News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What America looked like before the EPA, in photos by zhyder on Friday March 16, 2018 @07:11AM (#16599851)
It's unfortunate that the EPA is under attack by conservatives who want limited government. If you start from first principles about what the min viable government should do, a big part of its charter would be to prevent major tragedies of the commons. And the environment is a textbook example of something that'd suffer the tragedy of the commons without government oversight.

I prefer a bigger government with a bigger social safety net with universal basic healthcare, etc. But I can understand conservative opposition to that; at least those don't produce tragedies of the commons. (They arguably do to a lesser extent: if people's basic needs are met, they're less likely to resort to crime to fulfill them. And a greater rate of crime is a tragedy for all; ask anyone who's paid a premium to live in a "safe" neighborhood.)

Re:What America looked like before the EPA, in photos by audunw on Friday March 16, 2018 @07:30AM (#16599919)
I think the answer to this paradox is that most conservatives aren't really all that into small/limited government. It's just a phrase they use to sell their policies to voters. What they're actually trying to implement is crony capitalism, which is a consequence of their dependence on money to get elected.

Democrats have the same problem by the way, it just manifests in different paradoxes (or "lies" if you want to be more direct)

Re:What America looked like before the EPA, in photos by Strang on Friday March 16, 2018 @01:38PM (#16602384)
Do I understand you correctly, that you believe that most voters in the US have been duped into their beliefs by bad-faith argument concealing the "true" agenda?
Re:What America looked like before the EPA, in photos by IAmEveryone on Friday March 16, 2018 @07:50AM (#16599994)
Being conservative used to have some meaning. The EPA was established by Richard Nixon, of all people.

If you care less about other people than Nixon, you should really ask yourself: “?How far have I strayed from the pack?”

Re:What America looked like before the EPA, in photos by boomboomsubban on Friday March 16, 2018 @10:04AM (#16600690)
To be fair, the EPA was established by Nixon as an organization to manage a number of laws passed by the Democrat controlled Congress. Nixon even tried to veto the Clean Water Act.
Re:What America looked like before the EPA, in photos by Anon1096 on Friday March 16, 2018 @09:58AM (#16600658)
Nixon was barely a conservative. He gets a bad rap due to Watergate but really he was one of the most liberal Republicans elected to the presidency.
Re:What America looked like before the EPA, in photos by zimpenfish on Friday March 16, 2018 @10:11AM (#16600745)
Re:What America looked like before the EPA, in photos by moduspol on Friday March 16, 2018 @08:07AM (#16600057)
This straw-mans common conservative views, though.

It frames the argument as either "the EPA, as it exists today and has been running" or "no EPA at all." There are plenty of legitimate criticisms of a lot of the EPA's activities and very few of those activities directly prevent what's shown in the photos.

Re:What America looked like before the EPA, in photos by Sangermaine on Friday March 16, 2018 @08:33AM (#16600187)
>This straw-mans common conservative views, though.

Not at all, when conservatives who do come to power always immediately move to dismantle the EPA, as with the current administration. Not to mention that conservative politicians endlessly rail against the evils of the EPA in terms not even remotely nuanced.

I know, I know, "they're not really conservatives!".

Re:What America looked like before the EPA, in photos by moduspol on Friday March 16, 2018 @09:15AM (#16600403)
But the EPA hasn't been dismantled, and we've had many Republican presidents. Regulations and budgets have been cut, but that's consistent with the belief that the EPA is too big and bureaucratic.

It's just so needlessly pointless to frame things this way. It'd be like posting pictures of people in bread lines in the USSR and saying, "this is what a country looks like with left-wing politicians in charge." I mean, yes, it's true, but it's straw-manning all left-wing politicians as full-blown communists.

Let's try to avoid straw-manning and demonizing political opponents and maybe we'll be able to improve the discourse a little.

> Not to mention that conservative politicians endlessly rail against the evils of the EPA in terms not even remotely nuanced.

Yes, sometimes politicians are a big exaggerated with their rhetoric. That's not unique to conservatives, though.

Re:What America looked like before the EPA, in photos by enraged_camel on Friday March 16, 2018 @10:48AM (#16601029)
>>But the EPA hasn't been dismantled, and we've had many Republican presidents. Regulations and budgets have been cut...

That’s exactly how you dismantle a large government agency. You cut budgets until the organization is so crippled it can’t do its job, then you point at how ineffective it is and use that to drum up enough political will to abolish it.

“My goal is to cut government in half in twenty-five years, to get it down to the size where we can drown it in the bathtub.” - Grover Norquist

Re:What America looked like before the EPA, in photos by moduspol on Friday March 16, 2018 @10:52AM (#16601053)
In your view, is there any way to curtail a bloated bureaucracy without being accused of trying to destroy it completely?

Can a bureaucracy ever get too big, or to the point that its negative effects outweigh its positives?

> “My goal is to cut government in half in twenty-five years, to get it down to the size where we can drown it in the bathtub.” - Grover Norquist

This quote doesn't imply desire to destroy it, but capability. The desire of people being more powerful than their government is not a radical idea.

Re:What America looked like before the EPA, in photos by swebs on Friday March 16, 2018 @08:56AM (#16600298)
So we have the issue where the majority of conservative voters think the country must do whatever it takes to protect the environment [1], but elected conservative officials think otherwise. How do you think this should be handled?

Option 1: Demonize all conservatives, turning the environment into a partisan agenda

Option 2: Demonize elected officials that choose to side with lobbyists over their constituents

Personally, I would chose option 2, but I guess option 1 is good too if your goal is to cause divisiveness or even to push conservatives away from agreeing with you [2]

[1] http://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2017/04/20/for-earth-da...

[2] https://www.pri.org/stories/2016-06-05/conservatives-dont-ha...

Re:What America looked like before the EPA, in photos by mcphage on Friday March 16, 2018 @10:01AM (#16600676)
> Option 1: Demonize all conservatives, turning the environment into a partisan agenda

> Option 2: Demonize elected officials that choose to side with lobbyists over their constituents

Sorry, could you remind me again who's electing those "elected officials that choose to side with lobbyists over their constituents"?

Re:What America looked like before the EPA, in photos by swebs on Friday March 16, 2018 @08:13AM (#16600076)
On the other hand, does the EPA really require 8 billion dollars per year when the protection laws have already been passed and improvements have already been made?

In a software project, you allocate $x per month during development, and only $(x/10) for maintenance after it has shipped. Is there a point where the EPA can say "mission accomplished" and downsize to maintenance/enforcement mode, or is this just a typical government organization that will happily consume as many tax dollars as it can get as long as it can?

Re:What America looked like before the EPA, in photos by rayiner on Friday March 16, 2018 @08:36AM (#16600204)
Yes it does, due to the structure of the environmental laws.

In a libertarian system, you’d simply ban pollution (I.e. ban the externalizations of environmental costs), and then let the market and the courts hash things out. If a company was found dumping pollutants into the water, people would sue them, and the costs of all of that would get properly priced into the company’s products.

But the environmental laws are all about the various ways in which companies are allowed to pollute. Companies can dump poison into rivers, so long as they conform the EPA limits. Those limits are, by design, not set any “correct” level (as above, the “correct” level is zero—forcing the externality to be fully internalized; from an economic efficiency point of view, all environmental externalities must be borne by parties to the transaction, either the company or its customers). Instead, the limits are of a “best effort” nature, and a “how to get there from here” nature. For example, the law requires air polluters to install “the best available control technology” on smoke stacks. What does that mean? Well, that requires continual review and revision.

The EPA doesn’t exist to enforce laws that prevent pollution. It exists to manage all the pollution that the law allows.

Re:What America looked like before the EPA, in photos by celeritascelery on Friday March 16, 2018 @08:50AM (#16600262)
“Banning” pollution is not realistic. Any economy of this scale is going to produce pollution. And while some technologies like fossil fuels are worse then others, there is no pollution solution. So the best the EPA can do it manange the pollution we do create to mitigate the harms.
Re:What America looked like before the EPA, in photos by rayiner on Friday March 16, 2018 @10:51AM (#16601046)
That's the point. In an idealized economic abstraction, banning pollution (more accurately, creating a cause of action for damages in connection with any level of pollution) would force the cost to be internalized. You can let phosphorous from your farm leach into the river, but any downstream property owners can sue you for reducing their property values by causing algal blooms. If the value created by your farm exceeds the externalized cost of pollution, you keep your farm, pay off the property owners, and pass the costs of that into people who buy your meat and vegetables. When the costs of pollution are priced into those products, the market will properly balance the benefits of farm products against the harms of farm pollution.

But that's wildly impractical. Hence the existence of the EPA, which is tasked with managing pollution, and using central planning to balance the benefits of productive activity against the harms of pollution.

Re:What America looked like before the EPA, in photos by 13years on Friday March 16, 2018 @09:11AM (#16600380)
Due to property rights, all pollution was illegal prior to the EPA.

The EPA's purpose is to determine how much pollution is allowed.

During the immediate period prior to the EPA, it wasn't so much it was legal, but the courts began to ignore property rights due to the pressures of what was believed to be common good to let industries thrive.

In some cases property rights are much stricter and can be better enforced, in other cases they are more difficult in areas such as air pollution.

Re:What America looked like before the EPA, in photos by rayiner on Friday March 16, 2018 @10:53AM (#16601062)
> During the immediate period prior to the EPA,

By "immediate period" you mean a couple of hundred years before 1970. English courts started ignoring property rights (e.g. the right of downstream riparian users to undiminished water quality from upstream activities) in the 1700s or so during the first industrial revolution.

Re:What America looked like before the EPA, in photos by 13years on Friday March 16, 2018 @11:11AM (#16601197)
True, poorly worded on my part. Intended to mean the state of the situations immediately prior was that property rights were no longer enforced, but that process took some time to undo such as the 1939 Restatement of Torts.

For anyone interested in a deep dive on the matter. A good reference book 'Managing the Environment, Managing Ourselves: A History of American Environmental Policy'

Re:What America looked like before the EPA, in photos by Androider on Friday March 16, 2018 @08:31AM (#16600172)
EPA could do nothing but spend 100% of that 8 billion on https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Superfund_sites for the next 20 years and it wouldn't be enough to cover it.

That's just to cover previously made mistakes. Reducing enforcement is going to keep adding to that list, and reducing safety and quality of life for all Americans.

The vast majority (60-80%, Robert L. Glass) of costs for software is also in maintenance, as any of the classic software project management books will tell you.

Re:What America looked like before the EPA, in photos by swebs on Friday March 16, 2018 @08:40AM (#16600216)
>The vast majority (60-80%, Robert L. Glass) of costs for software is also in maintenance, as any of the classic software project management books will tell you.

What's the purpose of stating total costs when discussing monthly costs? Of course maintenance will end up costing more in total if the maintenance period is much longer than the development period. The per month cost is still much lower.

Re:What America looked like before the EPA, in photos by notahacker on Friday March 16, 2018 @09:26AM (#16600455)
Regulations aren't much good if you don't have personnel with the technical expertise to monitor compliance, enforce them and arrange for damage limitation or mitigation. A lot of environmental protection activity has a positive return on investment for tax dollars because cleanup and health hazard mitigation is really, really expensive.

$8bn per annum is a tiny sum of money to spend on environmental protection for a developed country the size of the United States.

Re:What America looked like before the EPA, in photos by davvolun on Friday March 16, 2018 @10:30AM (#16600884)
I don't know that I'd turn to the software industry for insight on development and maintenance. Things have changed, but AFAIK we still don't have that silver bullet.
Re:What America looked like before the EPA, in photos by mnm1 on Friday March 16, 2018 @12:20PM (#16601666)
You think laws enforce themselves?
Re:What America looked like before the EPA, in photos by throwaway2016a on Friday March 16, 2018 @08:30AM (#16600164)
It really is a shame that is considered a "conservative" view.

I think a lot of Libertarians are coming around to have a view similar to your's. That the commons belongs to all of us and polluting and destroying it should be punished. Republican's on the other hand seem to thing liberty only applies to corporations.

In fact if you delete the part about wanting big government, I could have almost mistaken you for a Libertarian.

However, if you look at the Libertarian's who do support protecting the environment you will find there are ideas out there to address the issue without a huge centralized government organization like the EPA. Some might require changing our laws and our legal system so it is less of "whoever has the most money wins" but there are ways.

Like all political parties Libertarians have their extremists too (anarchists) but by and large I think they are reasonable people.

Edit: Those people in the Republican party that the media likes to call "Libertarians" are not. They cherry pick what liberties are important to them and what are not based on their moral code and special interests.

Edit 2: My original post has the word "not" where it should't have been. See bellow.

Re:What America looked like before the EPA, in photos by wallace_f on Friday March 16, 2018 @08:59AM (#16600311)
The word has been hijacked. Libertarians want to maximize liberty, which since the Age of Reason has been interpreted in government to mean to restrict as few freedoms as necessary to protect the remainder. One example: don't let people commit murder.

It is perfectly reasonable this kind of reasoning apply to other types of killing or unjust aggression, such as poisoning the environment. So we have the NAP.

But the whole movement is being hijacked by people who either don't care about much else than not wanting to pay taxes, or people who are anarchists (which is decidedly not libertarian).

Perhaps we need to run away and invent a new word. I think you'll find a lot of libertarians agree more often with Greenwald than the Koch bros.

Re:What America looked like before the EPA, in photos by throwaway2016a on Friday March 16, 2018 @09:25AM (#16600453)
I'm actually a Libertarian myself. And I agree with all you say. Except of course the anarchist part because it directly contradicts me :)

> But the whole movement is being hijacked by people who either don't care about much else than not wanting to pay taxes

Many of those people have moved to the Republican party. Often the same people who think that liberty only applies to you if you have the right income level, color skin, gender, sexual orientation, and religion. As I said in my first post, an dI'm sure you agree, you can't pick and chose who gets liberties.

Unfortunately the anarchist have chosen to use the Libertarian party to give themselves a voice. And while I agree they are not true Libertarians, they are the extremist in the party and are the party's demons to fight.

Re:What America looked like before the EPA, in photos by LyndsySimon on Friday March 16, 2018 @11:36AM (#16601357)
> or people who are anarchists (which is decidedly not libertarian).

I grant you that most anarchists are not libertarians, but I fail to see how Anarcho-Capitalists are not.

> Perhaps we need to run away and invent a new word.

We've done that, several times. We were once "liberals", then "libertarians", and it feels like we're now fracturing into subgroups that take on various labels: "ancap", "minarchist", "classical liberal", etc.

Re:What America looked like before the EPA, in photos by wallace_f on Friday March 16, 2018 @01:10PM (#16602132)
Because the central premise of anarcho capitalism is not to maximize liberty. The central premise is to place private ownership above all else--even above rule of law that would forbid murder.
Re:What America looked like before the EPA, in photos by bobwaycott on Friday March 16, 2018 @08:43AM (#16600232)
> That the commons belongs to all of us and polluting and destroying it should not be punished.

Did you really mean should not be punished here?

Re:What America looked like before the EPA, in photos by throwaway2016a on Friday March 16, 2018 @08:46AM (#16600247)
I fixed it before you posted that comment but didn't put an "edit" note because I thought I edited it quick enough for people not to notice. I was writing quickly and moved some words around that changed the meaning in a bad way :(

Yes, of course. The "not" shouldn't have been in that sentence. Polluters should have consequences.

Re:What America looked like before the EPA, in photos by Strang on Friday March 16, 2018 @01:31PM (#16602322)
Keep in mind that in the US, the Federal Government is not the only game in town. The EPA as currently constituted is not the only possible way for our society to protect our environment.

It seems to me that conservatives often make the case that "The Federal Government should not do <foo>," but others instead hear, "we as a society don't need to do <foo>."

Re:What America looked like before the EPA, in photos by bosie on Saturday March 17, 2018 @02:44PM (#16608388)
what's the non-government solution for an implementation of the EPA?
Re:What America looked like before the EPA, in photos by Strang on Monday March 19, 2018 @09:08AM (#16618036)
I was mostly referring to state and local government as an alternative to the Federal Government.