News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Stock trade app Robinhood raising at $5B+, up 4X in a year by dguo on Thursday March 15, 2018 @09:22PM (#16597902)
I appreciate the zero commission trading, but at the same time, I'm worried about the attitude towards "investing" that they promote. Most people should arguably be putting their money into index funds and holding for the long term[1], not picking individual stocks and following price movements on a daily basis. I wouldn't criticize anyone for speculating (i.e. gambling) with money they can afford to lose. I've done that before, and I know how fun it can be. But it shouldn't be the primary strategy for most people. We should be signing up with Betterment/Wealthfront/Vanguard before Robinhood.

I have the Robinhood app but haven't made any trades yet. I had to turn off push notifications for things like "Snapchat declined 5% today". That kind of thing is what causes people to trade on their emotions, a great starting point for losing money in the long term. Instead of buying low and selling high, they end up doing the opposite.

[1]: https://www.bogleheads.org/wiki/Getting_started

Re:Stock trade app Robinhood raising at $5B+, up 4X in a year by wgerard on Thursday March 15, 2018 @09:55PM (#16598019)
> Most people should arguably be putting their money into index funds and holding for the long term

I think Robinhood is great for that! Zero commission means you can afford to buy small amounts without worrying about fees eating into your principal too much.

You can put in $250 every pay period and buy a share of $SPY without losing ~3% to fees.

With commissions involved you'd want to wait until you could afford a larger trade, at which point you've lost time in the market.

Re:Stock trade app Robinhood raising at $5B+, up 4X in a year by dguo on Thursday March 15, 2018 @10:15PM (#16598083)
That is true. I'm not saying Robinhood is all bad or can't be used in good ways. My concern is that overall, the product and marketing seem to be geared towards speculative, short-term trading. When I first signed up, the app was recommending that I check out stocks like Apple, Netflix, and Snapchat, not index funds.
Re:Stock trade app Robinhood raising at $5B+, up 4X in a year by wgerard on Thursday March 15, 2018 @10:49PM (#16598213)
> My concern is that overall, the product and marketing seem to be geared towards speculative, short-term trading. When I first signed up, the app was recommending that I check out stocks like Apple, Netflix, and Snapchat, not index funds.

There's a broad spectrum of public companies obviously, but it's hard to see $AAPL as speculative in the same sense that people call penny stocks or cryptocurrencies speculative (i.e. much, much more risk involved in the latter two). Investing in large cap equities isn't the stupidest thing you could be doing as a new investor - that award would certainly go to buying derivatives.

And indeed if I have criticism of RH it's that they're trying to appeal to all investor types at the same time, new and experienced alike. It's easy to see how new investors can get confused when RH offers the ability to sign up for cryptocurrency trading and options trading, two things new investors obviously should not be doing (though admittedly there's obviously a questionnaire involved before you can be approved for options trading, not sure about cryptocurrencies).

Re:Stock trade app Robinhood raising at $5B+, up 4X in a year by jjeaff on Thursday March 15, 2018 @11:36PM (#16598419)
Washington Mutual, Bear Stearns, Lehman Brothers, General Motors, Fannie Mae, Freddie Mac are all good examples of why you should avoid individual stocks, even if they are "blue chip".
Re:Stock trade app Robinhood raising at $5B+, up 4X in a year by bigtunacan on Friday March 16, 2018 @12:57AM (#16598732)
Amazon, Alibaba, Mercado Libre, and Netflix are good examples of reasons not to avoid individual stocks.

More than 90% of my investments go into index funds and 10% into individual stocks, but if hindsight was 20/20 it would be 100% into my individual stocks and I’d be retired on my own private island today.

Re:Stock trade app Robinhood raising at $5B+, up 4X in a year by dragonwriter on Friday March 16, 2018 @03:13PM (#16603221)
Aside from the hindsight/foresight inversion, you probably mean if your foresight was 20/20, but the rest of the market had no better foresight than they actually do.

In which case, of course, you should invest entirely in the highest rate-of-return investmentd that the rest of the market currently undervalues.

The problem is people are prone to overrate their own foresight.

Re:Stock trade app Robinhood raising at $5B+, up 4X in a year by wmeredith on Friday March 16, 2018 @10:25AM (#16600850)
Hindsight IS 20/20. I think you meant if foresight was 20/20.
Re:Stock trade app Robinhood raising at $5B+, up 4X in a year by bigtunacan on Friday March 16, 2018 @01:02PM (#16602064)
LOL. Indeed I did.
Re:Stock trade app Robinhood raising at $5B+, up 4X in a year by 2trill2spill on Friday March 16, 2018 @12:04AM (#16598541)
Depends on when you bought them of course. I bought FNMA(Fannie Mae) in 2010 and it turned out pretty nicely.

But yes most people are better off buying index funds. That's where most of my money goes.

Re:Stock trade app Robinhood raising at $5B+, up 4X in a year by beiller on Friday March 16, 2018 @05:39AM (#16599550)
I find a good approach is to buy index funds, but when it comes to whatever your subject is, like I.T, you can pick companies you like or think will succeed. Just make sure to look at it in terms of the business and its future.
Re:Stock trade app Robinhood raising at $5B+, up 4X in a year by grahamannett on Thursday March 15, 2018 @10:44PM (#16598190)
I can understand why they guide people towards investing in "hip" companies versus an index fund, but regardless why is their so much animosity towards robinhood on HN? Is someone getting into investing and investing in an Apple/Amazon/etc. not overall a pretty good entry point compared to opening up thinkorswim or the pretty atrocious (at least on mac) schwab desktop client? Investing a small amount of money is better than blowing that money on tons of consumeristic bullshit that that tons of people do and RH seems like a genuinely good stepping stone compared to the current incumbents in a lot of ways (fees/minimum deposit/super simple). The fact that you can even start with RH and then at a later date transfer to a brokerage once you have a large enough portfolio is also a huge plus in my opinion to people who may have otherwise never set aside that money in the first place.
Re:Stock trade app Robinhood raising at $5B+, up 4X in a year by dguo on Thursday March 15, 2018 @11:20PM (#16598327)
I agree Robinhood is better than the incumbents in multiple ways. But at some time, other startups offer similar benefits while promoting an approach that is more likely to help the average person increase their wealth in the long term.

I don't think Robinhood is terrible. I just think someone who doesn't know what they're doing would be better off starting with Betterment or Acorns, which are just as user friendly as Robinhood.

Re:Stock trade app Robinhood raising at $5B+, up 4X in a year by adrr on Thursday March 15, 2018 @11:09PM (#16598289)
Etrade, Schwab and Ameritrade have commission free ETFs. Or you can just go to Vanguard and there's no commission if you buy their ETFs on their platform.
Re:Stock trade app Robinhood raising at $5B+, up 4X in a year by jcdavis on Thursday March 15, 2018 @10:08PM (#16598056)
Vanguard charges no fees for buying/selling their owns ETFs. I believe Schwab and others do as well.
Re:Stock trade app Robinhood raising at $5B+, up 4X in a year by wgerard on Thursday March 15, 2018 @10:53PM (#16598225)
True! That being said, using the Vanguard website is... significantly different from using the RH app.
Re:Stock trade app Robinhood raising at $5B+, up 4X in a year by jurassic on Thursday March 15, 2018 @11:22PM (#16598337)
The Vanguard web experience isn't great, I agree. But if you set up a recurring automated purchase you rarely need to log in and mess with it. Set it and forget it.

Viewed another way, I would say the Vanguard fund costs are low for a reason. It seems unfair to expect a Mercedes experience for a Honda worth of expense ratio.

Re:Stock trade app Robinhood raising at $5B+, up 4X in a year by dguo on Thursday March 15, 2018 @10:56PM (#16598241)
The Vanguard website/experience is definitely not that user-friendly/modern. That's the main reason I usually recommend Betterment to my friends instead.
Re:Stock trade app Robinhood raising at $5B+, up 4X in a year by dlp211 on Thursday March 15, 2018 @11:26PM (#16598355)
Betterment, where you pay an extra quarter percent to buy Vanguard funds.
Re:Stock trade app Robinhood raising at $5B+, up 4X in a year by dguo on Thursday March 15, 2018 @11:50PM (#16598482)
That's better than the alternative of not investing at all because Vanguard is not user-friendly. And I know that's possible because I have friends who were in that situation.

If you sign up with Vanguard, you still have to pick which fund(s) to buy. If you don't know anything about investing, that can be a daunting task. With Betterment, the only decision you have to make is the percentage split for stocks vs. bonds.

Re:Stock trade app Robinhood raising at $5B+, up 4X in a year by luckydata on Friday March 16, 2018 @12:12AM (#16598568)
Have you ran the math on how much that "user friendly" layer is costing you? I adore nice UIs, but I love even more keeping my money. Vanguard is really not that hard to use, and for how often you need to mess with it I don't think it's worth to spend more just to have prettier graphics.
Re:Stock trade app Robinhood raising at $5B+, up 4X in a year by dguo on Friday March 16, 2018 @12:41AM (#16598680)
I have both Betterment and Vanguard accounts. I haven't bothered to consolidate yet because Betterment is trying to add value to justify the fee with features like tax loss harvesting, and I haven't decided if it's worth it or not.

With regards to my friends though, my priority was to get them to invest in the first place, and the user friendliness of Betterment helped a lot.

Re:Stock trade app Robinhood raising at $5B+, up 4X in a year by kelnos on Friday March 16, 2018 @02:51AM (#16599050)
Your friends can't exercise some level of long term financial responsibility unless they're presented with pretty graphics and a slick UI?

The lack of financial education in the US really makes me sad sometimes. And it pisses me off that companies like RH will take advantage of that.

Re:Stock trade app Robinhood raising at $5B+, up 4X in a year by dguo on Friday March 16, 2018 @10:23AM (#16600837)
I totally share[1] your feelings on the lack of financial education. In defense of my friends, they already knew to fund their 401(k)s. The question was what to do with their free cash. And considering the risk of losing money, any amount of friction (like a bad UI) can make it easy to procrastinate.

[1]: https://twitter.com/dannyguo/status/961684866285924354

Re:Stock trade app Robinhood raising at $5B+, up 4X in a year by southphillyman on Friday March 16, 2018 @10:08AM (#16600725)
>That's better than the alternative of not investing at all because Vanguard is not user-friendly

This is literally what happened to me. I lost out on 20%+ in gains because I procrastinated a year after reading about how much Betterment fees eat into your gains. In hindsight the amount of money I missed out on was WAY more than any fee Betterment would have hit me with.

Re:Stock trade app Robinhood raising at $5B+, up 4X in a year by btmorex on Friday March 16, 2018 @02:26AM (#16599000)
Isn't that why Vanguard has their Total Stock Market and Total Bond Market funds? Basically, they're the "invest in these if you don't want to bother" funds.
Re:Stock trade app Robinhood raising at $5B+, up 4X in a year by dguo on Friday March 16, 2018 @10:50AM (#16601040)
That's a good point. Deciding to go with those is still a choice though. It's like going to a restaurant that has both an omakase[1] option and regular dishes. Versus a restaurant that only offers omakase. The latter involves even less decision making.

[1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Omakase

Re:Stock trade app Robinhood raising at $5B+, up 4X in a year by mcintyre1994 on Friday March 16, 2018 @03:48AM (#16599230)
They also have LifeStrategy 0/20/40/60/80/100 so you can balance stocks vs bonds however you want, and have diversification handled for you.
Re:Stock trade app Robinhood raising at $5B+, up 4X in a year by TorKlingberg on Friday March 16, 2018 @05:15AM (#16599474)
I think the numbered LifeStrategy funds are only a UK (GBP) thing. Am I wrong?
Re:Stock trade app Robinhood raising at $5B+, up 4X in a year by matwood on Friday March 16, 2018 @07:35AM (#16599937)
There are US equivalents.
Re:Stock trade app Robinhood raising at $5B+, up 4X in a year by mcintyre1994 on Friday March 16, 2018 @07:49AM (#16599993)
I'm in the UK and hold the GBP products, so I'm unsure sorry.
Re:Stock trade app Robinhood raising at $5B+, up 4X in a year by tysonzni on Friday March 16, 2018 @12:48AM (#16598700)
You pay an extra quarter percent to 1) not have to think about allocation and risk under-diversfication, and 2) commit to the "buy and hold" strategy since its withdrawal process is more cumbersome than normal trading.

I think for most people this actually ends up producing better long term returns.

Re:Stock trade app Robinhood raising at $5B+, up 4X in a year by wils1245 on Friday March 16, 2018 @11:04AM (#16601140)
How much are you willing to spend on a nice user interface? The whole point of passive investing is that you rarely interact with your account.

Even a slight difference in fees is worth thousands in the long run.

Re:Stock trade app Robinhood raising at $5B+, up 4X in a year by meatbundragon on Thursday March 15, 2018 @10:10PM (#16598067)
While this is a great point, the casual segment of the customer base that is being discussed would certainly not have enough awareness of this fact. At the very least, I didn't even though I do trade ETFs and large cap stocks casually...
Re:Stock trade app Robinhood raising at $5B+, up 4X in a year by AFNobody on Friday March 16, 2018 @01:42AM (#16598876)
I am sorry but "casual investors" should be doing long term buy and hold because if you can't be bothered to spend 30 minutes on research to compare brokerages, I am genuinely horrified at the idea of you doing anything other than buying and holding an index fund.

Robinhood's encouragement of the instant gratification, poorly researched trades is going to end badly for many of it's customers when we enter a bear market.

Re:Stock trade app Robinhood raising at $5B+, up 4X in a year by meatbundragon on Friday March 16, 2018 @02:36PM (#16602918)
I disagree that investors' abilities to understand stocks and create portfolios should be judged by someone's willingness to find which individual brokerages offer free buy/sell of their own ETFs.
Re:Stock trade app Robinhood raising at $5B+, up 4X in a year by vasilipupkin on Thursday March 15, 2018 @11:31PM (#16598392)
Their own ETFs - yes. But still a fee to buy other ETFs that aren't their own.
Re:Stock trade app Robinhood raising at $5B+, up 4X in a year by arsenico on Friday March 16, 2018 @06:50AM (#16599789)
You're paying fees for something different than just buying and holding an index ETF - and that is a long-term diversification across asset classes and georgraphies, regular automatic rebalancing of portfolios, goal-based investing with multiple financial goals, reporting, etc. I am not saying that buying a single S&P ETF is bad, but you can do so mych more for your financial future with robos, that it is basically incomparable.

Edit: I also forgot an increasingly important diversification by asset manager as well.

Re:Stock trade app Robinhood raising at $5B+, up 4X in a year by saryant on Friday March 16, 2018 @12:08PM (#16601554)
But that's not new?

Vanguard has long offered commission-free trades of their ETFs and mutual funds. Same for many index fund providers.

Re:Stock trade app Robinhood raising at $5B+, up 4X in a year by rak00n on Friday March 16, 2018 @02:52AM (#16599056)
You can open a Vanguard account and buy $VOO for zero commission too.
Re:Stock trade app Robinhood raising at $5B+, up 4X in a year by vikascoder on Thursday March 15, 2018 @09:31PM (#16597938)
That's a good thought but zero commision doesnt really change the investment attitude that much apart from the fact that it makes very low value plays possible. There are tons of people having the same speculative investment behaviour on both sides of the line especially on larger bets. It's the smaller bets that Robinhood makes possible. I would also argue that Robinhood is a great playground to learn trading at minimal cost. I have tons of freinds with 500 dollar portfolios playing around and learning the ropes. This was seldom attractive with web based serious accounts. In the end it's all about discipline and eventually Robinhood users reach the same investment mindset as regular account players very soon.
Re:Stock trade app Robinhood raising at $5B+, up 4X in a year by siruncledrew on Thursday March 15, 2018 @11:58PM (#16598520)
That's why the $0 commission is such a key feature. They know people enjoy the emotional high of seeing the green numbers in their account when they open the app. This isn't a tool for high net-worth individuals, people that want "traditional" (Vanguard, Wealthfront, Schwab) wealth management investing with long-term planning, or advanced traders looking for Bloomberg terminal-esque features. This is designed to allow the average person to play with their money and see if they can "beat the market". It's like a fintech online casino. It's not gambling per se, but it definitely has a lot of psychological overlap with it for many of its users. With the addition of crypto trading, they've basically just opened up their new slot machines to the public.

I played with the Robinhood app before as well, but stopped using it after a couple weeks because it's just more of a novelty than a dedicated investment platform with all the features I want. I can see how some people that don't want all the complicated financial markets stuff would enjoy it though. If people think $0 trading is a short-cut to becoming a millionaire day trader though, they are in for a very bad time.

Re:Stock trade app Robinhood raising at $5B+, up 4X in a year by bigtunacan on Friday March 16, 2018 @12:50AM (#16598708)
I’m probably not the average Robinhood user, but I was already putting about $50k/year into index funds for retirement.

So rather than putting even more in these I wanted to research and invest directly in a handful of stocks long term. I used to use Scottrade for this. That’s not too bad $7/trade ($14/round-trip).

If I’m making a sizable enough investment that won’t matter too much. But what if I only had $24 this week? I could buy one share of Ford on Scott-trade, but then I’m upside down until the price doubles (e.g. forever upside down).

With Robinhood I can make buys no matter how small the purchase.

Re:Stock trade app Robinhood raising at $5B+, up 4X in a year by what_ever on Friday March 16, 2018 @04:22AM (#16599329)
Thanks. I think so many people here don't understand how people use RH and quickly jump to conclusion thinking it's only "low net-worth individuals" using it. Before RH, people still invested in individual stocks and it wasn't only "low net-worth" individuals attracted by the greens and reds in the UI doing those.
Re:Stock trade app Robinhood raising at $5B+, up 4X in a year by bigtunacan on Friday March 16, 2018 @01:13PM (#16602154)
I’m sure for some users the notifications can be alarming or induce bad/impulsive behavior.

I have on occasion though found them useful where I get a notification that X stock is down Y% today. Most of these have been bad market days and I’ve said, “Nice, I’m long on X and it’s on sale today so I’ll pick up a few more shares.”

So on the one hand I understand how these could lead to a rash decision from some I don’t think Robinhood is trying to get people to buy high and sell low.

Re:Stock trade app Robinhood raising at $5B+, up 4X in a year by kelnos on Friday March 16, 2018 @02:56AM (#16599074)
> They know people enjoy the emotional high of seeing the green numbers in their account when they open the app. This isn't a tool for high net-worth individuals, people that want "traditional" (Vanguard, Wealthfront, Schwab) wealth management investing with long-term planning, or advanced traders looking for Bloomberg terminal-esque features. This is designed to allow the average person to play with their money and see if they can "beat the market".

And this is exactly why these sorts of people will continue to remain low-net-worth individuals. Far be it for me to tell anyone what to do with their money to have fun, but these are exactly the sort of people who should be targeted for an easy to use solution that just auto deposits some amount of money into an index fund or target retirement date fund every pay period. It might not be "fun", but they'll be pretty happy later in life when they actually have retirement savings.

Re:Stock trade app Robinhood raising at $5B+, up 4X in a year by retube on Friday March 16, 2018 @03:29AM (#16599172)
what does $0 commission mean? unless they're sourcing assets at mid then it's not 0 commission. and they can't be giving trades at mid to customers unless they're taking a loss on every transaction. they must be charging bid-offer - so how much?
Re:Stock trade app Robinhood raising at $5B+, up 4X in a year by what_ever on Friday March 16, 2018 @04:25AM (#16599335)
I think it's pretty clear in the industry what commission means when it comes to trading stocks. It's on top of the spread. Go to any other broker and they have the same spread. It's not going to be much better at brokers for individual investors like us. And if you are worried about getting worse spread, use limit orders.
Re:Stock trade app Robinhood raising at $5B+, up 4X in a year by johnpowell on Friday March 16, 2018 @10:32AM (#16600898)
For some perspective. My uncle (retired from the Air Force) got into stocks in 1998. He did not tell my aunt until around 2002. He lost around 200K of their retirement because he was unwilling to accept loss. He is still at it and has moved on to day-trading and is doing just as bad. It is a addiction and he does not use Robinhood.

I was living with my sisters kid and set him up with a Robinhood account and stuck a few hundred in it. I explained things a bit and he was still sure he could time the market just with SPY and QQQ. He could not. I guess it is good people have a playground to learn that they really don't know what they are doing before they become my uncle.

Re:Stock trade app Robinhood raising at $5B+, up 4X in a year by sf_rob on Friday March 16, 2018 @11:28AM (#16601305)
While it may be helpful to make the stakes real for your nephew, there are fake/paper trading accounts available at many brokerages.
Re:Stock trade app Robinhood raising at $5B+, up 4X in a year by selectodude on Friday March 16, 2018 @11:31AM (#16601321)
Paper trading is like playing poker without money. You’re still going to take risks you wouldn’t otherwise because there’s no pain.
Re:Stock trade app Robinhood raising at $5B+, up 4X in a year by johnpowell on Friday March 16, 2018 @11:34AM (#16601345)
I used them for a bit. Perhaps I am weak but I took my paper losses as a mistake and my gains as my prowess. And I don't like to think I made the wrong decision. So we can go from there into how people make horrible decisions.
Re:Stock trade app Robinhood raising at $5B+, up 4X in a year by ozmbie on Thursday March 15, 2018 @09:49PM (#16598001)
The whole software/startup approach is currently based on user growth which relies on retention, trigger, actions, and rewards. Long-term investments don’t fit that model so there is no incentive for them to encourage that form of user behaviour.
Re:Stock trade app Robinhood raising at $5B+, up 4X in a year by tysonzni on Thursday March 15, 2018 @10:14PM (#16598079)
User retention is arguably linked to capital preservation. So they do have some incentive to ensure people don’t lose their investments by trading too much.

When the market gets more volatile or if there’s a sharp downturn, that would become a big issue. Not sure they had to address this yet because since 2014 their founding year the market had been on a smooth, upward trajectory. A recession however is already around the corner.

Re:Stock trade app Robinhood raising at $5B+, up 4X in a year by omarforgotpwd on Thursday March 15, 2018 @10:08PM (#16598058)
There's a middle ground between day trading and just putting your money in an S&P 500 index fund and never looking at it again. Trading stocks can be fun and help you make a lot of money if you're able to spot undervalued investments. It's very complicated, but anyone can learn the basics of value investing and do a little bit of stock picking on the side.
Re:Stock trade app Robinhood raising at $5B+, up 4X in a year by stouset on Thursday March 15, 2018 @10:15PM (#16598087)
That is an absolutely gargantuan “if”, given that any particular retail investor is overwhelmingly unlikely to possess novel knowledge or insight in any market.

The number of times this ever happens is outweighed a millionfold by the frequency of times where people incorrectly believe this to be the case.

What happens in the vast majority of cases is that people believe they’re making money, but after fees are actually losing to index funds. Or people believe they’re making money, but lose their shirts the moment the market turns sideways. Or people do succeed due to completely random chance, but the level of risk they took on to make that return is significantly higher than other investments with comparable returns.

Re:Stock trade app Robinhood raising at $5B+, up 4X in a year by smileysteve on Friday March 16, 2018 @11:20AM (#16601251)
> given that any particular ~~retail~~ professional investor is overwhelmingly unlikely

Reminder from Random Walk Down Wall Street; Professionals rarely beat the S&P 500 Index on a time horizon. It's statistically likely, that if a professional fund does beat the index one year, then it will underperform the next year.

Re:Stock trade app Robinhood raising at $5B+, up 4X in a year by omarforgotpwd on Thursday March 15, 2018 @11:57PM (#16598514)
That's true, most people likely won't know what they're doing. But it's possible to spend some time, pick up something like The Intelligent Investor by Ben Graham, and invest a little yourself. Ordinary people can sometimes have investable insights that most players in the market are not aware of.
Re:Stock trade app Robinhood raising at $5B+, up 4X in a year by rifung on Friday March 16, 2018 @10:41AM (#16600967)
While I also would like to learn how to trade stocks and believe in value investing, I think this comment severely understates the difficulty of beating the market. Let's not forget that the vast majority of professionals who do this day in and out can not beat the market on consistently.
Re:Stock trade app Robinhood raising at $5B+, up 4X in a year by prostoalex on Friday March 16, 2018 @12:03AM (#16598538)
> Most people should arguably be putting their money into index funds and holding for the long term

Fidelity’s internal survey revealed that best performance correlated with low account activity http://www.businessinsider.com/forgetful-investors-performed...

Re:Stock trade app Robinhood raising at $5B+, up 4X in a year by what_ever on Friday March 16, 2018 @04:26AM (#16599340)
But it's very possible most of the users of RH wouldn't have invested any money at all if not for RH. I know many of my friends wouldn't have. Now whether they make money is a different argument.
Re:Stock trade app Robinhood raising at $5B+, up 4X in a year by icelancer on Friday March 16, 2018 @04:57AM (#16599423)
The vast majority of that is due to transaction fees/commissions, which RH doesn't have. I would still expect this to hold up even on a zero-commission basis, but the effect would be significantly diminished.
Re:Stock trade app Robinhood raising at $5B+, up 4X in a year by prostoalex on Friday March 16, 2018 @11:33AM (#16601336)
The transaction fees start to matter when the number of transactions goes up. Fidelity's thesis was the account growth was correlated to complete lack of transactions (except for DRIP, I guess).

On a side note, zero-fee instruments are not that rare for brokerages nowadays. Fidelity itself lists 3,691 mutual funds https://www.fidelity.com/fund-screener/research.shtml and 93 ETFs https://www.fidelity.com/etfs/overview as fee-free, and I think they're not even the leader in the space.

Re:Stock trade app Robinhood raising at $5B+, up 4X in a year by Veraticus on Thursday March 15, 2018 @11:51PM (#16598487)
There's also M1 Finance (https://www.m1finance.com/), which is all about long term investing. Commission-free like Robinhood, but it also has fractional shares. Makes it even easier than Robinhood to manage a well-balanced portfolio.
Re:Stock trade app Robinhood raising at $5B+, up 4X in a year by misterbowfinger on Thursday March 15, 2018 @11:16PM (#16598318)
If Robinhood opened up an API, wouldn't it be possible to invest in a way that mirrors existing index funds? I'm not super familiar with the details but it feels like it would be.
Re:Stock trade app Robinhood raising at $5B+, up 4X in a year by dguo on Thursday March 15, 2018 @11:29PM (#16598382)
It'd be possible, but you can buy index funds on Robinhood already.

Other services that are built around long term investing provide additional features like automatic rebalancing and dividend reinvesting. An API could allow you to emulate those as well, but at that point, it seems like you might as well just use a robo-advisor instead of building your own on top of an API.

Re:Stock trade app Robinhood raising at $5B+, up 4X in a year by username223 on Friday March 16, 2018 @10:49AM (#16601032)
> I had to turn off push notifications for things like "Snapchat declined 5% today".

This is telling to me. If they have opt-out notifications nudging users to make various day-trades, they're in shady territory. Kind of the opposite of Robin Hood.

Re:Stock trade app Robinhood raising at $5B+, up 4X in a year by AdenFlorian on Thursday March 15, 2018 @09:51PM (#16598007)
Have you seen the vanguard ETFs in Robinhood? Would those be just as good as using the funds directly with vanguard?
Re:Stock trade app Robinhood raising at $5B+, up 4X in a year by astrange on Thursday March 15, 2018 @09:59PM (#16598031)
Yes, better because the minimum is $0 not $10,000.

It's not as good as Betterment/Wealthfront/Hedgeable because you can't rebalance, reinvest dividends, or get fractional shares.

Re:Stock trade app Robinhood raising at $5B+, up 4X in a year by dandud on Thursday March 15, 2018 @10:25PM (#16598121)
Important to note that when purchasing ETFs through Vanguard the minimum investment amount is the cost of a single share. No large minimum amounts such as the $3000 or $10000 with their mutual funds.
Re:Stock trade app Robinhood raising at $5B+, up 4X in a year by adrr on Thursday March 15, 2018 @11:12PM (#16598304)
Vanguard has a full robo-advisor which has more assets under management than all fintech robo-advisors combined.
Re:Stock trade app Robinhood raising at $5B+, up 4X in a year by vasilipupkin on Thursday March 15, 2018 @11:33PM (#16598400)
Vanguard has no robo advisor. There is a human advisor involved
Re:Stock trade app Robinhood raising at $5B+, up 4X in a year by tanderson92 on Thursday March 15, 2018 @10:49PM (#16598212)
You can rebalance and reinvest dividends at Vanguard.
Re:Stock trade app Robinhood raising at $5B+, up 4X in a year by Scoundreller on Thursday March 15, 2018 @10:55PM (#16598236)
Does the amount of dividend need to be the cost of one share?

If so, with VTI trading at $140, you would need about 250 shares to buy a share with each dividend.

Re:Stock trade app Robinhood raising at $5B+, up 4X in a year by dguo on Thursday March 15, 2018 @11:00PM (#16598254)
No, they allow fractional shares. Source: https://investor.vanguard.com/investing/brokerage-dividend-r...

"When reinvesting dividends, Vanguard Brokerage Services combines the cash distributions from the accounts of all clients who have requested reinvestment in the same security, and then uses that combined total to purchase additional shares of the security in the open market. Vanguard Brokerage will attempt to purchase the reinvestment shares by entering a market order at the market opening on the payable date. The new shares are divided proportionately among the clients' accounts, in whole and fractional shares rounded to three decimal places. If the total purchase can't be completed in one trade, clients will receive shares purchased at the weighted average price paid by Vanguard Brokerage Services."

Re:Stock trade app Robinhood raising at $5B+, up 4X in a year by adrr on Thursday March 15, 2018 @11:22PM (#16598334)
Most ETFs support DRIP and the dividends reinvestment happens at the fund level.
Re:Stock trade app Robinhood raising at $5B+, up 4X in a year by tanderson92 on Thursday March 15, 2018 @11:36PM (#16598421)
Dividend reinvestment for ETFs happens at the brokerage level, not at the fund level. You can see this because some brokers don't support reinvestment in the same ETFs.
Re:Stock trade app Robinhood raising at $5B+, up 4X in a year by tanderson92 on Thursday March 15, 2018 @10:58PM (#16598250)
No.
Re:Stock trade app Robinhood raising at $5B+, up 4X in a year by astrange on Friday March 16, 2018 @12:29AM (#16598634)
> You can rebalance and reinvest dividends at Vanguard.

Right. I mean you can't do this on Robinhood.

Re:Stock trade app Robinhood raising at $5B+, up 4X in a year by syassami on Thursday March 15, 2018 @10:24PM (#16598119)
you think they need a slap on the wrist for the attitude they promote? have you seen etrades recent ad campaigns? https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yZ2Fa0zVglU
Re:Stock trade app Robinhood raising at $5B+, up 4X in a year by kelukelugames on Thursday March 15, 2018 @10:27PM (#16598125)
Etrade has always been doing this though.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BnQMq5wtZcg

Re:Stock trade app Robinhood raising at $5B+, up 4X in a year by logicallee on Thursday March 15, 2018 @11:06PM (#16598276)
Index funds aren't just boring, there is something morally abhorrent about simply investing in everything that has done well enough to be in an index fund. At that rate, why not invest in government bonds, given that the government gets whatever share it wants of literally every penny that goes through commerce in any capacity? If you want security, why invest in anything other than the government?

I admire people for investing their money actively instead of in an index.

It is the closest you can come to the capitalist spirit without actually doing anything. (Not a slight - not everyone needs to "do something" in the sense of starting a business - but being an active investor is very close to the same.)

Actively investing takes guts and a kind of entrepreneurial risk-taking.

Re:Stock trade app Robinhood raising at $5B+, up 4X in a year by zanny on Thursday March 15, 2018 @11:32PM (#16598398)
> If you want security, why invest in anything other than the government?

Because you make more money in index funds with comparable security?

Bonds used to be the principal way to save and invest in the past when interest rates were much higher. Its honestly a bit of a shame that as a society loaning money to the government is such a poor investment - it more reflects on the failings of the state if there is literally nothing profitable they can do with money to justify a competitive return. States can do pretty much anything a company can and more, and in a perfect world would be the best managers of capital. Thats where concepts like single payer healthcare come from, after all.

And add to that that not everyone wants to be a capitalist. Index funds are specialization of labor - let the teachers teach and the doctors save lives while their money is invested and managed by people who are good at tracking markets.

That being said, financial advisory in general is adjacent to such prestigious professions as televangelists and online poker in my mind - the most successful in the business have almost no correlation with actually sane analytical expertise and more to do with who can advertise the best. Fundamentally it is all making educated guesses, and until shit hits the fan people flock to whoever boasts the most rather than whoever is nuanced and rational, at least until after a stock crashes or a market tanks.

Re:Stock trade app Robinhood raising at $5B+, up 4X in a year by logicallee on Tuesday March 27, 2018 @07:35PM (#16693793)
I'm sorry it took so many days (11 - this is now on the third page of your userpage so you might not see this) to reply to this: you write extremely counterintuitive and challenging things. (While also supporting your statements with uncontroversial observations that are easy to agree with.)

Thanks for taking the time to reply! I'll reflect on what you've written.

Re:Stock trade app Robinhood raising at $5B+, up 4X in a year by twblalock on Thursday March 15, 2018 @11:25PM (#16598354)
I don't admire active investors. Most of them are going to get killed on commissions and fees and won't be able to compete with the professionals who spend all day, every day investing and have sources of information that aren't available to retail investors.

It's good that most Robin Hood investors are young and don't have much to lose. I hope they learn their lesson before they put they are old enough to put their retirement investments at risk.

Re:Stock trade app Robinhood raising at $5B+, up 4X in a year by rak00n on Friday March 16, 2018 @02:58AM (#16599079)
To be honest it's a good sandbox.
Re:Stock trade app Robinhood raising at $5B+, up 4X in a year by jldugger on Friday March 16, 2018 @12:38PM (#16601791)
> Index funds aren't just boring, there is something morally abhorrent

Hyperbole much? There's plenty of capitalist spirit in placing your trust in the outcomes of markets. Specialization is a perfectly rational economic decision, and requires you not specialize in other things. There's no reason to believe a medical doctor for example is going to excel at active investing, or that society would be better off if we required it.

The wonderful thing about markets is that we can all benefit from the specialization of others. Specialization (and competition) produces cheap pencils, cheap food, and even stocks that are closer to fairly valued. It is a fundamental misallocation of human capital -- I'm better off further pursuing specialization in server administration than trying to stare at stocks and newsfeeds to separate information from noise.

Re:Stock trade app Robinhood raising at $5B+, up 4X in a year by dguo on Thursday March 15, 2018 @11:41PM (#16598442)
We do need active investors, but the average person shouldn't be one if his or her goal is long term wealth generation. That doesn't mean maximizing security. It means maximizing the expected risk-adjusted rate of return.
Re:Stock trade app Robinhood raising at $5B+, up 4X in a year by dlp211 on Thursday March 15, 2018 @11:33PM (#16598405)
If that's your attitude, you should only buy corporate bonds and IPO's.
Re:Stock trade app Robinhood raising at $5B+, up 4X in a year by logicallee on Friday March 16, 2018 @10:14AM (#16600769)
Well, maybe not every IPO, but yeah. Good, armchair capitalist strategy.