News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Apple Plans to Use Its Own Chips in Macs from 2020, Repla... by Bud on Monday April 02, 2018 @03:29PM (#16738318)
That's not "likely" at all. Apple's CPUs are already faster in single-core benchmarks than the Intel competition, even though the Apple processors in question are designed for mobile devices and have much less power to work with.

Apple would not be making this switch if they didn't think they could improve performance.

Re:Apple Plans to Use Its Own Chips in Macs from 2020, Repla... by ajross on Monday April 02, 2018 @03:46PM (#16738536)
That's not remotely true. There is some crossover, which is notable. But that means that the fastest iPhone is faster than some of the slower desktops. Intel's current single core leader is a coffee lake running at 4.7 GHz with like 12MB of core-speed cache. Be real.
Re:Apple Plans to Use Its Own Chips in Macs from 2020, Repla... by samcat116 on Monday April 02, 2018 @06:06PM (#16739846)
Gotta remember that all these previous ARM chips have been designed in the context of the phone. If you suddenly tell the chip designers they have 10x the power and thermal headroom, theres a lot you could do.
Re:Apple Plans to Use Its Own Chips in Macs from 2020, Repla... by ajross on Monday April 02, 2018 @09:57PM (#16741286)
Sure, but "could do" isn't remotely the same thing as "already faster" now, is it?
Re:Apple Plans to Use Its Own Chips in Macs from 2020, Repla... by princekolt on Tuesday April 03, 2018 @09:03AM (#16744231)
Apple's A CPUs are already the best in their category, by far.

Knowing Apple had Intel Macs running in the background for years before they announced the jump to x86, I wouldn't be surprised if they already have the chips and know how well it performs.

And I also wouldn't mind if they did another demo like they used to: https://youtu.be/oxwmF0OJ0vg?t=24m45s

Re:Apple Plans to Use Its Own Chips in Macs from 2020, Repla... by Bud on Monday April 02, 2018 @05:31PM (#16739567)
The current A11 chip is faster single-core than the current MacBook Pro.

The Intel chip you mention isn't in any Apple machine at all. (Except maybe the iMac Pro? Is it even in that?) So you be real. I don't think you've actually looked at the benchmarks. You should do so. I think you'll be shocked at just how much overlap there is, just like I was.

Re:Apple Plans to Use Its Own Chips in Macs from 2020, Repla... by asdginionio on Monday April 02, 2018 @07:41PM (#16740497)
>I don't think you've actually looked at the benchmarks.

What benchmarks? Geekbench? That's the only one I've ever seen where the fight is close, and Geekbench (like everything that boils performance down to one number) is nearly completely useless.

If you see a two-watt phone CPU beating a 45-watt actively-cooled laptop CPU, you can either conclude that the phone is alien technology decades ahead of anything else on the market or that the benchmark is broken. Which is more likely?

https://www.realworldtech.com/forum/?threadid=136526&curpost...

Re:Apple Plans to Use Its Own Chips in Macs from 2020, Repla... by throwahey on Monday April 02, 2018 @08:08PM (#16740662)
Does Linus not realize that Intel processors also have hardware assisted SHA?

Geekbench may not be the best tool for determining the power of a processor, but at the least it gives you a general idea of power across devices in a consistent set of tests, which can be extrapolated.

Re:Apple Plans to Use Its Own Chips in Macs from 2020, Repla... by asdginionio on Monday April 02, 2018 @08:25PM (#16740770)
They didn't at the time he wrote that.

That post is pretty outdated. It's about old hardware and an old version of Geekbench. But people still use Geekbench 3 and old x86 hardware, so it's not totally irrelevant.

Re:Apple Plans to Use Its Own Chips in Macs from 2020, Repla... by dannyw on Monday April 02, 2018 @10:52PM (#16741527)
We are talking about the MacBook, IE passively cooled Intel Core m3 running at 1.2 GHz on something like 8 Watts TDP.
Re:Apple Plans to Use Its Own Chips in Macs from 2020, Repla... by LoSboccacc on Monday April 02, 2018 @06:41PM (#16740128)
that's because apple is fixed on choosing the intel parts with the least tdp power they can get away with. it's their choice to make the mbp slow, up and including the numerous thermal issues that force the cpu out of the nominal turbo mode for the longer workloads
Re:Apple Plans to Use Its Own Chips in Macs from 2020, Repla... by Bud on Monday April 02, 2018 @07:16PM (#16740334)
Those are valid points, but it's still shocking that Apple's own CPUs can outperform Intel laptop CPUs with far higher TDP.
Re:Apple Plans to Use Its Own Chips in Macs from 2020, Repla... by hvidgaard on Tuesday April 03, 2018 @05:26AM (#16743078)
Benchmarks aside, because they can and are gamed, the only real way to see this, is loading a big workload such as Photoshop, Kernel compilation, ect., that professionals do every single day. I very much doubt that A11 is even remotely close to a mid range quadcore Intel cpu, and let's not forget that we're in the middle of moving to 6-8 core cpus.
Re:Apple Plans to Use Its Own Chips in Macs from 2020, Repla... by walshemj on Monday April 02, 2018 @07:18PM (#16740355)
The 8700k which the previous poster mentioned is a hex core with 12 Threads!
Re:Apple Plans to Use Its Own Chips in Macs from 2020, Repla... by awalton on Monday April 02, 2018 @06:13PM (#16739905)
> Apple's CPUs are already faster in single-core benchmarks than the Intel competition

Extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence. "But Geekbench..." is not extraordinary evidence. Give me a board where I can do an Apple to apples comparison, booting both under the same revision of the same OS, and running industry standard benchmarks (read: plural), and then we can come to that conclusion.

Re:Apple Plans to Use Its Own Chips in Macs from 2020, Repla... by snowwrestler on Monday April 02, 2018 @07:00PM (#16740241)
No one is stopping you from doing that experiment.

> Extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence.

"Extraordinary" is in the eye of the beholder. We have some evidence; you're welcome to believe it or not, but unless you supply alternative evidence you're not really making an argument. You're just saying "it might not be true," which is something anyone can say at any time about anything.

Re:Apple Plans to Use Its Own Chips in Macs from 2020, Repla... by hcnews on Monday April 02, 2018 @11:38PM (#16741713)
Nice, that was a good explanation for your stance. I am not supporting either, just liked the turnout. Obviously this isn't my usual kind of hn comment.
Re:Apple Plans to Use Its Own Chips in Macs from 2020, Repla... by ReverseCold on Tuesday April 03, 2018 @12:12AM (#16741863)
"booting both under the same revision of the same OS"

It should be irrelevant in Apple's case anyway since they run their own OS. If their OS is faster for a certain task than some other OS then that's part of what you would define as "faster" for a user of the device.

Right? Am I missing something?

Re:Apple Plans to Use Its Own Chips in Macs from 2020, Repla... by drham on Monday April 02, 2018 @03:36PM (#16738414)
Faster, probably, but 2x+ Faster like in PowerPC > Intel very unlikely. Which is why there’s much less likely to be enough performance budget for effective emulation.
Re:Apple Plans to Use Its Own Chips in Macs from 2020, Repla... by saagarjha on Monday April 02, 2018 @03:46PM (#16738530)
Presumably their "desktop-grade" A-whatever chip will have a higher TDP and clock speed than their mobile counterparts.
Re:Apple Plans to Use Its Own Chips in Macs from 2020, Repla... by gascan on Monday April 02, 2018 @03:59PM (#16738670)
If they could just turn up the TDP and clock speed on their chips and get 2x the performance of Intel's best chips that easily- they would already own the entire desktop market.
Re:Apple Plans to Use Its Own Chips in Macs from 2020, Repla... by mozumder on Monday April 02, 2018 @04:12PM (#16738800)
And some of us, with actual CPU design backgrounds, have been saying that for a while now.

We've been asking why Apple doesn't already do it.

Re:Apple Plans to Use Its Own Chips in Macs from 2020, Repla... by samcat116 on Monday April 02, 2018 @06:08PM (#16739872)
As someone without a CPU design backround, would something like this scale pretty linearly with added power and thermal headroom? I assume there are limit that would have to be overcome, but what would an ARM chip in the conditions of an i7 look like?
Re:Apple Plans to Use Its Own Chips in Macs from 2020, Repla... by bzbarsky on Tuesday April 03, 2018 @10:28AM (#16744922)
TDP typically scales as somewhere between the cube and fourth power of the clock speed if you're pushing the envelope (in the sense of running at frequencies where further frequency increase also needs a voltage increase). So having 10x the thermal envelope means you can probably clock about twice as fast, all else being equal.
Re:Apple Plans to Use Its Own Chips in Macs from 2020, Repla... by mozumder on Monday April 02, 2018 @07:43PM (#16740516)
It's more of a logarithmic scale.

The same architecture can generally scale to 10x over a few process generations.

Re:Apple Plans to Use Its Own Chips in Macs from 2020, Repla... by arbie on Monday April 02, 2018 @11:09PM (#16741592)
This does not hold at 10nm and below.
Re:Apple Plans to Use Its Own Chips in Macs from 2020, Repla... by BillinghamJ on Monday April 02, 2018 @06:39PM (#16740116)
Seems that it’s more of a logistical and network-effect issue in getting everyone to support it, rather than a technical issue.

Possibly a patent issue also

Re:Apple Plans to Use Its Own Chips in Macs from 2020, Repla... by mozumder on Monday April 02, 2018 @11:27PM (#16741671)
My only question is if they actually use ARM for their next-generation architecture, or something completely new...
Re:Apple Plans to Use Its Own Chips in Macs from 2020, Repla... by mozumder on Monday April 02, 2018 @03:46PM (#16738537)
Computer architectures routinely see 3x performance jumps across different power budgets. This rule has held over decades.

Clock speeds alone can probably increase by 30%. Caches and internal datapaths can double or more. Then you can start to add in more execution units or more expensive branch-prediciton or even new more power-hungry instructions.

A 4 Watt Intel Pentium 4410Y Kaby Lake for mobile devices gets about 1800 on Geekbench, while a 115 Watt Intel Core i7-7700K Kaby Lake for desktops gets 5600.

I'm just going to say it: the Apple laptop CPU is going to get Geekbench score... above 9000!

And, yes, I do have a CPU design background.

Re:Apple Plans to Use Its Own Chips in Macs from 2020, Repla... by michaelmrose on Monday April 02, 2018 @05:15PM (#16739393)
So artificial benchmarks already do a very poor job of capturing performance. The apple laptop cpu does not exist. If it did exist it would likely suffer a very substantial performance hit if forced to emulate x86 software. So you are going to speculate on the meaningless benchmark numbers of an imaginary cpu that will take a wholly unknown hit if everyone does not rewrite everything why?
Re:Apple Plans to Use Its Own Chips in Macs from 2020, Repla... by mozumder on Monday April 02, 2018 @06:59PM (#16740236)
Artificial benchmarks do a great job of capturing performance, since they're more controlled and eliminate unnecessary variables.

Once you understand this, then you can understand how CPU designers work to predict future performance. CPU designers use artificial testbenches.

Re:Apple Plans to Use Its Own Chips in Macs from 2020, Repla... by michaelmrose on Monday April 02, 2018 @10:26PM (#16741414)
You making up numbers doesn't appear to be a useful endeavor.
Re:Apple Plans to Use Its Own Chips in Macs from 2020, Repla... by sjwright on Tuesday April 03, 2018 @12:34AM (#16741937)
I suspect if Apple designs a desktop CPU, performant x86 emulation will be a key design criteria. I know very little about CPU design, but I imagine it would be possible to have hardware optimisations for x86 emulation just like we have today for video codecs.

Or even further they could bake a "rosetta" into the chip's microcode and have their CPU natively support the x86 instruction set along with ARM or whatever they come up with.

Re:Apple Plans to Use Its Own Chips in Macs from 2020, Repla... by walshemj on Monday April 02, 2018 @07:20PM (#16740375)
Which is the previous gen and was sandbagged as the 50% increase in cores for coffee lake show.
Re:Apple Plans to Use Its Own Chips in Macs from 2020, Repla... by your-nanny on Monday April 02, 2018 @07:02PM (#16740251)
If someone disagrees they should state why
Re:Apple Plans to Use Its Own Chips in Macs from 2020, Repla... by megy on Monday April 02, 2018 @07:42PM (#16740508)
Do you think they will use the same chip? In 2020?