner didn't require an ID because they're cheap and (allegedly) performant.

I wonder if serverpilot etc will work equally well with these guys.

Re:United States v. Microsoft Corp. Dismissed [pdf] by rgbrenner on Tuesday April 17, 2018 @10:56AM (#16858897)
[this was not entirely correct.. so I'm removing it]
Re:United States v. Microsoft Corp. Dismissed [pdf] by dx034 on Tuesday April 17, 2018 @11:00AM (#16858937)
Even if they sign an agreement, access to content of EU servers run by a company based in the EU will need a local warrant. The FBI won't get access without help of local law enforcement. And that can be hard even within the EU, as Spain just found out when they tried to arrest a politician.

I think many US citizens would be outraged if a Chinese court could issue warrants to access their data stored at any company. Not sure if EU citizens trust the US judicial system much more.

Re:United States v. Microsoft Corp. Dismissed [pdf] by rgbrenner on Tuesday April 17, 2018 @11:04AM (#16858967)
[removed]
Re:United States v. Microsoft Corp. Dismissed [pdf] by dx034 on Tuesday April 17, 2018 @11:12AM (#16859050)
Thanks for the clarification. In this case I'm not sure how many agreements they'll actually sign? Safe harbour already wasn't very popular and public opinion in the EU has shifted a lot more towards privacy in recent months (from my subjective feeling).