News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Subway Is So Late, It’s Making New Yorkers Early by SOLAR_FIELDS on Sunday April 08, 2018 @06:25PM (#16788833)
Reading this doubly reinforces how good it is in Sweden where I live now. While trains and buses are notoriously delayed (somewhat frequently), I can look on a phone app and tell when the next one will arrive +- 1 minute.

It’s no Switzerland or Japan, but it’s what a reasonably well run system looks like.

Re:The Subway Is So Late, It’s Making New Yorkers Early by wgerard on Sunday April 08, 2018 @07:05PM (#16789024)
Truthfully, it's mostly a problem caused by the sheer population density.

It's common for people to just head for the subway without knowing when the next train's arriving, which at off-hours can mean a 10-15+ minute wait for the next train. By which I mean: The concept of waiting around for an unknown amount of time for the next train isn't a huge deal.

The problem is how miserable the whole experience becomes when it's an unexpected delay at peak hours. If unexpected delays meant just hanging out on an uncrowded platform for 15 minutes to wait for an uncrowded train, the amount of complaining would be significantly lower.

Re:The Subway Is So Late, It’s Making New Yorkers Early by heliodor on Sunday April 08, 2018 @07:32PM (#16789143)
> "it's mostly a problem caused by the sheer population density"

That might seem like the obvious reason, but it's not the case at all. Read up on the NYC subway and its recent problems and their causes. Politicians use the growth in ridership as a scapegoat. There's more to the story than that. There's no physical/mathematical reason why a metro system of a bigger scale is precluded from running well.

Here's an article that offers a glimpse into various other angles and reasons:

https://www.villagevoice.com/2018/03/13/the-trains-are-slowe...

Re:The Subway Is So Late, It’s Making New Yorkers Early by wgerard on Sunday April 08, 2018 @07:40PM (#16789166)
Sorry, I meant that the experience for riders becomes miserable because of the population density (the third paragraph). If delays just meant waiting on an uncrowded platform for an uncrowded train, it wouldn't be nearly as much of a sore point.

I certainly agree with you that population density isn't the root cause of the recent subway issues - as evidenced by the fact that Tokyo's train system is working just fine.

Re:The Subway Is So Late, It’s Making New Yorkers Early by Bahamut on Sunday April 08, 2018 @09:23PM (#16789601)
As someone who currently is on a train to Osaka from Tokyo & who has lived near NYC, one thing I can say is while Tokyo’s system is well run, the rush hour crunch is real - basically everyone is nut to butt on the train. Sometimes you can’t even get on the train and have to wait for the next one.
Re:The Subway Is So Late, It’s Making New Yorkers Early by adrianN on Monday April 09, 2018 @01:00AM (#16790519)
Luckily trains in Tokyo run in really short intervals during rush hour.
Re:The Subway Is So Late, It’s Making New Yorkers Early by jac_no_k on Monday April 09, 2018 @03:30AM (#16791078)
Unless one lives way out in the suburbs and the train ride is 90 minutes. The first thirty minutes into Tokyo isn't too bad. It's the remaining sixty minutes which would shock most Westerners. Not looking forward to summer...

Which is why I bicycle into work. Sure it takes 90 minutes (I'm as fast as the train with all the stops) but my soul isn't squashed out by all the other sad salary men.

Re:The Subway Is So Late, It’s Making New Yorkers Early by addicted on Sunday April 08, 2018 @09:38PM (#16789678)
The density argument is probably incorrect. The city wasn't significantly less dense 6 years ago and things were a lot better.

This is a reflection of under investment and lack of maintenance and upkeep which was exacerbated by Hurrixane Sandy damaging the subway system significantly. It brought the chickens home to roost.

Re:The Subway Is So Late, It’s Making New Yorkers Early by dnautics on Monday April 09, 2018 @01:45AM (#16790688)
Is it under investment or mismanagement?
Re:The Subway Is So Late, It’s Making New Yorkers Early by caminante on Sunday April 08, 2018 @06:47PM (#16788928)
>[Sweden's public transit is] no Switzerland or Japan, but it’s what a reasonably well run system looks like.

Comparing Sweden to NYC isn't fair.

NYC Subway has ~742 stations (v. ~100 in Stockholm) and 1,756M in annual ridership (v. ~328M in Stockholm). This is just for the subway and excludes NY transit bus ridership.

Re:The Subway Is So Late, It’s Making New Yorkers Early by feiofh398r39rty on Sunday April 08, 2018 @07:49PM (#16789198)
Moscow metro has 250 stations on 3 times as much area (why did NY get to 750 stations?) and annual ridership of 2.4 billion. Train delays are rare, in my experience maybe one delay of 10 minutes a week (not counting the late night-time when intervals can get to 10 mins).
Re:The Subway Is So Late, It’s Making New Yorkers Early by BWStearns on Sunday April 08, 2018 @08:55PM (#16789460)
Moscow was one of the only places I've spent more than a week riding public transportation and not experienced a delay. Honestly confused as to that particular efficiency given the rest of the city/country's inefficiencies but they're doing something right.
Re:The Subway Is So Late, It’s Making New Yorkers Early by jacobush on Monday April 09, 2018 @02:46AM (#16790926)
Someone should investigate this. It's really, really strange.
Re:The Subway Is So Late, It’s Making New Yorkers Early by sah2ed on Monday April 09, 2018 @01:33AM (#16790651)
> Moscow metro has 250 stations on 3 times as much area (why did NY get to 750 stations?) and annual ridership of 2.4 billion.

Perhaps area is not a representative metric since you have to factor in population density when deciding where to site stations. Wikipedia says that NYC Subway is 380.2 km (236.2 mi) long while Moscow Metro is 364.9 km (226.7 mi) long, so the two are close in terms of route length. Also, Moscow beats out New York in terms annual ridership: 2.4b vs 1.8b.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_metro_systems#List

Re:The Subway Is So Late, It’s Making New Yorkers Early by g_sch on Monday April 09, 2018 @04:05AM (#16791215)
I think you may have transposed some digits. According to Wikipedia [0], the NYC Subway has 472 stations. Or 424, depending on how you count.

> The official count of stations is 472; however, this tabulation classifies some transfer stations as two or more stations, which are called "station complexes" within the nomenclature of the New York City Subway. If station complexes are counted as one station each, the number of stations is 424.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/New_York_City_Subway_stations

Re:The Subway Is So Late, It’s Making New Yorkers Early by caminante on Monday April 09, 2018 @07:53PM (#16797976)
>I think you may have transposed some digits.

I definitely did![0] Should be 472 (as you stated.) Thank you for correcting.

[0] http://web.mta.info/nyct/facts/ridership/

Re:The Subway Is So Late, It’s Making New Yorkers Early by tokyoguy on Sunday April 08, 2018 @08:20PM (#16789336)
so compare to Tokyo with ~2100 stations 14 billion annual riders and the trains run on time. NYC has zero excuse
Re:The Subway Is So Late, It’s Making New Yorkers Early by caminante on Monday April 09, 2018 @01:50AM (#16790709)
Can you provide citation for 2100 stations for Tokyo subway?

The wiki says 179 (1/10th your number).[0]

[0] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tokyo_Metro

Re:The Subway Is So Late, It’s Making New Yorkers Early by timlod on Monday April 09, 2018 @02:08AM (#16790768)
I'm not sure about the exact numbers, but 'Tokyo Metro' is only a small part of the Tokyo train network.

There is also Toei Subway, JR East trains, Minato-Mirai, ...the list goes on. 2100 may work for the entire metropolitan area of greater Tokyo.

In any case, the city is massive, extremely well connected by public transport, and services millions of people daily without delay.

Re:The Subway Is So Late, It’s Making New Yorkers Early by ajdlinux on Monday April 09, 2018 @04:07AM (#16791226)
Wikipedia (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Transport_in_Greater_Tokyo#Rai...) says "There are 882 interconnected rail stations in the Tokyo Metropolis, 282 of which are Subway stations, with several hundred more in each of the 3 surrounding densely populated suburban prefectures. There are 30 operators running 121 passenger rail lines (102 serving Tokyo and 19 more serving Greater Tokyo but not Tokyo's city center itself), excluding about 12 cable cars."

I could probably believe the 2,100 number if you include all the surrounding prefectures that are in the broader Tokyo area, and if you count stations multiple times for each railway operator services them (it's not uncommon for a single station in Tokyo to be run by three or five different companies).

Re:The Subway Is So Late, It’s Making New Yorkers Early by innocenat on Monday April 09, 2018 @04:32AM (#16791322)
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Greater_Tokyo_Area#Rail

> There are around 136 individual rail lines in the Greater Tokyo Area, and between 1,000 and 1,200 railway stations depending on one's definition of the area.

Re:The Subway Is So Late, It’s Making New Yorkers Early by taobility on Monday April 09, 2018 @01:13PM (#16794891)
Shanghai Metro has 393 stations and it's still expanding, with 3.53 billion annual ridership, and it has really rare delay.
Re:The Subway Is So Late, It’s Making New Yorkers Early by stefs on Sunday April 08, 2018 @08:23PM (#16789345)
well, do all factors scale linearly? if so, it shouldn't make that much of a difference. let's compare it to the subway system of vienna, austria (which is said to have one of the best public transport systems in the world).

so here's my personal theory.

all numbers - city population count, station numbers, system length and ridership - scale at a pretty much constant factor of 4. there are at least two huge differences though: density - that's ny:28,491/sq mi vs. vie:11,205/sq mi and year of opening is 1904 vs. 1976.

i'm pretty sure density is one of the deciding factors here, but let's pretend it's not - as ridership is comparatively lower at 3.99x -, what else might be different is the budget. viennas subway system is excellent but is so far up the curve of diminishing returns that the last few percent of reliability that sets it apart come at a steep price (the city pays with taxes).

other factors: vienna has a lot of alternatives in the form of trams and busses (and to a certain extend, trains), which take pressure of the subway. rate of biking is actually low compared to other cities because the public transport system is so good (and cheap).

so, some guesses as to why the ny subway system is so much worse:

* age: 1904 vs. 1976 - not sure if there's much of a difference as stations, trains and tracks have to be renewed periodically anyway. * density: population density is almost trice as high, but actual ridership scales linearly with the rest * travel distance in a randomized environment with choke points: if you'd assume that entry and exit stations are randomly distributed and the average travel distance is thus 4 times as long, the risk of encountering a malfunction is 4 times as high - and it takes just one to fuck your timetable up. not sure how likely that is, as, i guess, travels tend not to be randomly distributed in real life (i.e. you'll more likely choose a job that's closer to home). * budget: the big question here. is the ny subway public transport system 4 times as expensive as the viennese one? do they employ 4 times as many people? do they have the same level of machinery maintenance?

Re:The Subway Is So Late, It’s Making New Yorkers Early by hyeonwho3 on Monday April 09, 2018 @04:40AM (#16791347)
Many people have written many articles about the NYC subway recently. Because the trains run 24/7, they cannot renovate lines and install advanced train control. Because of the terrible train control, they put simplistic speed limits on trains. Because of all the slow trains the number of passengers per train increases, resulting in more platform delays and medical emergencies.
Re:The Subway Is So Late, It’s Making New Yorkers Early by berbec on Sunday April 08, 2018 @07:45PM (#16789182)
So NYC has 7x the number of stations for 5x the number of riders?
Re:The Subway Is So Late, It’s Making New Yorkers Early by CydeWeys on Sunday April 08, 2018 @07:59PM (#16789243)
The New York City subway system is old, one of the first in the world. It's not built to modern standards; in a lot of places it was built by cut-and-cover, which means excavating the entire route along the subway and then rebuilding the road essentially as a roof above the subway line.

As a result of this lineage it also has quite frequent stops, which are easy to put in when the subway is just a stairway's height beneath the street. To give you an idea, the 1 line stops at 14th, 18th, 23rd, 28th, and 34th Streets. That's five stops in one mile.

Re:The Subway Is So Late, It’s Making New Yorkers Early by mancerayder on Sunday April 08, 2018 @08:56PM (#16789461)
One of the first is a stretch, because the most compared lines were around or before NY's experience. The London Underground had its first line in 1863. Paris, 1900. NY, 1904.
Re:The Subway Is So Late, It’s Making New Yorkers Early by CydeWeys on Sunday April 08, 2018 @09:22PM (#16789598)
Maybe we should say "metro system" then, as NYC's first el train was 36 years prior to its first subway.

This table has the subway at the world's ninth oldest, which is definitely still one of the oldest considering there's hundreds now: https://www.worldatlas.com/articles/the-world-s-oldest-metro...

Re:The Subway Is So Late, It’s Making New Yorkers Early by mancerayder on Sunday April 08, 2018 @09:33PM (#16789657)
Agreed, although I'd add it's substantially more complicated to dug tunnels under dense cities. The Underground is a substantial feat in that regard.

As a tangent, London is adding overground trains as part of its expansion. The Overground is pretty recent (and it shows) as is the fully-automated DLR, and now there's a Crossrail making an appearance. NY hasn't invested in a hell of a lot in overground infrastructure and it feels like that's a logical step in the outer boroughs.

Re:The Subway Is So Late, It’s Making New Yorkers Early by lhopki01 on Monday April 09, 2018 @05:29AM (#16791561)
Crossrail is underground through London. The Overground uses existing rail infrastructure just under direct TFL management so isn't really new. There are a few new sections but they exist only to join up two lines. DLR is possibly the only real example of new overground trains and partly that is because it follows existing rail lines for quite a distance.
Re:The Subway Is So Late, It’s Making New Yorkers Early by tokyoguy on Sunday April 08, 2018 @08:23PM (#16789349)
not sure what your point was. Tokyo has several subways of a similar styl yet they manage to maintain them, renew, and rebuild while the train is running and stations are in use
Re:The Subway Is So Late, It’s Making New Yorkers Early by CydeWeys on Sunday April 08, 2018 @08:27PM (#16789362)
The point was to explain why the NYC subway system has a relatively high number of stations, in direct reply to someone who was asking why the NYC subway system has a relatively high number of stations. I'm not sure what your point is though.
Re:The Subway Is So Late, It’s Making New Yorkers Early by NikolaeVarius on Sunday April 08, 2018 @07:55PM (#16789227)
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stockholm_metro https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/New_York_City_Subway

Quick Wiki search indicates NYC has about 1,112 km of rail vs Stockholms 105.7 km. So about 8-9 times the distance

Re:The Subway Is So Late, It’s Making New Yorkers Early by DrScump on Sunday April 08, 2018 @09:46PM (#16789714)
Caltrain (on the SF peninsula) has a great Caltraindroid app that contains the schedules in a highly intuitive interface and with no privacy suckage.