News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Analysts argue that over-automation is to blame for Tesla... by throwaway84742 on Thursday March 29, 2018 @01:25AM (#16704687)
Hmm, who do I trust, the guy who figured out how to land rockets onto a barge, or some “analyst” desk jockey who has been consistently wrong his entire career? Tough question. I think I’ll go with the rocket guy. He has a pretty good track record.
Re:Analysts argue that over-automation is to blame for Tesla... by provost on Thursday March 29, 2018 @04:24AM (#16705434)
> Hmm, who do I trust, the guy who figured out how to land rockets onto a barge, or some “analyst” ...

This kind of comment is a disservice to all the engineers who actually figured it out. Elon Musk is certainly a visionary and a financier, but is not a 1000x engineer/mathematician who did all the work himself

Re:Analysts argue that over-automation is to blame for Tesla... by nickik on Thursday March 29, 2018 @07:47AM (#16706200)
The reality is that Elon is and was the Chief Engineer for the Falcon rocket family. He had the vision, the finance and he lead the engineering effort extremely directly and successfully. He overruled his top guys on multiple decisions and usually he turned out to be right.

Go listen to Tom Mueller on the design choices made for the Merlin example.

But of course nobody does everything himself, but for some reason I read this sort of comment made about Musk in every single thread but not with most other people.

Re:Analysts argue that over-automation is to blame for Tesla... by dingaling on Thursday March 29, 2018 @08:35AM (#16706462)
Mr Musk has strategic vision, but not necessarily engineering vision. Which is fine, engineering is a huge field.

Bear in mind that the first time one of his staff proposed verticals landing rocket stages, he laughed.

Re:Analysts argue that over-automation is to blame for Tesla... by throwaway84742 on Thursday March 29, 2018 @02:51PM (#16709965)
He does have a degree in physics though. So he probably has a pretty good grasp on the concepts involved, as well as a finely tuned bullshit detector.
Re:Analysts argue that over-automation is to blame for Tesla... by examancer on Thursday March 29, 2018 @05:37AM (#16705707)
While it is a good idea to spread to credit for SpaceX's acheivements around, Musk himself has done more engineering of products at SpaceX and Tesla than any of his peers. His title as CEO of both companies is somewhat misleading as he has very little involvement in business operations of either company and spends most of his time engineering.
Re:Analysts argue that over-automation is to blame for Tesla... by TheArcane on Thursday March 29, 2018 @05:42AM (#16705735)
Source?
Re:Analysts argue that over-automation is to blame for Tesla... by nickik on Thursday March 29, 2018 @07:50AM (#16706212)
He is Chief Engineer at SpaceX, because they couldn't get anybody.

Go listen to Tom Mueller for example. Musk himself says at SpaceX 80% of the time he is working on engineering not traditional 'CEO' things..

Re:Analysts argue that over-automation is to blame for Tesla... by simonh on Thursday March 29, 2018 @02:47AM (#16705035)
Not a comparison I would choose. He has a pretty good track record of producing a few dozen rockets a year. You could be generous and say a few hundred rocket engines a year. A comedian might say he has the same track record with cars - ba dum - tish!

Tesla's inability to quickly ramp up Model 3 production is pretty much one of those "fact" things at this point. The same goes for every model they've brought out, it's taken a long time to get decent production rates on any of them. So this isn't so much predicting problems he's going to have, but explaining the causes of all the problems they've already had and are having right now.

Re:Analysts argue that over-automation is to blame for Tesla... by aerovistae on Thursday March 29, 2018 @02:54AM (#16705060)
But that's the great trick he pulled....convincing everyone that not reaching 500,000 cars per year in 2 years is "failure"-- that Tesla is exhibiting an "inability."
Re:Analysts argue that over-automation is to blame for Tesla... by jacquesm on Thursday March 29, 2018 @03:24AM (#16705188)
But it is a failure. If you make predictions as a public company and then you can't live up to them you have a problem. That's not to say Musk has done some spectacular stuff but he's definitely not on target. Let's hope it all gets fixed before time runs out.
Re:Analysts argue that over-automation is to blame for Tesla... by ggm on Thursday March 29, 2018 @05:25AM (#16705651)
Investors are entitled to believe goals are achievable. If the goals are not achievable, they have to be corrected as quickly as possible or else legal consequences may stem. If you made an investment even with all the flowery legal contract language, how would you feel if the CEO said "it was always a moonshot" having previously said "it's achievable"
Re:Analysts argue that over-automation is to blame for Tesla... by dx034 on Thursday March 29, 2018 @01:29AM (#16704708)
But SpaceX builds very complex machines at a low rate, whereas Tesla tries to build less complex machines at a very high rate. I'm not sure if knowledge is transferable.
Re:Analysts argue that over-automation is to blame for Tesla... by qubex on Thursday March 29, 2018 @04:38AM (#16705484)
This is an interesting juxtaposition, but I’m not (really) sure it’s true. Is a rocket, even one with an advanced control system such as those designed by SpaceX, really ‘simpler’ than an electric vehicle? We certainly think in those terms, because rockets are exotic to our experience whereas cars are experientially mundane for most of us, but I don’t think the facts of the matter are that clear cut.
Re:Analysts argue that over-automation is to blame for Tesla... by dx034 on Thursday March 29, 2018 @09:45AM (#16706965)
They're certainly more complex as a result of higher quality demands. A car can be tested under real-world conditions and fixed if it shows any manufacturing defects. Any mistakes with a rocket are very expensive.

Testing is also very different. For a car, you can build a batch and test it extensively under all conditions, fixing errors as they come up. If you develop an assistance system, you can test this extensively before releasing it. Rockets are so expensive that SpaceX had only a few trials for their landing system. You need to make sure that both hardware and software work perfectly without ever testing them in production.

Re:Analysts argue that over-automation is to blame for Tesla... by greglindahl on Thursday March 29, 2018 @02:34PM (#16709752)
It's worth noting that one big advantage SpaceX has over other rocket makers is that SpaceX gets to inspect landed first stages. That makes their rocket development closer to airplane development than everyone else's rocket development, and no, it doesn't have to be perfect before it is tested. It just has to be good enough to land.
Re:Analysts argue that over-automation is to blame for Tesla... by regularfry on Thursday March 29, 2018 @06:29AM (#16705901)
There was a point in the early 2000s (and I don't know how long it persisted for) when ESA had a very hard time hiring rocket scientists because they were all being slurped up by car manufacturers to work on drive-by-wire systems.
Re:Analysts argue that over-automation is to blame for Tesla... by ggm on Thursday March 29, 2018 @05:26AM (#16705656)
Werner von Braun had to crash hundreds into London and Antwerp to learn how not to crash them at white sands and Cape Canaveral
Re:Analysts argue that over-automation is to blame for Tesla... by wongarsu on Thursday March 29, 2018 @06:59AM (#16706007)
And how does that compare to the development of early combustion or electric engines?

I'm not so sure about electric cars, but I would judge a rocket to be less complex than an ICE car. Rockets just have much more spectacular failure modes and are more expensive due to size.

Re:Analysts argue that over-automation is to blame for Tesla... by ballooney on Thursday March 29, 2018 @04:02AM (#16705354)
They guy who figured out how to land a rocket on a barge is a spacex employee who is an expert in control theory, who was probably hired by another employee of Elon Musk. So I’m not really sure what you comparison means.
Re:Analysts argue that over-automation is to blame for Tesla... by IshKebab on Thursday March 29, 2018 @04:35AM (#16705471)
Or even more realistically, no "one guy figured it out". A team of people worked on it for years and eventually got it to work.
Re:Analysts argue that over-automation is to blame for Tesla... by sundvor on Thursday March 29, 2018 @05:57AM (#16705790)
Musk created the company and instilled the work culture as well as the vision that made it happen - the hiring and all.

Can't help but think that if learning to get really good at robotics is a strategic goal, then that's something which might pay off later.

Re:Analysts argue that over-automation is to blame for Tesla... by SubNoize on Thursday March 29, 2018 @08:06AM (#16706285)
he's so obviously setting up for asteroid mining. autonomous spaceships, robotics and more autonomous vehicles, mining company etc.

when his 100% robotic and autonomous ships mine an asteroids and bring back huge payloads we'll still probably see articles like this.

Re:Analysts argue that over-automation is to blame for Tesla... by jetru on Thursday March 29, 2018 @04:53AM (#16705539)
Who do I trust? A person I can identify by name and track a person down who has written an article. Or an anonymous account on HN named 'throwaway*'. Yea...you see?
Re:Analysts argue that over-automation is to blame for Tesla... by kolinko on Thursday March 29, 2018 @01:02PM (#16708687)
I digged out a report from Bernstein (the same company that delivered the one reported in the article) from 2011:

"They have concluded that improvements to conventional engines will be key over the next 10 to 15 years and HEVs will become viable on a large scale by 2020. They believe near-term mass market adoption of electric vehicles is unlikely given the tough financial comparison with ever improving combustion engine vehicles. While premium-priced plug-ins may become viable earlier, by definition they will be niche products."

https://seekingalpha.com/article/310159-bernstein-and-ricard...

Re:Analysts argue that over-automation is to blame for Tesla... by tajen on Thursday March 29, 2018 @11:42AM (#16707946)
Who do I trust, the guy who was told “It is impossible to reuse rockets” by all NASA engineers and built a company around it, or the analyst described as follow:

> Warburton, who spent his career before Wall Street at the International Motor Vehicle Program — a partly academic, partly commercial organization based at MIT — wrote that "automation in final assembly doesn't work."

It doesn’t even matter since it’s not public money. Which makes me wonder about the analyst’s intent: Tell people not to invest? Do people not know Tesla is super-risky? but if they succeed to obliterate this anchored rule that automation doesn’t work in the final assembly, isn’t that a superwin that stakeholders dream of?

Friends who invested in Tesla didn’t “invest” so much as “donated” money for what they think is a good cause. And perhaps because it’s fun to hear the NASA chief say “I had asked my engineers and they told me it wasn’t possible”.

I’d pay for that kind of fun.

Re:Analysts argue that over-automation is to blame for Tesla... by empath75 on Thursday March 29, 2018 @05:28AM (#16705661)
Alternatively, do you trust the guy that is running a company that is going to be out of money in a few months?
Re:Analysts argue that over-automation is to blame for Tesla... by slivym on Thursday March 29, 2018 @05:37AM (#16705711)
Or to put it another way. Why is the guy running a car company busy putting rockets into space?
Re:Analysts argue that over-automation is to blame for Tesla... by blackbagboys on Thursday March 29, 2018 @03:14AM (#16705152)
"He" figured this out, or some of the hundreds of engineers and scientists employed by him in an entirely separate enterprise figured it out?
[dead]
Re:Analysts argue that over-automation is to blame for Tesla... by dang on Saturday March 31, 2018 @06:21PM (#16725474)
Personal attacks will get you banned on HN. Please don't do that again.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:Analysts argue that over-automation is to blame for Tesla... by sveme on Thursday March 29, 2018 @07:03AM (#16706023)
Appeal to authority is never a good argument for or against something.
Re:Analysts argue that over-automation is to blame for Tesla... by prostoalex on Thursday March 29, 2018 @01:36AM (#16704742)
The report also seems to discuss the evils of excessive automation in general.

So yeah, this could apply to Tesla cars. Or rubber toys, which are also manufactured in a highly automated environment.

Re:Analysts argue that over-automation is to blame for Tesla... by pretendscholar on Thursday March 29, 2018 @01:31AM (#16704717)
Does he really have a good track record? If I recall correctly the Falcon 9 has a terrible success rate for a modern rocket. Something like 94 percent.
Re:Analysts argue that over-automation is to blame for Tesla... by arrrg on Thursday March 29, 2018 @01:59AM (#16704828)
Falcon 9

51 launches

48 completely successful

49 partially successful

94% success rate (complete success)

96% success rate (partial success)

Ariane 5

97 launches

92 completely successful

95 partially successful

95% success rate (complete success)

98% success rate (partial success)

Atlas V

76 launches

75 completely successful

76 partially successful

99% success rate (complete success)

100% success rate (partial success)

Delta IV (including Heavy)

36 launches

35 completely successful

36 partially successful

97% success rate (complete success)

100% success rate (partial success)

Proton (since 2010 as an arbitrary cutoff)

65 launches

58 completely successful

59 partially successful

89% success rate (complete success)

91% success rate (partial success)

I don’t really think there is any way in which the adjective “terrible” would be an appropriate use of the word here. Also note the low numbers involved here, the different contexts and the plain arbitrariness of such comparisons. One failure more or less can make a world of difference here, despite maybe not being the most reliable indicator.

94% is about the long term ballpark figure for successful orbital launches but it is true that some newer rocket families may have ever so slightly higher reliabilities.

Re:Analysts argue that over-automation is to blame for Tesla... by toufka on Thursday March 29, 2018 @02:30AM (#16704968)
Now divide that failure rate from dollars invested in each project to truly see the differences.
Re:Analysts argue that over-automation is to blame for Tesla... by qubex on Thursday March 29, 2018 @04:43AM (#16705499)
(Adjusted for inflation etc and remove the arbitrary cutoff for Proton.)
Re:Analysts argue that over-automation is to blame for Tesla... by ggm on Thursday March 29, 2018 @05:29AM (#16705665)
Atlas, Ariane and proton have fifty+ years of investment tail behind them and a fifth generation in atlas is probably more than musk has had in spacex in generation terms no?
Re:Analysts argue that over-automation is to blame for Tesla... by oldgradstudent on Thursday March 29, 2018 @05:35AM (#16705694)
Does it include the rocket and satellite destroyed while refueling?

What about Soyuz? IIRC, they haven't lost a manned mission since 1971.

Re:Analysts argue that over-automation is to blame for Tesla... by wongarsu on Thursday March 29, 2018 @07:19AM (#16706075)
>What about Soyuz? IIRC, they haven't lost a manned mission since 1971.

Neither has SpaceX :)

Soyuz is somewhat more complicated since it's an entire family of rockets:

The Soyuz-FG (2001-today, currently does all manned flights) has a 63/63 success record.

The Soyuz-U2 (1982-1995) also has a 72/72 success record.

The Soyuz-U (1973-2017, also manned flight) has a 765/786 (97%) success rate, with no failure in their manned flights.

The Soyuz-2 (2004-today) has a 68/75 (91%) success rate.

Re:Analysts argue that over-automation is to blame for Tesla... by jacquesm on Thursday March 29, 2018 @03:25AM (#16705195)
Given the rate at which SpaceX has been improving their line-up you can't really do a 1:1 comparison between platforms that are essentially static and what SpaceX has been up to.

And over time their failure rate has been dropping steadily, since 1/1/2017 they've launched about half of all F9s and all have worked perfectly. It's gotten to the point where the press will crow 'failure' if they don't manage to land the first stage on the barge, which is apples-to-oranges with the rest of the industry, who are - rightly - getting seriously worried.

Re:Analysts argue that over-automation is to blame for Tesla... by basdp on Thursday March 29, 2018 @01:56AM (#16704815)
How many years did SpaceX do over that modern rocket? How many years did NASA do to get to said modern rocket? I'd say he's on a pretty good roll.
Re:Analysts argue that over-automation is to blame for Tesla... by ant6n on Thursday March 29, 2018 @02:39AM (#16704998)
SpaceX didn't start in a vacuum, or in the 40s.
Re:Analysts argue that over-automation is to blame for Tesla... by wongarsu on Thursday March 29, 2018 @07:24AM (#16706107)
Neither did Ariane 5, Atlas V, Delta IV or Soyuz-FG. Of course SpaceX profits from the state of the art, but not developing the Xth iteration over a proven and battle-tested design with decades of flight-data is a disadvantage for SpaceX.
Re:Analysts argue that over-automation is to blame for Tesla... by greglindahl on Thursday March 29, 2018 @02:43PM (#16709878)
SpaceX benefits from being able to inspect landed boosters. This comparison is apples-to-oranges.
Re:Analysts argue that over-automation is to blame for Tesla... by tajen on Thursday March 29, 2018 @04:58AM (#16705557)
And don’t forget in 1969 when they landed on the moon, they had to code all the timestamps in negative.