News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Stock trade app Robinhood raising at $5B+, up 4X in a year by wgerard on Thursday March 15, 2018 @09:55PM (#16598019)
> Most people should arguably be putting their money into index funds and holding for the long term

I think Robinhood is great for that! Zero commission means you can afford to buy small amounts without worrying about fees eating into your principal too much.

You can put in $250 every pay period and buy a share of $SPY without losing ~3% to fees.

With commissions involved you'd want to wait until you could afford a larger trade, at which point you've lost time in the market.

Re:Stock trade app Robinhood raising at $5B+, up 4X in a year by dguo on Thursday March 15, 2018 @10:15PM (#16598083)
That is true. I'm not saying Robinhood is all bad or can't be used in good ways. My concern is that overall, the product and marketing seem to be geared towards speculative, short-term trading. When I first signed up, the app was recommending that I check out stocks like Apple, Netflix, and Snapchat, not index funds.
Re:Stock trade app Robinhood raising at $5B+, up 4X in a year by wgerard on Thursday March 15, 2018 @10:49PM (#16598213)
> My concern is that overall, the product and marketing seem to be geared towards speculative, short-term trading. When I first signed up, the app was recommending that I check out stocks like Apple, Netflix, and Snapchat, not index funds.

There's a broad spectrum of public companies obviously, but it's hard to see $AAPL as speculative in the same sense that people call penny stocks or cryptocurrencies speculative (i.e. much, much more risk involved in the latter two). Investing in large cap equities isn't the stupidest thing you could be doing as a new investor - that award would certainly go to buying derivatives.

And indeed if I have criticism of RH it's that they're trying to appeal to all investor types at the same time, new and experienced alike. It's easy to see how new investors can get confused when RH offers the ability to sign up for cryptocurrency trading and options trading, two things new investors obviously should not be doing (though admittedly there's obviously a questionnaire involved before you can be approved for options trading, not sure about cryptocurrencies).

Re:Stock trade app Robinhood raising at $5B+, up 4X in a year by jjeaff on Thursday March 15, 2018 @11:36PM (#16598419)
Washington Mutual, Bear Stearns, Lehman Brothers, General Motors, Fannie Mae, Freddie Mac are all good examples of why you should avoid individual stocks, even if they are "blue chip".
Re:Stock trade app Robinhood raising at $5B+, up 4X in a year by bigtunacan on Friday March 16, 2018 @12:57AM (#16598732)
Amazon, Alibaba, Mercado Libre, and Netflix are good examples of reasons not to avoid individual stocks.

More than 90% of my investments go into index funds and 10% into individual stocks, but if hindsight was 20/20 it would be 100% into my individual stocks and I’d be retired on my own private island today.

Re:Stock trade app Robinhood raising at $5B+, up 4X in a year by dragonwriter on Friday March 16, 2018 @03:13PM (#16603221)
Aside from the hindsight/foresight inversion, you probably mean if your foresight was 20/20, but the rest of the market had no better foresight than they actually do.

In which case, of course, you should invest entirely in the highest rate-of-return investmentd that the rest of the market currently undervalues.

The problem is people are prone to overrate their own foresight.

Re:Stock trade app Robinhood raising at $5B+, up 4X in a year by wmeredith on Friday March 16, 2018 @10:25AM (#16600850)
Hindsight IS 20/20. I think you meant if foresight was 20/20.
Re:Stock trade app Robinhood raising at $5B+, up 4X in a year by bigtunacan on Friday March 16, 2018 @01:02PM (#16602064)
LOL. Indeed I did.
Re:Stock trade app Robinhood raising at $5B+, up 4X in a year by 2trill2spill on Friday March 16, 2018 @12:04AM (#16598541)
Depends on when you bought them of course. I bought FNMA(Fannie Mae) in 2010 and it turned out pretty nicely.

But yes most people are better off buying index funds. That's where most of my money goes.

Re:Stock trade app Robinhood raising at $5B+, up 4X in a year by beiller on Friday March 16, 2018 @05:39AM (#16599550)
I find a good approach is to buy index funds, but when it comes to whatever your subject is, like I.T, you can pick companies you like or think will succeed. Just make sure to look at it in terms of the business and its future.
Re:Stock trade app Robinhood raising at $5B+, up 4X in a year by grahamannett on Thursday March 15, 2018 @10:44PM (#16598190)
I can understand why they guide people towards investing in "hip" companies versus an index fund, but regardless why is their so much animosity towards robinhood on HN? Is someone getting into investing and investing in an Apple/Amazon/etc. not overall a pretty good entry point compared to opening up thinkorswim or the pretty atrocious (at least on mac) schwab desktop client? Investing a small amount of money is better than blowing that money on tons of consumeristic bullshit that that tons of people do and RH seems like a genuinely good stepping stone compared to the current incumbents in a lot of ways (fees/minimum deposit/super simple). The fact that you can even start with RH and then at a later date transfer to a brokerage once you have a large enough portfolio is also a huge plus in my opinion to people who may have otherwise never set aside that money in the first place.
Re:Stock trade app Robinhood raising at $5B+, up 4X in a year by dguo on Thursday March 15, 2018 @11:20PM (#16598327)
I agree Robinhood is better than the incumbents in multiple ways. But at some time, other startups offer similar benefits while promoting an approach that is more likely to help the average person increase their wealth in the long term.

I don't think Robinhood is terrible. I just think someone who doesn't know what they're doing would be better off starting with Betterment or Acorns, which are just as user friendly as Robinhood.

Re:Stock trade app Robinhood raising at $5B+, up 4X in a year by adrr on Thursday March 15, 2018 @11:09PM (#16598289)
Etrade, Schwab and Ameritrade have commission free ETFs. Or you can just go to Vanguard and there's no commission if you buy their ETFs on their platform.
Re:Stock trade app Robinhood raising at $5B+, up 4X in a year by jcdavis on Thursday March 15, 2018 @10:08PM (#16598056)
Vanguard charges no fees for buying/selling their owns ETFs. I believe Schwab and others do as well.
Re:Stock trade app Robinhood raising at $5B+, up 4X in a year by wgerard on Thursday March 15, 2018 @10:53PM (#16598225)
True! That being said, using the Vanguard website is... significantly different from using the RH app.
Re:Stock trade app Robinhood raising at $5B+, up 4X in a year by jurassic on Thursday March 15, 2018 @11:22PM (#16598337)
The Vanguard web experience isn't great, I agree. But if you set up a recurring automated purchase you rarely need to log in and mess with it. Set it and forget it.

Viewed another way, I would say the Vanguard fund costs are low for a reason. It seems unfair to expect a Mercedes experience for a Honda worth of expense ratio.

Re:Stock trade app Robinhood raising at $5B+, up 4X in a year by dguo on Thursday March 15, 2018 @10:56PM (#16598241)
The Vanguard website/experience is definitely not that user-friendly/modern. That's the main reason I usually recommend Betterment to my friends instead.
Re:Stock trade app Robinhood raising at $5B+, up 4X in a year by dlp211 on Thursday March 15, 2018 @11:26PM (#16598355)
Betterment, where you pay an extra quarter percent to buy Vanguard funds.
Re:Stock trade app Robinhood raising at $5B+, up 4X in a year by dguo on Thursday March 15, 2018 @11:50PM (#16598482)
That's better than the alternative of not investing at all because Vanguard is not user-friendly. And I know that's possible because I have friends who were in that situation.

If you sign up with Vanguard, you still have to pick which fund(s) to buy. If you don't know anything about investing, that can be a daunting task. With Betterment, the only decision you have to make is the percentage split for stocks vs. bonds.

Re:Stock trade app Robinhood raising at $5B+, up 4X in a year by luckydata on Friday March 16, 2018 @12:12AM (#16598568)
Have you ran the math on how much that "user friendly" layer is costing you? I adore nice UIs, but I love even more keeping my money. Vanguard is really not that hard to use, and for how often you need to mess with it I don't think it's worth to spend more just to have prettier graphics.
Re:Stock trade app Robinhood raising at $5B+, up 4X in a year by dguo on Friday March 16, 2018 @12:41AM (#16598680)
I have both Betterment and Vanguard accounts. I haven't bothered to consolidate yet because Betterment is trying to add value to justify the fee with features like tax loss harvesting, and I haven't decided if it's worth it or not.

With regards to my friends though, my priority was to get them to invest in the first place, and the user friendliness of Betterment helped a lot.

Re:Stock trade app Robinhood raising at $5B+, up 4X in a year by kelnos on Friday March 16, 2018 @02:51AM (#16599050)
Your friends can't exercise some level of long term financial responsibility unless they're presented with pretty graphics and a slick UI?

The lack of financial education in the US really makes me sad sometimes. And it pisses me off that companies like RH will take advantage of that.

Re:Stock trade app Robinhood raising at $5B+, up 4X in a year by dguo on Friday March 16, 2018 @10:23AM (#16600837)
I totally share[1] your feelings on the lack of financial education. In defense of my friends, they already knew to fund their 401(k)s. The question was what to do with their free cash. And considering the risk of losing money, any amount of friction (like a bad UI) can make it easy to procrastinate.

[1]: https://twitter.com/dannyguo/status/961684866285924354

Re:Stock trade app Robinhood raising at $5B+, up 4X in a year by southphillyman on Friday March 16, 2018 @10:08AM (#16600725)
>That's better than the alternative of not investing at all because Vanguard is not user-friendly

This is literally what happened to me. I lost out on 20%+ in gains because I procrastinated a year after reading about how much Betterment fees eat into your gains. In hindsight the amount of money I missed out on was WAY more than any fee Betterment would have hit me with.

Re:Stock trade app Robinhood raising at $5B+, up 4X in a year by btmorex on Friday March 16, 2018 @02:26AM (#16599000)
Isn't that why Vanguard has their Total Stock Market and Total Bond Market funds? Basically, they're the "invest in these if you don't want to bother" funds.
Re:Stock trade app Robinhood raising at $5B+, up 4X in a year by dguo on Friday March 16, 2018 @10:50AM (#16601040)
That's a good point. Deciding to go with those is still a choice though. It's like going to a restaurant that has both an omakase[1] option and regular dishes. Versus a restaurant that only offers omakase. The latter involves even less decision making.

[1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Omakase

Re:Stock trade app Robinhood raising at $5B+, up 4X in a year by mcintyre1994 on Friday March 16, 2018 @03:48AM (#16599230)
They also have LifeStrategy 0/20/40/60/80/100 so you can balance stocks vs bonds however you want, and have diversification handled for you.
Re:Stock trade app Robinhood raising at $5B+, up 4X in a year by TorKlingberg on Friday March 16, 2018 @05:15AM (#16599474)
I think the numbered LifeStrategy funds are only a UK (GBP) thing. Am I wrong?
Re:Stock trade app Robinhood raising at $5B+, up 4X in a year by matwood on Friday March 16, 2018 @07:35AM (#16599937)
There are US equivalents.
Re:Stock trade app Robinhood raising at $5B+, up 4X in a year by mcintyre1994 on Friday March 16, 2018 @07:49AM (#16599993)
I'm in the UK and hold the GBP products, so I'm unsure sorry.
Re:Stock trade app Robinhood raising at $5B+, up 4X in a year by tysonzni on Friday March 16, 2018 @12:48AM (#16598700)
You pay an extra quarter percent to 1) not have to think about allocation and risk under-diversfication, and 2) commit to the "buy and hold" strategy since its withdrawal process is more cumbersome than normal trading.

I think for most people this actually ends up producing better long term returns.

Re:Stock trade app Robinhood raising at $5B+, up 4X in a year by wils1245 on Friday March 16, 2018 @11:04AM (#16601140)
How much are you willing to spend on a nice user interface? The whole point of passive investing is that you rarely interact with your account.

Even a slight difference in fees is worth thousands in the long run.

Re:Stock trade app Robinhood raising at $5B+, up 4X in a year by meatbundragon on Thursday March 15, 2018 @10:10PM (#16598067)
While this is a great point, the casual segment of the customer base that is being discussed would certainly not have enough awareness of this fact. At the very least, I didn't even though I do trade ETFs and large cap stocks casually...
Re:Stock trade app Robinhood raising at $5B+, up 4X in a year by AFNobody on Friday March 16, 2018 @01:42AM (#16598876)
I am sorry but "casual investors" should be doing long term buy and hold because if you can't be bothered to spend 30 minutes on research to compare brokerages, I am genuinely horrified at the idea of you doing anything other than buying and holding an index fund.

Robinhood's encouragement of the instant gratification, poorly researched trades is going to end badly for many of it's customers when we enter a bear market.

Re:Stock trade app Robinhood raising at $5B+, up 4X in a year by meatbundragon on Friday March 16, 2018 @02:36PM (#16602918)
I disagree that investors' abilities to understand stocks and create portfolios should be judged by someone's willingness to find which individual brokerages offer free buy/sell of their own ETFs.
Re:Stock trade app Robinhood raising at $5B+, up 4X in a year by vasilipupkin on Thursday March 15, 2018 @11:31PM (#16598392)
Their own ETFs - yes. But still a fee to buy other ETFs that aren't their own.
Re:Stock trade app Robinhood raising at $5B+, up 4X in a year by arsenico on Friday March 16, 2018 @06:50AM (#16599789)
You're paying fees for something different than just buying and holding an index ETF - and that is a long-term diversification across asset classes and georgraphies, regular automatic rebalancing of portfolios, goal-based investing with multiple financial goals, reporting, etc. I am not saying that buying a single S&P ETF is bad, but you can do so mych more for your financial future with robos, that it is basically incomparable.

Edit: I also forgot an increasingly important diversification by asset manager as well.

Re:Stock trade app Robinhood raising at $5B+, up 4X in a year by saryant on Friday March 16, 2018 @12:08PM (#16601554)
But that's not new?

Vanguard has long offered commission-free trades of their ETFs and mutual funds. Same for many index fund providers.

Re:Stock trade app Robinhood raising at $5B+, up 4X in a year by rak00n on Friday March 16, 2018 @02:52AM (#16599056)
You can open a Vanguard account and buy $VOO for zero commission too.